Intro

  • Stability of attention is crucial for Freedom.
  • In shamatha, we are developing Concentration which is achieved not by force but through deep relaxation.
  • Successful dream practice:
    1. Prospective memory [ Preparing to remember something in a future dream ]
    2. Retrospective memory [ Remembering the sequences of dream events from the past ]
    3. Remembering curs that alert one to the dream state
    4. Steady, relaxed concentration on visual images.
  • We awaken and then quickly return to sleep a number of times over the night but barely remember it.
  • Over time, we can compile a list of events that occur regularly in our dreams.
    • Locations
    • Certain Situations
  • Remembering these events will help us have the mental clarity to find dreams and to be awake in them.
  • Distraction is pretty common during meditation and is countered by relaxation as well as vigilance.

Dream Yoga and Lucid Dreaming

  • Theories and practices derived from Six Yogas of Naropa as well as Six Bardos taught in Nyingma lineage of Tibetan Buddhism.
  • During Stages of sleep, one wakes up 15 times or more during the night briefly which can be used for lucid dreaming.
  • Time passed in lucid dreams closely approximates sense of time in waking state.

Remembering

  • Lie still, think back, and try to remember immediately on waking up.
  • Try to remain immobile, close your eyes, try to maintain the atmosphere of dream you’ve started remembering.
  • Keep a notebook close to your bed.

Dream Journal

  • Keep dream journal, and analyse it to discover things that repeat frequently in dreams.
    • Try categorizing this.
    • It will help you learn that it’s a dream when you see this.
    • Asking questions in dream when you see those objects will help you get awake there in the dream state.

Achieving Lucid Dreaming

  • Intense interest and desire to achieve lucid dreaming.
    • Speak to yourself clear and loud that you’re going to dream lucidly tonight before going to sleep.
  • Anticipate of lucid dreams during wake hours.
  • Imagine a recent dream and see ourselves becoming lucid.
  • Using dream journal to find patterns and use them.
  • Testing if it’s a dream:
    • Do activities in real life as well such as trying to fly to see if it’s a dream.
    • Printed text and digital clock numerals change when you look away and then return your gaze in a dream.
    • e.g. Affirm yourself like this: “The next time I see a white rabbit I will jump up in the air. If I float or descend more slowly than usual, I will know I am dreaming and become lucid”
    • Having a cue to ask “Am I dreaming or not?” e.g. When entering a door. And do certain action that separates dream from reality. e.g. Jumping in the air to check it.
    • Trying to pull your nose.
    • Reading something once, looking away and looking back at the same material, the contents are likely to change.
  • Experiencing something spectacularly strange that startles us into lucidity.
  • State check when you see a dream sign
  • Using alarm clock to awaken yourself periodically during the night.
    • If you’ve trained yourself to remember your dreams upon waking, then you can continue your dream lucidly after you reflect back and fall to sleep again.
  • Towards the end of sleep cycle, read about lucid dreaming for half an hour or so. Then, have a resolve and go back to sleep.
    • Try to use weekend to sleep one more sleep cycle or so to dream.

Maintaining lucid dreams

  • Remind yourself that it’s a dream.
  • Spin your dream body with eyes wide open. Also, can be used to change dreams.
  • Refocus on the sensation of dreams more than logical ideas of your mind.
  • Rub your dream body skin vigorously.

Playing lucid dreams

  • Use anticipation consciously to maintain lucidity. e.g. “I bet my best friend is going to walk through the door now.” etc.

Getting out of lucid dreams

  • Close dream eyes. This takes to lucid dreamless sleep.

Lucid Dreamless Sleep

  • Getting to it
    • Closing eyes in lucid dreams
    • Concentrate on visualized image at the heart chakra.
  • Ask questions:
    • About it’s vacuous nature.
    • About it’s shape, size, characteristics.
    • What is the nature of being conscious?

Putting to use

  • Train physical skills in lucid dreams.
  • Explore your fears, neuroses, obstacles and so forth.
  • Solve your difficulties in interaction by rehearsing there.
  • Going beyond dualism of “I”.

Dream Lab

  • After enough experience, frequency, stability, and vividness of your dreams, one can now create dream labs.
  • From designing experiments to free-form imaging.
  • Building space for meditation
    • Longer periods without distractions
    • Cave, mountain top or any other place.
  • By getting stability to create a visual image, such as candle flame, a jewel etc; you can develop concentration and eventually arrive at samadhi by focusing on that image for longer periods of time.

