Quotes

On ignorance

An abecedarian ignorance that precedes knowledge, and a doctoral ignorance that comes after it.” The first is the ignorance of those who, not knowing their ABC’s, cannot read at all. The second is the ignorance of those who have misread many books. – Montaigne

On readiness and habit

The difference between your activity before and after you have formed a habit is a difference in facility and readiness.

On rules

Reading is like skiing. When done well, when done by an expert, both reading and skiing are graceful, harmonious activities. When done by a beginner, both are awkward, frustrating, and slow.

On reading

“Read not to contradict and confute; nor to believe and take for granted; nor to find talk and discourse; but to weigh and consider.” – Francis Bacon

On poet and revolution

A despot doesn’t fear eloquent writers preaching freedom-he fears a drunken poet who may crack a joke that will take hold. – E.B. White

On beauty

Beauty has its own excuse for being. – Ralph Waldo Emerson

On book

“I have no more made my book,” said Montaigne, “than my book has made me; a book co-substantial with its author, concerned with my own self, an integral part of my life.” And he added, “Everyone recognizes me in my book, and my book in me.” – Montaigne

On methods and materials

Having a method without materials to which it can be applied is as useless as having the materials with no method to apply to them.

Notes

  • Reading or listening can’t be passive. It’s more like a batsmen and bowler, more than receiving a judgement.
  • The book should enlighten us from less knowledge to more knowledge once we are through it. It should lighten some part of us that we never knew existed.
  • Reading speed should vary based on what we are trying to get from reading. Is it for information or knowledge?
    • Increasing your store of information is not the same as being more enlightened about a topic.
  • Criteria for reading for understanding to happen
    • Communication of a book can’t be of equals. There is at least something that should flow from the writer to the reader.
    • The reader should be able to overcome this inequality. To the extent that equality is approached, clarity of communication is achieved.
  • We shouldn’t also forget that reciting information also can sometimes lead to understanding, albeit very infrequent.
  • Imparting information is the first step before we impart understanding.
  • Perfect word to describe who read poorly.
  • Discovery means learning without a teacher. That’s why it’s possible for learning to happen. Else, it would all be a recursive loop where there could be no teacher in the first place to teach.
  • Need to have a cohesive act of reading rather than a memorized set of steps. It’s one habit that we need to form, not a list of distinct habits.
  • We need to read books that stretch our mind, that don’t feel like within our capacity if we are to improve our reading skills.
  • Reading for information only changes our mind quantitatively not qualitatively.
  • A good book rewards us by improving our reading skill on one hand, and teach us about the world and ourselves in the other.

Stages of Reading

Reading Readiness
Learning the alphabets, words, sentences. Until the age of about six or seven.
  • Physical Readiness: Good vision and hearing.
  • Intellectual Readiness: Remember letters and how they combine to a word.
  • Language Readiness: Ability to use sentences, speak clearly.
  • Personal Readiness: Ability to work with other children, follow guidelines etc.
Second stage
Starting to read very simple materials. Master of some hundred words. Can read simple materials independently. Start finding meaning from symbols on a page.
Third stage
Building a vocabulary fast. Unlock meaning through context. Starts reading for fun too.
Fourth stage
Refine the skills previously acquired.

Questions for active reading

We will need to have answer to first three questions to answer the fourth one. Inspectional Reading tends to answer the first two. Analytical the third and syntopical the fourth.

  1. What is the book about as a whole?
  2. What is being said in detail, and how?
  3. Is the book true, in whole, or part?
  4. What of it?

Classifying a reading material

First way

Expository Books
Conveys knowledge. Opinions, Theories, Hypotheses, or Speculations for which claim is made.
  • History Books : Narration of events. Chronotopic. ( Chronos being time , and topos being place )
  • Philosophy Books: Seeks truths rather than account of particular events, but employs common knowledge for it.
  • Science and Mathematics: Special experience to explain any point.
Poetry
Conveys artistic view.

Social Sciences :

Second way

Practical Books
Ends in action. Emphasis on application. Need to convert knowledge into rules of operation eventually.
  • Guidebooks, Manuals, Moral Treatises ( Like something on how economic, ethical, or political morals teaching how to act).
  • Books starting with “The Art of”, “How to”.
  • Questions about end of anything or the purpose it serves.
  • “Should/Ought/Good/Bad/Means” etc. used frequently.
Theoretical Books
Ends in knowledge.
  • Reportorial, Mathematical, or Statistical Studies that present, but don’t tell us what we should do or not do.
  • Questions about validity of something.
  • Uses “Is” instead of “should/ought” etc.
  • Example

    The Critique of Pure Reason and The Critique of Practical Reason classifies this distinction clearly. The first is about what is and how we know it, not how to know it. So, it’s theoretical. The second is about how we should conduct ourselves in a virtuous way. So, it’s practical.

Book Titles

  1. Knowing how “Principles of Psychology” is alike “Elements of Geometry” where principles and elements almost mean the same thing.
  2. Knowing how two books are alike and different based on some practical terms, we know what we can understand from the title.

How to make a book your own

  1. Underlining
  2. Vertical lines at the margin
  3. Stark, asterisk, or markers at the margin.
  4. Number in the margin :: To indicate sequence of points made by author in developing an argument.
  5. Numbers of other pages in the margin :: To follow a sequence to a consistent or contradictory opinions
  6. Circling key words or phrases
  7. Writing in the margin, top, or the bottom of the page.

Stating with brevity

  1. Don’t take sample summaries as if they are the only formulation of book’s unity. They can be different, and one better than the other.
  2. Though readers are different, the book is the same. So, there will always be a possibility of check of how accurate this summary is.

Aristotle’s summary of Odyssey

A certain man is absent from home for many years; he is jealously watched by Poseidon, and left desolate. Meanwhile his home is in a wretched plight; suitors are wasting his substance and plotting against his son. At length, tempest-tossed, he himself arrives; he makes certain persons acquainted with him; he attacks the suitors with his own hand, and is himself preserved while he destroys them.

Of Aristotle’s Ethics

This is an inquiry into the nature of human happiness and an analysis of the conditions under which happiness may be gained or lost, with an indication of what men must do in their conduct and thinking in order to become happy or to avoid unhappiness, the principal emphasis being placed on the cultivation of the virtues, both moral and intellectual, although other goods are also recognized as necessary for happiness, such as wealth, health, friends, and a just society in which to live.

Of Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations

This is an inquiry into the source of national wealth in any economy that is built on a division of labor, considering the relation of the wages paid labor, the profits returned to capital, and the rent owed the landowner, as the prime factors in the price of commodities. It discusses the various ways in which capital can be more or less gainfully employed, and relates the origin and use of money to the accumulation and employment of capital. Examining the development of opulence in different nations and under different conditions, it compares the several systems of political economy, and argues for the beneficence of free trade.

Darwin’s Origin Of Species

This is an account of the variation of living things during the course of countless generations and the way in which this results in new groupings of plants and animals; it treats both of the variability of domesticated animals and of variability under natural conditions, showing how such factors as the struggle for existence and natural selection operate to bring about and sustain such groupings; it argues that species are not fixed and immutable groups, but that they are merely varieties in transition from a less to a more marked and permanent status, supporting this argument by evidences from extinct animals found in the earth’s crust, and from comparative embryology and anatomy.

Using Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding

You may recall our observing that Locke himself summarized his work by saying that it was “an inquiry into the origin, certainty and extent of human knowledge, together with the grounds and degrees of belief, opinion and assent.” We would not quarrel with so excellent a statement of plan by the author, except to add two subordinate qualifications to do justice to the first and third parts of the essay: it will be shown, we would add, that there are no innate ideas, but that all human knowledge is acquired from experience; and language will be discussed as a medium for the expression of thought, its proper use and most familiar abuses to be indicated.

Outlining a book

  • Just like Stating with brevity means seeing the parts as a whole, we would like to see what parts make up the whole. We are trying to find the organization of parts that account for the whole.
  • One is simplifying the book, another is trying to bring complexity into our understanding.
  • For large books, it can span several pages.
  • We don’t have to follow the apparent structure of the book as indicated by it’s chapters.
  • Purpose of outlining is to necessarily verify our brief summary on the basis of our outline. It should be supportive to our main theme.

Sample Outline

The whole book is about so and so and such and such. That done, we might obey the third rule by proceeding as follows: (1) The author accomplished this plan in five major parts, of which the first part is about so and so, the second part is about such and such, the third part is about this, the fourth part about that, and the fifth part about still another thing. (2) The first of these major parts is divided into three sections, of which the first considers X, the second considers Y, and the third considers Z. (3) In the first section of the first part, the author makes four points, of which the first is A, the second B, the third C, and the fourth D. And so on and so forth.

Example 1 :: The United States Constitution

FIRST: The Preamble, setting forth the purpose(s) of the Constitution;
SECOND: The first Article, dealing with the legislative department of the government;
THIRD: The second Article, dealing with the executive department of the government;
FOURTH: The third Article, dealing with the judicial department of the government;
FIFTH: The fourth Article, dealing with the relationship between the state governments and the federal government;
SIXTH: The fifth, sixth, and seventh Articles, dealing with the amendment of the Constitution, its status as the supreme law of the land, and provisions for its ratifications;
SEVENTH: The first ten amendments, constituting the Bill of Rights;
EIGHTH: The remaining amendments up to the present day.

Example 2 :: Division of the First Article of U.S. Constitution

II, 1: Section I, establishing legislative powers in a Congress of the United States, divided into two bodies, a Senate and a House of Representatives;
II, 2: Sections 2 and 3, respectively describing the composition of the House and Senate and stating the qualifications of members. In addition, it is stated that the House has the sole power of impeachment, while the Senate has the sole power of trying impeachments;
II, 3: Sections 4 and 5, having to do with the election of members of both branches of Congress and with the internal organization and affairs of each;
II, 4: Section 6, stating the perquisites and emoluments of members of both branches, and stating one limitation on civil employment of members;
II, 5: Section 7, defining the relationship between the legislative and executive departments of the government and describing the President’s veto power;
II, 6: Section 8, stating the powers of Congress; II, 7: Section 9, stating some limitations on the powers outlined in Section 8;
II, 8: Section 10, stating limitations on the powers of the states and the extent to which they must give over certain powers to the Congress.

Discovering the author’s intentions

  • We are trying to start by finding what questions the author starts with.
  • Fallacy of thinking you can discover what was in an author’s mind from the book he has written.

Theoretical Questions

  • Does something exist?
  • What kind of thing is it?
  • What caused it to exist, or under what conditions can it exist, or why does it exist?
  • What purpose does it serve?
  • What are the consequences of its existence?
  • What are its characteristic properties?
  • What are its relations to other things of a similar sort, or of a different sort?
  • How does it behave?

Practical Questions

  • What ends should be sought?
  • What means should be chosen to a given end?
  • What things must one do to gain a certain objective, and in what order?
  • Under these conditions, what is the right thing to do, or the better rather than the worse?
  • Under what conditions would it be better to do this rather than that?

Terms

  • Terms are words/sentences/phrases that are used with similar meaning through the text.
  • Can be synonyms.
  • Same word might not refer to the same term.
  • Coming to Terms with the author means we agree on the meaning of words as used by the author.
  • Philosophers can often coin their own terms.
  • Different philosophers can use same common word as different terms.
  • Find meaning of term using context, and by finding other places it’s used in.
  • Single word is rarely repeated all over the place since it makes the text boring. So, synonyms are likely to be expected.
  • Single word may be related to multiple terms or single term related to multiple words.
  • “Illustration”, “Reading for Enlightenment”, “the process of passing from understanding less to understanding more by the operation of your mind upon a book” all mean the same term.
  • words used to arouse emotions, move us to action, change our minds etc.
  • Readers must usually come to terms with an author first before starting to understand the author’s discussions.

Finding key terms

  1. Frequent repetition
  2. Words that give you trouble. Maybe to author as well.
  3. Technical
  4. Explicit stress
  5. Typographical Marks ( Quotation / Italics )
  6. Discussion about the word before mentioning it

Example

  1. Adam Smith
    • labor
    • capital
    • land
    • wages
    • profits
    • rent
    • commodity
    • price
    • exchange
    • productive
    • unproductive
    • money
  2. Darwin
    • variety
    • genus
    • election
    • survival
    • adaptation
    • hybrid
    • fittest
    • creation

Key Sentences

  • Know the type of sentences:
    • Propositions
    • Problem Statements
    • Answers
    • Wishes/Intentions
  • Need to be able to slow down at key sentences while reading a book. Not everything is to be read at the same pace.
  • Author’s ideas not ours.
  • Terms make up propositions. By understanding proposition conveyed, we come to terms with the author.
  • Pausing over sentences that interest us rather than over ones that puzzle us is the single most obstacle to reading well.
  • Best guide to check whether we have understood propositions or not. Not knowing this means we got words from the author, not thought or knowledge. Think of it as translation in the same language.
    • Can you point to some experience you have had that the proposition describes or to which the proposition is in any way relevant?
    • Can you exemplify the general truth that has been enunciated by referring to a particular instance of it?
    • Imagining a possible case is as good as an actual one. Not being able to do this means we imparted words, not wisdom.
  • Be aware of propagandist/orator who try to leave certain things unsaid, just to ensure that they could be challenged if they were made explicit.
  • Always make sure of common notions used by the author. They may not be as common as the author’s thinking.

Finding propositions

Propositions are statements about what the author is proposing. Smallest logical element that we can work with.

  • Finding sentences that together form a sequence.
  • Finding something that’s stated by the author.

Finding arguments

  1. If you find conclusion first, look for reasons. If you find reasons first, see where they lead.
  2. Discriminate between the kind of argument that points to one or more particular facts as evidence for some generalization and the kind that offers a series of general statements to prove some further generalizations.
  3. Observe the things the author says he must assume, what he says can be proved, and what need not be proved because it’s self-evident.

Finding solutions

  1. Which of the problems that the author tried to solve did he succeed in solving?
  2. In the course of solving these, did he raise any new ones?
  3. Of the problems that he failed to solve, old or new, which did the author himself know he had failed on?

Criticizing a book

  • Even when saying that we agree, reader must be able to give grounds for agreeing, disagreeing, or even for suspending judgement.
  • Being passive and pliable is not same as teachable. For being teachable, you need to be able to exercise the power of independent judgement.
  • Understand the location and purpose of rhetoric correctly.
  • Suspend judgement until we’re satisfied with first two stages of reading. Then comes the right as well as the duty to turn critic.
  • Identifying criticism doesn’t mean disagreement. Criticism needs to be repeated in their own words, just to verify that they have understood the argument. Else, ignore it.
    • One who puts up a criticism with serious understanding, it’s a delight.
  • If the arguments need other book to be properly discussed, those works must be read before making a fair criticism.
  • Disagreements need to be resolved. Often times, emotion can color thoughts.
  • Inequality of knowledge is always curable by instruction.
  • Disagreement is related to either teaching or being taught.
  • The reader who doesn’t distinguish between the reasoned statement of knowledge and expression of opinion, isn’t reading to learn.
  • There is nothing that we know that is sure of not getting invalidated in the future. New evidence can surely invalidate.
  • A reader must say that he understands before he starts saying more about it. If he doesn’t understand, keep working on it. In case, the book itself is faulty, the reader must be able to locate reasons why it’s such a case. This requires great rigor on reader’s part before a judgement.
  • To resolve any dispute:
    • We need to acknowledge the emotions we bring to the table. We may even think we have reasons, when all we have are strong feelings.
    • We must make our assumptions explicit. What can then happen is that author and reader might have started with different assumptions. Good disagreement should not be in regards to assumptions.
    • An attempt for impartiality is a good antidote for blindness that’s almost inevitable.

Aids to Reading

  • No book should be, because no book can be, read entirely and completely in isolation.

Relevant Experiences

  • Common experience doesn’t have to be shared by everyone to be common. Common is not the same as universal. e.g. Experience of being a child of parents isn’t shared by orphans, but is considered to be common.
  • Mostly relevant to fiction and philosophy.
  • Special experiences required for understanding scientific literature.

Other Books

  • Not only are many of the great books related, but also written in a certain order that shouldn’t be ignored.
    They may try to read The Federalist Papers without having first read the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution. Or they may try all these without having read Montesquieu’s The Spirit of Laws, Rousseau’s The Social Contract, and Locke’s second treatise Of Civil Government.
    
  • Great authors, by being great readers themselves, are constantly engaged in conversation with each other.
  • The chronology is often the easiest way to see the relationship, but there can be other ways too.
  • Very important in philosophy because philosophers are great readers of each other.

Commentaries and Abstracts

  • Should be used sparingly, thus being wise with their usage. The reason being commentators aren’t always right about comments into a book. They purport to tell everything that one has to know about the topic. e.g. Handbooks and manuals are often particularly misleading.
  • Another reason is that they may not be exhaustive, even if they are correct.
  • So, a maxim about commentary is to never use a commentary until after you have read the book.
  • An abstract cannot replace the reading of a book, but can tell us whether we want to read that book or not.

Reference Books

  • Dictionaries and Encyclopedias are two primary kinds of reference books frequently used.
  • Try to use context to find meaning of words as much as you can.
  • To use reference book, we need to vaguely understand it first. Else, you have 100 meanings in dictionary. Now, you can take it all wrong.
  • We need to be able to ask intelligent question to reference book to get an intelligent answer.
  • We need to know how information is organized in a reference book in order to use it effectively. Better read the author’s advice on how to use it.
  • There shouldn’t be opinions on reference books.
Santayana’s remark about the Greeks—that they were the only uneducated people in European history—has a double significance. The masses were, of course, uneducated, but even the learned few—the leisure class—were not educated in the sense that they had to sit at the feet of foreign masters. Education, in that sense, begins with the Romans, who went to school to Greek pedagogues, and became cultivated through contact with the Greek culture they had conquered.
  • Trying to use dictionary to settle argument about communism, or justice, or freedome is utter foolishness, since some of those theories came before a dictionary came.
    • So, dictionaries should be used without any judgement.
  • Don’t forget dictionary is a book about words, not about things.
    1. WORDS ARE PHYSICAL THINGS—writable words and speak-able sounds. There must, therefore, be uniform ways of spelling and pronouncing them, though the uniformity is often spoiled by variations, and in any event is not as eternally important as some of your teachers may have indicated.
    2. WORDS ARE PARTS OF SPEECH. Each single word plays a grammatical role in the more complicated structure of a phrase or sentence. The same word can vary in different usages, shifting from one part of speech to another, especially in a non-inflected language like English.
    3. WORDS ARE SIGNS. They have meanings, not one but many. These meanings are related in various ways.
    4. WORDS ARE CONVENTIONAL. They are man-made signs. That is why every word has a history, a cultural career in the course of which it goes through certain transformations.
    
  • Though the word “encyclopedia” is Greek, they didn’t have one. The reason why dictionaries came in the first place is when Romans tried studying Greek.
  • The first alphabetically ordered encyclopedia didn’t appear until about 1700.
  • Previously, knowledge war arranged based on seven liberal arts – grammar, rhetoric, and logic ( the trivium ); arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music ( the quadrivium ).
  • Best encyclopedia is one arranged by both alphabets as well as by topic. For that reason alone, we need to understand how important the index is in a encyclopedia.
  • Facts should never be argued about in the first place. Encyclopedias should only be about facts, and nothing else.
  • Encyclopedias can properly describe a theory which is no longer held to be correct, when it is associated with a topic; but that doesn’t mean it’s putting false facts in there.
  • They shouldn’t be used to pursue understanding, which requires both imagination and reason.

Syntopicon

  • 3000 subjects or topics with references to pages where the subject is discussed.
  • Helps starting out any syntopical reading project.
  • Can help in three ways:
    • Initiatively: Help you start on particular ones on the subjects in which they are interested.
    • Suggestively: You can read relatively short passages from a large number of authors. So, suggests where to look deeply.
    • Instructively: Give direction to the reader, help compare based on different works and different authors, helps show multiple meaning of same passage because it’s repeated in different sections.

Pyramid of Books

  1. Books that teach both how to read and how to live :: < 1 out of 100 or 1000 or even 10000. No more than a few thousand books.
    • Worth reading analytically once. Skillful may get it in one run.
    • You might return to them but they will most likely always remain in the shelf.
    • You have milked it dry. The book unlikely has anything more to give to you.
  2. Out of few thousand such books, probably < 100 can’t be exhausted even by the best reading we can manage.
    • We know that when we have completed the book analytically, but have a suspicion as to there is more than that you got. If you knew immediately, you would have read it. Analytical reading demands us to. But at the time, we don’t know what is that we missed.
    • You cannot stop thinking about the book. Finally, you return to it when a remarkable thing happens.
  3. Of those books you return to, most will feel that there was less than you remembered. This is because you grew with time as well.
  4. Of those books you return to, there are very few books which you feel like have grown with you on returning to the book. < 100. Number decreases based on what appeals an individual reader.
    • You see things that you had never seen before.
    • Your previous understanding was true, and is true now, but in a different way.
    • You accessed the book on different surface level than you did the last time.

Levels of Reading

The levels of reading mean that they follow one after the another. You cannot skip the first and go to the second level.

Elementary Reading

It is about learning the basic rules so that we are able to understand what each sentence is saying.

  • Goal

    1. What is the sentence trying to say?
    2. Are you able to not look at dictionary all the time, not stumble over grammar and syntax?
  • Tools to employ

    • Vocabulary
    • Elemental Reading Skills
    • Grammar Rules and Mechanics

Inspectional Reading

Reading done the best given limited amount of time. Answers to questions in goal section can be written down in on the contents page, outline or anywhere possible so that we can come to it later for analytical reading even after months.

  • Goal

    1. To know whether this book deserves an analytical reading by answering the following questions:
      1. What is the book about?
      2. What is the structure of the book?
      3. What are it’s parts?
    2. Find answer to whether this book deserves more reading in limited amount of time.
  • Types

    Not necessarily distinct for experienced readers. Should be performed as separate at the starting phase though.

    1. Systematic Skimming/Pre-reading
    2. Superficial Reading
  • Tools to employ

    • Preface
    • Table of Contents
    • Random skimming
  • Rules

    • Skimming

      1. Look at the title page, and preface if available.
      2. Study the TOC.
      3. Check the index to estimate the range of topics covered and kinds of books and authors that are referred to. Look at some passages cited to some interesting terms.
      4. Look at the chapters that seem to be pivotal to its argument based on our current bias.
      5. Randomly turn the pages, read some paragraphs or pages in sequence, not more than that.
  • Suggestions

    • While tackling a difficult book for the first time, try to go one shot to the end, rather than stop where you get stuck.
    • Consulting footnotes, scholarly commentaries, and other sources for help without first reading it ourselves hinder our reading for understanding than boost it.
    • Don’t lose sight of the whole by nitpicking while going through for the first time. You will miss the forest for the trees.
    • Reading speed should vary based on complexity and nature of what material we read.
    • Racing through even the hardest way is the best way to read it inspectionally. Don’t be afraid to seem superficial.
  • What not to do

    • Not read inspectional when reading analytically or merging these two steps into one.

Analytical Reading

  • Reading done the best given unlimited amount of time.
  • Chewing and digesting what you can read.
  • Outlining a book and Interpretation of book meet at the level of propositions and arguments. By dividing the book into parts, we understand what points are being made. Out of those points, some will be questions and some answers. Some taken together make an answer. Now, we understand what the content of the book is.
  • Rules

    • First Stage :: Finding what a book is about

      1. Classify the book according to kind and subject matter. Classifying a reading material
      2. State what the whole book is about with the utmost brevity. ( One or at most a few sentences ) Stating with brevity
      3. Enumerate its major parts in their order and relation, and outline these parts as you have outlined the whole. Outlining a book
      4. Define the problem or problems the author is trying to solve.
    • Second Stage :: Coming to Terms (Interpreting its contents)

      1. Find the important words and come to Terms.
      2. Mark the most important sentences and find propositions.
      3. Locate or construct the basic arguments in the book by finding them in connection of sentences. Key Sentences
      4. Find out what author’s solutions are.
    • Third Stage Part 1 :: Maxims of Intellectual Etiquette while criticizing a book

      1. You must be able to say, with reasonable certainty, “I UNDERSTAND”, before you can say any one of the following things: “I AGREE,” or “I DISAGREE,” or “I SUSPEND JUDGEMENT”.
      2. When you disagree, do so reasonably, and not disputatiously or contentiously.
      3. Respect the difference between knowledge and mere personal opinion, by giving reasons for any critical judgement you make.
    • Third Stage Part 2 :: Points of criticism

      • If the reader has done his due part, then the final conversation of reader with the author during disagreement “I understand but I disagree” can be made with following remarks:
        1. You are uniformed :: Saying that he lacks some piece of knowledge that is relevant to the problem at hand. e.g. Darwin lacked knowledge of genetics. In science, later researches often point this out.
        2. You are misinformed :: Saying that author asserts what is not the case. It’s a claim to have knowledge he doesn’t possess.
        3. You are illogical :: That he has committed a fallacy in reasoning. Inconsistency or incompatibility between assumptions and answers.
        4. Your analysis is incomplete :: If we fail to raise first three points before we come to this, that means we agree with author as far as he has gone. This is saying that author hasn’t solved all the problems he started with, or hasn’t made good use of his materials as possible, or hasn’t seen potential ramifications, or has failed to make distinctions that are relevant to the argument. e.g. Aristotle’s Politics because of erroneous acceptance of slavery. Euclid’s postulates about relation of parallel lines etc.

Syntopical Reading

  • Comparative Reading
  • Knowing that to answer the question, we need to read more than one book.
  • Curious paradox is involved in syntopical reading.
  • Identification of subject matter must follow the reading, not precede it.
  • Reading inspectionally becomes very necessary at this point. So, both inspectional and analytical reading come as a part of syntopical reading.
  • Inspectional reading helps us to give idea of our subject so that our subsequent analytical reading is productive, and helps cut down our bibliography to a reasonable size.
    • You need to know how to read some books faster than others.
  • We aren’t concerned about author’s questions when reading syntopically. It’s about us and our concerns.
  • Everything we read must try to lighten up our ignorance about the question we have asked ourselves.
  • But we must also agree that an adequate understanding of the problem isn’t always available until we have inspected many of the books from our original list.
  • Unless you know what books to read, you cannot read syntopically, but unless you can read syntopically, you do not know what to read.
    • Asking for help with someone familiar with it might also turn out to be a hindrance than of help.
    • For this reason, syntopicon is a great tool.
  • Goal

    • To properly formulate answer to a question on a broad topic
  • Difficulty

    If you are just trying to read about love, it’s hard to skip any material at all.

    Stones are said to love the center of the earth. The upward motion of fire is called a function of its love. The attraction of iron filings to a magnet is described as an effect of love. Tracts have been written on the love life of amoebae, paramecia, snails, and ants, to say nothing of most of the so-called higher animals, who are said to love their masters as well as one another. When we come to human beings, we discover that authors speak and write of their love for men, women, a woman, a man, children, themselves, mankind, money, art, domesticity, principles, a cause, an occupation or profession, adventure, security, ideas, a country life, loving itself, a beefsteak, or wine. In certain learned treatises, the motions of the heavenly bodies are said to be inspired by love; in others, angels and devils are differentiated by the quality of their love. And of course God is said to be Love.
    

    What kind of love are you trying to understand becomes a pressing question now. Then, as you narrow down, love can sometimes be attributed as just desire by some writers, mystical by others, and logical by another group. They can completely disagree about what love is. Even if you dissect deep enough, there are still plenty of questions as to how it changes, differences between motherly love and child’s love, etc.

  • Tools to employ

    • Read more than one book
    • Use a syntopicon
    • Take help from one already familiar on the subject
    • Library
    • Reference section of books
  • Rules

    1. Finding the relevant passages. Identifying the relevant books as well as relevant passages at the same time might be difficult. As we start our reading list, it’s easier to make these two steps coalesce.
    2. Bringing the authors to terms. Identifying the different wording but same terminology used by different authors into one that you choose. It means you are forcing author to use your language. If it coincides, we should tend that as merely accidental. So, it’s in one way like translation.
    3. Getting the questions clear. We need to frame a set of neutral questions to shed light on our problem, to which each of our authors will try to answer. Also, we have to accept that an author might not give answer to any of our questions. Sometimes, we may have to implicitly tell the answers if not stated explicitly.
      • Questions should be put in an order that’s helpful for our investigation. The first questions usually have to do with existence or character of the phenomenon or idea we are investigating. Final set of questions might have to do with consequences of answers to previous questions.
    4. Defining the issues
      • Not all authors agree or disagree on all or some points that they have made in their book. There could well be more than two alternative answers given by different authors.
      • Differences in answers can be ascribed to differences in conception of question or different views on the subject.
      • Sorting and arranging of controversies, as well as constituent issues, is essential.
    5. Analyzing the discussion
      • Is it true? What of it?
      • Truth is to be found in the conflict of opposing answers, many of which will have persuasive evidence and convincing reasons to support them.
      • Thus, we must ask questions in a certain order, and be able to defend that order.
      • More general issues should precede less general ones, and relations among them should be clearly indicated.
      • We must be able to point to the texts in the books examined that support our classification of answers.
      • Now, it may result in a detailed question that may lay groundwork for a complete work in itself. That’s how an original thinker is born.
      • We need to be very objective else it’s just a mere voice in the discussion. It should be “Dialectial Objectivity”.

Special Notes on Reading Specific Books

Practical Books

  • Practical books can never solve the practical problems with which they are concerned. It can be solved by action alone.
  • Practical books can state rules, but can state principles that underlie the rules to make them digestable.
    • Principles generally are theoretical in sense, even for a practical book.
  • Presentation of rules OR Principles that generate rules. eg. Driver’s manual vs Books in Economics and Politics.
  • There will always be mixture of oratory and propaganda in practical books. It will try to persuade you. We just need to make sure that we identify its oratory. We don’t need to be emotionally restraint, but just enough to not take bad deals.
  • “Personality” of author is more important in these cases than theoretical books. e.g. Knowing about Greek society at the time of Aristotle can put us in light of his comments on slavery.
  • Are the two most important questions in case of practical books.
  • This question changes to Is it the best way to seek it?

Rule Book

  • Look for imperative rather than declarative sentence, which is a rule.
  • If rules follow principles, significance of principles found in rules is in the actions they recommend.
  • We not only need to figure out whether rules can be derived from principles, but also figure how they should be applied in practice.

Imaginative Literature

  • Though it’s hard to define rules to read imaginative literature, skill to read such books is more widely possessed.
  • Many of us know that we liked a novel, but can’t give a clear account on why we liked it.
    • Those who cannot say what they liked about a book haven’t dived beyond the obvious surface of the book.
  • Beauty is harder to analyze than truth, and such books are more for pleasure, than for teaching.
  • Know that author tries to maximize the latent ambiguities of words for richness.
  • Metaphors and multiplicity of meanings can lead to an entire different outcome which is perfectly fine.
  • Rules on how to not read it:
    • Don’t try to resist the effect that the work has on you. We must allow it to move us, let it do whatever it wants to do on us.
    • Don’t look for terms, propositions, or arguments in imaginative literature.
    • Don’t criticize fiction by standards of truth or with standards of communication of knowledge.
  • The truth of a imaginative literature is it’s verisimilitude.
  • Rules are not to spoil enjoyment of a novel or a play, but to enrich pleasure by knowledge of sources of delight.
  • For the final question, “What of it” is irrelevant to reading of stories and poems. But some stories like “Animal Farm” etc. are powerful attacks on totalitarianism. So, they can lead to action, but isn’t necessary that they do so.
  • Fiction is important because it has the power to move the unconscious.

Rules

  • Structural Rules

    • Classify a work of imaginative literature according to its kind. e.g. Play, Novel, Poem
    • Must grasp the unity of the whole work. e.g. For story it’s the plot.
    • Need to know where it begins, and where it comes out at.
  • Outlining

    • Elements of fiction are its episodes and incidents, its characters, and their thoughts, speeches, feelings, and actions.
    • Terms are connected in propositions. Elements of fiction are connected by the background against which they stand out in.
    • Just like we move from evidence to conclusion in expository book, we after being acquainted with characters join them in the imaginary world, and live it in imaginative literature. The unraveling of the plot is the dynamic connection.
  • Critical Rules

    • Don’t criticize until you fully appreciate what the author has tried to make you experience. Criticism is only applied to what he makes of it, not what we make of it. We cannot change the world he create as we like, and criticize it.

