- Random errors vs biased errors :: Random errors tend to be spread out but biased errors have directionality. So, what we have as a view can often be very misleading because of the directionality. e.g. Chimps’s errors would be equally shared between two wrong answers, whereas human errors all tend to be in one direction. Chimps got higher score on three-answer question than humans on the same test.
- People have an outdated view of the world, and though they hear new information; they don’t update their models.
Highlights
Introduction CHAPTER ONE: The Gap Instinct CHAPTER TWO: The Negativity Instinct CHAPTER THREE: The Straight Line Instinct CHAPTER FOUR: The Fear Instinct CHAPTER FIVE: The Size Instinct CHAPTER SIX: The Generalization Instinct CHAPTER SEVEN: The Destiny Instinct CHAPTER EIGHT: The Single Perspective Instinct CHAPTER NINE: The Blame Instinct CHAPTER TEN: The Urgency Instinct CHAPTER ELEVEN: Factfulness in Practice
If I did this (and I wouldn’t ever actually do this, but just imagine), the chimps, by picking randomly, would do consistently better than the well-educated but deluded human beings who take my tests. Through pure luck, the troop of chimps would score 33 percent on each three-answer question, or four out of the first 12 on the whole test. Remember that the humans I have tested get on average just two out of 12 on the same test. What’s more, the chimps’ errors would be equally shared between the two wrong answers, whereas the human errors all tend to be in one direction. Every group of people I ask thinks the world is more frightening, more violent, and more hopeless—in short, more dramatic—than it really is.
I decided to start doing more than just testing knowledge and exposing ignorance. I decided to try to understand why. Why was this ignorance about the world so widespread and so persistent? We are all wrong sometimes—even me, I will readily admit that—but how could so many people be wrong about so much? Why were so many people scoring worse than the chimps?
Aha! I had it! What I was dealing with here—or so I thought, for many years—was an upgrade problem: my global health students, and all the other people who took my tests over the years, did have knowledge, but it was outdated, often several decades old. People had a worldview dated to the time when their teachers had left school.
But gradually, gradually, we came to realize that there was something more going on. The ignorance we kept on finding was not just an upgrade problem. It couldn’t be fixed simply by providing clearer data animations or better teaching tools. Because even people who loved my lectures, I sadly realized, weren’t really hearing them.
I shouldn’t have worried. This top international audience who would spend the next few days explaining the world to each other did indeed know more than the general public about poverty. A stunning 61 percent of them got it right. But on the other two questions, about future population growth and the availability of basic primary health care, they still did worse than the chimps. Here were people who had access to all the latest data and to advisers who could continuously update them. Their ignorance could not possibly be down to an outdated worldview. Yet even they were getting the basic facts about the world wrong