Written by Nagarjuna The Buddhist Monk Madhyamka is not :
- Mystical doctrine concerned with otherworldly revelations. Neither it is philosophical explanation of reality.
- Nihlisim. Though it says pheonomena are empty, their functional effectiveness on experiential level is never questioned.
What’s the overall summary?
- Goal
- Liberation of beings
- Method
- Correct our mistaken apprehension of phenomena and to dissolve our long-ingrained belief that they exist in the way they appear.
Truth of the phenomena isn’t found to be in none of the four “ontological” extremes : existence, nonexistence, both existence and nonexistence, and neither nonexistence nor existence.
Highlights
As one tries to negotiate the labyrinthine arguments, however, it may be useful to bear the following four points in mind. The first is that, however tortuous and rarefied the karikas may seem, it is worth remembering that Madhyamaka is not a mystical doctrine concerned with strange and otherworldly revelations. Neither is it a philosophical explanation of Reality, if by that is meant some remote transcendental absolute. The purpose of Madhyamaka is simply to elucidate the nature of phenomena: the things and situations that make up the world of our experience.
The second point is that Madhyamaka is not a species of philosophical nihilism. Although phenomena are said to be empty, their functional effectiveness on the experiential level is not at all called into question. Phenomena appear and they do affect us regardless of the theories that we may entertain about them.
The third point is that—like all Buddhist teachings—Madhyamaka has one essential goal: the liberation of beings. Its aim is to correct our mistaken apprehension of phenomena and to dissolve our long-ingrained belief that they exist in the way that they appear.
In this context, however, “middle way” means that the truth of phenomena is to be found in none of the four “ontological extremes”: existence, nonexistence, both existence and nonexistence, and neither existence nor nonexistence.
It lies beyond the reach of thought and word. But if language and, by extension, reasoning are in themselves unable to deliver the actual truth, they nevertheless have a crucial, if indirect, role to play.
Dope example
As Chandrakirti said, when we drink, we need a cup to bring the water to our lips. But we do not drink the cup; we drink the water. Although words and logic are unable to capture the nature of phenomena, they may nevertheless carry us to the threshold of the truth by exposing the incoherence of our mistaken ideas
Therefore, the fourth point to bear in mind is that in the karikas, Nagarjuna does not attempt the impossible; he does not describe the nature of phenomena. He expresses no thesis of his own and does not supply us with yet another theory about the universe. Instead, in order to encourage, and perhaps trigger, a more profound insight, he systematically destroys any idea contrived by human intelligence to account for phenomena—any theory that serves to confirm our mistaken apprehension that they truly exist.
The Mulamadhyamakakarika therefore plots a meandering course as Nagarjuna relentlessly obliterates the successive positions of his hapless victim: the advocate of real existence. He thus demolishes a whole series of categories—whether characteristically Buddhist or else the common property of Indian philosophy—beginning with the most basic and coming by gradual degrees to the most sacrosanct notions of Buddhist doctrine: the Tathagata, the four noble truths, nirvana, and so on.