Suggestions for stories

  • Read it quickly and with total immersion. Read in one sitting if possible so that the unity of plot doesn’t escape you.
  • Try as hard as you can to live in his world, not yours. Don’t judge unless you have lived it completely to your ability.
  • Terms of story are its characters and incidents. This doesn’t mean remembering every character and every relation. We need to understand the action of main characters.
  • A story is like life itself; in life, we do not expect to understand every events as they occur, at least with total clarity, but looking back on them, we understand.
  • As a story’s finished, all speculations are meaningless. Preludes are ridiculous. Life goes on, but the story does not. We have to accept it and move on.
  • Fictions do make us empathize with some character, and that’s most likely the reason we like any story. We suspect life as we know is unjust. Our stories, by doing a just ending, makes it extremely satisfying to us. Even with high tragedy, we are convinced that our hero comes to understand his fate even though he may not deserve it. This is the kind of satisfying remark to good stories.
  • “As long as man is man, they will go on satisfying him, giving him something that he needs to have—a belief in justice and understanding and the allaying of anxiety.”

On Epics

  • A long epic poem is apparently the most difficult thing a man can write.
  • Epics are hard to read because they are written in verse. They demand a lot of attention, involvement, and imagination on the parts of the reader.
  • e.g. Iliad and Odyssey of Homer, Dante’s Divine Comedy, Milton’s Paradise Lost, and Virgil’s Aeneid.

Suggestions for plays

  • Play too is story, added with the fact that we have to be more active to create the background, which is not available in play like in novels.
  • Play can’t be completely apprehended without acting on stage. So, we as readers need to supply that dimension.
  • The final question about understanding a play is to try directing the play. Try to make characters say the line, put emphasis on words, see the climax in action.
  • Shaw’s plays were written not just to be acted, but to be read as well. Aristophanes plays had leading actor step out of character every now and then to deliver something for the audience like political speech.
  • Read puzzling pieces out aloud with expression.

On Tragedy

  • The tragedies of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripedes, the plays of Shakespeare, Molière’s comedies, the works of a very few moderns—are very great indeed, for they contain within them some of the deepest and richest insights men have ever expressed in words.
  • The first advice while reading a tragedy is to remember that the essence of tragedy is time, or rather lack of it. None of the Greek tragedies wouldn’t have resolved simply if there was enough time.
  • The second advice is that we should imagine words being spoken by people of enormous stature.

On Lyric Poetry

  • Poetry is kind of spontaneous overflowing of the personality.
  • A good poem can be worked at, re-read, and thought about over and over for the rest of your life. You will never stop finding new delights in there.
  • Great poems can grow alongside us, thus unlocking something that we had never seen before during our last read.
  • The first rule is to read it without stopping, whether you think you understand it or not.
  • The second rule is to read it again but out loud.
  • Know whether the words pop out because of the rhythm, repetition, or a sequence. This helps us discover our understanding of the poem.
  • Good lyrics describe conflict. Sometimes, it is just implied not stated. Conflict can be between people, images, or ideas. e.g. Love and Time, Life and Death, Transience and Eternity of Beauty etc.

On Reading History

  • History as written restricts us to essentially narrative accounts, thus a story.
  • History is implicit in time, whether they’re ordered or not.
  • Like law assumes that recent accounts of eyewitnesses can’t be true, it’s a foolish excuse to expect that out of historical narratives.
  • Historian doesn’t make up the facts, still history is more close to fiction than to science.
  • It’s essential to recognize which way the historian we are reading is operating. Thus, we must read multiple account if we really want to understand an event or period.
  • Example of how impactful a piece of history is:
Let us take the example of Thucydides. You may be aware that he wrote the only major contemporary history of the Peloponnesian War at the end of the fifth century B.C. In a sense, there is nothing to check his work against. What, then, can we expect to learn from it?
Greece is now a tiny country; a war that occurred there twenty-five centuries ago can have little real effect on our life today. Everyone who fought in it is long dead, and the specific things for which they fought are long dead, too. The victories are now meaningless, and the defeats without pain. The cities that were taken and lost have crumbled into dust. Indeed, if we stop to think of it, almost all that remains of the Peloponnesian War is Thucydides’ account of it.
Yet that account is still important. For Thucydides’ story —we might as well use that word—has had an influence on the subsequent history of man. Leaders in later eras read Thucydides. When they found themselves in situations that even faintly approximated that of the tragically divided Greek city-states, they compared their own position to that of Athens or Sparta. They used Thucydides as an excuse and a justification, and even as a pattern of conduct. The result was that by ever so little, perhaps, but perceptibly, the history of the world was changed by the view held of a small portion of it by Thucydides in the fifth century B.C
Thus we read Thucydides not because he described perfectly what happened before he wrote his book, but because he to a certain extent determined what happened after.
  • Read history to learn the way men act in all times and places, especially now.
  • While reading history book, we need to precisely know what it is about and what it is not about.
  • How an author outlines history book e.g. based on decade, based on wars, based on other rubrics of his own choosing is an important question to be answered while reading history.
  • We expect a historian to be informed by reading other sources on it. We can then identify misuse of sources etc.
  • History not only is account, but changes other pieces of history that follow it, by result of their effects in later time.
  • History is for giving us direction of practical, political action.

Reading biographies and autobiographies

  • Definitive biographies cannot be written about living persons.
  • Since the ability to gather materials is different from the talent for shaping those into a good book, definitive biographies aren’t always easy to read.
  • “Boswell’s Life of Johnson” is interesting in that regards.
  • An authorized biography tries to show everything in the best light possible, thus not that great either.
  • We want biographies to be as accurate as the ycan be.
  • Some good biographies : Izaak Walton’s Lives of his friends, the poets John Donne and George Herbert, John Tyndall’s account of his friend Michael Faraday in Faraday the Discoverer. Plutarch’s Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans are didactic with a moral purpose.
Incidentally, Plutarch’s is another historical work that has exercised a profound influence on subsequent history. For example, just as Plutarch shows Alexander the Great modeling his own life on that of Achilles (whose life he learned about from Homer), so many later conquerors have tried to model their lives on that of Plutarch’s Alexander.
  • Everyone has secrets they cannot divulge or some illusions about themselves. Every book is tainted by the character of the author in some respect.
  • Read as many biographies as you can if you really want to know about the person, including his own autobiography if there is one.

Reading about current events

  • As much as we cannot know about veracity of history, we cannot know facts even for the current events.
  • Reporters tell stories, and mostly they are parts of fact, not fact itself.
  • Ask these questions because it always matters what reporter’s mind is at when reading about current events:
    1. What does the author want to prove?
    2. Whom does he want to convince?
    3. What special knowledge does he assume?
    4. What special language does he use?
    5. Does he really know what he is talking about
  • Try to know whom the author is trying to convince. Do you fall in that category? If you don’t belong to the audience for which it is intended, you may not want to read it.
  • Know what “opinions” and “prejudices” the author has.
  • Keep note of special trigger words that author is using to trigger a certain reaction from us.
  • Be very aware while reading books and articles about current events. We don’t have to be this aware while reading Aristotle or Shakespeare.

A note on digests

  • Reading for information about understanding – how others have understood it.
  • A summary only functions well if it impelled us to read the original since it was merely informational.
  • The more succinct a digest is, the question of what’s left out becomes more critical. So, it can be very demanding and difficult to know what was left out.

On Reading Science and Literature

  • Today, science tends to be written by experts for experts.
  • Read the great scientific classics of our tradidion like Newton’s Principia Mathematica. These are read to understand the history and philosophy of science, not get contemporary knowledge in Science.
  • Scientific objectivity isn’t about not having a bias. It’s about honest confessions of bias beforehand.
  • Suggestions for reading classical scientific books:
    • Understand the presuppositions.
    • Look for inductive arguments primarily, but know that we may not follow the evidence for these because of the lack of expertise in the field.
  • Science needs new words to improve the language and the language needs new words to improve science as well.

Mathematics

  • Some psychologists think we have “symbol blindness” which might be the reason for being afraid of maths.
  • We learned our language twice: once by speaking and once by reading. For maths, it’s almost only writing.
  • So, the deal might be that we are puzzled at the elementary level in Maths. We need to learn its vocabulary, grammar, and syntax properly to understand treatises written with it.
  • The beauty of mathematics is that unlike we cannot truly comprehend each other’s emotions and relations, we can perfectly communicate what we can express in mathematical language.
  • Start with “Elements of Geometry” by Euclid to see how beautiful and satisfying maths can be.
  • Quod erat facendium ( What is required to do )
  • Quod erat demostradum ( What is required to prove )
  • The truth of the connection between postulates is what’s being proved.
  • Handling maths in scientific books

    1. Read elementary mathematics better than you think. Can start by reading classical Greek Mathematicians.
    2. Read from beginning to end – with pencil in hand – with a scratch pad. What seems difficult skip. It’s not necessary to read all proposition, construction problems, theorems, complicated stuff in detail, especially the first time.
    3. You can avoid diagrams if they trouble you.
    4. Think how difficult it would have been to communicate if there was no mathematics here. e.g. Galileo’s Two New Sciences.

On Reading Philosophy

  • Children ask amazing questions all the time. “Why are people”, “What makes the cat tick?”, “What’s the world’s first name?”, “Did God have a reason for creating the earth?”. The search for wisdom comes from a child’s mouth. Philosophy, according to Aristotle, begins in wonder. It begins in childhood, even if for most of us it stops there as well.
  • As we grow, our curiosity degrades in quality.
  • We must understand that the mind not agitated by good questions cannot appreciate the significance of even the best answers.
  • By telling a child there is no answer, even when there’s one, or demanding them to ask no more, we slowly poison their curiosity to ask only those questions what adults think are important.
    • Child will then start to think its impolite to be too inquisitive. Then and there, the questions start to switch from seeking understanding to seeking information.
  • Some good philosophical questions on being/existence:
    • What is the difference between existing and not existing?
    • What is common to all the things that do exist, and what are the properties of everything that does exist?
    • Are there different ways in which things can exist—different modes of being or existence?
    • Do some things exist only in the mind or for the mind, whereas others exist outside the mind, and whether or not they are known to us, or even knowable by us?
    • Does everything that exists exist physically, or are there some things that exist apart from material embodiment?
    • Do all things change, or is there anything that is immutable?
    • Does anything exist necessarily, or must we say that everything that does exist might not have existed?
    • Is the realm of possible existence larger than the realm of what actually does exist?
  • These questions start on the idea of becoming/non-becoming, but start a whole lot of other questions. About necessity and contingency; about the material and the immaterial; about the physical and the non-physical; about freedom and indeterminacy; about the nature and extent of human knowledge; about the freedom of the will etc.
  • There are two groups of questions:
    • Practical or Normative: Questions concerning good and evil, right and wrong, what’s to be done etc.
    • Theoretical or Speculative: Questions about being and becoming, have to do with what is or happens in the world
      • Metaphysical: Questions about being or existence. Work in the philosophy of nature.
      • Epistemology: Questions about our knowing anything, with the causes, extent, and limits of human knowledge, certainties and uncertainties with it etc.
  • Normative philosophy tend to seek goals like leading a good life, instituting a good society etc.
  • What is and what happens in the world OR What men ought to do or seek.
  • Questions about first order knowledge, about the content of our thinking when we try to answer first order questions.
  • These days most philosophers devote exclusively to second order questions because they feel like first order questions cannot be answered reasonably well. And they seek experts only opinions rather than populace these days.
  • Up to about 1930, philosophy books were written for general public. Hoped to be read by peers, but by intelligent folks as well.
  • In answering philosophical questions, there is only one method to employ. To think.
If your question were scientific, you would know that to answer it you would have to perform some kind of special research, either by way of developing an experiment to test your answer, or by way of observing a wide range of phenomena. If your question were historical, you would know that you would also have to perform research, although of a different kind. But there is no experiment that will tell you what all existing things have in common, precisely in respect to having existence. There are no special kinds of phenomena that you can observe, no documents that you can seek out and read, in order to find out what change is or why things change. All you can do is reflect upon the question. There is, in short, nothing to do but think.
  • So philosophers do think more profoundly about the common experience than rest of us have.
  • We need to understand what questions can a philosopher deal with, if that could instead be solved scientifically. Often times, philosophers don’t know that answer at the time of writing.
    • Example is how ancient philosophers asked about the difference between the matter of terrestrial and celestial bodies. Without telescope, they thought celestial bodies only changed in place. Until the discovery of a telescope, they didn’t know.

Common Exposition Methods Employed in Philosophy

  • Philosophical Dialogue

    • Adopted by Plato, in his Dialogues.
    • When the style is enriched by the high drama—some would say the high comedy—of the story of Socrates, it becomes enormously powerful.
    • But attempt at this by anyone except Plato had little success. Their dialogues are flat and dull, almost unreadable.
    • This is the way of simply keep asking questions.
  • Philosophical Treatise or Essay

    • Aristotle was Plato’s best pupil. He’s said to have written dialogues, but none has survived.
    • What survived are curiously difficult essays on different subjects. So, these can be notes taken by the students when they heard the master speak.
    • Immanuel Kant, though being influenced by Plato in philosophical sense, adopted Aristotle’s way of exposition.
    • There is a philosophical beginning, middle, and end.
  • Meeting of Objections

    • Developed in the Middle Ages and perfected by St. Thomas Aquinas in “Summa Theologica”.
    • Question raising and objection meeting.
    • Divided into parts, treatises, questions, and articles.
      • Question is posed. (Wrong) answer to it is given. Arguments are put forth in support of that wrong answer. Then they are countered by an authoritative text. The final answer is then given. Then reples to each of the arguments against each of the wrong answer.
    • This detailed recognition of conflicts, and reporting of different views is amazing.
    • At that time, philosophers should be prepared to defend their views in open public dispute.
  • Systemization of Philosophy

    • In 17th century, Descartes and Spinoza developed this style fascinated by the promised success of maths in organizing human knowledge about nature.
    • Tried giving same formal structure like Euclid did to geometry.
    • propositions, proofs, corollaries, lemmas etc.
    • Because of this, we can skip a great deal here like we can in Newton’s. But, we cannot do this with Aristotle’s or Kant’s.
  • Aphoristic Style

    • Adopted by Nietzsche in works like “Thus Spoke Zarathustra” and certain modern French philosophers.
    • The advantage of such style is that it is heuristic; the reader has more impression that more is being said than is actually said. So, it employs you to think as much as the philosophers. Hard to criticize.

Suggestions to read Philosophy

  • Discover the questions it is trying to answer.
  • Look for the controlling principle. It might sometime take years and many readings to discover this. The discovery that we come ono our own will be much more valuable than someone else’s ideas. Look if they agree throughout in their controlling principle.
    • For Plato it is that conversation about philosophical subjects is perhaps the most important of all human activities. He may not state it directly but there are traces of that in the writing.
    • In Ethics, Aristotle talks about a wide variety of things: happiness, habit, virtue, pleasure etc. but the controlling principle is that happiness is the whole of good, not the highest good.
    • In Kant’s, limitation of mind is a controlling principle.
  • In philosophy, we need to pay closest attention to philosopher’s principles. What he marks as self-evident. Some are drawn directly from experience.
  • “A philosopher, faced with a problem, can do nothing but think about it. A reader, faced with a philosophical book, can do nothing but read it—which means, as we know, thinking about it. There are no other aids except the mind itself.”
  • There’s utility in reading the works of other great philosophers who have dealt with same problems as your author. The philosophers carry a long conversation with each other in history of thought.
  • When philosophers disagree, it shouldn’t trouble us. If it is persistent disagreement, it may point to perhaps a great unsolved , or insoluble problem. Secondly, disagreements of others are relatively unimportant because we have to make up our own mind. We must answer for ourselves.

On Theology

  • Natural Theology and Dogmatic Theology
  • e.g. To find causation, you need to stop somewhere. Aristotle called this uncaused cause an unmoved mover.
  • Dogmatic Theology differs from Philosophy because the first principles are articles of faith adhered beforehand.
  • We should read dogmatic theology by accepting the first principles of author as true while reading the book.
A note on dogmatic theology:
The first mistake many readers make is to refuse to accept, even temporarily, the articles of faith that are the first principles of the author. As a result, the reader continues to struggle with these first principles, never really paying attention to the book itself. The second mistake is to assume that, because the first principles are dogmatic, the arguments based on them, the reasoning that they support, and the conclusions to which they lead are all dogmatic in the same way.
  • Reading canonical books like “Holy Bible” is similar to how a fledgling lawyer, in order to pass his bar exam, must read certain texts in a certain way to attain a perfect score.
  • So, we take their ways first to read it in their sense.
A note on dogmatic reader who's reading the canonical book:
He reads essentially without freedom; but in return for this he gains a kind of satisfaction that is possibly never obtained when reading other books.

On Reading Social Science

  • Aim is to create artificial models of society that allow us to explore social consequences of technological innovation.
  • The ease of reading social science is that we can add any term with society from “aberrant” to “zymotic”, and that sounds well. And we do likely have strong opinions already without much reading on these topics. The same fact makes the topic difficult to read. The very familiarity of terms and propositions in social science is an obstacle to understanding.
    • e.g. GNP ( Gross National Product ) can be used misleadingly without an understanding of what it means.
  • It is one thing to define a circle or an isosceles triangle; it is quite another to define an economic depression or mental health.
  • Much social science is a mixture of science, philosophy, history, and some fiction as well. The mixture changes which is the major issue.
  • To even answer what kind of book is this, it’s difficult. Though it is the most difficult, its essence cannot be negated.
  • And to answer the last question “What of it” is difficult because it is one thing to agree on the conclusions, and another to change your already owned opinions on it.
  • In social science, you have to read not one book but many to keep up with it. They update it with revised versions, new works come up rapidly rendering old ones obsolete.
  • It needs to be read syntopically.

Dialectical Objectivity

  • Looking at all sides and take no sides. A reader will fail to do that, but must try.
Perfect dialectical objectivity is not guaranteed by avoiding explicit judgments on the truth of conflicting opinions. Partiality can intrude in a variety of subtle ways—by the manner in which arguments are summarized, by shades of emphasis and neglect, by the tone of a question or the color of a passing remark, and by the order in which the various different answers to key questions are presented.
  • So, a reader must constantly refer back to the actual text, read relevant passages over and over, quote that while presenting that to a wider audience.
  • The language though when presenting the idea must not be author’s. It should accompany the quoted text, so that reader can judge for himself whether the interpretation of the author is correct.

Exercise in Syntopical Reading

The author of this book did do a full exercise to show how it’s done. It’s in “The Idea of Progress”

  1. Produce a list of works, a massive bibliography, to be examined for relevant passages. (450)
    • Done by inspectional reading of several times for many books. Educated guesses.
    • Progress in Titles.
    • Mostly focused on expository works. Not fictional or poetical works.
    • Including novels, plays, and poems in syntopical reading is difficult because:
      • Characters rarely take clear positions.
      • Backbone or Essence of the story is plot.
      • Hard to seperate irony and humor from logical undertaking.
    • Understanding what authors mean by progress and making a clear statement from our side.
      • Majority is “Likeable movement forward in time”. So, rather than a neutral movement in time, we decide to choose a favorable movement. And those who just care about movement become minority now.
  2. Now, we define the questions to which we expect authors to give answers on:
    • Does progress occur in history?
    • Is it a fact that general course of movement is in the direction of improvement?
  3. We also need to define possible answers to this, but must recognize different ways of saying one answer.
    • Yes
    • No
    • We cannot know
  4. Find out sub-ordinate issues even between authors who have a same answer. In this case, further questions can be:
    • Is progress necessary, or is it contingent on other occurences?
    • Will progress continue indefinitely, or will it eventually come to an end or “plateau out”?
    • Is there progress in human nature as well as in human institutions —in the human animal itself, or merely in the external conditions of human life?
  5. Even among progress authors, we can dive deep into the respects in which progress occurs. Identification of key respects in which they believe that progress occurs:
    • Knowledge
    • Technological
    • Economic
    • Political
    • Moral
    • Fine Arts

Book Recommendations

Poetry

  1. Palgrave’s The Golden Treasury and The Oxford Book of English Verse for Poetry.
  2. Mark Van Doren’s Introduction to Poetry

Great Books

  1. Iliad by Homer
  2. Odyssey by Homer
  3. The Old Testament
  4. Aeschylus (c. 525-456 B.C.) Tragedies
  5. Sophocles (c. 495-406 B.C.) Tragedies
  6. Herodotus (c. 484-425 B.C.) History (of the Persian Wars)
  7. Euripides (c. 485-406 B.C.) Tragedies (esp. Medea, Hippolytus, The Bacchae)
  8. Thucydides (c. 460-400 B.C.) History of the Peloponnesian War
  9. Hippocrates (c. 460-377? B.C.) Medical writings
  10. Aristophanes (c. 448-380 B.C.) Comedies (esp. The Clouds, The Birds, The Frogs)
  11. Plato (c. 427-347 B.C.) Dialogues (esp. The Republic, Symposium, Phaedo, Meno, Apology, Phaedrus, Protagoras, Gorgias, Sophist, Theaetetus)
  12. Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) Works (esp. Organon, Physics, Metaphysics, On the Soul, The Nichomachean Ethics, Politics, Rhetoric, Poetics)
  13. Epicurus (c. 341-270 B.C.) Letter to Herodotus Letter to Menoeceus
  14. Euclid (fl.c. 300 B.C.) Elements (of Geometry)
  15. Archimedes (c. 287-212 B.C.) Works (esp. On the Equilibrium of Planes, On Floating Bodies, The Sand-Reckoner)
  16. Apollonius of Perga (fl.c. 240 B.C.) On Conic Sections
  17. Cicero (106-43 B.C.) Works (esp. Orations, On Friendship, On Old Age)
  18. Lucretius (c. 95-55 B.C.) On the Nature of Things
  19. Virgil (70-19 B.C.) Works
  20. Horace (65-8 B.C.) Works (esp. Odes and Epodes, The Art of Poetry)
  21. Livy (59 B.C.-A.D. 17) History of Rome
  22. Ovid (43 B.C.-A.D.17) Works (esp. Metamorphoses)
  23. Plutarch (c. 45-120) Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans Moralia
  24. Tacitus (c. 55-117) Histories Annals, AgricolaGermania
  25. Nicomachus of Gerasa (ft.c. 100 A.D.) Introduction to Arithmetic
  26. Epictetus (c. 60-120) Discourses, Encheiridion (Handbook)
  27. Ptolemy (c. 100-178; fl. 127-151) Almagest
  28. Lucian (c. 120-c. 190) Works (esp. The Way to Write History, The True History, The Sale of Creeds)
  29. Marcus Aurelius (121-180) Meditations
  30. Galen (c. 130-200) On the Natural Faculties
  31. The New Testament
  32. Plotinus (205-270) The Enneads
  33. St. Augustine (354-430) Works (esp. On the Teacher,*Confessions, *The City of God,*Christian Doctrine)
  34. The Song of Roland (12th century?)
  35. The Nibelungenlied (13th century) (The Völsunga Saga is the Scandinavian version of the same legend.)
  36. The Saga of Burnt Njal
  37. St. Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225-1274) Summa Theologica
  38. Dante Alighieri (1265-1321) Works (esp. The New Life, On Monarchy, The Divine Comedy)
  39. Geoffrey Chaucer (c. 1340-1400) Works Troilus and Criseyde, Canterbury Tales)
  40. Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) Notebooks
  41. Niccolò Machiavelli (1469-1527) The Prince, Discourses on the First Ten Books of Livy
  42. Desiderius Erasmus (c. 1469-1536) The Praise of Folly
  43. Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543) On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres
  44. Sir Thomas More (c. 1478-1535) Utopia
  45. Martin Luther (1483-1546) Three Treatises, Table-Talk
  46. François Rabelais (c. 1495-1553) Gargantua and Pantagruel
  47. John Calvin (1509-1564) Institutes of the Christian Religion
  48. Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592) Essays
  49. William Gilbert (1540-1603) On the Loadstone and Magnetic Bodies
  50. Miguel de Cervantes (1547-1616) Don Quixote
  51. Edmund Spenser (c. 1552-1599) Prothalamion, The Faërie Oueene
  52. Francis Bacon (1561-1626) Essays, Advancement of Learning, Novum Organum, New Atlantis
  53. William Shakespeare (1564-1616) Works
  54. Galileo Galilei (1564-1642) The Starry Messenger, Dialogues Concerning Two New Sciences
  55. Johannes Kepler (1571-1630) Epitome of Copemican Astronomy, Concerning the Harmonies of the World
  56. William Harvey (1578-1657) On the Motion of the Heart and Blood in Animals, On the Circulation of the Blood, On the Generation of Animals
  57. Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) The Leviathan
  58. René Descartes (1596-1650) Rules for the Direction of the Mind, Discourse on Method, Geometry, Meditations on First Philosophy
  59. John Milton (1608-1674) Works(esp. *the minor poems,*Areopagitica,*Paradise Lost,*Samson Agonistes)
  60. Molière (1622-1673) Comedies (esp. The Miser, The School for Wives, The Misanthrope, The Doctor in Spite of Himself, Tartuffe)
  61. Blaise Pascal (1623-1662) The Provincial Letters, Pensées, Scientific treatises
  62. Christiaan Huygens (1629-1695) Treatise on Light
  63. Benedict de Spinoza (1632-1677) Ethics
  64. John Locke (1632-1704) Letter Concerning Toleration, “Of Civil Government” (second treatise in Two Treatises on Government), Essay Concerning Human Understanding Thoughts Concerning Education
  65. Jean Baptiste Racine (1639-1699) Tragedies (esp. Andromache, Phaedra)
  66. Isaac Newton (1642-1727) Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, Optics
  67. Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz (1646-1716) Discourse on Metaphysics, New Essays Concerning Human Understanding, Monadology
  68. Daniel Defoe (1660-1731) Robinson Crusoe
  69. Jonathan Swift (1667-1745) A Tale of a Tub Journal to Stella, Gulliver’s Travels A Modest Proposal
  70. William Congreve (1670-1729) The Way of the World
  71. George Berkeley (1685-1753) Principles of Human Knowledge
  72. Alexander Pope (1688-1744) Essay on Criticism, Rape of the LockEssay on Man
  73. Charles de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu (1689-1755) Persian Letters
  74. Charles de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu, continued Spirit of Laws
  75. Voltaire (1694-1778) Letters on the English, Candide, Philosophical Dictionary
  76. Henry Fielding (1707-1754) Joseph Andrews Tom Jones
  77. Samuel Johnson (1709-1784) The Vanity of Human Wishes, Dictionary, Rasselas, The Lives of the Poets (esp. the essays on Milton and Pope)
  78. David Hume (1711-1776) Treatise of Human Nature, Essays Moral and Political, An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding
  79. Jean Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778) On the Origin of Inequality, On Political Economy Emile, The Social Contract
  80. Laurence Sterne (1713-1768) Tristram Shandy, A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy
  81. Adam Smith (1723-1790) The Theory of the Moral Sentiments, Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
  82. Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) Critique of Pure Reason, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals, Critique of Practical Reason, The Science of Right, Critique of Judgment, Perpetual Peace
  83. Edward Gibbon (1737-1794) The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire Autobiography
  84. James Boswell (1740-1795) Journal (esp. London Journal), Life of Samuel Johnson Ll.D.
  85. Antoine Laurent Lavoisier (1743-1794) Elements of Chemistry
  86. John Jay (1745-1829), James Madison (1751-1836), and Alexander Hamilton (1757-1804) Federalist Papers

(together with the *Articles of Confederation, the * Constitution of the United States, and the * Declaration of Independence)

  1. Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832) Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation Theory of Fictions
  2. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749-1832) Faust, Poetry and Truth
  3. Jean Baptiste Joseph Fourier (1768-1830) Analytical Theory of Heat
  4. Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831) Phenomenology of Spirit, Philosophy of Right, Lectures on the Philosophy of History
  5. William Wordsworth (1770-1850) Poems (esp. Lyrical Ballads, Lucy poems, sonnets; The Prelude)
  6. Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1772-1834) Poems (esp. “Kubla Khan,” Rime of the Ancient Mariner)
  7. Samuel Taylor Coleridge Biographia Literaria
  8. Jane Austen (1775-1817) Pride and Prejudice Emma
  9. Karl von Clausewitz (1780-1831) On War
  10. Stendhal (1783-1842) The Red and the BlackThe Charterhouse of ParmaOn Love
  11. George Gordon, Lord Byron (1788-1824) Don Juan
  12. Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860) Studies in Pessimism
  13. Michael Faraday (1791-1867) Chemical History of a Candle*Experimental Researches in Electricity
  14. Charles Lyell (1797-1875) Principles of Geology
  15. Auguste Comte (1798-1857) The Positive Philosophy
  16. Honoré de Balzac (1799-1850) Père Goriot Eugénie Grandet
  17. Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882) Representative Men, Essays, Journal
  18. Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-1864) The Scarlet Letter
  19. Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-1859) Democracy in America
  20. John Stuart Mill (1806-1873) A System of Logic, On Liberty, Representative Government, Utilitarianism
  21. John Stuart Mill, continued The Subjection of Women Autobiography
  22. Charles Darwin (1809-1882) The Origin of Species, The Descent of Man Autobiography
  23. Charles Dickens (1812-1870) Works (esp. Pickwick Papers, David Copperfield, Hard Times)
  24. Claude Bernard (1813-1878) Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine
  25. Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) Civil Disobedience Waiden
  26. Karl Marx (1818-1883) Capital (together with the * Communist Manifesto)
  27. George Eliot (1819-1880) Adam Bede Middlemarch
  28. Herman Melville (1819-1891) Moby Dick Billy Budd
  29. Fyodor Dostoevsky (1821-1881) Crime and Punishment The Idiot, The Brothers Karamazov
  30. Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880) Madame Bovary Three Stories
  31. Henrik Ibsen (1828-1906) Plays (esp. Hedda Gabler, A Doll’s House, The Wild Duck)
  32. Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910) War and Peace Anna Karenina What Is Art? Twenty-three Tales
  33. Mark Twain (1835-1910) The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn The Mysterious Stranger
  34. William James (1842-1910) The Principles of Psychology The Varieties of Religious Experience Pragmatism

Essays in Radical Empiricism

  1. Henry James (1843-1916) The American The Ambassadors
  2. Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche (1844-1900) Thus Spoke Zarathustra,Beyond Good and Evil,The Genealogy of Morals,The Will to Power
  3. Jules Henri Poincaré (1854-1912) Science and Hypothesis Science and Method
  4. Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) The Interpretation of Dreams,Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis, Civilization and Its Discontents, New Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis
  5. George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950) Plays (and Prefaces) (esp. Man and Superman, Major Barbara, Caesar and Cleopatra, Pygmalion, Saint Joan)
  6. Max Planck (1858-1947) Origin and Development of the Quantum Theory Where Is Science Going? Scientific Autobiography
  7. Henri Bergson (1859-1941) Time and Free Will Matter and Memory Creative Evolution, The Two Sources of Morality and Religion
  8. John Dewey (1859-1952) How We Think Democracy and Education Experience and Nature Logic, the Theory of Inquiry
  9. Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947) An Introduction to Mathematics Science and the Modern World, The Aims of Education and Other Essays Adventures of Ideas
  10. George Santayana (1863-1952) The Life of Reason Skepticism and Animal Faith Persons and Places
  11. Nikolai Lenin (1870-1924) The State and Revolution
  12. Marcel Proust (1871-1922) Remembrance of Things Past
  13. Bertrand Russell (1872-1970) The Problems of Philosophy, The Analysis of Mind, An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth, Human Knowledge; Its Scope and Limits
  14. Thomas Mann (1875-1955) The Magic Mountain Joseph and His Brothers
  15. Albert Einstein (1879-1955) The Meaning of Relativity, On the Method of Theoretical Physics, The Evolution of Physics (with L. Inf eld)
  16. James Joyce (1882-1941) “The Dead” in Dubliners
  17. James Joyce, continued Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Ulysses
  18. Jacques Maritain (1882-      ) Art and Scholasticism, The Degrees of Knowledge, The Rights of Man and Natural Law, True Humanism
  19. Franz Kafka (1883-1924      ) The Trial The Castle
  20. Arnold Toynbee (1889-      ) A Study of History Civilization on Trial
  21. Jean Paul Sartre (1905-      ) Nausea No Exit, Being and Nothingness

Highlights

Hence when we contrast active with passive reading, our purpose is, first, to call attention to the fact that reading can be more or less active, and second, to point out that the more active the reading the better.

The mistake here is to suppose that receiving communication is like receiving a blow or a legacy or a judgment from the court. On the contrary, the reader or listener is much more like the catcher in a game of baseball. Catching the ball is just as much an activity as pitching or hitting it. The pitcher or batter is the sender in the sense that his activity initiates the motion of the ball. The catcher or fielder is the receiver in the sense that his activity terminates it. Both are active, though the activities are different.