Dream Consciousness

  • Humans dream of human realities, but dogs may dream in scents.
  • This follows the idea that people that are blind from birth do dream, but without visual objects.
  • So, we dream based on our Conditioning.
  • Dreams aren’t constrained by physical input from the environment. e.g. You can fly without giving a note to gravity.

Stages of Practice

  • Stage 1-4 : Mindfulness of breathing.
  • Stage 5-7 : Setting the mind in natural state. Awareness of mental phenomenon such as thoughts, mental images, and emotions – all objectively without any involvement.
  • Stage 8 onwards : Shamatha – Awareness of Awareness

Practice Session

  • Length : 24 minutes [ “Ghatika” in Sanskrit ]
  • Each higher session usually contains previous session as well.
  • Root of the whole practice is relaxation. The trunk is stability.
    • If relaxation is too strong, you are likely to become dull and sleepy.
    • If vividness is too energetic, you may become agitated.
  • Find Relaxation born out of stability.

Session One: Relaxation

Length
One Ghatika
Intention
Relaxation

Initial Practice

  • Physical Relaxation

    • Keep abdominal muscles loose
    • Belly expand with each inhalation.
    • Breathe into any area that you feel tense
    • While breathing out, release the muscular tension.
    • Particular attention to muscles of the face.
  • Forced Breathing

    • 3 slow deep breaths through the nostrils, down into the body, expanding the diaphgram, and finally breathing into the chest, breathing in almost to full, and releasing effortlessly.
    • Attend sensations correlated with breath that happens through the body.
  • Natural Breathing

    • Let go of control and allow it to go on its own accord.
    • Take each exhalation as moment to relax and let go.
      • Feel loosening with each exhalation.
      • Release images that come up to your mind with exhalation.
      • Try to be aware of the bodily sensations.

Shamatha Practice

  • Effortless breathing without taking note as to how long inhalations and exhalations should be.
  • Use faculties of Mindfulness and Introspection

Potential Bed Practice

  • Supine position for a short time – 5, 10, 20 minutes or longer before you go into your normal sleeping position.
  • On initial exhalations, release first all muscular tension in the body.
  • Then, release thoughts breathing out and then allow the inhalation to flow in of its own accord.
  • Now, rather than watching the whole body, you watch only the tactile sensations in one part of your body to build attention skills.

Session Two: Stabilizing Attention

Length
One Ghatika
Intention
Training in Stability

Focus on rise and fall of abdomen as we breathe.

Relax, 3 slow, deep breaths.

Let the breath flow naturally without effort.

Continue relaxation with each inhalation, and arouse attention with each inhalation.

As attention gets deep, relaxation too gets deep. There is a flow from one towards another.

Session Three: Vividness of Attention

  • Settle body in natural state.
  • Attention on the aperture of your nostrils and on the area above the upper lip.
    • Try to attend to the sensations of breath flowing in and out.
    • Try to attend to the temperature difference, or other sensations like sweating, irritation etc.

Cultivating directly

Length
One Ghatika
Goal
Attend mental phenomenon with lucidity

21 breaths with counting to stabilize and calm your mind.

Then, look at vacant space in front of you. At first, your mind might generate mental event, or an object, or a thought, or image. Focus on that single pointedly, allow it to fade. Be ready to focus on the next that arises. - This is attending to stage and to the players. When there are no players, attend to the stage.

Practice : Lucid Dreamless Sleep

Goal
Explore substrate consciousness, Enter lucid dreamless sleep
Length
One ghatika

Relax physical body and breathing. - 3 deep luxurious breaths and then natural rhythm. - Let eyes be partially open and rest gaze in space before you. Continue breathing with relaxation and vigilance.

Once, mental content is settled, rest awareness on awareness itself.

From time to time, check that your breath is deeply relaxed.

Highlights

Brian Hodel

The practices of dream yoga are based upon a three-tiered theory of consciousness

psyche

psyche comprises the five physical senses along with conscious and unconscious mental phenomena—thoughts, feelings, sensations, and so forth

substrate consciousness

subtle mind stream containing latent habits, tendencies, and attitudes tracing back to previous lifetimes

deepest and most fundamental layer, primordial consciousness—encompassing both the psyche and the substrate consciousness—is an ultimate level of pure wisdom where the “inner” (mind) and “outer” (phenomenal world) are nondual

shamatha

With shamatha, the basic idea is to increase one’s relaxed concentration to a point where one can easily sustain the attention on a chosen object

Concentration on the inflow and outflow of the breath—a method favored by the Buddha—is one such technique