The analogy with writing and reading is almost perfect. The thing that is written and read, like the ball, is the passive object common to the two activities that begin and terminate the process.

If the book is completely intelligible to you from start to finish, then the author and you are as two minds in the same mold. The symbols on the page merely express the common understanding you had before you met.

Without external help of any sort, you go to work on the book. With nothing but the power of your own mind, you operate on the symbols before you in such a way that you gradually lift yourself from a state of understanding less to one of understanding more. Such elevation, accomplished by the mind working on a book, is highly skilled reading, the kind of reading that a book which challenges your understanding deserves.

Thus we can roughly define what we mean by the art of reading as follows: the process whereby a mind, with nothing to operate on but the symbols of the readable matter, and with no help from outside,* elevates itself by the power of its own operations. The mind passes from understanding less to understanding more.

The distinction between reading for information and reading for understanding is deeper than this. Let us try to say more about it. We will have to consider both goals of reading because the line between what is readable in one way and what must be read in the other is often hazy.

The first sense is the one in which we speak of ourselves as reading newspapers, magazines, or anything else that, according to our skill and talents, is at once thoroughly intelligible to us. Such things may increase our store of information, but they cannot improve our understanding, for our understanding was equal to them before we started.

The second sense is the one in which a person tries to read something that at first he does not completely understand. Here the thing to be read is initially better or higher than the reader.

Such communication between unequals must be possible, or else one person could never learn from another, either through speech or writing.

What are the conditions under which this kind of reading —reading for understanding—takes place? There are two.

First, there is initial inequality in understanding. The writer must be “superior” to the reader in understanding, and his book must convey in readable form the insights he possesses and his potential readers lack. Second, the reader must be able to overcome this inequality in some degree, seldom perhaps fully, but always approaching equality with the writer. To the extent that equality is approached, clarity of communication is achieved.

We do not want to give the impression that facts, leading to increased information, and insights, leading to increased understanding, are always easy to distinguish. And we would admit that sometimes a mere recital of facts can itself lead to greater understanding.

Our subject, then, is the art of reading good books when understanding is the aim you have in view.

Enlightenment is achieved only when, in addition to knowing what an author says, you know what he means and why he says

Being informed is prerequisite to being enlightened. The point, however, is not to stop at being informed.

Montaigne speaks of “an abecedarian ignorance that precedes knowledge, and a doctoral ignorance that comes after it.” The first is the ignorance of those who, not knowing their ABC’s, cannot read at all. The second is the ignorance of those who have misread many books.

The Greeks had a name for such a mixture of learning and folly which might be applied to the bookish but poorly read of all ages. They are all sophomores.

We can, however, gain knowledge without being taught. If this were not the case, and every teacher had to be taught what he in turn teaches others, there would be no beginning in the acquisition of knowledge.

Discovery stands to instruction as learning without a teacher stands to learning through the help of one. In both cases, the activity of learning goes on in the one who learns. It would be a mistake to suppose that discovery is active learning and instruction passive. There is no inactive learning, just as there is no inactive reading.

Similarly, although the teacher may help his student in many ways, it is the student himself who must do the learning. Knowledge must grow in his mind if learning is to take place.

The reason is that listening is learning from a teacher who is present—a living teacher—while reading is learning from one who is absent.

If you are puzzled by what he says, you can save yourself the trouble of thinking by asking him what he means. If, however, you ask a book a question, you must answer it yourself.

But if you are seeking an explanation, you have to understand it or nothing has been explained to you.

There are four levels of reading. They are here called levels rather than kinds because kinds, strictly speaking, are distinct from one another, whereas it is characteristic of levels that higher ones include lower ones.

The first level of reading we will call Elementary Reading.

In mastering this level, one learns the rudiments of the art of reading, receives basic training in reading, and acquires initial reading skills.

this level of reading is ordinarily learned in elementary school

At this level of reading, the question asked of the reader is “What does the sentence say?” That could be conceived as a complex and difficult question, of course. We mean it here, however, in its simplest sense.

second level of reading we will call Inspectional Reading

characterized by its special emphasis on time. When reading at this level, the student is allowed a set time to complete an assigned amount of reading

Still another name for this level might be skimming or pre-reading.

When reading at this level, your aim is to examine the surface of the book, to learn everything that the surface alone can teach you.

the question typically asked at this level is “What is the book about?” That is a surface question; others of a similar nature are “What is the structure of the book?” or “What are its parts?”

We do want to stress, however, that most people, even many quite good readers, are unaware of the value of inspectional reading. They start a book on page one and plow steadily through it, without even reading the table of contents. They are thus faced with the task of achieving a superficial knowledge of the book at the same time that they are trying to understand it. That compounds the difficulty.

The third level of reading we will call Analytical Reading.

Analytical reading is thorough reading, complete reading, or good reading—the best reading you can do. If inspectional reading is the best and most complete reading that is possible given a limited time, then analytical reading is the best and most complete reading that is possible given unlimited time.

Reading a book analytically is chewing and digesting it.

Analytical reading is preeminently for the sake of understanding.

fourth and highest level of reading we will call Syntopical Reading. It is the most complex and systematic type of reading of all. It makes very heavy demands on the reader, even if the materials he is reading are themselves relatively easy and unsophisticated

Another name for this level might be comparative reading.

When reading syntopically, the reader reads many books, not just one, and places them in relation to one another and to a subject about which they all revolve.

With the help of the books read, the syntopical reader is able to construct an analysis of the subject that may not be in any of the books. It is obvious, therefore, that syntopical reading is the most active and effortful kind of reading.

Stages of Learning to Read

The first stage is known by the term “reading readiness.” This begins, it has been pointed out, at birth, and continues normally until the age of about six or seven.

Reading readiness includes several different kinds of preparation for learning to read. Physical readiness involves good vision and hearing. Intellectual readiness involves a minimum level of visual perception such that the child can take in and remember an entire word and the letters that combine to form it. Language readiness involves the ability to speak clearly and to use several sentences in correct order. Personal readiness involves the ability to work with other children, to sustain attention, to follow directions, and the like.

Delaying the beginning of reading instruction beyond the reading readiness stage is not nearly so serious, despite the feelings of parents who may fear that their child is “backward” or is not “keeping up” with his peers.

In the second stage, children learn to read very simple materials. They usually begin, at least in the United States, by learning a few sight words, and typically manage to master perhaps three hundred to four hundred words by the end of the first year. Basic skills are introduced at this time, such as the use of context or meaning clues and the beginning sounds of words. By the end of this period pupils are expected to be reading simple books independently and with enthusiasm

It is incidentally worth observing that something quite mysterious, almost magical, occurs during this stage. At one moment in the course of his development the child, when faced with a series of symbols on a page, finds them quite meaningless. Not much later—perhaps only two or three weeks later-he has discovered meaning in them;

this discovery of meaning in symbols may be the most astounding intellectual feat that any human being ever performs—and most humans perform it before they are seven years old!

The third stage is characterized by rapid progress in vocabulary building and by increasing skill in “unlocking” the meaning of unfamiliar words through context clues.

They learn that reading, besides being something one does at school, is also something one can do on one’s own, for fun, to satisfy curiosity, or even to “expand one’s horizons.”

Finally, the fourth stage is characterized by the refinement and enhancement of the skills previously acquired.

This, the mature stage of reading, should be reached by young persons in their early teens. Ideally, they should continue to build on it for the rest of their lives.

To this day, most institutions of higher learning either do not know how to instruct students in reading beyond the elementary level, or lack the facilities and personnel to do so.

We say this despite the fact that a number of four-year and community colleges have recently instituted courses in speed reading, or in “effective” reading, or “competence” in reading. On the whole (though there are exceptions), these courses are remedial. They are designed to overcome various kinds of failures of the lower schools. They are not designed to take the student beyond the first level or to introduce him to the kinds and levels of reading that are the main subject of this book.

This, of course, should not be the case. A good liberal arts high school, if it does nothing else, ought to produce graduates who are competent analytical readers

good college, if it does nothing else, ought to produce competent syntopical readers. A college degree ought to represent general competence in reading such that a graduate could read any kind of material for general readers and be able to undertake independent research on almost any subject (for that is what syntopical reading, among other things, enables you to do

But, as we noted in Chapter 2, the levels of reading are cumulative. Thus, elementary reading is contained in inspectional reading, as, indeed, inspectional reading is contained in analytical reading, and analytical reading in syntopical reading.

Practically, this means that you cannot read on the inspectional level unless you can read effectively on the elementary level. You must be able to read an author’s text more or less steadily, without having to stop to look up the meaning of many words, and without stumbling over the grammar and syntax.

there are two types of inspectional reading

They are aspects of a single skill, but the beginning reader is well-advised to consider them as two different steps or activities. The experienced reader learns to perform both steps simultaneously, but for the moment we will treat them as if they were quite distinct.

Inspectional Reading I: Systematic Skimming or Pre-reading

First, you do not know whether you want to read the book. You do not know whether it deserves an analytical reading.

Second, let us assume—and this is very often the case-that you have only a limited time in which to find all this out.

In this case, what you must do is skim the book, or, as some prefer to say, pre-read it. Skimming or pre-reading is the first sublevel of inspectional reading.

The habit of skimming should not take much time to acquire. Here are some suggestions about how to do it.

  1. LOOK AT THE TITLE PAGE AND, IF THE BOOK HAS ONE, AT ITS PREFACE

Before completing this step you should have a good idea of the subject, and, if you wish, you may pause for a moment to place the book in the appropriate category in your mind. What pigeonhole that already contains other books does this one belong in?

  1. STUDY THE TABLE OF CONTENTS

use it as you would a road map before taking a trip

In fact, many authors spend a considerable amount of time in creating the table of contents, and it is sad to think their efforts are often wasted.

  1. CHECK THE INDEX if the book has one—most expository works do

Make a quick estimate of the range of topics covered and of the kinds of books and authors referred to. When you see terms listed that seem crucial, look up at least some of the passages cited.

  1. From your general and still rather vague knowledge of the book’s contents, LOOK NOW AT THE CHAPTERS THAT SEEM TO BE PIVOTAL TO ITS ARGUMENT. If these chapters have summary statements in their opening or closing pages, as they often do, read these statements carefully
  1. Finally, TURN THE PAGES, DIPPING IN HERE AND THERE, READING A PARAGRAPH OR TWO, SOMETIMES SEVERAL PAGES IN SEQUENCE, NEVER MORE THAN THAT.

You have now skimmed the book systematically; you have given it the first type of inspectional reading. You should know a good deal about the book at this point, after having spent no more than a few minutes, at most an hour, with it.

Think of yourself as a detective looking for clues to a book’s general theme or idea, alert for anything that will make it clearer. Heeding the suggestions we have made will help you sustain this attitude. You will be surprised to find out how much time you will save, pleased to see how much more you will grasp, and relieved to discover how much easier it all can be than you supposed

Inspectional Reading II: Superficial Reading

Approached in the right way, no book intended for the general reader, no matter how difficult, need be a cause for despair.

That rule is simply this: In tackling a difficult book for the first time, read it through without ever stopping to look-up or ponder the things you do not understand right away.

Pay attention to what you can understand and do not be stopped by what you cannot immediately grasp. Go right on reading past the point where you have difficulties in understanding, and you will soon come to things you do understand.

If you let yourself get stalled, if you allow yourself to be tripped up by any one of these stumbling blocks, you are lost

And even if you never go back, understanding half of a really tough book is much better than not understanding it at all, which will be the case if you allow yourself to be stopped by the first difficult passage you come to.

We were told to consult footnotes, scholarly commentaries, or other secondary sources to get help. But when these things are done prematurely, they only impede our reading, instead of helping it.

The tremendous pleasure that can come from reading Shakespeare, for instance, was spoiled for generations of high school students who were forced to go through Julius Caesar, As You Like It, or Hamlet, scene by scene, looking up all the strange words in a glossary and studying all the scholarly footnotes. As a result, they never really read a Shakespearean play. By the time they reached the end, they had forgotten the beginning and lost sight of the whole.

You will miss the forest for the trees. You will not be reading well on any level.

On Reading Speeds

The competent inspectional reader will accomplish them both quickly, no matter how long or difficult the book he is trying to read.

A good speed reading course should therefore teach you to read at many different speeds, not just one speed that is faster than anything you can manage now. It should enable you to vary your rate of reading in accordance with the nature and complexity of the material.

The obstacles that stand in the way of comprehension of a difficult book are not ordinarily, and perhaps never primarily, physiological or psychological. They arise because the reader simply does not know what to do when approaching a difficult —and rewarding—book. He does not know the rules of reading; he does not know how to marshal his intellectual resources for the task. No matter how quickly he reads, he will be no better off if, as is too often true, he does not know what he is looking for and does not know when he has found it.

Fixations and Regressions

The mind, that astounding instrument, can grasp a sentence or even a paragraph at a “glance”—if only the eyes will provide it with the information it needs.

The Problem of Comprehension

cannot comprehend a book without reading it analytically; analytical reading, as we have noted, is undertaken primarily for the sake of comprehension (or understanding

Summary of Inspectional Reading

Finally, do not try to understand every word or page of a difficult book the first time through. This is the most important rule of all; it is the essence of inspectional reading. Do not be afraid to be, or to seem to be, superficial. Race through even the hardest book. You will then be prepared to read it well the second time.

The Essence of Active Reading: The Four Basic Questions a Reader Asks

  1. WHAT IS THE BOOK ABOUT AS A WHOLE? You
  1. WHAT IS BEING SAID IN DETAIL, AND HOW?
  1. Is THE BOOK TRUE, IN WHOLE OR PART
  1. WHAT OF IT

Why does the author think it is important to know these things? Is it important to you to know them? And if the book has not only informed you, but also enlightened you, it is necessary to seek further enlightenment by asking what else follows, what is further implied or suggested.

The last question—What of it?—is probably the most important one in syntopical reading. Naturally, you will have to answer the first three questions before attempting the final one.

Inspectional reading tends to provide more accurate answers to the first two questions than to the last two, but it nevertheless helps with those also.

It is not the stretching that tires you, but the frustration of stretching unsuccessfully because you lack the skill to stretch effectively.

How to Make a Book Your Own

It is an old saying that you have to “read between the lines” to get the most out of anything. The rules of reading are a formal way of saying this. But we want to persuade you to “write between the lines,” too. Unless you do, you are not likely to do the most efficient kind of reading

Full ownership of a book only comes when you have made it a part of yourself, and the best way to make yourself a part of it—which comes to the same thing—is by writing in it.

Marking a book is literally an expression of your differences or your agreements with the author. It is the highest respect you can pay him.

There are all kinds of devices for marking a book intelligently and fruitfully. Here are some devices that can be used:

  1. UNDERLINING—
  1. VERTICAL LINES AT THE MARGIN—
  1. STAR, ASTERISK, OR OTHER DOODAD AT THE MARGIN—
  1. NUMBERS IN THE MARGIN—to indicate a sequence of points made by the author in developing an argument.
  1. NUMBERS OF OTHER PAGES IN THE MARGIN—to indicate where else in the book the author makes the same points, or points relevant to or in contradiction of those here marked
  1. CIRCLING OF KEY WORDS OR PHRASES—
  1. WRITING IN THE MARGIN, OR AT THE TOP OR BOTTOM OF THE PAGE—

That outline will be the measure of your understanding of the work; unlike a bookplate, it will express your intellectual ownership of the book.

The Three Kinds of Note-making

The questions answered by inspectional reading are: first, what kind of book is it? second, what is it about as a whole? and third, what is the structural order of the work whereby the author develops his conception or understanding of that general subject matter? You may and probably should make notes concerning your answers to these questions, especially if you know that it may be days or months before you will be able to return to the book to give it an analytical reading. The best place to make such notes is on the contents page, or perhaps on the title page, which are otherwise unused in the scheme we have outlined above.

Then, during an analytical reading, you will need to give answers to questions about the truth and significance of the book. The notes you make at this level of reading are, therefore, not structural but conceptual. They concern the author’s concepts, and also your own, as they have been deepened or broadened by your reading of the book.

What kind of notes do you make when you are giving several books a syntopical reading—when you are reading more than one book on a single subject? Again, such notes will tend to be conceptual; and the notes on a page may refer you not only to other pages in that book, but also to pages in other books.

For reasons that will become clear in Part Four, we prefer to call such notes dialectical. Since they are made concerning several books, not just one, they often have to be made on a separate sheet (or sheets) of paper.

Incidentally, not everyone understands that being an artist consists in operating according to rules. People point to a highly original painter or sculptor and say, “He isn’t following rules. He’s doing something entirely original, something that has never been done before, something for which there are no rules.” But they fail to see what rules it is that the artist follows. There are no final, unbreakable rules, strictly speaking, for making a painting or sculpture. But there are rules for preparing canvas and mixing paints and applying them, and for moulding clay or welding steel

From Many Rules to One Habit

In other words, you must learn to forget the separate acts in order to perform all of them, and indeed any of them, well. But in order to forget them as separate acts, you have to learn them first as separate acts. Only then can you put them together to become a good skier.

The multiplicity of the rules indicates the complexity of the one habit to be formed, not a plurality of distinct habits. The parts coalesce and telescope as each reaches the stage of automatic execution.

The beginning skier must think of physical acts that he can later forget and perform almost automatically. It is relatively easy to think of and be conscious of physical acts. It is much harder to think of mental acts, as the beginning analytical reader must do; in a sense, he is thinking about his own thoughts.

The Third Level of Reading: Analytical Reading

PIGEONHOLING A BOOK

The Importance of Classifying Books

RULE 1. YOU MUST KNOW WHAT KIND OF BOOK YOU ARE READING, AND YOU SHOULD KNOW THIS AS EARLY IN THE PROCESS AS POSSIBLE, PREFERABLY BEFORE YOU BEGIN TO READ

An expository book is one that conveys knowledge primarily, “knowledge” being construed broadly. Any book that consists primarily of opinions, theories, hypotheses, or speculations, for which the claim is made more or less explicitly that they are true in some sense, conveys knowledge in this meaning of knowledge and is an expository work.

Here, however, the problem is not to distinguish nonfiction from fiction, but to recognize that there are various kinds of expository books.

The kinds of information or enlightenment that a history and a philosophical work afford are not the same. The problems dealt with by a book on physics and one on morals are not the same, nor are the methods the writers employ in solving such different problems.

As we have already suggested, you do so by first inspecting the book—giving it an inspectional reading. You read the title, the subtitle, the table of contents, and you at least glance at the preface or introduction by the author and at the index. If the book has a dust jacket, you look at the publisher’s blurb. These are the signal flags the author waves to let you know which way the wind is blowing. It is not his fault if you will not stop, look, and listen.

What You Can Learn from the Title of a Book

We mention this common error because many think they know the title of the book, although few have actually ever read the title carefully and thought about what it means.

They did not see that if the book as a whole was titled Decline and Fall, then it might be assumed that the narrative would begin with the high point of the Roman Empire, and continue through to the end. Unconsciously, they had translated “decline and fall” into “rise and fall.” They were puzzled because there was no discussion of the Roman Republic, which ended a century and a half before the Age of the Antonines.

Obviously, the author thinks it is important for the reader to know the kind of book he is being given. That is why he goes to the trouble of making it plain in the preface, and usually tries to make his title—or at least his subtitle—descriptive.

You will not know the sense in which Euclid’s Elements of Geometry and William James’ Principles of Psychology are books of the same sort if you do not know that psychology and geometry are both sciences—and, incidentally, if you do not know that “elements” and “principles” mean much the same thing in these two titles (though not in general), nor will you further be able to distinguish them as different unless you know there are different kinds of science. Similarly, in the case of Aristotle’s Politics and Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, you can tell how these books are alike and different only if you know what a practical problem is, and what different kinds of practical problems there are.

Again, however, to group books as being of the same kind is not enough; to follow this first rule of reading you must know what that kind is. The title will not tell you, nor all the rest of the front matter, nor even the whole book itself sometimes, unless you have some categories you can apply to classify books intelligently.

Among expository works, we can further distinguish history from philosophy, and both from science and mathematics.

For the moment, we want to confine ourselves to one basic distinction, a distinction that applies across the board to all expository works. It is the distinction between theoretical and practical works.

Practical vs. Theoretical Books

If we polish the rough truth that is here being grasped, we come to the distinction between knowledge and action as the two ends a writer may have in mind.

They communicate knowledge, too, but always with a view to and an emphasis upon its application.

To make knowledge practical we must convert it into rules of operation. We must pass from knowing what is the case to knowing what to do about it if we wish to get somewhere.

This book is practical, not theoretical. Any guidebook is a practical book. Any book that tells you either what you should do or how to do it is practical.

Thus you see that the class of practical books includes all expositions of arts to be learned, all manuals of practice in any field, such as engineering or medicine or cooking, and all treatises that are conveniently classified as moral, such as books on economic, ethical, or political problems. We will later explain why this last group of books, properly called “normative,” constitutes a very special category of practical books

Thus, whether or not we agree with its conclusions, any such work is practical.

Similarly with a work on economics. Apart from reportorial, mathematical, or statistical studies of economic behavior, which are theoretical rather than practical, such works usually teach us how to organize our economic life, either as individuals or as societies or states, tell us what we should do and not do, and also inform us of the penalties involved if we do not do what we should. Again, we may disagree, but our disagreement does not make the book unpractical.

Immanuel Kant wrote two famous philosophical works, one called The Critique of Pure Reason, the other, The Critique of Practical Reason. The first is about what is and how we know it—not how to know it, but how we in fact do know it—as well as about what can and cannot be known. It is a theoretical book par excellence. The Critique of Practical Reason is about how men should conduct themselves and about what constitutes virtuous or right conduct.

Although every practical book is somewhat oratorical and hortatory, it does not follow that oratory and exhortation are coextensive with the practical. There is a difference between a political harangue and a treatise on politics, between economic propaganda and an analysis of economic problems. The Communist Manifesto is a piece of oratory, but Marx’s Capital is much more than that.

Sometimes you can detect that a book is practical by its title. If the title contains such phrases as “the art of” or “how to,” you can spot it at once. If the title names fields that you know are practical, such as ethics or politics, engineering or business, and in many cases economics, law, or medicine, you can classify the book fairly readily.

Questions about the validity of something are theoretical, whereas to raise questions about the end of anything, the purpose it serves, is practical.

practical book will soon betray its character by the frequent occurrence of such words as “should” and “ought,” “good” and “bad,” “ends” and “means.” The characteristic statement in a practical book is one that says that something should be done (or made); or that this is the right way of doing (or making) something; or that one thing is better than another as an end to be sought, or a means to be chosen. In contrast, a theoretical book keeps saying “is,” not “should” or “ought

For one thing, you will have to learn to mistrust them. You have to be suspicious in classifying books. We have noted that although economics is primarily and usually a practical matter, there are nevertheless books on economics that are purely theoretical.

Similarly, although understanding is primarily and usually a theoretical matter, there are books (most of them are terrible) that purport to teach you “how to think.”

You will find books that are partly of one sort and partly of another, such as Spinoza’s Ethics. It remains, nevertheless, to your advantage as a reader to detect the way an author approaches his problem.

The essence of history is narration. History is knowledge of particular events or things that not only existed in the past but also underwent a series of changes in the course of time. The historian narrates these happenings and often colors his narrative with comment on, or insight into, the significance of the events.

History is chronotopic. Chronos is the Greek word for time, topos the Greek word for place. History always deals with things that existed or events that occurred on a particular date and in a particular place. The word “chronotopic” can remind you of that.

There is even trouble with the very words “philosophy” and “science,” for they have been variously used. Aristotle called his book on Physics a scientific treatise, although according to current usage we should regard it as philosophical; and Newton titled his great work Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, though for us it is one of the masterpieces of science.

Philosophy is like science and unlike history in that it seeks general truths rather than an account of particular events, either in the near or distant past. But the philosopher does not ask the same questions as the scientist, nor does he employ the same kind of method to answer them.

In contrast, a philosophical book appeals to no facts or observations that lie outside the experience of the ordinary man.

philosopher refers the reader to his own normal and common experience for the verification or support of anything the writer has to say. Thus, Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding is a philosophical work in psychology, whereas many of Freud’s writings are scientific

The distinction proposed here is popularly recognized when we say that science is experimental or depends upon elaborate observational researches, whereas philosophy is merely armchair thinking.

however they may have arrived at the conclusions that they want to prove, they prove them in different ways, the scientist by pointing to the results of his special experiences, the philosopher by pointing to experiences that are common to all.

A narrative is a narrative, whether it be fact or fiction. The historian must write poetically, which means he must obey the rules for telling a good story. Whatever other excellences Locke’s Essay on Human Understanding or Newton’s Principia may have, neither is a good story.

Recognition of the need to see the structure of a book leads to the discovery of the second and third rules for reading any book.

second rule of analytical reading can be expressed as follows: RULE 2. STATE THE UNITY OF THE WHOLE BOOK IN A SINGLE SENTENCE, OR AT MOST A FEW SENTENCES (A SHORT PARAGRAPH

The third rule can be expressed as follows: RULE 3. SET FORTH THE MAJOR PARTS OF THE BOOK, AND SHOW HOW THESE ARE ORGANIZED INTO A WHOLE, BY BEING ORDERED TO ONE ANOTHER AND TO THE UNITY OF THE WHOLE.

You must also know how it is many, not a many that consists of a lot of separate things, but an organized many.

Of Plots and Plans: Stating the Unity of a Book

Aristotle, in his Poetics, insists that this is the mark of every good story, novel, or play. To support his point, he shows how the unity of the Odyssey can be summarized in a few sentences.

A certain man is absent from home for many years; he is jealously watched by Poseidon, and left desolate. Meanwhile his home is in a wretched plight; suitors are wasting his substance and plotting against his son. At length, tempest-tossed, he himself arrives; he makes certain persons acquainted with him; he attacks the suitors with his own hand, and is himself preserved while he destroys them. “This,” says Aristotle, “is the essence of the plot; the rest is episode

Be guided by the prospectus the author gives you, but always remember that the obligation of finding the unity belongs finally to the reader, as much as the obligation of having one belongs to the writer. You can discharge that obligation honestly only by reading the whole book.

The unity of Aristotle’s Ethics can be stated thus:

This is an inquiry into the nature of human happiness and an analysis of the conditions under which happiness may be gained or lost, with an indication of what men must do in their conduct and thinking in order to become happy or to avoid unhappiness, the principal emphasis being placed on the cultivation of the virtues, both moral and intellectual, although other goods are also recognized as necessary for happiness, such as wealth, health, friends, and a just society in which to live.

Another practical book is Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations. Here the reader is aided by the author’s own statement of “the plan of the work” at the very beginning. But that takes several pages. The unity can be more briefly stated as follows:

This is an inquiry into the source of national wealth in any economy that is built on a division of labor, considering the relation of the wages paid labor, the profits returned to capital, and the rent owed the landowner, as the prime factors in the price of commodities. It discusses the various ways in which capital can be more or less gainfully employed, and relates the origin and use of money to the accumulation and employment of capital. Examining the development of opulence in different nations and under different conditions, it compares the several systems of political economy, and argues for the beneficence of free trade.

Darwin’s The Origin of Species provides us with a good example of the unity of a theoretical book in science. Here is a statement of it: This is an account of the variation of living things during the course of countless generations and the way in which this results in new groupings of plants and animals; it treats both of the variability of domesticated animals and of variability under natural conditions, showing how such factors as the struggle for existence and natural selection operate to bring about and sustain such groupings; it argues that species are not fixed and immutable groups, but that they are merely varieties in transition from a less to a more marked and permanent status, supporting this argument by evidences from extinct animals found in the earth’s crust, and from comparative embryology and anatomy.

Finally, let us take Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding as a theoretical book in philosophy. You may recall our observing that Locke himself summarized his work by saying that it was “an inquiry into the origin, certainty and extent of human knowledge, together with the grounds and degrees of belief, opinion and assent.” We would not quarrel with so excellent a statement of plan by the author, except to add two subordinate qualifications to do justice to the first and third parts of the essay: it will be shown, we would add, that there are no innate ideas, but that all human knowledge is acquired from experience; and language will be discussed as a medium for the expression of thought, its proper use and most familiar abuses to be indicated

But it also indicates that many readers pay as little attention to the author’s introductory words as they ordinarily do to his title.

The second point is a word of caution. Do not take the sample summaries we have given you as if they were, in each case, a final and absolute formulation of the book’s unity. A unity can be variously stated. There is no one right way to do it. One statement is better than another, of course, in proportion as it is brief, accurate, and comprehensive.

We have here sometimes stated the unity of a book quite differently from the author’s expression of it, and without apologies to him. You may differ similarly from us. After all, a book is something different to each reader. It would not be surprising if that difference expressed itself in the way the reader stated its unity. This does not mean, however, that anything goes. Though readers are different, the book is the same, and there can be an objective check upon the accuracy and fidelity of the statements anyone makes about it.

Mastering the Multiplicity: The Art of Outlining a Book

well-stated unity indicates the major parts that compose the whole; you cannot comprehend a whole without somehow seeing its parts. But it is also true that unless you grasp the organization of its parts, you cannot know the whole comprehensively.

It is easier to grasp a complex and unified structure in two steps than in one. The second rule directs your attention toward the unity, the third toward the complexity, of a book.

The whole book is about so and so and such and such. That done, we might obey the third rule by proceeding as follows: (1) The author accomplished this plan in five major parts, of which the first part is about so and so, the second part is about such and such, the third part is about this, the fourth part about that, and the fifth part about still another thing. (2) The first of these major parts is divided into three sections, of which the first considers X, the second considers Y, and the third considers Z. (3) In the first section of the first part, the author makes four points, of which the first is A, the second B, the third C, and the fourth D. And so on and so forth

You may object to this much outlining. It would take a lifetime to read a book that way. But of course this is only a formula. The rule looks as if it required an impossible amount of work from you. In fact, the good reader does this sort of thing habitually, and hence easily and naturally.

The word “approximation” should relieve your anxiety. A good rule always describes the ideal performance. But a person can be skilled in an art without being the ideal artist. He can be a good practitioner if he merely approximates the rule.

Even when you become more skilled, you will not want to read every book with the same degree of effort. You will not find it profitable to expend all your skill on some books.

Hence you should not feel that we are urging you merely to be lazy about following this rule. You could not follow it out to the bitter end even if you wanted to.

in the case of a large and complex book, a careful and adequate outline of the parts, and their parts, and their parts down to the least structural unit that is comprehensible and worthwhile identifying, would take a great many pages to write out

Some of the great medieval commentaries on the works of Aristotle are longer than the works they comment on.

The United States Constitution is an interesting, practical document, and a very well-organized piece of writing. If you examine it, you should have no difficulty in finding its major parts. They are pretty clearly indicated, though you have to do some thinking to make the main divisions. Here is a suggested outline of the document: FIRST: The Preamble, setting forth the purpose(s) of the Constitution; SECOND: The first Article, dealing with the legislative department of the government; THIRD: The second Article, dealing with the executive department of the government; FOURTH: The third Article, dealing with the judicial department of the government; FIFTH: The fourth Article, dealing with the relationship between the state governments and the federal government; SIXTH: The fifth, sixth, and seventh Articles, dealing with the amendment of the Constitution, its status as the supreme law of the land, and provisions for its ratifications; SEVENTH: The first ten amendments, constituting the Bill of Rights; EIGHTH: The remaining amendments up to the present day.

Those are the major divisions. Now let us outline one of them, the Second, comprising the Constitution’s first Article. Like most of the other Articles, it is divided into Sections. Here is a suggested outline. II, 1: Section I, establishing legislative powers in a Congress of the United States, divided into two bodies, a Senate and a House of Representatives; II, 2: Sections 2 and 3, respectively describing the composition of the House and Senate and stating the qualifications of members. In addition, it is stated that the House has the sole power of impeachment, while the Senate has the sole power of trying impeachments; II, 3: Sections 4 and 5, having to do with the election of members of both branches of Congress and with the internal organization and affairs of each; II, 4: Section 6, stating the perquisites and emoluments of members of both branches, and stating one limitation on civil employment of members; II, 5: Section 7, defining the relationship between the legislative and executive departments of the government and describing the President’s veto power; II, 6: Section 8, stating the powers of Congress; II, 7: Section 9, stating some limitations on the powers outlined in Section 8; II, 8: Section 10, stating limitations on the powers of the states and the extent to which they must give over certain powers to the Congress.

We mention this to show you that you need not follow the apparent structure of a book as indicated by its chapter divisions.

very simple example will show what we mean. A two-year-old child, just having begun to talk, might say that “two plus two is four.” Objectively, this is a true statement; but we would be wrong to conclude from it that the child knew much mathematics

Similarly, you might be right in your guess about a book’s main theme or point, but you still need to go through the exercise of showing how and why you stated it as you did. The requirement that you outline the parts of a book, and show how they exemplify and develop the main theme, is thus supportive of your statement of the book’s unity.

The Reciprocal Arts of Reading and Writing

These two rules, therefore, can be used to distinguish well made books from badly made ones. If, after you have attained sufficient skill, no amount of effort on your part results in your apprehension of the unity of a book, and if you are also not able to discern its parts and their relation to one another, then very likely the book is a bad one, whatever its reputation.

Discovering the Author’s Intentions

This fourth rule can be stated thus: RULE 4. FIND OUT WHAT THE AUTHOR’S PROBLEMS WERE. The author of a book starts with a question or a set of questions. The book ostensibly contains the answer or answers.

We want to emphasize, however, that we do not mean for you to fall into what is called by critics the intentional fallacy. That is the fallacy of thinking you can discover what was in an author’s mind from the book he has written

In the case of expository works, the rule has obvious merit. And yet most readers, no matter how skilled in other respects, very often fail to observe it.

If you know the kinds of questions anyone can ask about anything, you will become adept in detecting an author’s problems. They can be formulated briefly: Does something exist? What kind of thing is it? What caused it to exist, or under what conditions can it exist, or why does it exist? What purpose does it serve? What are the consequences of its existence? What are its characteristic properties,

What are its relations to other things of a similar sort, or of a different sort? How does it behave? These are all theoretical questions. What ends should be sought? What means should be chosen to a given end? What things must one do to gain a certain objective, and in what order? Under these conditions, what is the right thing to do, or the better rather than the worse? Under what conditions would it be better to do this rather than that? These are all practical questions.

The First Stage of Analytical Reading

You should not take the term “stage” in a chronological sense, unless perhaps at the very beginning of your exercise as an analytical reader. That is, it is not necessary to read a book through in order to apply the first four rules, then to read it again and again in order to apply the other rules. The practiced reader accomplishes all of these stages at once.

The First Stage of Analytical Reading, or Rules for Finding What a Book Is About

  1. Classify the book according to kind and subject matter.
  2. State what the whole book is about with the utmost brevity.
  3. Enumerate its major parts in their order and relation, and outline these parts as you have outlined the whole.
  4. Define the problem or problems the author is trying to solve.

The first stage of analytical reading has been accomplished when you have applied the four rules listed at the end of the last chapter, which together allow you to tell what a book is about and to outline its structure. You are now ready to go on to the next stage, which also comprises four rules of reading. The first of these we call, for short, coming to terms.

Unless the reader comes to terms with the author, the communication of knowledge from one to the other does not take place. For a term is the basic element of communicable knowledge.

Words vs. Terms

But a word can have many meanings, especially an important word. If the author uses a word in one meaning, and the reader reads it in another, words have passed between them, but they have not come to terms.

Just look at the word “communication” for a moment. Its root is related to the word “common.” We speak of a community as a group of people who have something in common. Communication is an effort on the part of one person to share something with another person (or with an animal or a machine): his knowledge, his decisions, his sentiments. It succeeds only when it results in a common something, such as an item of information or knowledge that two parties share.

A term can be defined as an unambiguous word. That is not quite accurate, for strictly there are no unambiguous words. What we should have said is that a term is a word used unambiguously

You cannot find terms in dictionaries, though the materials for making them are there. Terms occur only in the process of communication

Poetry and fiction are not nearly so concerned with the unambiguous use of words as expository works—works that convey knowledge in the broad sense of the word that we have been employing. It can even be argued that the best poetry is that which is the most richly ambiguous, and it has been said with justice that any good poet is sometimes intentionally ambiguous in his writing.

RULE 5. FIND THE IMPORTANT WORDS AND THROUGH THEM COME TO TERMS WITH THE AUTHOR. Note that the rule has two parts. The first part is to locate the important words, the words that make a difference. The second part is to determine the meaning of these words, as used, with precision.

Finding the Key Words

Take any page of this book and count the words we are using in that way: all the prepositions, conjunctions, and articles, and almost all of the verbs, nouns, adverbs, and adjectives. In this chapter so far, there have been only a few important words: “word,” “term,” ambiguity,” “communication,” and perhaps one or two more. Of these, “term” is clearly the most important; all the others are important in relation to it.

From your point of view as a reader, therefore, the most important words are those that give you trouble. It is likely that these words are important for the author as well. However, they may not be.

It is also possible that words that are important for the author do not bother you, and precisely because you understand them. In that case, you have already come to terms with the author. Only where you fail to come to terms have you work still to do.

Technical Words and Special Vocabularies

But is there any other way of spotting the important words? Are there any positive signs that point to them?

There are several. The first and most obvious sign is the explicit stress an author places upon certain words and not others.

He may use such typographical devices as quotation marks or italics to mark the word for you. He may call your attention to the word by explicitly discussing its various senses and indicating the way he is going to use it here and there. Or he may emphasize the word by defining the thing that the word is used to name.

No one can read Euclid without knowing that such words as “point,” “line,” “plane,” “angle,” “parallel,” and so forth are of the first importance. These are the words that name geometrical entities defined by Euclid.

Every field of knowledge has its own technical vocabulary. Euclid makes his plain right at the beginning.

From this you know, for example, that “wealth” is a technical word for Adam Smith, and “species” for Darwin.

You can soon make a list of the important words used by Adam Smith: labor, capital, land, wages, profits, rent, commodity, price, exchange, productive, unproductive, money, and so forth. And here are some you cannot miss in Darwin: variety, genus, selection, survival, adaptation, hybrid, fittest, creation.

You can spot them positively through having some acquaintance with the field, or negatively by knowing what words must be technical, because they are not ordinary.

Unfortunately, there are many fields in which a technical vocabulary is not well established. Philosophers are notorious for having private vocabularies.

But philosophers often find it necessary to coin new words, or to take some word from common speech and make it a technical word. This last procedure is likely to be most misleading to the reader who supposes that he knows what the word means, and therefore treats it as an ordinary word.

When you find an author telling you how a particular word has been used by others, and why he chooses to use it otherwise, you can be sure that word makes a great difference to him.

Most of us are addicted to non-active reading. The outstanding fault of the non-active or undemanding reader is his inattention to words, and his consequent failure to come to terms with the author.

Finding the Meanings

A good example of the use of important words so that they are restricted to a single meaning is found in Euclid. In the second alternative, the word stands for several terms

First, try to determine whether the word has one or many meanings. If it has many, try to see how they are related. Finally, note the places where the word is used in one sense or another, and see if the context gives you any clue to the reason for the shift in meaning.

The answer is that you have to discover the meaning of a word you do not understand by using the meanings of all the other words in the context that you do understand.

Euclid wants to be sure you use it in only one way. He tells you what he means by first defining the thing he is later going to use the word to name. He says: “A point is that which has no part.”

The fact that a book can give you new insights or enlighten you indicates that it probably contains words you may not readily understand. If you could not come to understand those words by your own efforts, then the kind of reading we are talking about would be impossible.

Here, as in the case of every other rule of reading, bad books are less readable than good ones.

But the author who distinguishes the several senses in which he is using a critical word and enables the reader to make a responsive discrimination is offering terms.

One way to remember this is to distinguish between the author’s vocabulary and his terminology. If you make a list in one column of the important words, and in another of their important meanings, you will see the relation between the vocabulary and the terminology.

In the second place, there is the problem of synonyms. The repetition of a single word over and over is awkward and boring, except in mathematical writing, and so good authors often substitute different words having the same or very similar meanings for important words in their text.

When we speak of reading “for insight” and reading “for “enlightenment,” we are referring to the same kind of reading, because the two phrases are being used with the same meaning. The words are different, but there is only one term for you as a reader to grasp.

You will find two relationships. On the one hand, a single word may be related to several terms. On the other hand, a single term may be related to several words

In the third place, and finally, there is the matter of phrases. If a phrase is a unit, that is, if it is a whole that can be the subject or predicate of a sentence, it is like a single word. Like a single word, it can refer to something being talked about in some way.

It follows, therefore, that a term can be expressed by a phrase as well as by a word. And all the relations that exist between words and terms hold also between terms and phrases. Two phrases may express the same term, and one phrase may express several terms, according to the way its constituent words are used.

In general, a phrase is less likely to be ambiguous than a word. Because it is a group of words, each of which is in the context of the others, the single words are more likely to have restricted meanings.

illustration should suffice. To be sure that you come to terms with us about reading, we substitute phrases like “reading for enlightenment” for the single word “reading.” To make doubly sure, we may substitute a more elaborate phrase, such as “the process of passing from understanding less to understanding more by the operation of your mind upon a book.” There is only one term here, a term referring to the kind of reading that this book is mostly about. But that one term has been expressed by a single word, a short phrase, and a longer one

The more you put it into practice, the more you will appreciate the intricacies of the problem. You will want to know something about the literal and metaphorical use of words. You will want to know about the distinction between abstract and concrete words, and between proper and common names. You will become interested in the whole business of definition: the difference between defining words and defining things; why some words are indefinable, and yet have definite meanings, and so forth.

You will seek light on what is called “the emotive use of words,” that is, the use of words to arouse emotions, to move men to action or change their minds, as distinct from the communication of knowledge. And you may even become interested in the relation between ordinary “rational” speech and “bizarre” or “crazy” talk—the speech of the mentally disturbed, where almost every word carries weird and unexpected but nevertheless identifiable connotations.

Not only coming to terms but also making propositions occurs among traders as well as in the world of books.

In honest dealings, the person who makes a proposition in this sense is declaring his intention to act in a certain way.

A proposition of this sort is a declaration of knowledge, not intentions

The author may tell us his intentions at the beginning in a preface.

Generally, the order of reading reverses the order of business. Businessmen usually come to terms after they find out what the proposition is. But the reader must usually come to terms with an author first, before he can find out what the author is proposing, what judgment he is declaring.

His propositions are nothing but expressions of personal opinion unless they are supported by reasons. If it is the book and the subject with which it deals that we are interested in, and not just the author, we want to know not merely what his propositions are, but also why he thinks we should be persuaded to accept them.

We go from terms to propositions to arguments, by going from words (and phrases) to sentences to collections of sentences (or paragraphs).

The movement at this stage of analytical reading—when interpretation is our goal—seems to be in the opposite direction from the movement in the first stage—when the goal was a structural outline

The major parts of a book and their principal divisions contain many propositions and usually several arguments. But if you keep on dividing the book into its parts, at last you have to say: “In this part, the following points are made.” Now each of these points is likely to be a proposition, and some of them taken together probably form an argument.

Thus, the two processes, outlining and interpretation, meet at the level of propositions and arguments. You work down to propositions and arguments by dividing the book into its parts. You work up to arguments by seeing how they are composed of propositions and ultimately of terms. When you have completed the two processes, you can really say that you know the contents of a book.

Sentences vs. Propositions

Sentences and paragraphs are grammatical units. They are units of language. Propositions and arguments are logical units, or units of thought and knowledge.

The greatest error you can make in applying these rules is to suppose that a one-to-one relationship exists between the elements of language and those of thought or knowledge.

Not every sentence in a book expresses a proposition. For one thing, some sentences express questions. They state problems rather than answers. Propositions are the answers to questions. They are declarations of knowledge or opinion

Other sentences express wishes or intentions. They may give us some knowledge of the author’s purpose, but they do not convey the knowledge he is trying to expound.

Thus, it is possible for the same sentence to express different propositions if there is a shift in the terms the words express. “Reading is learning” is a simple sentence; but if at one place we mean by “learning” the acquisition of information, and at another we mean the development of understanding, the proposition is not the same, because the terms are different. Yet the sentence is the same.

The second reason is that all sentences are not as simple as “Reading is learning.” When its words are used unambiguously, a simple sentence usually expresses a single proposition. But even when its words are used unambiguously, a compound sentence expresses two or more propositions. A compound sentence is really a collection of sentences, connected by such words as “and,” or “if … then,” or “not only … but also.” You may rightly conclude that the line between a long compound sentence and a short paragraph may be difficult to draw. A compound sentence can express a number of propositions related in the form of an argument.

Let us take an interesting sentence from Machiavelli’s The Prince to show what we mean:

The semicolon and the “because” indicate the major break in it. The first proposition is that a prince ought to inspire fear in a certain way

Beginning with the word “because,” we have what is in effect another sentence. (It could be made independent by saying: “The reason for this is that he can endure,” and so forth.) And this sentence expresses two propositions at least: (1) the reason why the prince ought to inspire fear in a certain way is that he can endure being feared so long as he is not hated; (2) he can avoid being hated only by keeping his hands off the property of his citizens and their women.

you may acknowledge his shrewdness in saying that the prince had better not arouse hatred along with fear

Here are the rules. The fifth rule of reading, as you will recall from the last chapter, was: RULE 5. FIND THE IMPORTANT WORDS AND COME TO TERMS. The sixth rule can be expressed thus: RULE 6. MARK THE MOST IMPORTANT SENTENCES IN A BOOK AND DISCOVER THE PROPOSITIONS THEY CONTAIN. The seventh rule is this: RULE 7. LOCATE OR CONSTRUCT THE BASIC ARGUMENTS IN THE BOOK BY FINDING THEM IN THE CONNECTION OF SENTENCES. You will see later why we did not say “paragraphs” in the formulation of this rule.

Finding the Key Sentences

From the author’s point of view, the important sentences are the ones that express the judgments on which his whole argument rests.

He not only states his definitions, his postulates, and his axioms—his principal propositions—at the beginning, but he also labels every proposition to be proved.

There is no excuse for not being able to locate the important sentences in such a book—those expressing the reasons as well as the conclusions—yet even here it remains all a blur for those readers who treat everything they read as equally important—and read it all at the same speed, either fast or slow. That usually means that everything is equally unimportant.

Wonder is the beginning of wisdom in learning from books as well as from nature. If you never ask yourself any questions about the meaning of a passage, you cannot expect the book to give you any insight you do not already possess.

Terms constitute propositions. Propositions contain terms. If you know the terms the words express, you have caught the proposition in the sentence. If you understand the proposition conveyed by a sentence, you have arrived at the terms also.

The fact that we have stated these rules in a fixed order does not mean that you have to follow them in that order.

Hence, if you can detect those sentences that seem to form a sequence, a sequence in which there is a beginning and an end, you probably have put your finger on the sentences that are important.

Many persons believe that they know how to read because they read at different speeds. But they pause and go slow over the wrong sentences. They pause over the sentences that interest them rather than the ones that puzzle them. Indeed, this is one of the greatest obstacles to reading a book that is not completely contemporary

Finding the Propositions

You discover terms by discovering what a word means in a given usage. You discover propositions similarly by interpreting all the words that make up the sentence, and especially its principal words.

There are only two differences between finding the terms that words express and the propositions that sentences express. One is that you employ a larger context in the latter case.

“State in your own words!” That suggests the best test we know for telling whether you have understood the proposition or propositions in the sentence.

But if you cannot get away at all from the author’s words, it shows that only words have passed from him to you, not thought or knowledge.

You know his words, not his mind. He was trying to communicate knowledge, and all you received was words.

The translation of one English sentence into another, however, is not merely verbal. The new sentence you have formed is not a verbal replica of the original. If accurate, it is faithful to the thought alone.

These remarks have a bearing on syntopical reading—the reading of several books about the same subject matter. Different authors frequently say the same thing in different words, or different things using almost the same words. The reader who cannot see through the language to the terms and propositions will never be able to compare such related works. Because of their verbal differences, he is likely to misread the authors as disagreeing, or to ignore their real differences because of verbal resemblances in their statements.

Can you point to some experience you have had that the proposition describes or to which the proposition is in any way relevant? Can you exemplify the general truth that has been enunciated by referring to a particular instance of it? To imagine a possible case is often as good as citing an actual one.

If you cannot do anything at all to exemplify or illustrate the proposition, either imaginatively or by reference to actual experiences, you should suspect that you do not know what is being said.

The failure in reading—the omnipresent verbalism—of those who have not been trained in the arts of grammar and logic shows how lack of such discipline results in slavery to words rather than mastery of them.

Finding the Arguments

We said before that there was a reason for not formulating this rule of interpretation by saying that the reader should find the most important paragraphs.

Because of all this, we suggest another formulation of RULE 7, as follows: FIND IF YOU CAN THE PARAGRAPHS IN A BOOK THAT STATE ITS IMPORTANT ARGUMENTS; BUT IF THE ARGUMENTS ARE NOT THUS EXPRESSED, YOUR TASK IS TO CONSTRUCT THEM, BY TAKING A SENTENCE FROM THIS PARAGRAPH, AND ONE FROM THAT, UNTIL YOU HAVE GATHERED TOGETHER THE SEQUENCE OF SENTENCES THAT STATE THE PROPOSITIONS THAT COMPOSE THE ARGUMENT.

The style of most writing in non-mathematical fields tends to present two or more arguments in a single paragraph or to have an argument run through several.

A good book usually summarizes itself as its arguments develop. If the author summarizes his arguments for you at the end of a chapter, or at the end of an elaborate section, you should be able to look back over the preceding pages and find the materials he has brought together in the summary

One of the most familiar tricks of the orator or propagandist is to leave certain things unsaid, things that are highly relevant to the argument, but that might be challenged if they were made explicit.

If you find the conclusion first, then look for the reasons. If you find the reasons first, see where they lead

In the second place, discriminate between the kind of argument that points to one or more particular facts as evidence for some generalization and the kind that offers a series of general statements to prove some further generalizations.

In the third place, observe what things the author says he must assume, what he says can be proved or otherwise evidenced, and what need not be proved because it is self-evident

assumptions agreed on between writer and reader, or with what are called self-evident propositions, which neither the writer nor reader can deny

That is why, incidentally, Euclid called them “common notions.” They are also instructive, despite the fact that Locke, for example, did not think they were. He could see no difference between a proposition that really does not instruct, such as the one about the grandparent, and one that does—one that teaches us something we would not otherwise know—such as the one about parts and wholes

Finding the Solutions

Which of the problems that the author tried to solve did he succeed in solving? In the course of solving these, did he raise any new ones? Of the problems that he failed to solve, old or new, which did the author himself know he had failed on?

This final step in interpretive reading is covered by RULE 8. FIND OUT WHAT THE AUTHOR’S SOLUTIONS ARE.

Up to this point, you have been following the author. From this point on, you are going to have a chance to argue with the author and express yourself.

The Second Stage of Analytical Reading

We have now described the second stage of analytical reading. Another way to say this is that we have now set forth the materials for answering the second basic question that you must ask about a book, or indeed anything that you read. You will recall that that second question is What is being said in detail, and how? Applying Rules 5 through 8 clearly helps you to answer this question.

The Second Stage of Analytical Reading, or Rules for Finding What a Book Says (Interpreting Its Contents

  1. Come to terms with the author by interpreting his key words.
  2. Grasp the author’s leading propositions by dealing with his most important sentences.
  3. Know the author’s arguments, by finding them in, or constructing them out of, sequences of sentences.
  4. Determine which of his problems the author has solved, and which he has not; and as to the latter, decide which the author knew he had failed to solve.

CRITICIZING A BOOK FAIRLY

We have learned the four rules for interpreting a book’s contents. We are now ready for the last stage of analytical reading.

If, however, the reader is undisciplined and impolite, it may be anything but orderly.

What is important is that there is an intellectual etiquette to be observed. Without it, conversation is bickering rather than profitable communication.

The reader owes him a considered judgment. If he cannot say, “I agree,” he should at least have grounds for disagreeing or even for suspending judgment on the question.

The activity of reading does not stop with the work of understanding what a book says. It must be completed by the work of criticism, the work of judging. The undemanding reader fails to satisfy this requirement, probably even more than he fails to analyze and interpret.

Teachability as a Virtue

It is the third stage in the analytical reading of a book; and there are rules here as in the case of the first two stages.

Remember Bacon’s recommendation to the reader: “Read not to contradict and confute; nor to believe and take for granted; nor to find talk and discourse; but to weigh and consider.”

There is a certain truth here, of course, but there is also a good deal of nonsense about the aura of impeccability with which books are thus surrounded, and the false piety it produces.

is true that a book that can enlighten its readers, and is in this sense superior to them, should not be criticized by them until they understand it. When they do, they have elevated themselves almost to equality with the author

He deserves that they act like his peers, that they engage in conversation with him, that they talk back.

A person is wrongly thought to be teachable if he is passive and pliable.

No one is really teachable who does not freely exercise his power of independent judgment. He can be trained, perhaps, but not taught. The most teachable reader is, therefore, the most critical.

Role of Rhetoric

we are the talkers, we wish not only to be understood but also to be agreed with in some sense

If our purpose in trying to communicate is serious, we wish to convince or persuade—more precisely

To regard anyone except yourself as responsible for your judgment is to be a slave, not a free man. It is from this fact that the liberal arts acquire their name.

On the part of the speaker or writer, rhetorical skill is knowing how to convince or persuade. Since this is the ultimate end in view, all the other aspects of communication must serve it. Grammatical and logical skill in writing clearly and intelligibly has merit in itself, but it is also a means to an end. Reciprocally, on the part of the reader or listener, rhetorical skill is knowing how to react to anyone who tries to convince or persuade us. Here, too, grammatical and logical skill, which enables us to understand what is being said, prepares the way for a critical reaction.

The Importance of Suspending Judgment

Not until you are honestly satisfied that you have accomplished the first two stages of reading should you feel free to express yourself. When you have, you not only have earned the right to turn critic; you also have the duty to do so.

RULE 9. YOU MUST BE ABLE TO SAY, WITH REASONABLE CERTAINTY, “I UNDERSTAND,” BEFORE YOU CAN SAY ANY ONE OF THE FOLLOWING THINGS: “I AGREE,” OR “I DISAGREE,” OR “I SUSPEND JUDGMENT

There are two reasons. In the first place, many people make the error already mentioned of identifying criticism with disagreement. (Even “constructive” criticism is disagreement.) In the second place, though this rule seems obviously sound, our experience has been that few people observe it in practice. Like the golden rule, it elicits more lip service than intelligent obedience.

Bullet point

There is actually no point in answering critics of this sort. The only polite thing to do is to ask them to state your position for you, the position they claim to be challenging. If they cannot do it satisfactorily, if they cannot repeat what you have said in their own words, you know that they do not understand, and you are entirely justified in ignoring their criticisms.

When you find the rare person who shows that he understands what you are saying as well as you do, then you can delight in his agreement or be seriously disturbed by his dissent.

The presumption, however, is in favor of the book, especially if it is a good one.

A good example of brashness in this last respect is furnished by literary critics who have agreed or disagreed with Aristotle’s Poetics without realizing that the main principles in Aristotle’s analysis of poetry depend in part on points made in other of his works, his treatises on psychology and logic and metaphysics.

The same is true of other writers, such as Plato and Kant, Adam Smith and Karl Marx, who have not been able to say everything they knew or thought in a single work. Those who judge Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason without reading his Critique of Practical Reason, or Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations without reading his Theory of the Moral Sentiments, or The Communist Manifesto without Marx’s Capital, are more likely than not to be agreeing or disagreeing with something they do not fully understand.

The Importance of Avoiding Contentiousness

It is RULE 10, and it can be expressed thus: WHEN YOU DISAGREE, DO SO REASONABLY, AND NOT DISPUTATIOUSLY OR CONTENTIOUSLY.

We learned this maxim first from Plato and Aristotle. In a passage in the Symposium, this interchange occurs: I cannot refute you, Socrates, said Agathon: Let us assume that what you say is true. Say rather, Agathon, that you cannot refute the truth; for Socrates is easily refuted.

On the Resolution of Disagreements

Where the second maxim urged you not to disagree disputatiously, this one warns you against disagreeing hopelessly. One is hopeless about the fruitfulness of discussion if he does not recognize that all rational men can agree. Note that we said “can agree.” We did not say all rational men do agree. Even when they do not agree, they can

These two facts, that people do disagree and can agree, arise from the complexity of human nature.

The language they must use to communicate is an imperfect medium, clouded by emotion and colored by interest, as well as inadequately transparent for thought.

There is, of course, another sort of disagreement, which is owing merely to inequalities of knowledge.

Inequality of knowledge is always curable by instruction.

Hence the person who, at any stage of a conversation, disagrees, should at least hope to reach agreement in the end. He should be as much prepared to have his own mind changed as seek to change the mind of another

The trouble is that many people regard disagreement as unrelated to either teaching or being taught.

On such a view, communication cannot be profitable if the profit to be gained is an increase in knowledge.

If genuine knowledge, not mere personal opinion, is at stake, then, for the most part, either disagreements are apparent only—to be removed by coming to terms and a meeting of minds; or they are real, and the genuine issues can be resolved—in the long run, of course—by appeals to fact and reason.

The reader who does not distinguish between the reasoned statement of knowledge and the flat expression of opinion is not reading to learn. He is at most interested in the author’s personality and is using the book as a case history. Such a reader will, of course, neither agree nor disagree. He does not judge the book but the man.

RULE 11, therefore, can be stated as follows: RESPECT THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN KNOWLEDGE AND MERE PERSONAL OPINION, BY GIVING REASONS FOR ANY CRITICAL JUDGMENT YOU MAKE.

What we know, we know subject to correction; we know it because all, or at least the weight, of the evidence supports it, but we are not and cannot be certain that new evidence will not sometime invalidate what we now believe is true.

Knowledge, if you please, consists in those opinions that can he defended, opinions for which there is evidence of one kind or another.

The first requires the reader to complete the task of understanding before rushing in. The second adjures him not to be disputatious or contentious. The third asks him to view disagreement about matters of knowledge as being generally remediable. This rule goes further: It also commands him to give reasons for his disagreements so that issues are not merely stated but also defined. In that lies all hope for resolution.

AGREEING OR DISAGREEING WITH AN AUTHOR

The first thing a reader can say is that he understands or that he does not. In fact, he must say he understands, in order to say more. If he does not understand, he should keep his peace and go back to work on the book.

There is one exception to the harshness of the second alternative. “I don’t understand” may itself be a critical remark. To make it so, the reader must be able to support it. If the fault is with the book rather than himself, the reader must locate the sources of trouble

The analytical reading is completely done. You have been enlightened, and convinced or persuaded. It is clear that we have additional steps to consider only in the case of disagreement or suspended judgment. The former is the more usual case.

If the reader understands a book, how can he disagree with it? Critical reading demands that he make up his own mind. But his mind and the author’s have become as one through his success in understanding the book. What mind has he left to make up independently?

There are some people who make the error that causes this apparent difficulty: they fail to distinguish between two senses of “agreement.” In consequence, they wrongly suppose that where there is understanding between men, disagreement is impossible. They say that all disagreement is simply owing to misunderstanding.

If you say, for instance, that “all men are equal,” we may take you to mean that all men are equally endowed at birth with intelligence, strength, and other abilities. In the light of the facts as we know them, we disagree with you. We think you are wrong. But suppose we have misunderstood you. Suppose you meant by these words that all men should have equal political rights. Because we misapprehended your meaning, our disagreement was irrelevant. Now suppose the mistake corrected. Two alternatives still remain. We can agree or disagree, but now if we disagree, there is a real issue between us. We understand your political position, but hold a contrary one.

Agreement about the use of words is the indispensable condition for genuine agreement or disagreement about the facts being discussed.

Prejudice and Judgment

Because this is true, then, from an ideal point of view, there are three conditions that must be satisfied if controversy is to be well conducted.

The first is this. Since men are animals as well as rational, it is necessary to acknowledge the emotions you bring to a dispute, or those that arise in the course of it. Otherwise you are likely to be giving vent to feelings, not stating reasons. You may even think you have reasons, when all you have are strong feelings.

Second, you must make your own assumptions explicit. You must know what your prejudices—that is, your prejudgments—are. Otherwise you are not likely to admit that your opponent may be equally entitled to different assumptions. Good controversy should not be a quarrel about assumptions.

Third and finally, an attempt at impartiality is a good antidote for the blindness that is almost inevitable in partisanship.

Controversy without partisanship is, of course, impossible. But to be sure that there is more light in it, and less heat, each of the disputants should at least try to take the other fellow’s point of view.

We continue to believe, however, that conversation and critical reading can be well disciplined. We are therefore going to substitute for those three ideal conditions, a set of prescriptions that may be easier to follow.

The four points can be briefly summarized by conceiving the reader as conversing with the author, as talking back. After he has said, “I understand but I disagree,” he can make the following remarks to the author: (1) “You are uninformed”; (2) “You are misinformed”; (3) “You are illogical—your reasoning is not cogent”; (4) “Your analysis is incomplete.”

Making one of these remarks does not prevent you from making another. Each and all can be made, because the defects they refer to are not mutually exclusive.

Judging the Author’s Soundness

  1. To say that an author is uninformed is to say that he lacks some piece of knowledge that is relevant to the problem he is trying to solve.

A few illustrations here must suffice. Darwin lacked the knowledge of genetics that the work of Mendel and later experimentalists now provides. His ignorance of the mechanism of inheritance is one of the major defects in The Origin of Species. Gibbon lacked certain facts that later historical research has shown to have a bearing on the fall of Rome. Usually, in science and history, the lack of information is discovered by later researches

  1. To say that an author is misinformed is to say that he asserts what is not the case. His error here may be owing to lack of knowledge, but the error is more than that.

He is claiming to have knowledge he does not possess.

For example, in one of his political treatises, Spinoza appears to say that democracy is a more primitive type of government than monarchy. This is contrary to well-ascertained facts of political history. Spinoza’s error in this respect has a bearing on his argument. Aristotle was misinformed about the role that the female factor plays in animal reproduction, and consequently came to unsupportable conclusions about the processes of procreation

These first two points of criticism may be related. Lack of information, as we have seen, may be the cause of erroneous assertions. Further, whenever a man is misinformed in a certain respect, he is also uninformed in the same respect.

Lack of relevant knowledge makes it impossible to solve certain problems or support certain conclusions. Erroneous suppositions, however, lead to wrong conclusions and untenable solutions.

  1. To say that an author is illogical is to say that he has committed a fallacy in reasoning.

There is the non sequitur, which means that what is drawn as a conclusion simply does not follow from the reasons offered.

And there is the occurrence of inconsistency, which means that two things the author has tried to say are incompatible.

It is more difficult to illustrate this third point, because few really good books make obvious slips in reasoning. When they do occur, they are usually elaborately concealed, and it requires a very penetrating reader to discover them

But we can show you a patent fallacy in Machiavelli’s The Prince. Machiavelli writes: The chief foundations of all states, new as well as old, are good laws. As there cannot be good laws where the state is not well armed, it follows that where they are well armed they have good laws.

A person who from sound premises reaches a conclusion invalidly is, in a sense, misinformed. But it is worthwhile to distinguish the kind of erroneous statement that is owing to bad reasoning from the kind previously discussed, which is owing to other defects, especially insufficient knowledge of relevant details

Judging the Author’s Completeness

The first three points of criticism, which we have just considered, deal with the soundness of the author’s statements and reasoning. Let us turn now to the fourth adverse remark a reader can make. It deals with the completeness of the author’s execution of his plan—the adequacy with which he discharges the task he has chosen.

Before we proceed to this fourth remark, one thing should be observed. Since you have said you understand, your failure to support any of these first three remarks obligates you to agree with the author as far as he has gone.

You cannot say, as so many students and others do, “I find nothing wrong with your premises, and no errors in reasoning, but I don’t agree with your conclusions.” All you can possibly mean by saying something like that is that you do not like the conclusions. You are not disagreeing. You are expressing your emotions or prejudices

If you have been convinced, you should admit it. (If, despite your failure to support one or more of these three critical points, you still honestly feel unconvinced, perhaps you should not have said you understood in the first place.)

  1. To say that an author’s analysis is incomplete is to say that he has not solved all the problems he started with, or that he has not made as good a use of his materials as possible, that he did not see all their implications and ramifications, or that he has failed to make distinctions that are relevant to his undertaking

Let us illustrate this point briefly

The analysis of types of government in Aristotle’s Politics is incomplete. Because of the limitations of his time and his erroneous acceptance of slavery, Aristotle fails to consider, or for that matter even to conceive, the truly democratic constitution that is based on universal suffrage; nor can he imagine either representative government or the modern kind of federated state.

Euclid’s Elements of Geometry is an incomplete account because Euclid failed to consider other postulates about the relation of parallel lines

Dewey’s How We Think is an incomplete analysis of thinking because it fails to treat the sort of thinking that occurs in reading or learning by instruction in addition to the sort that occurs in investigation and discovery.

To a Christian who believes in personal immortality, the writings of Epictetus or Marcus Aurelius are an incomplete account of human happiness.

This fourth point is strictly not a basis for disagreement. It is critically adverse only to the extent that it marks the limitations of the author’s achievement.