Laying the Groundwork for Lucidity

Ordinarily our dreams are characterized by a lack of stability. Our attention is pulled hither and yon by the contents of our dreams and our habitual reactions to these events. Shamatha is a practice that stabilizes our attention. Stability of attention is a crucial step to freedom—the freedom to transcend normal dream consciousness and recognize we are dreaming, then to maintain that lucidity, and to transform our dreams into a laboratory where we can carefully explore the mind

Although in shamatha we are developing concentration, it is achieved not by force but through deep relaxation

Research has shown that most of us awaken and then quickly return to sleep a number of times during the night. Few notice this habit. However, these spontaneous awakenings provide one of the most useful opportunities for entering into lucid dreams. We may learn that deliberately reentering a dream after one of these intervals can lead to a lucid dream, but if we don’t remember to do so, we will continually miss these opportunities. The clarity and stability of a mind trained in shamatha is a reliable basis for remembering to take these opportunities

The same holds for another technique we will learn later: using typical dream events (called dream signs) to remind us while asleep that we are experiencing a dream. Over time, we can compile a list of events that occur regularly in our dreams. We may, for instance, repeatedly find ourselves in a specific location, or encounter a certain situation or the same people or objects. If we have the mental clarity to remember the importance of these signs when they appear in our dreams, that can prompt us to awaken within them

The overall framework for shamatha training presented here is drawn from Stages of Meditation, by the eighth-century Indian Buddhist contemplative Kamalashila

There are ten stages, beginning with the coarsest of attentional states and leading up to the most subtle—the achievement of shamatha itself. With the achievement of shamatha, the practitioner will be able to concentrate effortlessly on a chosen object continuously for at least four hours

Although training in shamatha is not absolutely required for successful dream practice, I highly recommend it. At a minimum, the achievement of the first two of the ten stages listed below would greatly improve one’s attentional stability, not only in this practice but for just about any endeavor

THE TEN STAGES IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF SHAMATHA (VERY BRIEFLY DESCRIBED):

Directed Attention—One develops the ability to focus on a chosen object

Continuous Attention—One can maintain continuous attention on the object for up to a minute

Resurgent Attention—One recovers swiftly when distracted from the object

Close Attention—The object of attention is no longer completely forgotten

Tamed Attention—One takes satisfaction in samadhi or “single-pointed concentration

Pacified Attention—There is no longer resistance to attentional training

Fully Pacified Attention—Attachment, melancholy, and lethargy are pacified

Single-Pointed Attention—Samadhi is sustained without excitation or laxity.

Attentional Balance—Flawless, effortlessly sustained samadhi.

Shamatha—One can effortlessly maintain concentration on an object for at least four hours; this is accompanied by greatly increased mental and physical pliancy and other positive side effects

HREE SEQUENTIAL PRACTICES ON THE PATH OF SHAMATHA

The first is mindfulness of breathing. Here one develops one’s attention by observing the inhalations and exhalations, passively witnessing the tactile sensations throughout the body associated with natural breathing. The experience of the breath provides an excellent grounding, allowing physical and mental relaxation to become the basis of the practice from the very beginning.

those committed to the full shamatha training described above, I recommend that mindfulness of breathing be practiced in stages one through four.

For the next three stages—five through seven—I recommend settling the mind in the natural state. In this practice, attention to mental phenomena replaces focus on the breath. One observes all appearing mental events—thoughts, mental images, and emotions—neutrally, objectively, without any involvement. These events—which usually draw us in—are allowed to pass before the window of the mind like clouds blown across the sky. From stage eight onward one practices shamatha without a sign, also called awareness of awareness. Previously we have been focusing on an object, that is, a sign. Here attention is placed on awareness itself

HAMATHA IN PRACTICE Session One: Relaxing

basic meditation sequence for mindfulness of the tactile sensations of the body, which promotes relaxation

comfortable posture, do your best to remain still, apart from the movement of the breath. If sitting (on a chair or cross-legged on the floor), see that your spine is straight and your sternum uplifted just enough so that there is no pressure on your abdomen that would prevent it from expanding freely as you breathe in. Keep your abdominal muscles loose, feeling your belly expand with each inhalation. Wherever you find tension or tightness in the body, breathe into that area and, especially when you breathe out, release the muscular tension. Pay particular attention to the muscles of the face—the jaw, the eyes. Round off this initial settling of the body by taking three slow, deep, luxurious breaths, breathing through the nostrils, down into the belly, expanding the diaphragm, and finally breathing into the chest, breathing in almost to full capacity and then releasing the breath effortlessly, mindfully attentive to the sensations correlated with the breath as they manifest throughout the entire body

Next, settle your respiration in its natural rhythm, noting how easy it is to influence the breath with your preferences. To the best of your ability, withdraw your control and allow the respiration to flow of its own accord, with no intervention, as effortlessly as possible.