But the profoundest comparison is made with respect to the completeness of the analysis that each presents.

You may also see how the fourth critical remark ties together the three stages of analytical reading of any book. The last step of structural outlining is to know the problems that the author is trying to solve.

The Third Stage of Analytical Reading

I. The First Stage of Analytical Reading: Rules for Finding What a Book Is About

  1. Classify the book according to kind and subject matter.
  2. State what the whole book is about with the utmost brevity.
  3. Enumerate its major parts in their order and relation, and outline these parts as you have outlined the whole.
  4. Define the problem or problems the author has tried to solve.

II. The Second Stage of Analytical Reading: Rules for Interpreting a Book’s Contents

  1. Come to terms with the author by interpreting his key words.
  2. Grasp the author’s leading propositions by dealing with his most important sentences.
  3. Know the author’s arguments, by finding them in, or constructing them out of, sequences of sentences.
  4. Determine which of his problems the author has solved, and which he has not; and of the latter, decide which the author knew he had failed to solve.

III. The Third Stage of Analytical Reading: Rules for Criticizing a Book as a Communication of Knowledge A. General Maxims of Intellectual Etiquette

  1. Do not begin criticism until you have completed your outline and your interpretation of the book. (Do not say you agree, disagree, or suspend judgment, until you can say “I understand.”)
  2. Do not disagree disputatiously or contentiously.
  3. Demonstrate that you recognize the difference between knowledge and mere personal opinion by presenting good reasons for any critical judgment you make.

B. Special Criteria for Points of Criticism

  1. Show wherein the author is uninformed.
  2. Show wherein the author is misinformed.
  3. Show wherein the author is illogical.
  4. Show wherein the author’s analysis or account is incomplete.

Note: Of these last four, the first three are criteria for disagreement. Failing in all of these, you must agree, at least in part, although you may suspend judgment on the whole, in the light of the last point.

A person who has read widely but not well deserves to be pitied rather than praised. As Thomas Hobbes said, “If I read as many books as most men do, I would be as dull-witted as they are.”

In the natural course of events, a good student frequently becomes a teacher, and so, too, a good reader becomes an author.

AIDS TO READING

We must have read other books before this one; no one starts his reading career by reading analytically. We may not bring to bear our experience both of other books and of life as systematically as we should, but we nevertheless measure the statements and conclusions of a writer against other things that we know, from many different sources.

Thus it is common sense to say that no book should be, because no book can be, read entirely and completely in isolation.

On the whole, it is best to do all that you can by yourself before seeking outside help; for if you act consistently on this principle, you will find that you need less and less outside help.

The extrinsic aids to reading fall into four categories. In the order in which we will discuss them in this chapter, they are: first, relevant experiences; second, other books; third, commentaries and abstracts; fourth, reference books.

Common experience does not have to be shared by everyone in order to be common. Common is not the same as universal. The experience of being a child of parents, for example, is not shared by every human being, for some are orphans from birth.

Nor is sexual love a universal experience, although it is common, in the sense we are giving the word common.

Common experience is most relevant to the reading of fiction, on the one hand, and to the reading of philosophy, on the other.

Special experience is mainly relevant to the reading of scientific works. To understand and judge the inductive arguments in a scientific book, you must be able to follow the evidence that the scientist reports as their basis.

The students appeared to have understood the point, but they were completely at a loss when called upon to supply an example. Obviously, they had not really understood the book.

Take Aristotle’s discussion of virtue in the Ethics, for example. He says over and over that virtue is a mean between the extremes of defect and excess. He gives some concrete examples; can you supply others?

They may try to read The Federalist Papers without having first read the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution. Or they may try all these without having read Montesquieu’s The Spirit of Laws, Rousseau’s The Social Contract, and Locke’s second treatise Of Civil Government.

Not only are many of the great books related, but also they were written in a certain order that should not be ignored

The utility of this kind of extrinsic reading is simply an extension of the value of context in reading a book by itself.

It has often been observed that the great books are involved in a prolonged conversation. The great authors were great readers, and one way to understand them is to read the books they read

Though the order from past to present has certain advantages through being more natural, the fact of chronology can be observed in either way.

It should be noted, incidentally, that the need to read books in relation to one another applies more to history and philosophy than to science and fiction

It is most important in the case of philosophy, because philosophers are great readers of each other. It is probably least important in the case of novels or plays, which, if they are really good, can be read in isolation, although of course the literary critic will not want to confine himself to doing so.

A third category of extrinsic aids to reading includes commentaries and abstracts. The thing to emphasize here is that such works should be used wisely, which is to say sparingly. There are two reasons for this. The first is that commentators are not always right in their comments on a book

The handbooks and manuals that are widely available in college bookstores and in stores frequented by high school students are often particularly misleading. These works purport to tell the student everything he has to know about a book that has been assigned by one of his teachers, but they are sometimes woefully wrong in their interpretations, and besides, as a practical matter, they irritate some teachers and professors.

The second reason for using commentaries sparingly is that, even if they are right, they may not be exhaustive. That is, you may be able to discover important meanings in a book that the author of a commentary about it has not discovered.

Whereas it is one of the rules of intrinsic reading that you should read an author’s preface and introduction before reading his book, the rule in the case of extrinsic reading is that you should not read a commentary by someone else until after you have read the book.

You will tend to see only the points made by the scholar or critic, and fail to see other points that may be just as important.

There is considerable pleasure associated with the reading of such introductions when it is done in this way. You have read the book and understood it. The writer of the introduction has also read it, perhaps many times, and has his own understanding of it. You approach him, therefore, on essentially equal terms. If you read his introduction before reading the book, however, you are at his mercy.

And there is this further point. If you get into the habit of depending on commentaries and handbooks, you will be totally lost if you cannot find one.

An abstract can never replace the reading of a book, but it can sometimes tell you whether you want or need to read the book or not.

There are many kinds of reference books. In the following section we will confine ourselves mainly to the two most used kinds, dictionaries and encyclopedias.

a reference book is an antidote to ignorance in only a limited way. It cannot cure total ignorance. It cannot do your thinking for you

To use a reference book well, you must, first, have some idea, however vague it may be, of what you want to know. Your ignorance must be like a circle of darkness surrounded by light. You want to bring light to the dark circle.

Another way to say this is that you must be able to ask a reference book an intelligible question.

Second, you must know where to find out what you want to know. You must know what kind of question you are asking, and which kinds of reference books answer that kind of question. There is no reference book that answers all questions; all such works are specialists, as it were.

There is a third, and correlative, kind of knowledge that is required before a reference book can be useful to you. You must know how the particular work is organized. It will do you no good to know what you want to know, and to know the kind of reference book to use, if you do not know how to use the particular work.

Do not try to use a reference book before getting the editor’s advice on how to use it.

Only those things about which men generally and conventionally agree are to be found in reference books. Unsupported opinions have no business there, though they sometimes creep in.

As you can see, we have just been suggesting that there is a fourth requirement for the intelligent use of reference books. You must know what you want to know; you must know in what reference work to find it; you must know how to find it in the reference work; and you must know that it is considered knowable by the authors or compilers of the book. All this indicates that you must know a good deal before you can use a work of reference. Reference books are useless to people who know nothing. They are not guides to the perplexed.

As a reference book, the dictionary is subject to all the considerations outlined above. But the dictionary also invites a playful reading. It challenges anyone to sit down with it in an idle moment.

Love this line

Santayana’s remark about the Greeks—that they were the only uneducated people in European history—has a double significance. The masses were, of course, uneducated, but even the learned few—the leisure class—were not educated in the sense that they had to sit at the feet of foreign masters. Education, in that sense, begins with the Romans, who went to school to Greek pedagogues, and became cultivated through contact with the Greek culture they had conquered.

If you look upon a dictionary merely as a spelling book or guide to pronunciation, you will use it accordingly, which is to say not well. If you realize that it contains a wealth of historical information, crystallized in the growth and development of language, you will pay attention, not merely to the variety of meanings listed under each word, but also to their order and relation.

The dictionary’s primary service is on those occasions when you are confronted with a technical word or with a word that is wholly new to you.

This suggests several other negative injunctions. There is no more irritating fellow than the one who tries to settle an argument about communism, or justice, or freedom, by quoting from the dictionary.

Lexicographers may be respected as authorities on word usage, but they are not the ultimate founts of wisdom.

In short, do not forget that the dictionary is a book about words, not about things

  1. WORDS ARE PHYSICAL THINGS—writable words and speak-able sounds. There must, therefore, be uniform ways of spelling and pronouncing them, though the uniformity is often spoiled by variations, and in any event is not as eternally important as some of your teachers may have indicated.
  2. WORDS ARE PARTS OF SPEECH. Each single word plays a grammatical role in the more complicated structure of a phrase or sentence. The same word can vary in different usages, shifting from one part of speech to another, especially in a non-inflected language like English.
  3. WORDS ARE SIGNS. They have meanings, not one but many. These meanings are related in various ways.

Finally, 4. WORDS ARE CONVENTIONAL. They are man-made signs. That is why every word has a history, a cultural career in the course of which it goes through certain transformations.

A good dictionary will answer all of these four different kinds of questions about words. The art of using a dictionary consists in knowing what questions to ask about words and how to find the answers. We have suggested the questions. The dictionary itself tells you how to find the answers.

Like the dictionary, the encyclopedia invites a playful reading. It too is diverting, entertaining, and, for some people, soothing.

Though the word “encyclopedia” is Greek, the Greeks had no encyclopedia, and for the same reason that they had no dictionary. The word meant to them not a book about knowledge, a book in which knowledge reposed, but knowledge itself—all the knowledge that an educated man should have. It was again the Romans who first found encyclopedias necessary; the oldest extant example is that of Pliny.

Interestingly enough, the first alphabetically-arranged en cyclopedia did not appear until about 1700.

The ordering of knowledge has changed with the centuries. All knowledge was once ordered in relation to the seven liberal arts—grammar, rhetoric, and logic, the trivium; arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music, the quadrivium

In an alphabetically-arranged encyclopedia, these relations are to a large extent obscured. In a topically-arranged encyclopedia, they are, of course, highlighted.

Ideally, the best encyclopedia would be one that had both a topical and an alphabetical arrangement. Its presentation of material in the form of separate articles would be alphabetical, but it would also contain some kind of topical key or outline—essentially, a table of contents.

Thus the index of a really good encyclopedia such as Britannica goes part of the way toward revealing the arrangement of knowledge that the work reflects. For this reason, any reader who fails to use the index has only himself to blame if the work does not serve his needs.

Nevertheless, they should be used to end disputes about matters of fact as quickly and permanently as possible.

Facts should never be argued about in the first place. An encyclopedia makes this vain effort unnecessary, because encyclopedias are full of facts. Ideally, they are filled with nothing else.

Hence, if you are really interested in a subject and are depending on encyclopedic treatments of it, do not restrict yourself to just one encylopedia. Read more than one, and preferably ones written at different times.

In the case of encyclopedias, the analogous points are about facts, for an encyclopedia is about facts as a dictionary is about words.

  1. FACTS ARE PROPOSITIONS. Statements of fact employ words in combination, such as “Abraham Lincoln was born on February 12, 1809,” or “the atomic number of gold is 79.” Facts are not physical things, as words are, but they do require to be explained.
  1. FACTS ARE “TRUE” PROPOSITIONS. Facts are not opinions. When someone says “it is a fact that,” he means that it is generally agreed that such is the case.

An encyclopedia that contains the unsupported opinions of its editors is dishonest; and although an encyclopedia may report opinions (for example, in a phrase like “it is held by some that this is the case, by others that that is the case”), it must clearly label them.

  1. FACTS ARE REFLECTIONS OF REALITY. Facts may be either (a) informational singulars or (b) relatively unquestioned generalizations, but in either case they are held to represent the way things really are.

Similarly, an explanation of reality (or of part of it) is not a fact until and unless there is general agreement that it is correct. There is one exception to the last statement. An encyclopedia can properly describe a theory that is no longer held to be correct, in whole or in part, or one that has not yet been fully validated, when it is associated with a topic, person or school that is the subject of an article. Thus, for example, Aristotle’s views on the nature of celestial matter could be expounded in an article on Aristotelianism even though we no longer believe them to be true.

Finally, 4. FACTS ARE TO SOME EXTENT CONVENTIONAL. Facts change, we say. We mean that some propositions that are considered to be facts in one epoch are no longer considered to be facts in another. Insofar as facts are “true” and represent reality, they cannot change, of course, because truth, strictly speaking, does not change, nor does reality.

This does not mean that the scientist and the primitive cannot agree on any facts; they must agree, for instance, that two plus two is four, or that a physical whole is greater than any of its parts. But the primitive may not agree with the scientist’s facts about nuclear particles, just as the scientist may not agree with the primitive’s facts about ritual magic (That was a hard sentence to write, because, being culturally determined ourselves, we tend to agree with the scientist rather than the primitive and were thus tempted to put the second “fact” in quotation marks. But that is precisely the point.)

You should also remember that an encyclopedia is not the best place to pursue understanding. Insights may be gained from it about the order and arrangement of knowledge; but that, although an important subject, is nonetheless a limited one.

Since both the imagination and the reason are required for understanding, this means that the encyclopedia must be a relatively unsatisfying tool in the pursuit of it.

HOW TO READ PRACTICAL BOOKS

It is important to note here that the fifteen rules of reading, in the form in which they were presented toward the end of Chapter 11, do not apply to the reading of fiction and poetry.

Nevertheless, it would be a mistake to think that no rules at all apply to reading imaginative literature.

The most imporant thing to remember about any practical book is that it can never solve the practical problems with which it is concerned.

But a practical problem can only be solved by action itself. When your practical problem is how to earn a living, a book on how to make friends and influence people cannot solve it, though it may suggest things to do. Nothing short of the doing solves the problem.

But a practical book may contain more than rules. It may try to state the principles that underlie the rules and make them intelligible.

The principles that underlie rules are usually in themselves scientific, that is, they are items of theoretical knowledge.

Practical books thus fall into two main groups. Some, like this one, or a cookbook, or a driver’s manual, are primarily presentations of rules. Whatever other discussion they contain is for the sake of the rules. There are few great books of this sort. The other kind of practical book is primarily concerned with the principles that generate rules. Most of the great books in economics, politics, and morals are of this sort.

In reading a book that is primarily a rule-book, the major propositions to look for, of course, are the rules. A rule is most directly expressed by an imperative rather than a declarative sentence.

If the intelligibility of rules is to be found in principles, it is no less true that the significance of practical principles is to be found in the rules they lead to, the actions they recommend.

He tries to see the rules that may not be expressed but that can, nevertheless, be derived from the principles. He goes further. He tries to figure out how the rules should be applied in practice.

rule of conduct is practically true on two conditions: one is that it works; the other is that its working leads you to the right end, an end you rightly desire

In judging a practical book, everything turns on the ends or goals

The Role of Persuasion

There is an admixture of oratory or propaganda in every practical book. We have never read a book of political philosophy—however theoretical it may have appeared, however “abstract” the principles with which it dealt —that did not try to persuade the reader about “the best form of government.”

Since your ultimate judgment of his work is going to turn on your acceptance of the goal for which he is proposing means, it is up to him to win you to his ends.

No one makes serious practical judgments or engages in action without being moved somehow from below the neck. The world might be a better place if we did, but it would certainly be a different world. The writer of practical books who does not realize this will be ineffective. The reader of them who does not is likely to be sold a bill of goods without his knowing it

This is the way to deal with sales

person who reads a practical book intelligently, who knows its basic terms, propositions, and arguments, will always be able to detect its oratory. He will spot the passages that make an “emotive use of words.” Aware that he must be subject to persuasion, he can do something about weighing the appeals. He has sales resistance; but this need not be one hundred percent. Sales resistance is good when it prevents you from buying hastily and thoughtlessly. But the reader who supposes he should be totally deaf to all appeals might just as well not read practical books

There is a further point here. Because of the nature of practical problems and because of the admixture of oratory in all practical writing, the “personality” of the author is more important in the case of practical books than theoretical. You need know nothing whatever about the author of a mathematical treatise; his reasoning is either good or not, and it makes no difference what kind of man he is.

In reading Aristotle’s Politics, for example, it is highly relevant to know that Greek society was based on slavery. Similarly, much light is thrown on The Prince by knowing the Italian political situation at the time of Machiavelli, and his relation to the Medicis; or, in the case of Hobbes’ Leviathan, that Hobbes lived during the English civil wars and was almost pathologically distressed by social violence and disorder.

What Does Agreement Entail in the Case of a Practical Book?

The first question, What is the book about?, does not change very much. Since a practical book is an expository one, it is still necessary, in the course of answering this first question, to make an outline of the book’s structure.

However, although you must always try to find out (Rule 4 covers this) what an author’s problems were, here, in the case of practical books, this requirement becomes the dominant one.

The second question does not change very much, either. You must still, in order to answer the question about the book’s meaning or contents, discover the author’s terms, propositions, and arguments.

But here again it is the last aspect of that task (covered by Rule 8) that now looms most important. Rule 8, you will recall, required you to say which of the author’s problems he solved and which he did not.

In other words, if Rule 4 as adapted for practical books is FIND OUT WHAT THE AUTHOR WANTS YOU TO DO, then Rule 8, as similarly adapted, is FIND OUT HOW HE PROPOSES THAT YOU DO THIS.

The third question, Is it true?, is changed somewhat more than the first two.

In the case of a practical book, although there is some such comparison of the book and reality, the main consideration is whether the author’s objectives—that is, the ends that he seeks, together with the means he proposes to reach them—accord with your conception of what it is right to seek, and of what is the best way of seeking it

The fourth question, What of it?, is changed most of all. If,

Agreement with a practical book, however, does imply action on your part. If you are convinced or persuaded by the author that the ends he proposes are worthy, and if you are further convinced or persuaded that the means he recommends are likely to achieve those ends, then it is hard to see how you can refuse to act in the way the author wishes you to.

Let us give an example of what we mean. If, after completing Part Two of this book, you (1) agreed that reading analytically is worthwhile, and (2) accepted the rules of reading as essentially supportive of that aim, then you must have begun to try to read in the manner we have described. If you did not, it is not just because you were lazy or tired. It is because you did not really mean either (1) or (2).

With regard to the ends proposed by the authors of such works, these are sometimes general or universal—applicable to all human beings—and sometimes applicable only to a certain portion of human beings. If the end is universal—as it is, for example, with this book, which maintains that all persons should read better, not just some—then the implication discussed in this section applies to every reader. If the end is selective, applying only to a certain class of human beings, then the reader must decide whether or not he belongs to that class.

14HOW TO READ IMAGINATIVE LITERATURE

To have expounded the rules for reading imaginative and expository literature at the same time would have been confusing. But now we cannot ignore the other types of reading any longer.

The problem of knowing how to read imaginative literature is inherently much more difficult than the problem of knowing how to read expository books. Nevertheless, it seems to be a fact that such skill is more widely possessed than the art of reading science and philosophy, politics, economics, and history. How can this be true?

From our teaching experience, we know how tongue-tied people become when asked to say what they liked about a novel. That they enjoyed it is perfectly clear to them, but they cannot give much of an account of their enjoyment or tell what the book contained that caused them pleasure.

A critical reading of anything depends upon the fullness of one’s apprehension. Those who cannot say what they like about a novel probably have not read it below its most obvious surfaces.

However, there is more to the paradox than that. Imaginative literature primarily pleases rather than teaches.

Beauty is harder to analyze than truth.

How Not to Read Imaginative Literature

Imaginative ones try to communicate an experience itself— one that the reader can have or share only by reading—and if they succeed, they give the reader something to be enjoyed.

This does not mean that we can think without using our imagination, or that sense experience is ever wholly divorced from rational insight or reflection. The matter is only one of emphasis. Fiction appeals primarily to the imagination. That is one reason for calling it imaginative literature, in contrast to science and philosophy which are intellectual.

Don’t try to resist the effect that a work of imaginative literature has on you.

The kind of activity that is appropriate in reading poetry and fiction is not the same. It is a sort of passive action, if we may be allowed the expression, or, better, active passion. We must act in such a way, when reading a story, that we let it act on us. We must allow it to move us, we must let it do whatever work it wants to do on us. We must somehow make ourselves open to it

The imaginative writer tries to maximize the latent ambiguities of words, in order thereby to gain all the richness and force that is inherent in their multiple meanings. He uses metaphors as the units of his construction just as the logical writer uses words sharpened to a single meaning. What Dante said of The Divine Comedy, that it must be read as having several distinct though related meanings, generally applies to poetry and fiction.

imaginative writing relies as much upon what is implied as upon what is said. The multiplication of metaphors puts almost more content between the lines than in the words that compose them. The whole poem or story says something that none of its words say or can say.

From this fact we obtain another negative injunction. Don’t look for terms, propositions, and arguments in imaginative literature. Such things are logical, not poetic, devices.

imaginative books teach only derivatively, by creating experiences from which we can learn

Finally, one last negative rule. Don’t criticize fiction by the standards of truth and consistency that properly apply to communication of knowledge.

The “truth” of a good story is its verisimilitude, its intrinsic probability or plausibility.

What do we do with a philosophical book, once we have read it and understood it? We test it—against the common experience that was its original inspiration, and that is its only excuse for being. We say, is this true? Have we felt this? Have we always thought this without realizing it? Is this obvious now, though it was not previously? Complicated as the author’s theory or explanation may be, is it actually simpler than the chaotic ideas and opinions we had about this subject before?

We cannot test Othello, say, against our own experience, unless we too are Moors and wedded to Venetian ladies whom we suspect of treachery. But even if this were so, Othello is not every Moor, and Desdemona is not every Venetian lady; and most such couples would have the good fortune not to know an Iago. In fact, all but one would be so fortunate; Othello, the character as well as the play, is unique.

General Rules for Reading Imaginative Literature

There are, as we have seen, three groups of such rules. The first group consists of rules for discovering the unity and part-whole structure; the second consists of rules for identifying and interpreting the book’s component terms, propositions, and arguments; the third consists of rules for criticizing the author’s doctrine so that we can reach intelligent agreement or disagreement with him.

We called these three groups of rules structural, interpretive, and critical.

First, we can translate the structural rules—the rules of outlining—into their fictional analogues as follows.

(1) You must classify a work of imaginative literature according to its kind

Everyone knows, furthermore, that a play differs from a novel by reason of the fact that it narrates entirely by means of actions and speeches.

reading. (2) You must grasp the unity of the whole work. Whether you have done this or not can be tested by whether you are able to express that unity in a sentence or two

the unity of a story is always in its plot. You have not grasped the whole story until you can summarize its plot in a brief narration—not a proposition or an argument. Therein lies its unity.

(3) You must not only reduce the whole to its simplest unity, but you must also discover how that whole is constructed out of all its parts.

To know the structure of a narrative, you must know where it begins—which is not necessarily on the first page, of course—what it goes through, and where it comes out at.

The parts or sub-wholes of an expository book are more likely to be independently readable than the parts of fiction.

(1) The elements of fiction are its episodes and incidents, its characters, and their thoughts, speeches, feelings, and actions.

have not grasped a story until you are familiar with its characters, until you have lived through its events

(2) Terms are connected in propositions. The elements of fiction are connected by the total scene or background against which they stand out in relief.

(3) If there is any motion in an expository book, it is the movement of the argument, a logical transition from evidences and reasons to the conclusions they support. In the reading of such books, it is necessary to follow the argument. Hence, after you have discovered its terms and propositions, you are called upon to analyze its reasoning. There is an analogous last step in the interpretive reading of fiction. You have become acquainted with the characters. You have joined them in the imaginary world wherein they dwell, consented to the laws of their society, breathed its air, tasted its food, traveled its highways. Now you must follow them through their adventures. The scene or background, the social setting, is (like the proposition) a kind of static connection of the elements of fiction. The unraveling of the plot (like the arguments or reasoning) is the dynamic connection. Aristotle said that plot is the soul of a story. It is its life. To read a story well you must have your finger on the pulse of the narrative, be sensitive to its very beat.

An analogy of this sort is like a metaphor that will disintegrate if you press it too hard

The three steps we have suggested outline the way in which one becomes progressively aware of the artistic achievement of an imaginative writer. Far from spoiling your enjoyment of a novel or play, they should enable you to enrich your pleasure by knowing intimately the sources of your delight. You will not only know what you like but also why you like it.

One other caution: the foregoing rules apply mainly to novels and plays. To the extent that lyric poems have some narrative line, they apply to lyrics also. But the rules do not cease to apply to non-narrative lyrics, although the connection is much less close.

Third, and last, what are the critical rules for reading fiction

here the maxim is: don’t criticize imaginative writing until you fully appreciate what the author has tried to make you experience.

There is an important corollary to this. The good reader of a story does not question the world that the author creates—the world that is re-created in himself. “We must grant the artist his subject, his idea, his donné,” said Henry James in The Art of Fiction;“our criticism is applied only to what he makes of it.”

The beauty of any work of art is related to the pleasure it gives us when we know it well.

Let us restate the maxims, then, in the following manner. Before you express your likes and dislikes, you must first be sure that you have made an honest effort to appreciate the work. By appreciation, we mean having the experience that the author tried to produce for you by working on your emotions and imagination.

Hence, to complete the task of criticism, you must objectify your reactions by pointing to those things in the book that caused them. You must pass from saying what you like or dislike and why, to saying what is good or bad about the book and why.

SUGGESTIONS FOR READING STORIES, PLAYS, AND POEMS

Before proceeding to those matters, however, it is desirable to make some remarks about the last of the four questions that the active and demanding reader must ask of any book, when that question is asked of a work of imaginative literature.

You will recall that the first three questions are: first, What is the book about as a whole?; second, What is being said in detail, and how?; and third, Is the book true, in whole or part? The application of these three questions to imaginative literature was covered in the last chapter. The first question is answered when you are able to describe the unity of the plot of a story, play, or poem—“plot” being construed broadly to include the action or movement of a lyric poem as well as of a story. The second question is answered when you are able to discern the role that the various characters play, and recount, in your own words, the key incidents and events in which they are involved. And the third question is answered when you are able to give a reasoned judgment about the poetical truth of the work. Is it a likely story? Does the work satisfy your heart and your mind? Do you appreciate the beauty of the work? In each case, can you say why?

The fourth question is, What of it? In the case of expository books, an answer to this question implies some kind of action on your part.

Action in this sense is not obligatory when the expository work is theoretical. There, mental action alone is required. But if you are convinced that such a book is true, in whole or part, then you must agree with its conclusions, and if they imply some adjustment of your views of the subject, then you are more or less required to make those adjustments.

in the case of a work of imaginative literature, this fourth and final question must be interpreted quite differently. In a sense, the question is irrelevant to the reading of stories and poems. Strictly speaking, no action whatever is called for on your part when you have read a novel, play, or poem well—that is, analytically. You have discharged all of your responsibilities as a reader when you have applied the parallel rules of analytical reading to such works, and answered the first three questions.

Sometimes a story is a better way of getting a point across—be it a political, economic, or moral point—than an expository work making the same point.

George Orwell’s Animal Farm and his 1984 are both powerful attacks on totalitarianism. Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World is an eloquent diatribe against the tyranny of technological progress.

As E. B. White once remarked, “A despot doesn’t fear eloquent writers preaching freedom-he fears a drunken poet who may crack a joke that will take hold.”

Imaginative writings can lead to action, but they do not have to. They belong in the realm of fine art.

It is, as Emerson said of beauty, its own excuse for being.

If you feel impelled because of a book you have read to go out and do something, ask yourself whether the work contains some implied statement that has produced this feeling.

Poetry, properly speaking, is not the realm of statement, although many stories and poems have statements in them, more or less deeply buried. And it is quite right to take heed of them, and to react to them.

How to Read Stories

The first piece of advice we would like to give you for reading a story is this: Read it quickly and with total immersion.

Ideally, a story should be read at one sitting, although this is rarely possible for busy people with long novels. Nevertheless, the ideal should be approximated by compressing the reading of a good story into as short a time as feasible. Otherwise you will forget what happened, the unity of the plot will escape you, and you will be lost.

Read quickly, we suggest, and with total immersion. We have indicated the importance of letting an imaginative book work on you.

Try as hard as you can to live in his world, not in yours; there, the things he does may be quite understandable. And do not judge the world as a whole until you are sure that you have “lived” in it to the extent of your ability.

Following this rule will allow you to answer the first question you should ask about any book—What is it about, as a whole? Unless you read it quickly you will fail to see the unity of the story. Unless you read intensely you will fail to see the details.

The terms of a story, as we have observed, are its characters and incidents.

But here a word of warning. To take War and Peace as an example, many readers start this great novel and are overwhelmed by the vast number of characters to whom they are introduced, especially since they all have strange-sounding names. They soon give up on the book in the belief that they will never be able to sort out all the complicated relationships, to know who is who. This is true of any big novel—and if a novel is really good, we want it to be as big as possible.

We should not expect to remember every character; many of them are merely background persons, who are there only to set off the actions of the main characters. However, by the time we have finished War and Peace or any big novel, we know who is important, and we do not forget.

We also, despite the plethora of incidents, soon learn what is important. Authors generally give a good deal of help in this respect; they do not want the reader to miss what is essential to the unfolding of the plot, so they flag it in various ways. But our point is that you should not be anxious if all is not clear from the beginning. Actually, it should not be clear then. A story is like life itself; in life, we do not expect to understand events as they occur, at least with total clarity, but looking back on them, we do understand. So the reader of a story, looking back on it after he has finished it, understands the relation of events and the order of actions.

Life goes on, but the story does not. Its characters have no vitality outside the book, and your imagination of what happens to them before the first page and after the last is only as good as the next reader’s. Actually, all such speculations are meaningless. Preludes to Hamlet have been written, but they are ridiculous. We should not ask what happens to Pierre and Natasha after War and Peace ends. We are satisfied with Shakespeare’s and Tolstoy’s creations partly because they are limited in time. We need no more.

fiction is important, too, because it also touches the unconscious

For example, we are often pleased when a character in a novel inherits money, or otherwise comes into good fortune. However, this tends to be true only if the character is “sympathetic”—meaning that we can identify with him or her. We do not admit to ourselves that we would like to inherit the money, we merely say that we like the book.

Perhaps we would all like to love more richly than we do. Many novels are about love—most are, perhaps—and it gives us pleasure to identify with the loving characters. They are free, and we are not. But we may not want to admit this; for to do so might make us feel, consciously, that our own loves are inadequate.

Again, almost everyone has some unconscious sadism and masochism in his makeup. These are often satisfied in novels, where we can identify with either the conqueror or victim, or even with both. In each case, we are prone to say simply that we like “that kind of book”—without specifying or really knowing why.

Finally, we suspect that life as we know it is unjust. Why do good people suffer, and bad ones prosper? We do not know, we cannot know, but the fact causes great anxiety in everyone. In stories, this chaotic and unpleasant situation is adjusted, and that is extremely satisfying to us.

great storyteller makes no mistakes. He is able to convince us that justice—poetic justice, we call it—has been done

This is true even of high tragedy. There, terrible things happen to good men, but we see that the hero, even if he does not wholly deserve his fate, at least comes to understand it.

As long as man is man, they will go on satisfying him, giving him something that he needs to have—a belief in justice and understanding and the allaying of anxiety.

A Note About Epics

Judging by the very small number that have been completed successfully in the past 2,500 years, a long epic poem is apparently the most difficult thing a man can write.

So honor is due the poet who sticks to the task and completes it. Greater honor is due him if he produces a work that has the qualities of the five just mentioned. But they are certainly not easy to read.

This is not only because they are written in verse—for in every case except that of Paradise Lost, prose translations are available to us. The difficulty seems rather to lie in their elevation, in their approach to their subject matter. Any of these major epics exerts enormous demands on the reader—demands of attention, of involvement, and of imagination. The effort required to read them is very great indeed.

Perhaps the most honored but probably the least read books in the great tradition of the Western World are the major epic poems, particularly the Iliad and Odyssey of Homer, Virgil’s Aeneid, Dante’s Divine Comedy, and Milton’s Paradise Lost. This paradox requires some comment.

We hope that you will take a stab at reading these five great epic poems, and that you will manage to get through all of them.

How to Read Plays

A play is fiction, a story, and insofar as that is true, it should be read like a story. Perhaps the reader has to be more active in creating the background, the world in which the characters live and move, for there is no description in plays such as abounds in novels. But the problems are essentially similar

When you read a play, you are not reading a complete work. The complete play (the work that the author intended you to apprehend) is only apprehended when it is acted on a stage. Like music, which must be heard, a play lacks a physical dimension when we read it in a book. The reader must supply that dimension.

Therefore, once you have discovered what the play is about, as a whole and in detail, and once you have answered the other questions you must ask about any story, then try directing the play.

Tell them how to say this line, how to play that scene. Explain the importance of these few words, and how that action is the climax of the work. You will have a lot of fun, and you will learn a lot about the play.

Your own decision will be central to your understanding of the play.

Our point is that it is always desirable, no matter how explicit the playwright was in telling us exactly what we should expect to see. (We cannot question what we are to hear, since the play’s words are before us.) Probably you have not read a play really well until you have pretended to put it on the stage in this way. At best, you have given it only a partial reading.

Aristophanes, the ancient Greek comic playwright, wrote the only examples of what is called Old Comedy that survive. From time to time in an Aristophanic play, and always at least once, the leading actor would step out of character, perhaps move forward toward the audience, and deliver a political speech that had nothing whatever to do with the action of the drama.

The other example is that of Shaw, who not only expected his plays to be acted but also hoped that they would be read.

He published them all, at least one (Heartbreak House) before it was ever acted, and accompanied the publication with long prefaces in which he explained the meaning of the plays and told his readers how to understand them.

We have already suggested the importance of reading the plays through, as nearly as possible at one sitting, in order to get a feel for the whole. But, since the plays are mostly in verse, and since the verse is more or less opaque in places because of changes in the language that have occurred since 1600, it is often desirable to read a puzzling passage out loud.

Read slowly, as if an audience were listening, and with “expression”—that is, try to make the words meaningful to you as you read them. This simple device will clear up many difficulties.

A Note About Tragedy

Most plays are not worth reading. This, we think, is because they are incomplete. They were not meant to be read—they were meant to be acted. There are many great expository works, and many great novels, stories, and lyric poems, but there are only a few great plays. However, those few—the tragedies of Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripedes, the plays of Shakespeare, Molière’s comedies, the works of a very few moderns—are very great indeed, for they contain within them some of the deepest and richest insights men have ever expressed in words.

Among these, Greek tragedy is probably the toughest nut to crack for beginning readers.

For one thing, in the ancient world three tragedies were presented at one time, the three often dealing with a common theme, but except in one case (the Oresteia of Aeschylus) only single plays (or acts) survive. For another, it is almost impossible to stage the plays mentally, since we know almost nothing about how the Greek directors did it. For still another, the plays often are based on stories that were well known to their audiences but are known to us only through the plays. It is one thing to know the story of Oedipus, for example, as well as we know the story of George Washington and the Cherry Tree, and thus to view Sophocles’ masterpiece as a commentary on a familiar tale; and it is quite another to see Oedipus Rex as the primary story and try to imagine the familiar tale that provided the background.

We have two bits of advice that may help.

The first is to remember that the essence of tragedy is time, or rather the lack of it. There is no problem in any Greek tragedy that could not have been solved if there had been enough time, but there is never enough.

That is the question that you should always ask in reading any Greek tragedy.

The second bit of advice is this. One thing we do know about the staging of Greek plays is that the tragic actors wore buskins on their feet that elevated them several inches above the ground. (They also wore masks.) But the members of the chorus did not wear buskins, though they sometimes wore masks. The comparison between the size of the tragic protagonists, on the one hand, and the members of the chorus, on the other hand, was thus highly significant.

Therefore you should always imagine, when you read the words of the chorus, that the words are spoken by persons of your own stature; while the words spoken by the protagonists proceed from the mouths of giants, from personages who did not only seem, but actually were, larger than life.

How to Read Lyric Poetry

Poetry, they hold, is a kind of spontaneous overflowing of the personality, which may be expressed in written words but may also take the form of physical action, or more or less musical sound, or even just feeling.

Whatever may be the origin of the poetic impulse, poetry, for us, consists of words, and what is more, of words that are arranged in a more or less orderly and disciplined way.

Other definitions of the term that similarly contain a kernel of truth are that poetry (again, primarily lyric poetry) is not truly poetry unless it praises, or unless it rouses to action (usually revolutionary), or unless it is written in rhyme, or unless it employs a specialized language that is called “poetic diction.”

We do not mean that you should not work on a poem. A good poem can be worked at, re-read, and thought about over and over for the rest of your life. You will never stop finding new things in it, new pleasures and delights, and also new ideas about yourself and the world.

The first rule to follow in reading a lyric is to read it through without stopping, whether you think you understand it or not. This is the same rule that we have suggested for many different kinds of books, but it is more important for a poem than it is for a philosophical or scientific treatise, and even for a novel or play

But any good lyric poem has a unity. Unless we read all of it, and all at once, we cannot comprehend its unity. We cannot discover, except possibly by accident, the basic feeling or experience that underlies it.

The second rule for reading lyrics is this: Read the poem through again—but read it out loud.

Your ear is offended by a misplaced emphasis that your eyes might miss.

The questions you ask of a lyric are usually rhetorical, though they may also be syntactical. You do not come to terms with a poem; but you must discover the key words.

Why do certain words pop out of the poem and stare you in the face? Is it because the rhythm marks them? Or the rhyme? Or are the words repeated? Do several stanzas seem to be about the same ideas; if so, do these ideas form any kind of sequence? Anything of this sort that you can discover will help your understanding.

In most good lyrics there is some kind of conflict. Some times two antagonists—either individual people, or images, or ideas—are named, and then the conflict between them is described. If so, this is easy to discover. But often the conflict is only implied and not stated.

For example, a large number of great lyric poems—perhaps even the majority of them—are about the conflict between love and time, between life and death, between the beauty of transient things and the triumph of eternity. But these words may not be mentioned in the poem itself.

Love’s not Time’s fool, though rosy lips and cheeksWithin his bending sickle’s compass come;Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks,But bears it out even to the edge of doom.

When my love swears that she is made of truthI do believe her, though I know she lies,

is also about the conflict between love and time, although the word “time” appears nowhere in the poem.

Marvell’s celebrated lyric “To His Coy Mistress” is about the same subject, for he makes this clear right at the beginning: Had we but world enough, and time,This coyness, lady, were no crime

Let us roll all our strength and allOur sweetness up into one ball,And tear our pleasures with rough strifeThorough the iron gates of life.Thus, though we cannot make our sunStand still, yet we will make him run

subject of “You, Andrew Marvell,” by Archibald MacLeish, is exactly the same.

The poem begins: And here face down beneath the sunAnd here upon earth’s noonward heightTo feel the always coming onThe always rising of the night

And here face downward in the sunTo feel how swift, how secretly,The shadow of the night comes on….

We put much faith in commentaries, criticism, biographies—but this may be only because we doubt our own ability to read.

But a vast knowledge of the context of a poem is no guarantee that the poem itself will be understood. To be understood it must be read—over and over. Reading any great lyric poem is a lifetime job—not, of course, in the sense that it should go on and on throughout a lifetime, but rather that as a great poem, it deserves many return visits. And during vacations from a given poem, we may learn more about it than we realize

HOW TO READ HISTORY

First of all, there is the difference between history as fact and history as a written record of the facts. We are obviously, here, employing the term in the latter sense, since in our sense of “read” you cannot read facts

The sense in which we use the word “history” in what follows is both narrower and broader than any of those. It is narrower because we want to restrict ourselves to essentially narrative accounts, presented in a more or less formal manner, of a period or event or series of events in the past. This is a traditional use of the term, and we do not apologize for it. Again, as with our definition of lyric poetry, we think you will agree with us that this is the ordinary meaning of the term, and we want to stick to the ordinary here.

We think, although not all historians agree with us, that the essence of history is narration, that the last five letters of the word—“story”—help us to understand the basic meaning. Even a collection of documents, as a collection, tells a story.

But it is implicit in them, whether they are ordered or not. Otherwise, we think, the collection would not be called a history of its time.

The Elusiveness of Historical Facts

A court concerns itself with events that have happened fairly recently and in the presence of living witnesses. In addition, there are stringent rules of evidence. A witness cannot suppose anything, he cannot guess or hypothecate or estimate (except under very carefully controlled conditions). And of course he is not supposed to lie.

With all the careful rules of evidence, and cross-examination besides, have you ever been absolutely sure, as a member of a jury, that you really knew what happened? The law assumes that you will not be absolutely sure.

A historical fact, though we may have a feeling of trust and solidity about the word, is one of the most elusive things in the world.

Theories of History

If not, if history, that is, is allowed to rest somewhere in between the two main divisions of the kinds of books, then it is usually admitted that history is closer to fiction than to science.

This does not mean that a historian makes up his facts, like a poet or story teller. However, we might get into trouble if we insisted too strongly that a writer of fiction makes up his facts.

It is only in dreams that human beings create really strange new worlds—yet even in the most fantastic dream the events and creatures of the imagination are made up out of elements of everyday experience. They are merely put together in strange new ways.

A good historian does not, of course, make up the past. He considers himself responsibly bound by some concept or criterion of accuracy or facts. Nevertheless, it is important to remember that the historian must always make up something

It is essential to recognize which way the historian you are reading is operating.

The causes of every human action, Tolstoy thought, were so manifold, so complex, and so deeply hidden in unconscious motivations that it is impossible to know why anything ever happened.

Because theories of history differ, and because a historian’s theory affects his account of events, it is necessary to read more than one account of the history of an event or period if we want to understand it.

The Universal in History

We are not always able to read more than one history of an event. When we are not, we must admit that we do not have much chance of learning the truth of the matter in question—of learning what really happened.

We, as lay readers of history, stand somewhere between the professional historian, on the one hand, and the irresponsible amateur, on the other hand, who reads history only for amusement.

Let us take the example of Thucydides. You may be aware that he wrote the only major contemporary history of the Peloponnesian War at the end of the fifth century B.C. In a sense, there is nothing to check his work against. What, then, can we expect to learn from it? Greece is now a tiny country; a war that occurred there twenty-five centuries ago can have little real effect on our life today. Everyone who fought in it is long dead, and the specific things for which they fought are long dead, too. The victories are now meaningless, and the defeats without pain. The cities that were taken and lost have crumbled into dust. Indeed, if we stop to think of it, almost all that remains of the Peloponnesian War is Thucydides’ account of it.

Yet that account is still important. For Thucydides’ story —we might as well use that word—has had an influence on the subsequent history of man. Leaders in later eras read Thucydides. When they found themselves in situations that even faintly approximated that of the tragically divided Greek city-states, they compared their own position to that of Athens or Sparta. They used Thucydides as an excuse and a justification, and even as a pattern of conduct. The result was that by ever so little, perhaps, but perceptibly, the history of the world was changed by the view held of a small portion of it by Thucydides in the fifth century B.C

Thus we read Thucydides not because he described perfectly what happened before he wrote his book, but because he to a certain extent determined what happened after.

And we read him, strange as this may seem, to know what is happening now.

But any good history is also universal.

Thucydides himself said that he was writing his history so that men of the future would not have to repeat the mistakes he had seen made and from which he had suffered personally and through the agony of his country.

Yet some of the very same errors that the Athenians and the Spartans made 2,500 years ago, or at least very similar ones, are being made now, as they have been made over and over again since Thucydides’ time.

Let us sum up these two suggestions for reading history. The first is: if you can, read more than one history of an event or period that interests you. The second is: read a history not only to learn what really happened at a particular time and place in the past, but also to learn the way men act in all times and places, especially now.

Questions to Ask of a Historical Book

Despite the fact that most histories are closer to fiction than to science, they can be read as expository works, and therefore they should be.

As far as the first question is concerned, every history has a particular and limited subject. It is surprising, then, how often readers do not trouble to find out what this is. In particular, they do not always note carefully what limitations the author sets for himself.

Hence, if we are to read a history well, it is necessary to know precisely what it is about and what it is not about. Certainly, if we are to criticize it, we must know the latter. An author cannot be blamed for not doing what he did not try to do.

With regard to the second question, the historian tells a story, and that story, of course, occurred in time. Its general outlines are thus determined, and we do not have to search for them. But there is more than one way to tell a story, and we must know how the historian has chosen to tell his. Does he divide his work into chapters that correspond to years or decades or generations? Or does he divide it according to other rubrics of his own choosing? Does he discuss, in one chapter, the economic history of his period, and cover its wars and religious movements and literary productions in others? Which of these is most important to him?

Criticism of history takes two forms. We can judge—but only, as always, after we understand what is being said—that a historian’s work lacks verisimilitude.

On the other hand, we may think, especially if we have some special knowledge of the subject, that the historian has misused his sources. We may be indignant to discover that he has not read a certain book that we have read. And he may be misinformed about the facts of the matter. In that case, he cannot have written a good history of it. We expect a historian to be informed.

The first criticism is, however, more important. A good historian must combine the talents of the storyteller and the scientist. He must know what is likely to have happened as well as what some witnesses or writers said actually did happen.

With regard to the last question, What of it?, it is possible that no kind of literature has a greater effect on the actions of men than history. Satires and pictures of philosophical utopias have little effect; we would all like the world to be better, but we are seldom inspired by the recommendations of authors who do no more than describe, often bitterly, the difference between the real and the ideal. History, which tells us of the actions of men of the past, often does lead us to make changes, to try to better our lot. In general, statesmen have been more learned in history than in other disciplines.

The main answer to the question, What of it?, therefore, lies in the direction of practical, political action. For this reason it is of great importance that history be read well. Unfortunately, leaders have often acted with some knowledge of history but not enough. With the world as small and dangerous as it has become, it would be a good idea for all of us to start reading history better.

How to Read Biography and Autobiography

A biography is a story about a real person. This mixed patrimony causes it to have a mixed character.

The reader must ask the same sort of questions—what is the author’s purpose? What are his criteria of truth?—as well, of course, as asking the questions we must ask of any book.

The definitive biography is intended to be the final, exhaustive, scholarly work on the life of someone important enough to deserve a definitive biography.

Definitive biographies cannot be written about living persons.

They are seldom written until several non-definitive biographies have first appeared, all of them often somewhat inadequate. All sources are gone through, all letters read, and a great deal of contemporary history examined by the author. Since the ability to gather the materials is somewhat different from the talent for shaping them into a good book, definitive biographies are not always easy reading.

One of the greatest of all biographies is Boswell’s Life of Johnson, and it is continuously fascinating. It is certainly definitive (though other biographies of Dr. Johnson have since appeared), but it is also uniquely interesting.

An authorized biography is not the same thing at all. Such works are usually commissioned by the heirs or friends of some important person, and they are carefully written so that the errors the person made and the triumphs he achieved are seen in the best light possible.

Instead of reading it simply as history, the reader should understand that it may be biased—that this is the way the reader is expected to think of the book’s subject; this is the way his friends and associates want him to be known to the world.

But we should not hope to discover the real life of a human being any more than we would hope to know the real story of a war if we read the communiqués of only one side.

There remain those biographies that are neither definitive nor authorized. Perhaps we may call them ordinary biographies. In such works, we expect the author to be accurate, to know his facts. We want above all to be given the feeling that we are viewing the life of a real person in another time and place. Human beings are curious, and especially curious about other human beings.

Such books, although not trustworthy in the way definitive biographies are, are often very good reading. The world would be the poorer without Izaak Walton’s Lives of his friends, the poets John Donne and George Herbert, for example (Walton is of course better known for his The Compleat Angler); or John Tyndall’s account of his friend Michael Faraday in Faraday the Discoverer.

Some biographies are didactic. They have a moral purpose. Not many of this sort are written any more, but they used to be common. (They are still written for children, of course.) Plutarch’s Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans is such a work.

Its subjects are interesting people, good and bad, but never indifferent. Plutarch realized this himself.

His original intention in writing had been to instruct others, he said, but in the course of the work he discovered that more and more it was he himself who was deriving profit and stimulation from “lodging these men one after the other in his house.”

Incidentally, Plutarch’s is another historical work that has exercised a profound influence on subsequent history. For example, just as Plutarch shows Alexander the Great modeling his own life on that of Achilles (whose life he learned about from Homer), so many later conquerors have tried to model their lives on that of Plutarch’s Alexander.

Autobiographies present some different and interesting problems. First of all, it is questionable whether anyone has ever written a true autobiography. If it is difficult to know the life of anyone else, it is even more difficult to know one’s own. And, of course, all autobiographies have to be written about lives that are not yet complete.

Everybody has some secrets he cannot bear to divulge; everybody also has some illusions about himself, which it is almost impossible for him to regard as illusions.

It is customary to say that the Confessions of Rousseau, or some other book written about the same time (about the middle of the eighteenth century), is the first real autobiography.

In fact, much of what anyone writes on any subject is autobiographical.

There is a great deal of Plato in the Republic, of Milton in Paradise Lost, of Goethe in Faust— though we may not be able to put our finger on it exactly. If we are interested in humanity, we will tend, within reasonable limits, to read any book partly with an eye to discovering the character of its author.

This should never be the primary consideration, and it leads, when it is overdone, to the so-called pathetic fallacy. But we should remember that words do not write themselves —the ones we read have been found and written down by a living man.

“I have no more made my book,” said Montaigne, “than my book has made me; a book co-substantial with its author, concerned with my own self, an integral part of my life.” And he added, “Everyone recognizes me in my book, and my book in me.”

Despite the fact that such books, and especially the autobiographies, reveal much about their authors, we should not spend so much time trying to discover a writer’s secrets that we do not find out what he says plainly.

if you wish to know the truth about a person’s life, you should read as many biographies of him as you can find, including his own account of his life, if he wrote one

What of it?, we would only say this: biography, like history, can be a cause of practical, moral action. A biography can be inspiring. It is the story of a life, usually a more or less successful one—and we too have lives to lead

How to Read About Current Events

Analytical reading is not always necessary. There are many things that we read that do not require the kind of effort and skill that is called for at this third level of reading ability.

Nevertheless, although the rules of reading do not all always have to be applied, the four questions must always be asked of anything you read.

But we do have an obligation, as human beings and as citizens, to try to understand the world around us.

How do we get the news, and how do we know that what we get is true?

We cannot be sure that we are getting at the facts—we cannot be sure that we know what is happening now any more than we can be sure about what happened in the past. And yet we must try to know, so far as that is possible.

If we could be everywhere at once, overhear all conversations on earth, look into the heart of every living person, we might be able to make a stab at the truth of current events. Being human and hence limited, we must fall back on the services of reporters. Reporters are persons who are supposed to know what is happening in a small area. They report it in newspaper stories, in magazines, or in books. What we can know depends on them

Thus the most important thing to know, when reading any report of current happenings, is who is writing the report.

To understand what kind of filter our reporter’s mind is, we must ask a series of questions about it. This amounts to asking a series of questions about any material dealing with current events. The questions are these:

  1. What does the author want to prove?
  2. Whom does he want to convince?
  3. What special knowledge does he assume?
  4. What special language does he use?
  5. Does he really know what he is talking about

Having asked what the book is trying to prove, you should next ask whom the author is trying to convince. Is the book intended for those “in the know”—and are you in that category? Is it for that small group of persons who can do something, and quickly, about the situation the author describes? Or is it for everyone? If you do not belong to the audience for which the book is intended, you may not want to read it.

must next discover what special knowledge the author assumes that you have. The word “knowledge” is intended here to cover a lot of ground. “Opinion” or “prejudice” might have been a better choice. Many authors write only for readers who agree with them. If you disagree sharply with a reporter’s assumptions, you may only be irritated if you try to read his book

He goes on to suggest that it is easier to discover the “doctrines felt as facts” of an age different from our own, and that is what he attempts to do in his book.

In reading books about our own time, however, we do not have the advantage of distance. Thus we must try to see through the filter not only of the author-reporter’s mind, but also of our own.

Next, you must ask if there is a special language that the author uses.

Certain words provoke special responses from us, responses that they might not provoke from other readers a century hence.

What we are suggesting, in other words, is that the possible bias of the author-reporter is not the only thing that has to be considered.

Perhaps it is most useful to sum up the difference in a warning rather than a set of rules for reading books of this kind. The warning is this: Caveat lector—“Let the reader beware.” Readers do not have to be wary when reading Aristotle, or Dante, or Shakespeare.

A Note on Digests

There is another consequence of our basic distinction—the distinction between reading for information and reading for understanding—that underlies everything we have said about reading. And this is that sometimes we have to read for information about understanding—to find out how others have interpreted the facts. Let us try to explain what this means.

A summary, in this case, would function well only if it impelled us to read the original.

original, because the average article is mainly informational. The skill that produces Reader’s Digest and the scores of similar periodicals is, first of all, a skill in reading, and only then one of writing simply and clearly

If we wish to be informed, we cannot avoid the task of reading, no matter how good the digests are.

In a sense, the function they perform profits us only if we can read their digests of information as well as they have done the prior reading in order to give us the digests.

We may not have to worry about this very much if 1,000 pages are cut down to 900, say; but if 1,000 pages are cut to ten, or even one, then the question of what has been left out becomes critical.

You cannot refer to the original to find out what was left out; you must somehow infer this from the condensation itself. Reading digests, therefore, is sometimes the most demanding and difficult reading that you can do.

HOW TO READ SCIENCE AND MATHEMATICS

We will confine ourselves to discussing only two kinds: the great scientific and mathematical classics of our tradition, on the one hand, and modern scientific popularizations, on the other hand.

What we say will often be applicable to the reading of specialized monographs on abstruse and limited subjects, but we cannot help you to read those.

Most modern scientists do not care what lay readers think, and so they do not even try to reach them.

Today, science tends to be written by experts for experts.

There are obvious advantages to this approach, not least that it serves to advance science more quickly.

Nowadays, philosophers seldom write for anyone except other philosophers; economists write for economists; and even historians are beginning to find that the kind of shorthand, monographic communication to other experts that has long been dominant in science is a more convenient way of getting ideas across than the more traditional narrative work written for everyone.

Understanding the Scientific Enterprise

The attitude of scientists to historians of science could be summed up in that famous remark of George Bernard Shaw’s: “Those who can, do; those who can’t, teach.”

The reason is that scientists are more concerned than ever before about the nature of the scientific enterprise itself.

Thus we have no hesitation in recommending that you try to read at least some of the great scientific classics of our tradition. In fact, there is really no excuse for not trying to read them. None of them is impossibly difficult, not even a book like Newton’s Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, if you are willing to make the effort.

There is another way of saying this. As a layman, you do not read the classical scientific books to become knowledgeable in their subject matters in a contemporary sense. Instead, you read them to understand the history and philosophy of science.

Suggestions for Reading Classical Scientific Books

In the great works of science, there is no oratory or propaganda, though there may be bias in the sense of initial presuppositions. You detect this, and take account of it, by distinguishing what the author assumes from what he establishes through argument

Scientific objectivity is not the absence of initial bias. It is attained by frank confession of it.

The main propositions are always general ones. Science thus is not chronotopic. Just the opposite; a scientist, unlike a historian, tries to get away from locality in time and place. He tries to say how things are generally, how things generally behave.

So far as proof is concerned, science does not differ much from philosophy. But the inductive argument is characteristic of science.

One is with respect to the arguments. Science is primarily inductive; that is, its primary arguments are those that establish a general proposition by reference to observable evidence—a single case created by an experiment, or a vast array of cases collected by patient investigation.

This first difficulty arises because, in order to understand the inductive arguments in a scientific book, you must be able to follow the evidence that the scientist reports as their basis. Unfortunately, this is not always possible with nothing but the book in hand.

Anyone who desires to acquire an understanding of the history of science must not only read the classical texts, but must also become acquainted, through direct experience, with the crucial experiments in that history.

“Every branch of physical science,” wrote Lavoisier, must consist of three things: the series of facts which are the objects of the science, the ideas which represent these facts, and the words by which these facts are expressed….

And, as ideas are preserved and communicated by means of words, it necessarily follows that we cannot improve the language of any science without at the same time improving the science itself; neither can we, on the other hand, improve a science without improving the language or nomenclature which belongs to it

This was exactly what Lavoisier did. He improved chemistry by improving its language, just as Newton, a century before, had improved physics by systematizing and ordering its language—in the process, as you may recall, developing the differential and integral calculus.

Facing the Problem of Mathematics

Many people are frightened of mathematics and think they cannot read it at all. No one is quite sure why this is so. Some psychologists think there is such a thing as “symbol blindness”—the inability to set aside one’s dependence on the concrete and to follow the controlled shifting of symbols.

We have to learn our own language twice, first when we learn to speak it, second when we learn to read it. Fortunately, mathematics has to be learned only once, since it is almost wholly a written language.

If we are puzzled by the syntax of a sentence, we are also working at the elementary level. Only when we have solved these problems can we go on to read at higher levels.

Since mathematics is a language, it has its own vocabulary, grammar, and syntax, and these have to be learned by the beginning reader. Certain symbols and relationships between symbols have to be memorized.

At the elementary level, in fact, it may even be easier.

The subjects of ordinary discourse are mainly emotional facts and relations. Such subjects are not entirely comprehensible by any two different persons. But two different persons can comprehend a third thing that is outside of and emotionally separated from both of them, such as an electrical circuit, an isosceles triangle, or a syllogism

Mathematics allows us to avoid this. There are no emotional connotations of mathematical terms, propositions, and equations when these are properly used.

We are also not told, at least not early enough, how beautiful and how intellectually satisfying mathematics can be. It is probably not too late for anyone to see this if he will go to a little trouble. You might start with Euclid, whose Elements of Geometry is one of the most lucid and beautiful works of any kind that has ever been written.

Let us consider, for example, the first five propositions in Book I of the Elements. (If a copy of the book is available, you should look at it.) Propositions in elementary geometry are of two kinds: (1) the statement of problems in the construction of figures, and (2) theorems about the relations between figures or their parts. Construction problems require that something be done, theorems require that something be proved.

At the end of a Euclidean construction problem, you will find the letters Q.E.F., which stand for Quod erat faciendum,“(Being) what it was required to do.” At the end of a Euclidean theorem, you will find the letters Q.E.D., which stand for Quod erat demonstrandum,“(Being) what it was required to prove.”

The first three propositions in Book I of the Elements are all problems of construction. Why is this? One answer is that the constructions are needed in the proofs of the theorems. This is not apparent in the first four propositions, but we can see it in the fifth proposition, which is a theorem. It states that in an isosceles triangle (a triangle with two equal sides) the base angles are equal. This involves the use of Proposition 3, for a shorter line is cut off from a longer line. Since Proposition 3, in turn, depends on the use of the construction in Proposition 2, while Proposition 2 involves Proposition 1, we see that these three constructions are needed for the sake of Proposition 5

the case of the postulates, the possibility is assumed; in the case of the propositions, it is proved

has then been shown that if something is true (namely, the hypothesis that we have an isosceles triangle), and if some additional things are valid (the definitions, postulates, and prior propositions), then something else is also true, namely, the conclusion

It is precisely the truth of this connection that is proved, and nothing else.

What we have here is a really logical exposition of a really limited problem. There is something very attractive about both the clarity of the exposition and the limited nature of the problem.

We have to examine our assumptions in a way that we do not have to do in mathematics. Euclid’s proposition does not suffer from this. It does not really matter to him whether there are such things as isosceles triangles.

Handling the Mathematics in Scientific Books

First, you can probably read at least elementary mathematics better than you think. We have already suggested that you should begin with Euclid, and we are confident that if you spent several evenings with the Elements you would overcome much of your fear of the subject. Having done some work on Euclid, you might proceed to glance at the works of other classical Greek mathematicians—Archimedes, Apollonius, Nicomachus. They are not really very difficult, and besides, you can skip.

That leads to the second point we want to make. If your intention is to read a mathematical book in and for itself, you must read it, of course, from beginning to end—and with a pencil in your hand, for writing in the margins and even on a scratch pad is more necessary here than in the case of any other kinds of books.

But your intention may not be that, but instead to read a scientific work that has mathematics in it. In this case, skipping is often the better part of valor.

Take Newton’s Principia for an example. The book contains many propositions, both construction problems and theorems, but it is not necessary to read all of them in detail, especially the first time through.

Read the statement of the proposition, and glance down the proof to get an idea of how it is done; read the statements of the so-called lemmas and corollaries; and read the so-called scholiums, which are essentially discussions of the relations between propositions and of their relations to the work as a whole.

Go through the whole work in this way, avoiding the diagrams if they trouble you (as they do many readers), merely glancing at much of the interstitial matter, but being sure to find and read the passages where Newton is making his main points

Oddly enough, however, even if mathematics is absolutely terrifying to you, its absence from certain works may cause you even more trouble.

A case in point is Galileo’s Two New Sciences, his famous treatise on the strength of materials and on motion. This work is particularly difficult for modern readers because it is not primarily mathematical; instead, it is presented in the form of a dialogue. The dialogue form, though appropriate to the stage and useful in philosophy when employed by such a master as Plato, is not really appropriate to science

Popular scientific articles are usually easier to read than popular scientific books, although not always.

Even a three-page article on DNA containing no reports of experiments and no diagrams or mathematical formulas demands considerable effort on the part of the reader. You cannot read it for understanding without keeping your mind awake. Thus, the requirement that you read actively is more important here than almost anywhere else. Identify the subject matter. Discover the relation between the whole and its parts. Come to terms and plot the propositions and arguments. Work at achieving understanding before you begin to criticize or to assess significance. These rules, by now, are all familiar. But they apply here with particular force.

Thus Commoner’s book, though essentially theoretical, has a significance that goes beyond the theoretical and into the realm of the practical.

When The Universe and Dr. Einstein was written, as a theoretical account (written for a popular audience) of the history of researches into the atom, people were widely aware of the perils inherent in atomic physics, as represented mainly but not exclusively by the recently discovered atomic bomb. Thus that theoretical book also had practical consequences. But even if people are today not so worried about the imminence of an atomic or nuclear war, there is still what may be called a practical necessity to read this theoretical book, or one like it.

HOW TO READ PHILOSOPHY

So profound !!

Children ask magnificent questions. “Why are people?” “What makes the cat tick?” “What’s the world’s first name?” “Did God have a reason for creating the earth?” Out of the mouths of babes comes, if not wisdom, at least the search for it. Philosophy, according to Aristotle, begins in wonder. It certainly begins in childhood, even if for most of us it stops there, too.

Adults do not lose the curiosity that seems to be a native human trait, but their curiosity deteriorates in quality.

mind not agitated by good questions cannot appreciate the significance of even the best answers

Why should we have to try to develop such minds, when children are born with them? Somewhere along the line, adults must fail somehow to sustain the infant’s curiosity at its original depth. School itself, perhaps, dulls the mind—by the dead weight of rote learning, much of which may be necessary.

We so often tell a child there is no answer, even when one is available, or demand that he ask no more questions. We thinly conceal our irritation when baffled by the apparently unanswerable query

He may get the impression that it is impolite to be too inquisitive. Human inquisitiveness is never killed; but it is soon debased to the sort of questions asked by most college students, who, like the adults they are soon to become, ask only for information.

the most remarkable things about the great philosophical books is that they ask the same sort of profound questions that children ask

We are not required to think as children in order to understand existence. Children certainly do not, and cannot, understand it—if, indeed, anyone can. But we must be able to see as children see, to wonder as they wonder, to ask as they ask.

Take the following questions about being or existence, for example: What is the difference between existing and not existing? What is common to all the things that do exist, and what are the properties of everything that does exist? Are there different ways in which things can exist—different modes of being or existence? Do some things exist only in the mind or for the mind, whereas others exist outside the mind, and whether or not they are known to us, or even knowable by us? Does everything that exists exist physically, or are there some things that exist apart from material embodiment? Do all things change, or is there anything that is immutable? Does anything exist necessarily, or must we say that everything that does exist might not have existed? Is the realm of possible existence larger than the realm of what actually does exist?

Such questions are asked by the philosopher who turns his attention from being to becoming and also tries to relate becoming to being.

There are questions not only about being and becoming, but also about necessity and contingency; about the material and the immaterial; about the physical and the non-physical; about freedom and indeterminacy; about the powers of the human mind; about the nature and extent of human knowledge; about the freedom of the will.

particular, even if we feel that whatever is right is good, we probably do not feel that whatever is wrong is evil. But how do we make this distinction precise

The two groups of questions that we have discussed determine or identify two main divisions of philosophy. The questions in the first group, the questions about being and becoming, have to do with what is or happens in the world. Such questions belong to the division of philosophy that is called theoretical or speculative.

The questions in the second group, the questions concerning good and evil, or right and wrong, have to do with what ought to be done or sought, and they belong to the division of philosophy that is sometimes called practical, and is more accurately called normative.

books of normative philosophy concern themselves primarily with the goals all men ought to seek—goals such as leading a good life or instituting a good society—and, unlike cookbooks and driving manuals, they go no further than prescribing in the most universal terms the means that ought to be employed in order to achieve these goals.