Rather than reacting by trying to clamp down and force the mind to be still, relax and let go of the pent-up, turbulent energy of the body-mind

Take advantage of each exhalation—a natural moment to relax and let go

With every exhalation feel a progressive sense of melting in the body, a softening, a loosening of the body. With each exhalation, as soon as you know that any involuntary thought or image has arisen, just release it without a second thought, and immediately upon release let your awareness descend quietly once again into the field of the body, simply taking note of whatever tactile sensations arise within this field, especially attending to those sensations correlated with the breath. Give

Keep the length of your practice session to twenty-four minutes (called, in Sanskrit, a ghatika, which was considered the ideal length for beginning meditation training in ancient India). Continue with the intention of maintaining your attention on the field of tactile sensations associated with the breath, and when you find that you have strayed, relax more deeply, abandoning distractions and returning to the body.

The basic technique of shamatha involves the interaction of two mental faculties: mindfulness and introspection

Mindfulness can be defined as continuous attention to a chosen object, which requires that one remember what the task is and not become distracted by other phenomena. Introspection (as the eighth-century Indian Buddhist adept Shantideva defined it) is “the repeated examination of the state of one’s body and mind.

I have a strong hunch that the manner of our breathing when we are in dreamless sleep is very restorative for the mind and body. When we are dreaming, our thoughts and emotions can interfere with our breathing

We gently surrender all control of the breath, unconcerned with the relative length of the inhalations and exhalations, breathing effortlessly

The attention is allowed to be diffuse, scanning the tactile sensations associated with the breath and also the sensations emanating from the lower part of the body—the legs and lower trunk. This draws our energy and attention away from the head, grounding us and lessening interference from thoughts

At bedtime, try this practice in the supine position for a short time—five, ten, twenty minutes, or more if you like—before you go into your normal sleeping position.

On the initial exhalations release first all muscular tension in the body, and once you are thoroughly relaxed physically, also release all thoughts that appear—slowly breathing out . . . out . . . out . . .—and then allow the inhalation to flow in of its own accord

Session Two: Stabilizing the Attention

we enter a second phase, narrowing our focus to the rise and fall of the abdomen as we breathe, promoting stability of attention.

Having settled into a comfortable posture, begin by settling the body in its natural state, imbued with the three qualities of relaxation, stillness, and vigilance. Having done so, round this off by taking three slow, deep breaths. Next, settle your breathing in its natural rhythm and then, as before, let your awareness permeate the entire field of tactile sensations while attending especially to those sensations correlated with the breath, wherever they arise within the field of the body. Within this field, let your awareness be diffuse

A sense of ease and relaxation is indispensable for cultivating attention skills and for dream practice. But by itself it’s not enough. We need to also introduce the element of stability—the voluntary continuity of attention. So let’s step up this practice now by narrowing the focus of attention. Instead of focusing on the whole body or letting the attention rove within the body, now zero in more steadily on the tactile sensations of the rise and fall of the abdomen with each inhalation and exhalation. Narrow your focus. Continue to let the breath flow unimpeded, without constraint or effort, and with bare attention simply attend to the sensations themselves, with no conceptual overlay, no cogitation—just the sensations in the area of the abdomen corresponding to the flow of the breath

Continue relaxing with each exhalation, thereby overcoming the agitation, the excitation of the mind. But with each inhalation arouse your attention, thereby overcoming laxity and dullness

As the mind becomes calm, the attention more and more stabilized, you may find this enhances the degree of relaxation and looseness in the body and mind. At the same time, the greater the sense of relaxation in the body and mind, the easier it is to stabilize the attention. There is a synergy between these two qualities. Continue alternating relaxation and arousal of attention on the exhalations and inhalations

And now, to help stem the flow of obsessive thinking, of being compulsively carried away by thoughts, you may find it helpful, at least occasionally, to count the breaths—to substitute many rambling thoughts for a few regular thoughts, the thoughts of counting. There are various methods; here is one: Breathe in, allowing the breath to flow in quite effortlessly, all the way to the end of the inhalation. Just before the exhalation begins, mentally, and very briefly, count “one.” Then breathe out, relaxing, letting go of thoughts all the way through the exhalation. Quietly

OUTLINE OF THE PRACTICE: Settle the body in its natural state Breathe in a natural rhythm Phase one: attention on the field of tactile sensations (training relaxation) Phase two: attention on the rise and fall of the abdomen (training stability) Alternate overcoming agitation (on exhalation) and arousing attention (inhalation) Count the breaths Length: one ghatika (twenty-four minutes) Intention: training in stability COMMENTARY

Soon we discover there are two major types of distraction that cause us to forget our task: agitation and dullness. For most of us, agitation is our biggest initial problem in focusing on a chosen object. We are in the habit of thinking rapidly, flitting among a variety of subjects—answering phone calls, chatting, surfing the internet, multi-tasking

Asking ourselves to suddenly slow down and focus on our breath is asking a lot.