The questions that philosophers ask also serve to distinguish subordinate branches of the two main divisions of philosophy. A work of speculative or theoretical philosophy is metaphysical if it is mainly concerned with questions about being or existence. It is a work in the philosophy of nature if it is concerned with becoming—with the nature and kinds of changes, their conditions and causes. If its primary concern is with knowledge—with questions about what is involved in our knowing anything, with the causes, extent, and limits of human knowledge, and with its certainties and uncertainties—then it is a work in epistemology, which is just another name for theory of knowledge.

Modern Philosophy and the Great Tradition

For the sake of brevity in what follows, let us call questions about what is and happens in the world, or about what men ought to do or seek, “first-order questions.” We should recognize, then, that there are also “second-order questions” that can be asked: questions about our first-order knowledge, questions about the content of our thinking when we try to answer first-order questions, questions about the ways in which we express such thoughts in language.

The majority of professional philosophers at the present day no longer believe that first-order questions can be answered by philosophers. Most professional philosophers today devote their attention exclusively to second-order questions,

Second-order questions are, almost by definition, ones of narrow appeal; and professional philosophers, like scientists, are not interested in the views of anyone but other experts.

Up to about 1930, or perhaps even a little later, philosophical books were written for the general reader. Philosophers hoped to be read by their peers, but they also wanted to be read by ordinary, intelligent men and women. Since the questions that they asked and tried to answer were of concern to everyone, they thought that everyone should know what they thought.

On Philosophical Method

the childishly simple questions we have mentioned—the question, for instance, about the properties of everything that exists, or the question about the nature and causes of change. How do you proceed? If your question were scientific, you would know that to answer it you would have to perform some kind of special research, either by way of developing an experiment to test your answer, or by way of observing a wide range of phenomena. If your question were historical, you would know that you would also have to perform research, although of a different kind. But there is no experiment that will tell you what all existing things have in common, precisely in respect to having existence. There are no special kinds of phenomena that you can observe, no documents that you can seek out and read, in order to find out what change is or why things change. All you can do is reflect upon the question. There is, in short, nothing to do but think.

What distinguishes them is that they thought about it extremely well: they formulated the most penetrating questions that could be asked about it, and they undertook to develop carefully and clearly worked-out answers. By what means? Not by investigation. Not by having or trying to get more experience than the rest of us have. Rather, by thinking more profoundly about the experience than the rest of us have.

Understanding this is not enough. We must also realize that not all of the questions that philosophers have asked and tried to answer are truly philosophical. They themselves were not always aware of this, and their ignorance or mistake in this crucial respect can cause unperceptive readers considerable difficulty. To avoid such difficulties, it is necessary to be able to distinguish the truly philosophical questions from the other questions that a philosopher may deal with, but that he should have waived and left for later scientific investigation to answer.

The philosopher was misled by failing to see that such questions can be answered by scientific investigation, though he probably could not have known this at the time of his writing.

An example of this is the question that ancient philosophers asked about the difference between the matter of terrestrial and celestial bodies. To their observation, unaided by telescopes, it appeared to be the case that the heavenly bodies changed only in place; they did not appear to come into being or to pass away, like plants and animals; nor did they appear to change in size or quality.

And, at the risk of repeating ourselves, we must emphasize that there is no other way than thinking to answer such questions. If we could build a telescope or microscope to examine the properties of existence, we should do so, of course. But no such instruments are possible.

Although there is only one philosophical method, there are at least five styles of exposition that have been employed by the great philosophers of the Western tradition. The student or reader of philosophy should be able to distinguish between them and know the advantages and disadvantages of each.

  1. THE PHILOSOPHICAL DIALOGUE:

adopted by Plato in his Dialogues

When the style is enriched by the high drama—some would say the high comedy—of the story of Socrates, it becomes enormously powerful.

“A master like Plato,” we said—but there is no one “like” Plato. Other philosophers have attempted dialogues—for example, Cicero and Berkeley—but with little success. Their dialogues are flat, dull, almost unreadable.

Plato himself had apparently no philosophical system, no doctrine—unless it was that there is no doctrine, that we should simply keep talking. And asking questions. For Plato, and Socrates before him, did indeed manage to raise most of the important questions that subsequent philosophers have felt it necessary to deal with.

  1. THE PHILOSOPHICAL TREATISE OR ESSAY:

Aristotle was Plato’s best pupil; he studied under him for twenty years. He is said to have also written dialogues, but none of these survives entirely.

What does survive are curiously difficult essays or treatises on a number of different subjects. Aristotle was obviously a clear thinker, but the difficulty of the surviving works has led scholars to suggest that they were originally notes for lectures or books—either Aristotle’s own notes, or notes taken down by a student who heard the master speak.

the documentary collections. The major one that we know about was a collection of 158 separate constitutions of Greek states. Only one of these survives, the constitution of Athens, which was recovered from a papyrus in 1890

Finally, there are the major treatises, some of which, like the Physics and Metaphysics, or the Ethics, Politics, and Poetics, are purely philosophical works, theoretical or normative; some of which, like the book On the Soul, are mixtures of philosophical theory and early scientific investigation; and some of which, like the biological treatises, are mainly scientific works in the field of natural history.

Immanuel Kant, although he was probably more influenced by Plato in a philosophical sense, adopted Aristotle’s style of exposition.

The clarity of both Kant and Aristotle may be said to consist in the order that they impose on a subject.

We see a philosophical beginning, middle, and end. We also, particularly in the case of Aristotle, are provided with accounts of the views and objections of others, both philosophers and ordinary men.

  1. THE MEETING OF OBJECTIONS

The philosophical style developed in the Middle Ages and perfected by St. Thomas Aquinas in his Summa Theologica has likenesses to both of those already discussed.

Plato, we have pointed out, raises most of the persistent philosophical problems; and Socrates, as we might have observed, asks in the course of the dialogues the kind of simple but profound questions that children ask. And Aristotle, as we have also pointed out, recognizes the objections of other philosophers and replies to them.

Aquinas’ style is a combination of question-raising and objection-meeting. The Summa is divided into parts, treatises, questions, and articles. The form of all the articles is the same. A question is posed; the opposite (wrong) answer to it is given; arguments are educed in support of that wrong answer; these are countered first by an authoritative text (often a quotation from Scripture); and finally, Aquinas introduces his own answer or solution with the words “I answer that.” Having given his own view of the matter, he then replies to each of the arguments for the wrong answer.

Rather, it is Aquinas’ explicit recognition of conflicts, his reporting of different views, and his attempt to meet all possible objections to his own solutions.

Philosophers in Aquinas’ time accepted as a matter of course that they should be prepared to defend their views in open, public disputes, which were often attended by crowds of students and other interested persons.

the philosopher was not a solitary thinker, but instead faced his oponents in the intellectual market place (as Socrates might have said).

  1. THE SYSTEMIZATION OF PHILOSOPHY

In the seventeenth century, a fourth style of philosophical exposition was developed by two notable philosophers, Descartes and Spinoza. Fascinated by the promised success of mathematics in organizing man’s knowledge of nature, they attempted to organize philosophy itself in a way akin to the organization of mathematics

What he tried to do, essentially, was to clothe philosophy in mathematical dress—to give it the certainty and formal structure that Euclid, two thousand years before, had given geometry.

Spinoza carried the conception even farther. His Ethics is written in strict mathematical form, with propositions, proofs, corollaries, lemmas, scholiums, and the like.

However, the subject matter of metaphysics and of morals is not very satisfactorily handled in this manner, which is more appropriate for geometry and other mathematical subjects than for philosophical ones.

Great point

A sign of this is that when reading Spinoza you can skip a great deal, in exactly the same way that you can skip in Newton. You cannot skip anything in Kant or Aristotle, because the line of reasoning is continuous; and you cannot skip anything in Plato, any more than you would skip a part of a play or poem.

  1. THE APHORISTIC STYLE

This is the aphoristic style adopted by Nietzsche in such works as Thus Spake Zarathustra and by certain modern French philosophers.

example of Pascal’s Pensées. But of course Pascal did not intend to leave his great work in the form of short, enigmatic statements; he died before he could finish writing out the book in essay form

The great advantage of the aphoristic form in philosophy is that it is heuristic; the reader has the impression that more is being said than is actually said, for he does much of the work of thinking—of making connections between statements and of constructing arguments for positions—himself

Thus, although the aphoristic style is enjoyable for those who are poetically inclined, it is irritating for serious philosophers who would rather try to follow and criticize an author’s line of thought.

The treatise or essay is probably the most common form, both in the past and in the present. It can range all the way from highly formal and difficult works like those of Kant, to popular philosophical essays or letters. Dialogues are notoriously hard to write, and the geometrical style is enormously difficult both to write and to read. The aphoristic style is highly unsatisfactory from a philosophical point of view. The Thomistic style has not been used very much in recent times. Perhaps it would not be acceptable to modern readers, but that seems a shame, considering all its advantages.

Hints for Reading Philosophy

It is perhaps clear from the discussion so far that the most important thing to discover in reading any philosophical work is the question or questions it tries to answer.

How the author answers these questions will be deeply affected by his controlling principles. These may be stated, too, but that is not always the case.

The great philosophers cannot be charged with having tried to hide their assumptions dishonestly, or with having been unclear in their definitions and postulations. It is precisely the mark of a great philosopher that he makes these things clearer than other writers can.

is difficult to give examples of such controlling principles. Any that we might proffer would probably be disputed by philosophers, and we do not here have space to defend our choices. Nevertheless, we could mention the controlling idea of Plato that conversation about philosophical subjects is perhaps the most important of all human activities. Now this idea is seldom explicitly stated in the dialogues, although Socrates may be saying it when, in the Apology, he asserts that the unexamined life is not worth living, and Plato mentions it in the Seventh Letter

We can find other examples in Aristotle. In the first place, it is always important to recognize, in reading any Aristotelean work, that things said in other works are relevant to the discussion.

Thus the basic principles of logic, expounded in the Organon, are assumed in the Physics.

In the second place, owing partly to the fact that the treatises are not finished works of art, their controlling principles are not always stated with satisfactory clarity.

The Ethics is about many things: happiness, habit, virtue, pleasure, and so forth—the list could be very long. But the controlling insight is discovered only by the very careful reader. This is the insight that happiness is the whole of the good, not the highest good,

One more example. Kant’s mature thought is often known as critical philosophy. He himself contrasted “criticism” to “dogmatism,” which he imputed to many previous philosophers. By “dogmatism” he meant the presumption that the human intellect can arrive at the most important truths by pure thinking, without being aware of its own limitations.

What is first required, according to Kant, is a critical survey and assessment of the mind’s resources and powers. Thus, the limitation of the mind is a controlling principle in Kant in a way that it is not in any philosopher who precedes him in time.

Sometimes it takes years to do this, and many readings and rereadings. Nevertheless, it is the ideal goal of a good and thorough reading, and you should keep in mind that it is ultimately what you must try to do if you are to understand your author.

The discovery you come to on your own will be much more valuable than someone else’s ideas.

Once you have found an author’s controlling principles, you will want to decide whether he adheres to them throughout his work. Unfortunately, philosophers, even the best of them, often do not do so.

Consistency, Emerson said, “is the hobgoblin of little minds.”

That is a very carefree statement, but although it is probably wise to remember it, there is no doubt, either, that inconsistency in a philosopher is a serious problem.

The major effort of the reader, therefore, must be with respect to the terms and the initial propositions. Although the philosopher, like the scientist, has a technical terminology, the words that express his terms are usually taken from common speech, but used in a very special sense. This demands special care from the reader

Whenever you talk generally about anything, you are using abstractions. What you perceive through your senses is always concrete and particular. What you think with your mind is always abstract and general.

Just as inductive arguments should be the reader’s main focus in the case of scientific books, so here, in the case of philosophy, you must pay closest attention to the philosophers principles.

They may be either things he asks you to assume with him, or matters that he calls self-evident.

Few philosophical books fail to state some propositions that the author regards as self-evident. Such propositions are drawn directly from experience rather than proved by other propositions

In other words, the method according to which you should read a philosophical book is very similar to the method according to which it is written. A philosopher, faced with a problem, can do nothing but think about it. A reader, faced with a philosophical book, can do nothing but read it—which means, as we know, thinking about it. There are no other aids except the mind itself.

On Making Up Your Own Mind

A good theoretical work in philosophy is as free from oratory and propaganda as a good scientific treatise

There is utility, however, in reading the works of other great philosophers who have dealt with the same problems as your author. The philosophers have carried on a long conversation with each other in the history of thought. You had better listen in on it before you make up your mind about what any of them says.

fact that philosophers disagree should not trouble you, for two reasons. First, the fact of disagreement, if it is persistent, may point to a great unsolved and, perhaps, insoluble problem. It is good to know where the true mysteries are. Second, the disagreements of others are relatively unimportant. Your responsibility is only to make up your own mind. In the presence of the long conversation that the philosophers have carried on through their books, you must judge what is true and what is false

It is, indeed, the most distinctive mark of philosophical questions that everyone must answer them for himself. Taking the opinions of others is not solving them, but evading them. And your answers must be solidly grounded, with arguments to back them up. This means, above all, that you cannot depend on the testimony of experts, as you may have to do in the case of science.

Note on Theology

There are two kinds of theology, natural theology and dogmatic theology. Natural theology is a branch of philosophy; it is the last chapter, as it were, in metaphysics.

If you ask, for example, whether causation is an endless process, whether everything is caused, you may find yourself, if you answer in the affirmative, involved in an infinite regress. Therefore you may have to posit some originating cause that is not itself caused. Aristotle called this uncaused cause an unmoved mover.

Dogmatic theology differs from philosophy in that its first principles are articles of faith adhered to by the communicants of some religion. A work of dogmatic theology always depends upon dogmas and the authority of a church that proclaims them.

But you must always keep in mind that an article of faith is not something that the faithful assume. Faith, for those who have it, is the most certain form of knowledge, not a tentative opinion.

Understanding this seems to be difficult for many readers today. Typically, they make either or both of two mistakes in dealing with dogmatic theology. The first mistake is to refuse to accept, even temporarily, the articles of faith that are the first principles of the author. As a result, the reader continues to struggle with these first principles, never really paying attention to the book itself. The second mistake is to assume that, because the first principles are dogmatic, the arguments based on them, the reasoning that they support, and the conclusions to which they lead are all dogmatic in the same way

We are speaking here, as you can see, of the difficulties that face a non-believing reader of a theological work. His task is to accept the first principles as true while he is reading the book, and then to read it with all the care that any good expository work deserves.

How to Read “Canonical” Books

We use the term “canonical” to refer to such books; in an older tradition we might have called them “sacred” or “holy,” but those words no longer apply to all such works, though they still apply to some of them.

A prime example is the Holy Bible, when it is read not as literature but instead as the revealed Word of God

Consider any institution—a church, a political party, a society—that among other things (1) is a teaching institution, (2) has a body of doctrine to teach, and (3) has a faithful and obedient membership.

The members of any such organization read reverentially. They do not—even cannot—question the authorized or right reading of the books that to them are canonical. The faithful are debarred by their faith from finding error in the “sacred” text, to say nothing of finding nonsense there.

A fledgling lawyer, intent on passing the bar exams, must read certain texts in a certain way in order to attain a perfect score

The characteristics of this kind of reading are perhaps summed up in the word “orthodox,” which is almost always applicable. The word comes from two Greek roots, meaning “right opinion

These are books for which there is one and only one right reading; any other reading or interpretation is fraught with peril, from the loss of an “A” to the damnation of one’s soul.

He reads essentially without freedom; but in return for this he gains a kind of satisfaction that is possibly never obtained when reading other books.

Here, in fact, we must stop. The problem of reading the Holy Book—if you have faith that it is the Word of God—is the most difficult problem in the whole field of reading

The Word of God is obviously the most difficult writing men can read; but it is also, if you believe it is the Word of God, the most important to read.

HOW TO READ SOCIAL SCIENCE

There is also a large and important category of contemporary writing that might be termed social-science fiction. Here the aim is to create artificial models of society that allow us, for example, to explore the social consequences of technological innovation

The reason commonly given for the separation of these schools from the social science divisions is that the main purpose of such schools is to train for professional work outside of the university, while the previously mentioned departments are more exclusively dedicated to the pursuit of systematic knowledge of human society, an activity that usually goes on within the university.

What about psychology? Those social scientists who interpret their field strictly tend to exclude psychology on the grounds that it concerns itself with individual and personal characteristics, while the social sciences proper focus on cultural, institutional, and environmental factors.

The accent on behavior served to emphasize observable, measurable behavior capable of being systematically investigated and of producing verifiable findings. Recently, the term behavioral sciences has come to be used almost as a synonym of the term social sciences, but many purists object to this usage.

The Apparent Ease of Reading Social Science

We hear of the aberrant society, the abortive society, the acquiescent society, the acquisitive society, the affluent society, and we can continue on through the alphabet until we arrive at the zymotic society, which is one that is in a continuous state of ferment, not unlike our own.

But on matters with which social science deals, we are likely to have strong opinions.

Difficulties of Reading Social Science

Paradoxically, the very factors we have discussed, the factors which make social science seem easy to read, also make it difficult to read. Consider the last factor mentioned, for instance—the commitment that you as a reader are likely to have to some view of the matter your author is considering.

The very familiarity of the terms and propositions in social science writing is also an obstacle to understanding.

An example of such a concept is that of the Gross National Product (GNP). In serious economic writing, the concept is employed in a relatively limited sense. But many reporters and columnists, some social scientists say, make the concept do too much work. They use it too widely, without really understanding what it means

Let us try to make this point clear by drawing a distinction between the social sciences, on the one hand, and the so-called hard sciences—physics, chemistry, and the like—on the other hand.

hard scientist does is to say that he “stipulates his usage”—that is, he informs you what terms are essential to his argument and how he is going to use them. Such stipulations usually occur at the beginning of the book, in the form of definitions, postulates, axioms, and so forth

Similarly, you do not dispute a hard scientist’s stipulations in reading his book. You accept them, and go on from there.

Until quite recently, at least, stipulation of usage was not as common in the social sciences as it is in the hard sciences. One reason for this is that the social sciences were typically not mathematicized.

It is one thing to define a circle or an isosceles triangle; it is quite another to define an economic depression or mental health.

Much social science is a mixture of science, philosophy, and history, often with some fiction thrown in for good measure.

If social science were always the same kind of mixture, we could become familiar with it as we have with history. But this is far from the case.

You will recall that the first step the analytical reader has to take is to answer the question, What kind of book is this? In the case of fiction, that question is relatively easy to answer. In the case of science and philosophy, it is also relatively easy; and even if history is a mixed form, at least the reader ordinarily knows that he is reading history.

The problem, in fact, is precisely as difficult as the problem of defining social science.

Nevertheless, the analytical reader must somehow manage to answer the question. It is not only his first task, but also his most important. If he is able to say what strands go to make up the book he is reading, he will have moved a good way toward understanding it.

But the last question, What of it?, requires considerable restraint on the part of the reader. It is here that the situation we described earlier may occur—namely, the situation in which the reader says, “I cannot fault the author’s conclusions, but I nevertheless disagree with them.” This comes about, of course, because of the prejudgments that the reader is likely to have concerning the author’s approach and his conclusions.

Reading Social Science Literature

More than once in the course of this chapter we have employed the phrase “social science literature” instead of “social science book.” The reason is that it is customary in social science to read several books about a subject rather than one book for its own sake.

Typically, there is no single, authoritative work on any of these subjects, and we must therefore read several.

One sign of this is that social science authors themselves, in order to keep up with the times, must constantly bring out new, revised editions of their works; and new works supersede older ones and rapidly render them obsolete.

Fully to understand a philosopher, you should make some attempt to read the philosophers your author himself has read, the philosophers who have influenced him. To some extent it is also true in history, where we suggested that, if you want to discover the truth of the past, you had better read several books about it rather than one. But in those cases the likelihood that you would find one major, authoritative work was much greater. In social science that is not so common, and so the necessity of reading several works rather than one is much more urgent.

Social science came last because of the need to read it syntopically. Thus the present chapter serves as both the end of Part Three and an introduction to Part Four.

THE FOURTH LEVEL OF READING: SYNTOPICAL READING

Knowing that more than one book is relevant to a particular question is the first requirement in any project of syntopical reading. Knowing which books should be read, in a general way, is the second requirement. The second requirement is a great deal harder to satisfy than the first.

Gone With the Wind and War and Peace are both novels about a great war—but there, for the most part, the resemblance stops.

but we do not go to these novels or any others if our primary intention is to study war.

Even a cursory perusal reveals a very great range of reference. There is hardly a single human action that has not been called—in one way or another—an act of love. Nor is the range confined to the human sphere. If you proceed far enough in your reading, you will find that love has been attributed to almost everything in the universe; that is, everything that exists has been said by someone either to love or to be loved—or both.

Stones are said to love the center of the earth. The upward motion of fire is called a function of its love. The attraction of iron filings to a magnet is described as an effect of love. Tracts have been written on the love life of amoebae, paramecia, snails, and ants, to say nothing of most of the so-called higher animals, who are said to love their masters as well as one another. When we come to human beings, we discover that authors speak and write of their love for men, women, a woman, a man, children, themselves, mankind, money, art, domesticity, principles, a cause, an occupation or profession, adventure, security, ideas, a country life, loving itself, a beefsteak, or wine. In certain learned treatises, the motions of the heavenly bodies are said to be inspired by love; in others, angels and devils are differentiated by the quality of their love. And of course God is said to be Love.

Faced with this chaotic situation, you may decide to limit the enquiry to human love—to love between human beings, of the same sex or different sexes, of the same age or different ages, and so forth. That would rule out the three statements we have just discussed.

You would find, for instance, that love is said by some writers to consist wholly in acquisitive desire, usually sexual desire; that is, love is merely a name for the attraction that almost all animals feel toward members of the opposite sex. But you would also find other authors who maintain that love, properly speaking, contains no acquisitive desire whatever, and consists in pure benevolence. Do acquisitive desire and benevolence have anything in common, considering that acquisitive desire always implies wanting some good for oneself, while benevolence implies wanting a good for someone else?

At least acquisitive desire and benevolence share a common note of tendency, of desire in some very abstract sense of the term.

But your investigation of the literature of the subject would soon uncover writers who conceive of the essence of love as being cognitive rather than appetitive. Love, these writers maintain, is an intellectual act, not an emotional one. In other words, knowing that another person is admirable always proceeds desiring him or her, in either of the two senses of desire. Such authors do not deny that desire enters into the picture, but they do deny that desire should be called love.

Let us suppose—in fact, we think it can be done—that you are able to identify some common meaning in these various conceptions of human love.

Even then not all of your problems are solved. Consider the ways in which love manifests itself between and among human beings. Is the love that a man and woman have for each other the same when they are courting as when they are married, the same when they are in their twenties as when they are in their seventies? Is the love that a woman has for her husband the same as that she has for her children? Does a mother’s love for her children change as they grow up? Is the love of a brother for his sister the same as his love for his father? Does a child’s love for its parents change as he or she grows? Is the love that a man has for a woman, either his wife or some other, the same as the friendship he feels for another man, and does it make a difference what relationship he has with the man—such as one with whom he goes bowling, one with whom he works, and one whose intellectual company he enjoys? Does the fact that “love” and “friendship” are different words mean that the emotions they name (if that is in fact what they name) differ? Can two men of different ages be friends? Can they be friends if they are markedly different in some other respect, such as possession of wealth or degree of intelligence? Can women be friends at all? Can brothers and sisters be friends, or brother and brother, or sister and sister? Can you retain a friendship with someone you either borrow money from or lend it to? It not, why not? Can a boy love his teacher? Does it make a difference whether the teacher is male or female? If humanoid robots existed, could human beings love them? If we discovered intelligent beings on Mars or some other planet, could we love them? Can we love someone we have never met, like a movie star or the President? If we feel that we hate someone, is that really an expression of love?

curious paradox is involved in any project of syntopical reading. Although this level of reading is defined as the reading of two or more books on the same subject, which implies that the identification of the subject matter occurs before the reading begins, it is in a sense true that the identification of the subject matter must follow the reading, not precede it. In the case of love, you might have to read a dozen or a hundred works before you could decide what you were reading about

The Role of Inspection in Syntopical Reading

We have stated more than once that the levels of reading are cumulative, that a higher level includes all of those that precede or lie below it.

You will recall that in explaining the relationship between inspectional reading and analytical reading, we pointed out that the two steps in inspectional reading—first, skimming; and second, superficial reading—anticipated the first two steps in analytical reading Skimming helps to prepare you for the first step of analytical reading, in the course of which you identify the subject matter of whatever you are reading, state what kind of book it is, and outline its structure. Superficial reading, while it is also helpful in that first step of analytical reading, is primarily a preparation for the second step, when you are called upon to interpret a book’s contents by coming to terms with the author, stating his propositions, and following his arguments.

In a somewhat analogous fashion, both inspectional and analytical reading can be considered as anticipations or preparations for syntopical reading. It is here, in fact, that inspectional reading comes into its own as a major tool or instrument for the reader.

Let us suppose once more that you have a bibliography of a hundred or so titles, all of which appear to be on the subject of love. If you read every one of them analytically, you would not only end up with a fairly clear idea of the subject that you were investigating—the “same subject” of the syntopical reading project—but you would also know which, if any, of the books you had read were not on that subject and thus irrelevant to your needs. But to read a hundred books analytically might well take you ten years. If you were able to devote full time to the project, it would still take many months. Some short cut is obviously necessary, in the face of the paradox we have mentioned concerning syntopical reading.

That short cut is provided by your skill in inspectional reading.

Inspectional reading will not acquaint you with all of the intricacies of the subject matter, or with all of the insights that your authors can provide, but it will perform two essential functions. First, it will give you a clear enough idea of your subject so that your subsequent analytical reading of some of the books on the list is productive. And second, it will allow you to cut down your bibliography to a more manageable size.

We can hardly think of any advice that would be more useful for students, especially graduate and research students, than this, if they would only heed it.

But their efforts are enormously wasteful because they do not understand how to read some books faster than others. They spend the same amount of time and effort on every book or article they read. As a result, they do not read those books that deserve a really good reading as well as they deserve, and they waste time on works that deserve less attention.

The skillful inspectional reader does more than classify a book in his mental card catalogue, and achieve a superficial knowledge of its contents. He also discovers, in the very short time it takes him to inspect it, whether the book says something important about his subject or not. He may not yet know what that something is precisely—that discovery will probably have to wait for another reading

There is a reason why this advice is often unheeded. In the case of analytical reading, we said that the skillful reader performs concurrently steps that the beginner must treat as separate.

By analogy, it might seem that this kind of prepararation for syntopical reading—the inspection of all of the books on your list before starting the analytical reading of any of them—could be done concurrently with analytical reading. But we do not believe that can be done by any reader, no matter how skillful. And this indeed is the mistake that so many younger researchers make. Thinking they can collapse these two steps into one, they end up reading everything at the same rate, which may be either too fast or too slow for a particular work, but in any event is wrong for most of the books they read.

The Five Steps in Syntopical Reading

We will assume that, by your inspection of a number of books, you have a pretty good idea of the subject that at least some of them are about, and furthermore that this is the subject you want to investigate. What, then, do you do?

There are five steps in syntopical reading. We shall not call them rules, although we might, for if any of the steps is not taken, syntopical reading becomes much more difficult, perhaps impossible. We will discuss them roughly in the order in which they occur, although in a sense all of them have to take place for any of them to.

STEP 1 IN SYNTOPICAL READING: FINDING THE RELEVANT PASSAGES

Since we are of course assuming that you know how to read analytically, we are assuming that you could read each of the relevant books thoroughly if you wanted to. But that would be to place the individual books first in the order of your priorities, and your problem second. In fact, the order is reversed. In syntopical reading, it is you and your concerns that are primarily to be served, not the books that you read.

It is unlikely that the whole of any of the books is directly on the subject you have chosen or that is troubling you. Even if this is so, as it very rarely is, you should read the book quickly. You do not want to lose sight of the fact that you are reading it for an ulterior purpose-namely, for the light it may throw on your own problem—not for its own sake.

It might seem that this step could be taken concurrently with the previously described inspection of the book, the purpose of which was to discover whether the book was at all relevant to your concerns. In many cases, that is so. But it is unwise to consider that this is always possible. Remember that one of the aims of your first inspection of the book was to zero in on the subejct matter of your syntopical reading project. We have said that an adequate understanding of the problem is not always available until you have inspected many of the books on your original list.

Therefore, to try to identify the relevant passages at the same time that you identify the relevant books is often perilous.

Unless you are very skillful, or already quite familiar with your subject, you had better treat the two steps as separate.

What is important here is to recognize the difference between the first books that you read in the course of syntopical reading, and those that you come to after you have read many others on the subject.

In the case of the later books, you probably already have a fairly clear idea of your problem, and in that case the two steps can coalesce.

Above all, remember that your task is not so much to achieve an overall understanding of the particular book before you as to find out how it can be useful to you in a connection that may be very far from the author’s own purpose in writing it. That does not matter at this stage of the proceedings.

In syntopical reading, as we have noted, the books that are read serve you, not the other way around.

But when you read a book analytically, you put yourself in a relation to it of disciple to master. When you read syntopically, you must be the master of the situation.

STEP 2 IN SYNTOPICAL READING: BRINGING THE AUTHORS TO TERMS.

In interpretive reading (the second stage of analytical reading) the first rule requires you to come to terms with the author, which means identifying his key words and discovering how he uses them. But now you are faced with a number of different authors, and it is unlikely that they will have all used the same words, or even the same terms. Thus it is you who must establish the terms, and bring your authors to them rather than the other way around

This is probably the most difficult step in syntopical reading. What it really comes down to is forcing an author to use your language, rather than using his.

In syntopical reading, however, we will very quickly be lost if we accept any one author’s terminology. We may understand his book, but we will fail to understand the others, and we will find that not much light is shed on the subject in which we are interested.

In other words, we must accept the fact that coincidence of terminology between us and any of the authors on our list is merely accidental

Often, indeed, such coincidence will be inconvenient; for if we use one term or set of terms of an author, we may be tempted to use others among his terms, and these may get in the way rather than help.

Syntopical reading, in short, is to a large extent an exercise in translation.

STEP 3 IN SYNTOPICAL READING: GETTING THE QUESTIONS CLEAR.

But since we ourselves are establishing the terminology in this case, we are faced with the task of establishing a set of neutral propositions as well. The best way to do this is to frame a set of questions that shed light on our problem, and to which each of our authors gives answers.

This, too, is difficult. The questions must be stated in such a way and in such an order that they help us to solve the problem we started with, but they also must be framed in such a way that all or most of our authors can be interpreted as giving answers to them.

Sometimes, indeed, we have to accept the fact that an author gives no answer to one or more of our questions. In that case, we must record him as silent or indeterminate on the question. But even if he does not discuss the question explicitly, we can sometimes find an implicit answer in his book.

If he had considered the question, we may conclude, he would then have answered it in such and such a way

We have said that the questions must be put in an order that is helpful to us in our investigation. The order depends on the subject, of course, but some general directions can be suggested. The first questions usually have to do with the existence or character of the phenomenon or idea we are investigating.

These may have to do with how the phenomenon is known or how the idea manifests itself. A final set of questions might have to do with the consequences of the answers to the previous questions.

We should not expect that all of our authors will answer our questions in the same way. If they did, we would once again have no problem to solve; it would have been solved by consensus. Since the authors will differ, we are faced with having to take the next step in syntopical reading.

STEP 4 IN SYNTOPICAL READING: DEFINING THE ISSUES

It is the issue between the authors who answer the question in one way, and those who answer it in one or another opposing way.

When only two answers are given by all of the authors examined, the issue is a relatively simple one, Often, more than two alternative answers are given to a question. In that case, the opposing answers must be ordered in relation to one another, and the authors who adopt them classified according to their views.

An issue is truly joined when two authors who understand a question in the same way answer it in contrary or contradictory ways. But this does not happen as often as one might wish.

Usually, differences in answers must be ascribed to different conceptions of the question as often as to different views of the subject. The task of the syntopical reader is to define the issues in such a way as to insure that they are joined as well as may be. Sometimes this forces him to frame the question in a way that is not explicitly employed by any author.

There may be many issues involved in the discussion of the problem we are dealing with, but it is likely that they will fall into groups. Questions about the character of the idea under consideration, for example, may generate a number of issues that are connected. A number of issues revolving around a closely connected set of questions may be termed the controversy about that aspect of the subject. Such a controversy may be very complicated, and it is the task of the syntopical reader to sort it out and arrange it in an orderly and perspicuous fashion, even if no author has managed to do that. This sorting and arranging of the controversies, as well as of the constituent issues, brings us to the final step in syntopical reading.

STEP 5 IN SYNTOPICAL READING: ANALYZING THE DISCUSSION

SO far we have found the relevant passages in the works examined, created a neutral terminology that applies to all or most of the authors examined, framed and ordered a set of questions that most of them can be interpreted as answering, and defined and arranged the issues produced by differing answers to the questions. What then remains to be done?

the case of the analytical reading of a single work, two further questions remained to be answered, namely, Is it true? and What of it? In the case of syntopical reading, we are now prepared to address ourselves to similar questions about the discussion

Let us assume that the problem with which we began was not a simple one, but was rather one of those perennial problems with which thinkers have struggled for centuries, and about which good men have disagreed and can continue to disagree. We should recognize, on this assumption, that our task as syntopical readers is not merely to answer the questions ourselves—the questions that we have so carefully framed and ordered both to elucidate the discussion of the subject and the subject itself. The truth about a problem of this sort is not found so easily. In fact, we would probably be presumptuous to expect that the truth could be found in any one set of answers to the questions. Rather, it is to be found, if at all, in the conflict of opposing answers, many if not all of which may have persuasive evidence and convincing reasons to support them.

Thus, in order to present this truth to our minds—and to the minds of others—we have to do more than merely ask and answer the questions. We have to ask them in a certain order, and be able to defend that order; we must show how the questions are answered differently and try to say why; and we must be able to point to the texts in the books examined that support our classification of answers. Only when we have done all of this can we claim to have analyzed the discussion of our problem. And only then can we claim to have understood it.

We may, indeed, have done more than that. A thorough analysis of the discussion of a problem may provide the groundwork for further productive work on the problem by others. It can clear away the deadwood and prepare the way for an original thinker to make a breakthrough. Without the work of analysis, that might not have been possible, for the dimensions of the problem might not have been visible.

The Need for Objectivity

On the contrary, agreement in most cases accompanies disagreement; that is, on most issues, the opinions or views that present opposite sides of the dispute are shared by several authors, often by many.

Seldom do we find a solitary exponent of a controversial position.

The agreement of human beings about the nature of things in any field of inquiry establishes some presumption of the truth of the opinions they commonly hold.

Among conflicting opinions, one may, of course, be wholly true and all the rest false; but it is also possible that each expresses some portion of the whole truth; and, except for flat and isolated contradictions

it is even possible that all the conflicting opinions may be false, just as it is possible for that opinion to be false on which all seem to agree.

the report we might try to make of such syntopical reading. It would be dogmatic, not dialectical, if, on any of the important issues that it identified and analyzed, it asserted or tried to prove the truth or falsity of any view. If it did that, the syntopical analysis would cease to be syntopical; it would become simply one more voice in the discussion, thereby losing its detached and objective character

The point is that a different type of contribution to the pursuit of understanding can and should be made. And this contribution consists in being resolutely objective and detached throughout. The special quality that a syntopical analysis tries to achieve can, indeed, be summarized in the two words “dialectical objectivity.”

The syntopical reader, in short, tries to look at all sides and to take no sides. Of course, he will fail in this exacting ideal. Absolute objectivity is not humanly possible. He may succeed in taking no sides, presenting the issues without prejudice to any partisan point of view, and treating opposing views impartially. But it is easier to take no sides than to look at all sides. In this latter respect, the syntopical reader will undoubtedly fail. All possible sides of an issue cannot be exhaustively enumerated. Nevertheless, he must try.

Perfect dialectical objectivity is not guaranteed by avoiding explicit judgments on the truth of conflicting opinions. Partiality can intrude in a variety of subtle ways—by the manner in which arguments are summarized, by shades of emphasis and neglect, by the tone of a question or the color of a passing remark, and by the order in which the various different answers to key questions are presented.

In order to avoid some of these dangers, the conscientious syntopical reader may resort to one obvious device and use it as much as possible. That is, he must constantly refer back to the actual text of his authors, reading the relevant passages over and over; and, in presenting the results of his work to a wider audience, he must quote the opinion or argument of an author in the writer’s own language.

That necessity remains, and when summaries of an author’s argument are presented, they must be presented in that language and not the author’s. But the author’s own words, carefully quoted so as not to wrench them out of context, must accompany the summary, so that the reader can judge for himself whether the interpretation of the author is correct.

although a reader may be the judge of the effectiveness of a written report of a dialectical exposition, only the writer of it—only the syntopical reader himself—can know whether he has satisfied these requirements.

An Example of an Exercise in Syntopical Reading: The Idea of Progress

An example may be helpful to explain how syntopical reading works. Let us consider the idea of progress.

The investigation of this important historical and philosophical idea occupied several years. The first task was to produce a list of works to be examined for relevant passages—to amass a bibliography (it finally ran to more than 450 items).

This task was accomplished by a series of inspectional readings of several times that many books, articles, and other pieces. It is important to point out that in the case of the idea of progress, as would be true in the case of most other important ideas, many of the items finally judged to be relevant were found more or less by accident, or at least with the help of educated guesses.

There were obvious places to start; many recent books contain the word “progress” in their titles. But others do not, and most of the older books, although relevant to the subject, do not even employ the term.

A few fictional and poetical works were read, but on the whole it was decided to concentrate on expository works.

We have already observed that including novels, plays, and poems in a syntopical reading project is difficult, and this is so for several reasons. First of all, the backbone or essence of a story is its plot, not its positions on issues. Second, even the most talkative characters seldom take clear positions on an issue—they tend to talk, in the story, about other matters, mainly emotional relations. Third, even if a character does make such a speech—as, for example, Settembrini does about progress in Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain—we can never be sure that it is the author’s view that is being represented. Is the author being ironic in allowing his character to go on about the subject? Is he intending you to see the foolishness of the position, rather than its wisdom? Generally speaking, an intensive effort of synthetic interpretation is required before a fictional work can be placed on one side or another of an issue. The effort is so great, and the results essentially so dubious, that usually it is prudent to abstain.

The discussion of progress in the many works that remained to be examined was, as is usually the case, apparently chaotic. Faced with this fact, the task was, as we have indicated, to develop a neutral terminology. This was a complex undertaking, but one example may help to explain what was done.

The word “progress” itself is used by authors in a number of different ways. Most of these different ways reflect no more than shades of meaning, and they can be handled in the analysis. But the word is used by some authors to denote a certain kind of movement forward in history that is not an improvement. Since most of the authors use the word to denote a historical change in the human condition that is for the better, and since betterment is of the essence of the conception, the same word could not be applied to both views.

In this case, the majority gained the day, and the minority faction had to be referred to as authors who assert “non-meliorative advance” in history. The point is that when discussing the views of the minority faction, we could not employ the word “progress,” even though the authors involved had used it themselves.

The third step in syntopical reading is, as we have noted, getting the questions clear. Our intuition about the primary question in the case of progress turned out to be correct upon examination. The first question to ask, the question to which authors can be interpreted as giving various answers, is, Does progress occur in history? Is it a fact that the general course of historical change is in the direction of improvement in man’s condition? Basically, there are three different answers to this question put forth in the literature of the subject: (1) Yes, (2) No, and (3) We cannot know. However, there are a number of different ways of saying Yes, several different ways of saying No, and at least three different ways of saying that we cannot know whether human progress occurs or not.

The multifarious and interrelated answers to this primary question constitute what we decided to call the general controversy about progress. It is general in the sense that every author we studied who has anything significant to say about the subject takes sides on the various issues that can be identified within it. But there is also a special controversy about progress, which is made up of issues that are joined only by progress authors—authors who assert that progress occurs.

These issues have to do with the nature or properties of the progress that they all, being progress authors, assert is a fact of history. There are only three issues here, although the discussion of each of them is complex. They can be stated as questions: (1) Is progress necessary, or is it contingent on other occurences? (2) Will progress continue indefinitely, or will it eventually come to an end or “plateau out”? (3) Is there progress in human nature as well as in human institutions —in the human animal itself, or merely in the external conditions of human life?

Finally, there is a set of subordinate issues, as we called them, again only among progress authors, about the respects in which progress occurs. We identified six areas in which progress is said by some authors to occur, although other writers deny its occurrence in one or more of these areas—although never in all (since they are by definition authors who assert the occurrence of some kind of progress). The six are: (1) progress in knowledge, (2) technological progress, (3) economic progress, (4) political progress, (5) moral progress, and (6) progress in the fine arts. The discussion of the last point raises special problems, since in our opinion no author genuinely asserts that such aesthetic progress occurs, although a number of writers deny that progress occurs in this respect.

The structure of the analysis of progress just described exemplifies our effort to define the issues within the discussion of this subject and to analyze the discussion itself—in other words, to take the fourth and fifth steps in syntopical reading. And something like this must always be done by a syntopical reader, although of course he does not always have to write a long book reporting his researches.

The Syntopicon and How to Use It

If you read this chapter carefully, you will have noticed that, although we spent some time discussing it, we did not really solve what we called the paradox of syntopical reading. That paradox can be stated thus: Unless you know what books to read, you cannot read syntopically, but unless you can read syntopically, you do not know what to read.

On the other hand, even if you did not have this knowledge yourself, you might be able to apply to someone else who did. But you should recognize that if you were able to apply to such a person, his advice might turn out to be almost as much a hindrance as a help. If the subject was one on which he had himself done special research, it would be hard for him merely to tell you the relevant passages to read without telling you how to read them—and that might well get in your way. But if he had not done special research on the subject, he might not know a great deal more than yourself, although it might seem so both to him and to you.

The Syntopicon is an example of such a work. Produced in the 1940’s, it is a topical index to the set of books titled Great Books of the Western World. Under each of some 3,000 topics or subjects, it lists references to pages within the set where that subject is discussed. Some of the references are to passages covering many pages, others are to key paragraphs or even parts of paragraphs. No more time is required to find them than is needed to take down the indicated volume and flip through its pages.

Nevertheless, it always provides you with at least a place to start on any syntopical reading project.

Useful as the Syntopicon is for that kind of reader, it is much more useful for the beginner. The Syntopicon can help such a reader in three ways: initiatively, suggestively, and instructively.

A syntopical reading of these major works with the aid of the Syntopicon provides a radically different solution. The Syntopicon initiates the reading of great books by enabling persons to read particular ones on the subjects in which they are interested; and on those subjects, to read relatively short passages from a large number of authors. It helps us to read in the great books before we have read through them.

Finally, syntopical reading with the aid of the Syntopicon works instructively, in three distinct ways. This, in fact, is one of the major benefits of this level of reading.

First, the topic in connection with which the passage is being read serves to give direction to the reader in interpreting the passage. But it does not tell him what the passage means, since the passage may be relevant to the topic in several or many different ways. Hence the reader is called upon to discover precisely what relevance the passage has to the topic. To learn to do this is to acquire a major skill in the art of reading.

Second, the collection of a number of passages on the same topic, but from different works and different authors, serves to sharpen the reader’s interpretation of each passage read. Sometimes, when passages from the same book are read in sequence and in the context of one another, each becomes clearer. Sometimes the meaning of each of a series of contrasting or conflicting passages from different books is accentuated when they are read against one another. And sometimes the passages from one author, by amplifying or commenting on the passages from another, materially help the reader’s understanding of the second author.

Third, if syntopical reading is done on a number of different subjects, the fact that the same passage will often be found cited in the Syntopicon under two or more subjects will have its instructive effect. The passage has an amplitude of meaning that the reader will come to perceive as he interprets it somewhat differently in relation to different topics. Such multiple interpretation not only is a basic exercise in the art of reading but also tends to make the mind habitually alert to the many strains of meaning that any rich or complex passage can contain.

There is a considerable difference between syntopical reading, with a small “s,” and Syntopical reading, where the latter phrase refers to reading the great books with the help of the Syntopicon. Syntopical reading, in the latter sense, can constitute a part of any syntopical reading project where the term is used in the former sense, and perhaps it would always be wise to start there. But syntopical reading with a small “s” is a term of much wider application than Syntopical reading

On the Principles That Underlie Syntopical Reading

Summary of Syntopical Reading

As we have seen, there are two main stages of syntopical reading. One is preparatory, and the other is syntopical reading proper. Let us write out all of these steps for review. I. Surveying the Field Preparatory to Syntopical Reading

  1. Create a tentative bibliography of your subject by recourse to library catalogues, advisors, and bibliographies in books.
  2. Inspect all of the books on the tentative bibliography to ascertain which are germane to your subject, and also to acquire a clearer idea of the subject.

Note: These two steps are not, strictly speaking, chronologically distinct; that is, the two steps have an effect on each other, with the second, in particular, serving to modify the first. II. Syntopical Reading of the Bibliography Amassed in Stage I

  1. Inspect the books already identified as relevant to your subject in Stage I in order to find the most relevant passages.
  2. Bring the authors to terms by constructing a neutral terminology of the subject that all, or the great majority, of the authors can be interpreted as employing, whether they actually employ the words or not.
  3. Establish a set of neutral propositions for all of the authors by framing a set of questions to which all or most of the authors can be interpreted as giving answers, whether they actually treat the questions explicitly or not.
  4. Define the issues, both major and minor ones, by ranging the opposing answers of authors to the various questions on one side of an issue or another. You should remember that an issue does not always exist explicitly between or among authors, but that it sometimes has to be constructed by interpretation of the authors’ views on matters that may not have been their primary concern.
  5. Analyze the discussion by ordering the questions and issues in such a way as to throw maximum light on the subject. More general issues should precede less general ones, and relations among issues should be clearly indicated.

Note: Dialectical detachment or objectivity should, ideally, be maintained throughout. One way to insure this is always to accompany an interpretation of an author’s views on an issue with an actual quotation from his text.

READING AND THE GROWTH OF THE MIND

What Good Books Can Do for Us

In the latter sense of the term, the means that will serve you in the further improvement of your reading are the books you will read

If you are reading in order to become a better reader, you cannot read just any book or article. You will not improve as a reader if all you read are books that are well within your capacity.

Reading for information does not stretch your mind any more than reading for amusement.

However, your mind is essentially in the same condition that it was before. There has been a quantitative change, but no improvement in your skill.

Some readers make the mistake of supposing that such books—the ones that provide a constant and never-ending challenge to their skill—are always ones in relatively unfamiliar fields. In practice, this comes down to believing, in the case of most readers, that only scientific books, and perhaps philosophical ones, satisfy the criterion. But that is far from the case.

We have already remarked that the great scientific books are in many ways easier to read than non-scientific ones, because of the care with which scientific authors help you to come to terms, identify the key propositions, and state the main arguments. These helps are absent from poetical works, and so in the long run they are quite likely to be the hardest, the most demanding, books that you can read.

The reason is that Homer deals with subjects that are harder to write well about.

Homer, for example, is in many ways harder to read than Newton,

A good book does reward you for trying to read it. The best books reward you most of all. The reward, of course, is of two kinds. First, there is the improvement in your reading skill that occurs when you successfully tackle a good, difficult work. Second—and this in the long run is much more important —a good book can teach you about the world and about yourself

These are matters about which you cannot think too much, or too well. The greatest books can help you to think better about them, because they were written by men and women who thought better than other people about them.

The Pyramid of Books

There is a second class of books from which you can learn —both how to read and how to live. Less than one out of every hundred books belongs in this class—probably it is more like one in a thousand, or even one in ten thousand.

There are in all probably no more than a few thousand such books. They make severe demands on the reader. They are worth reading analytically—once. If you are skillful, you will be able to get everything out of them that they can give in the course of one good reading. They are books that you read once and then put away on your shelf. You know that you will never have to read them again, although you may return to them to check certain points or to refresh your memory of certain ideas or episodes. (It is in the case of such books that the notes you make in the margin or elsewhere in the volume are particularly valuable.)

How do you know that you do not ever have to read such books again? You know it by your own mental reaction to the experience of reading them. Such a book stretches your mind and increases your understanding. But as your mind stretches and your understanding increases, you realize, by a process that is more or less mysterious, that you are not going to be changed any more in the future by this book. You realize that you have grasped the book in its entirety. You have milked it dry. You are grateful to it for what it has given you, but you know it has no more to give.

Of the few thousand such books there is a much smaller number—here the number is probably less than a hundred—that cannot be exhausted by even the very best reading you can manage. How do you recognize this? Again it is rather mysterious, but when you have closed the book after reading it analytically to the best of your ability, and place it back on the shelf, you have a sneaking suspicion that there is more there than you got.

be all it is at this stage. If you knew what it was that you had missed, your obligation as an analytical reader would take you back to the book immediately to seek it out. In fact, you cannot put your finger on it, but you know it is there. You find that you cannot forget the book, that you keep thinking about it and your reaction to it. Finally, you return to it. And then a very remarkable thing happens

If the book belongs to the second class of books to which we referred before, you find, on returning to it, that there was less there than you remembered. The reason, of course, is that you yourself have grown in the meantime. Your mind is fuller, your understanding greater. The book has not changed, but you have. Such a return is inevitably disappointing

But if the book belongs to the highest class—the very small number of inexhaustible books—you discover on returning that the book seems to have grown with you. You see new things in it—whole sets of new things—that you did not see before. Your previous understanding of the book is not invalidated (assuming that you read it well the first time); it is just as true as it ever was, and in the same ways that it was true before. But now it is true in still other ways, too

Since it is a really good book—a great book, as we might say—it is accessible at different levels. Your impression of increased understanding on your previous reading was not false. The book truly lifted you then. But now, even though you have become wiser and more knowledgeable, it can lift you again. And it will go on doing this until you die.

There are obviously not many books that can do this for any of us. Our estimate was that the number is considerably less than a hundred. But the number is even less than that for any given reader.

Human beings differ in many ways other than in the power of their minds. They have different tastes; different things appeal more to one person than to another. You may never feel about Newton the way you feel about Shakespeare, either because you may be able to read Newton so well that you do not have to read him again, or because mathematical systems of the world just do not have all that appeal to you.

The Life and Growth of the Mind

Suppose, the test went, that you know in advance that you will be marooned on a desert island for the rest of your life, or at least for a long period. Suppose, too, that you have time to prepare for the experience. There are certain practical and useful articles that you would be sure to take with you. You will also be allowed ten books. Which ones would you select?

By the time most people are thirty years old, their bodies are as good as they will ever be; in fact, many persons’ bodies have begun to deteriorate by that time. But there is no limit to the amount of growth and development that the mind can sustain.

But we would recommend starting with a good anthology of poetry rather than with the collected works of a single author. Palgrave’s The Golden Treasury and The Oxford Book of English Verse are excellent places to start. These older anthologies should be supplemented by more modern ones—for example, Selden Rodman’s One Hundred Modern Poems, a collection widely available in paperback that extends the notion of a lyric poem in interesting ways.

Mark Van Doren’s Introduction to Poetry, an anthology that also contains short discussions of how to read many famous lyrics.

However, we have indicated which authors and titles are included in two sets that we ourselves have edited. Titles included in Great Books of the Western World are identified by a single asterisk; authors represented in Gateway to the Great Books are identified by a double asterisk.

  1. Homer (9th century B.C.?)
  2. lIiad
  3. Odyssey
  4. The Old Testament
  5. Aeschylus (c. 525-456 B.C.)
  6. Tragedies
  7. Sophocles (c. 495-406 B.C.)
  8. Tragedies
  9. Herodotus (c. 484-425 B.C.)
  10. History (of the Persian Wars)
  11. Euripides (c. 485-406 B.C.)
  12. Tragedies (esp. Medea, Hippolytus, The Bacchae)
  13. Thucydides (c. 460-400 B.C.)
  14. History of the Peloponnesian War
  15. Hippocrates (c. 460-377? B.C.)
  16. Medical writings
  17. Aristophanes (c. 448-380 B.C.)
  18. Comedies (esp. The Clouds, The Birds, The Frogs)
  19. Plato (c. 427-347 B.C.)
  20. Dialogues (esp. The Republic, Symposium, Phaedo, Meno, Apology, Phaedrus, Protagoras, Gorgias, Sophist, Theaetetus)
  21. Aristotle (384-322 B.C.)
  22. Works (esp. Organon, Physics, Metaphysics, On the Soul, The Nichomachean Ethics, Politics, Rhetoric, Poetics)
  23. * *Epicurus (c. 341-270 B.C.)

Letter to Herodotus Letter to Menoeceus

  1. Euclid (fl.c. 300 B.C.)
  2. Elements (of Geometry)
  3. Archimedes (c. 287-212 B.C.)
  4. Works (esp. On the Equilibrium of Planes, On Floating Bodies, The Sand-Reckoner)
  5. Apollonius of Perga (fl.c. 240 B.C.)
  6. On Conic Sections
  7. * *Cicero (106-43 B.C.)

Works (esp. Orations, On Friendship, On Old Age)

  1. Lucretius (c. 95-55 B.C.)
  2. On the Nature of Things
  3. Virgil (70-19 B.C.)
  4. Works
  1. Horace (65-8 B.C.)

Works (esp. Odes and Epodes, The Art of Poetry)

  1. Livy (59 B.C.-A.D. 17)

History of Rome

  1. Ovid (43 B.C.-A.D.17)

Works (esp. Metamorphoses)

  1. * * Plutarch (c. 45-120)
  2. Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans Moralia
  3. * *Tacitus (c. 55-117)
  4. Histories
  5. AnnalsAgricolaGermania
  6. Nicomachus of Gerasa (ft.c. 100 A.D.)
  7. Introduction to Arithmetic
  8. * *Epictetus (c. 60-120)
  9. DiscoursesEncheiridion (Handbook)
  10. Ptolemy (c. 100-178; fl. 127-151)
  11. Almagest
  12. ** Lucian (c. 120-c. 190)

Works (esp. The Way to Write History, The True History, The Sale of Creeds)

  1. Marcus Aurelius (121-180)
  2. Meditations
  3. Galen (c. 130-200)
  4. On the Natural Faculties
  5. The New Testament
  6. Plotinus (205-270)
  7. The Enneads
  8. St. Augustine (354-430)

Works (esp. On the Teacher,*Confessions, *The City of God,*Christian Doctrine)

  1. The Song of Roland (12th century?)
  2. The Nibelungenlied (13th century)

(The Völsunga Saga is the Scandinavian version of the same legend.)

  1. The Saga of Burnt Njal
  2. St. Thomas Aquinas (c. 1225-1274)
  3. Summa Theologica
  4. * *Dante Alighieri (1265-1321)

Works (esp. The New Life, On Monarchy,*The Divine Comedy)

  1. Geoffrey Chaucer (c. 1340-1400)

Works esp. *Troilus and Criseyde,*Canterbury Tales)

  1. Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519)

Notebooks

  1. Niccolò Machiavelli (1469-1527)
  2. The Prince

Discourses on the First Ten Books of Livy

  1. Desiderius Erasmus (c. 1469-1536)

The Praise of Folly

  1. Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543)
  2. On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres
  3. Sir Thomas More (c. 1478-1535)

Utopia

  1. Martin Luther (1483-1546)

Three Treatises Table-Talk

  1. François Rabelais (c. 1495-1553)
  2. Gargantua and Pantagruel
  3. John Calvin (1509-1564)

Institutes of the Christian Religion

  1. Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592)
  2. Essays
  3. William Gilbert (1540-1603)
  4. On the Loadstone and Magnetic Bodies
  5. Miguel de Cervantes (1547-1616)
  6. Don Quixote
  7. Edmund Spenser (c. 1552-1599)

Prothalamion The Faërie Oueene

  1. * *Francis Bacon (1561-1626)

Essays

  • Advancement of Learning
  • Novum Organum
  • New Atlantis
  • William Shakespeare (1564-1616)
  • Works
  • * * Galileo Galilei (1564-1642)

The Starry Messenger

  • Dialogues Concerning Two New Sciences
  • Johannes Kepler (1571-1630)
  • Epitome of Copemican Astronomy
  • Concerning the Harmonies of the World
  • William Harvey (1578-1657)
  • On the Motion of the Heart and Blood in Animals
  • On the Circulation of the Blood
  • On the Generation of Animals
  • Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679)
  • The Leviathan
  • René Descartes (1596-1650)
  • Rules for the Direction of the Mind
  • Discourse on Method
  • Geometry
  • Meditations on First Philosophy
  • John Milton (1608-1674)

Works(esp. *the minor poems,*Areopagitica,*Paradise Lost,*Samson Agonistes)

  1. * *Molière (1622-1673)

Comedies (esp. The Miser, The School for Wives, The Misanthrope, The Doctor in Spite of Himself, Tartuffe)

  1. Blaise Pascal (1623-1662)
  2. The Provincial Letters

Pensées

  • Scientific treatises
  • Christiaan Huygens (1629-1695)
  • Treatise on Light
  • Benedict de Spinoza (1632-1677)
  • Ethics
  • John Locke (1632-1704)
  • Letter Concerning Toleration
  • “Of Civil Government” (second treatise in Two Treatises on Government)
  • Essay Concerning Human Understanding Thoughts Concerning Education
  • Jean Baptiste Racine (1639-1699)

Tragedies (esp. Andromache, Phaedra)

  1. Isaac Newton (1642-1727)
  2. Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy
  3. Optics
  4. Gottfried Wilhelm von Leibniz (1646-1716)

Discourse on Metaphysics New Essays Concerning Human Understanding Monadology

  1. * *Daniel Defoe (1660-1731)

Robinson Crusoe

  1. * *Jonathan Swift (1667-1745)

A Tale of a Tub Journal to Stella

  • Gulliver’s Travels A Modest Proposal
  • William Congreve (1670-1729)

The Way of the World

  1. George Berkeley (1685-1753)
  2. Principles of Human Knowledge
  3. Alexander Pope (1688-1744)

Essay on CriticismRape of the LockEssay on Man

  1. Charles de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu (1689-1755)

Persian Letters

  1. Charles de Secondat, Baron de Montesquieu, continued
  2. Spirit of Laws
  3. * *Voltaire (1694-1778)

Letters on the English Candide Philosophical Dictionary

  1. Henry Fielding (1707-1754)

Joseph Andrews “Tom Jones

  1. ** Samuel Johnson (1709-1784)

The Vanity of Human Wishes Dictionary Rasselas The Lives of the Poets (esp. the essays on Milton and Pope)

  1. * *David Hume (1711-1776)

Treatise of Human Nature Essays Moral and Political

  • An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding
  • * * Jean Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778)
  • On the Origin of Inequality
  • On Political Economy Emile
  • The Social Contract
  • Laurence Sterne (1713-1768)
  • Tristram Shandy

A Sentimental Journey Through France and Italy

  1. Adam Smith (1723-1790)

The Theory of the Moral Sentiments

  • Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations
  • * *Immanuel Kant (1724-1804)
  • Critique of Pure Reason
  • Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals
  • Critique of Practical Reason
  • The Science of Right
  • Critique of Judgment
  • Immanuel Kant, continued

Perpetual Peace

  1. Edward Gibbon (1737-1794)
  2. The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire Autobiography
  3. James Boswell (1740-1795)

Journal (esp. London Journal)

  • Life of Samuel Johnson Ll.D.
  • Antoine Laurent Lavoisier (1743-1794)
  • Elements of Chemistry
  • John Jay (1745-1829), James Madison (1751-1836), and Alexander Hamilton (1757-1804)
  • Federalist Papers

(together with the *Articles of Confederation, the * Constitution of the United States, and the * Declaration of Independence)

  1. Jeremy Bentham (1748-1832)

Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation Theory of Fictions

  1. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe (1749-1832)
  2. Faust

Poetry and Truth

  1. Jean Baptiste Joseph Fourier (1768-1830)
  2. Analytical Theory of Heat
  3. Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831)

Phenomenology of Spirit

  • Philosophy of Right
  • Lectures on the Philosophy of History
  • William Wordsworth (1770-1850)

Poems (esp. Lyrical Ballads, Lucy poems, sonnets; The Prelude)

  1. Samuel Taylor Coleridge (1772-1834)

Poems (esp. “Kubla Khan,” Rime of the Ancient Mariner)

  1. Samuel Taylor Coleridge, continued

Biographia Literaria

  1. Jane Austen (1775-1817)

Pride and Prejudice Emma

  1. * *Karl von Clausewitz (1780-1831)

On War

  1. Stendhal (1783-1842)

The Red and the BlackThe Charterhouse of ParmaOn Love

  1. George Gordon, Lord Byron (1788-1824)

Don Juan

  1. * *Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)

Studies in Pessimism

  1. * *Michael Faraday (1791-1867)

Chemical History of a Candle*Experimental Researches in Electricity

  1. * *Charles Lyell (1797-1875)

Principles of Geology

  1. Auguste Comte (1798-1857)

The Positive Philosophy

  1. * *Honoré de Balzac (1799-1850)

Père Goriot Eugénie Grandet

  1. * *Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882)

Representative Men Essays Journal

  1. * *Nathaniel Hawthorne (1804-1864)

The Scarlet Letter

  1. * *Alexis de Tocqueville (1805-1859)

Democracy in America

  1. * *John Stuart Mill (1806-1873)

A System of Logic*On Liberty

  • Representative Government
  • Utilitarianism
  • John Stuart Mill, continued

The Subjection of Women Autobiography

  1. * *Charles Darwin (1809-1882)
  • The Origin of Species*The Descent of Man Autobiography
  • * *Charles Dickens (1812-1870)

Works (esp. Pickwick Papers, David Copperfield, Hard Times)

  1. * *Claude Bernard (1813-1878)

Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine

  1. * *Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862)

Civil Disobedience Waiden

  1. Karl Marx (1818-1883)
  • Capital

(together with the * Communist Manifesto)

  1. George Eliot (1819-1880)

Adam Bede Middlemarch

  1. * *Herman Melville (1819-1891)
  • Moby Dick Billy Budd
  • * *Fyodor Dostoevsky (1821-1881)

Crime and Punishment The Idiot

  • The Brothers Karamazov
  • * *Gustave Flaubert (1821-1880)

Madame Bovary Three Stories

  1. * *Henrik Ibsen (1828-1906)

Plays (esp. Hedda Gabler, A Doll’s House, The Wild Duck)

  1. * *Leo Tolstoy (1828-1910)
  • War and Peace Anna Karenina What Is Art? Twenty-three Tales
  • * *Mark Twain (1835-1910)

The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn The Mysterious Stranger

  1. * * William James (1842-1910)
  • The Principles of Psychology The Varieties of Religious Experience Pragmatism

Essays in Radical Empiricism

  1. * *Henry James (1843-1916)

The American The Ambassadors

  1. Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche (1844-1900)

Thus Spoke Zarathustra Beyond Good and Evil The Genealogy of Morals The Will to Power

  1. Jules Henri Poincaré (1854-1912)

Science and Hypothesis Science and Method

  1. Sigmund Freud (1856-1939)
  • The Interpretation of Dreams*Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis*Civilization and Its Discontents*New Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis
  • * *George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950)

Plays (and Prefaces) (esp. Man and Superman, Major Barbara, Caesar and Cleopatra, Pygmalion, Saint Joan)

  1. * *Max Planck (1858-1947)

Origin and Development of the Quantum Theory Where Is Science Going? Scientific Autobiography

  1. Henri Bergson (1859-1941)

Time and Free Will Matter and Memory Creative Evolution The Two Sources of Morality and Religion

  1. * *John Dewey (1859-1952)

How We Think Democracy and Education Experience and Nature Logic, the Theory of Inquiry

  1. * *Alfred North Whitehead (1861-1947)

An Introduction to Mathematics Science and the Modern World The Aims of Education and Other Essays Adventures of Ideas

  1. * *George Santayana (1863-1952)

The Life of Reason Skepticism and Animal Faith Persons and Places

  1. Nikolai Lenin (1870-1924)

The State and Revolution

  1. Marcel Proust (1871-1922)

Remembrance of Things Past

  1. * * Bertrand Russell (1872-1970)

The Problems of Philosophy The Analysis of Mind An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth Human Knowledge; Its Scope and Limits

  1. * *Thomas Mann (1875-1955)

The Magic Mountain Joseph and His Brothers

  1. * *Albert Einstein (1879-1955)

The Meaning of Relativity On the Method of Theoretical Physics The Evolution of Physics (with L. Inf eld)

  1. * *James Joyce (1882-1941)

“The Dead” in Dubliners

  1. James Joyce, continued

Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man Ulysses

  1. Jacques Maritain (1882-      )

Art and Scholasticism The Degrees of Knowledge The Rights of Man and Natural Law True Humanism

  1. Franz Kafka (1883-1924      )

The Trial The Castle

  1. Arnold Toynbee (1889-      )

A Study of History Civilization on Trial

  1. Jean Paul Sartre (1905-      )

Nausea No Exit Being and Nothingness

  1. Aleksandr I. Solzhenitsyn (1918-      )

The First Circle Cancer Ward