Relaxation and stillness counter agitation, while vigilance counteracts dullness

Session Three: Vividness of Attention

Settle the body once again in its natural state, letting awareness permeate the whole field of the body, setting the body at ease, in stillness, in a posture of vigilance. If

Continue relaxing and letting go with every exhalation. We shift now to the second phase, where—as in the previous practice—we more narrowly focus the attention on the rise and fall of the abdomen, introducing the element of stabilizing the attention,

With each inhalation, arouse your attention, and to the best of your ability maintain a continuous flow of mindfulness on the tactile sensations corresponding to the inhalation and exhalation as they manifest at the abdomen. Let this be a full-time job. There is always something to do. Remain engaged. Sustain the focus. Relaxing with each exhalation, arousing your attention with each inhalation.

finally, let’s now introduce the element of vividness. We move into the third phase of mindfulness of breathing by elevating the focus of attention to the apertures of the nostrils or the area just above the upper lip, wherever you most distinctly discern the sensations of the breath flowing in and out

Keep the muscles of the face relaxed, the eyes soft, the forehead spacious. See that you are not directing your eyes to the tip of your nose, which will just give rise to tension, perhaps even headaches

Focus your attention on the difference in temperature between the sensations of the inhalation at the nostrils and the warmer exhalation. As your breathing becomes quieter and more refined, this difference will become more and more subtle, challenging you to become more vividly aware

the best of your ability, maintain a continuous flow of mindfulness; engage with the ongoing flow of sensations at the apertures of the nostrils. In this way you exercise and enhance the faculty of mindfulness

OUTLINE OF THE PRACTICE: Settle the body in its natural state Breathe in a natural rhythm Attention on the tactile field of the body (phase one—relaxation) Attention on rise and fall of the abdomen (phase two—stability of attention) Attention on apertures of the nostrils (phase three—cultivating vividness of attention) Count your breaths Enhance mindfulness with introspection

The root of the whole practice is relaxation. The trunk is stability. Just as the roots of a tree support the trunk, so relaxation supports the stability of attention

If relaxation is too strong, you are likely to become dull and sleepy. If vividness is too bright and energetic, you may become agitated

Stability born of relaxation will enable you to be grounded rather than overexcited, prolonging lucid dreams

The second balancing act is between stability and vividness. Just as it is important that stability not be gained at the expense of relaxation, increased vividness must not weaken stability. Here you increase the clarity, luminosity, and brightness but without giving rise to agitation that would cause you to lose your coherence

introspection signals that your level of vividness is causing agitation, back off, relax, and increase stability

EEPER POSSIBILITIES

While we are developing shamatha, experiences relating to much deeper layers of consciousness may spontaneously appear

The Theory of Lucid Dreaming

Psychology, the study of the mind, was a central issue—perhaps the central issue—for Buddhism ever since Shakyamuni Buddha began teaching in India 2,500 years ago

When we arrive at dream yoga, we will be studying theories and practices derived from the Six Yogas of Naropa,3 dating from the eleventh century, as well as the presentation of dream yoga within the Six Bardos taught in the Nyingma lineage of Tibetan Buddhism

LEEPING AND DREAMING—SOME BASICS

four levels or substages of sleep that precede dreaming. They are called NREM 1 through 4 (NREM means non-rapid eye movement—in reference to whether the closed eyes are moving or not beneath the eyelids). NREM 1 is the transition between the waking state and sleep. Here we become progressively drowsier until we lose consciousness. This normally short period is characterized by slow

The first occurrence of NREM 2 lasts about twenty minutes. One is actually asleep with little mental activity, disengaged from one’s physical surroundings. This is followed by NREM 3 and NREM 4, characterized by deeper sleep and exhibiting regular, large, slow, delta brain wave patterns. All of these are essentially dreamless stages of sleep. Blood pressure drops and breathing slows. This is also the deepest and most restorative sleep.5 Initially, after thirty

Initially, after thirty to forty minutes of delta sleep, one enters REM sleep. This is where dreams occur. The sequence of the stages of sleep, then, is NREM 1, 2, 3, 4, REM. During REM sleep the body is immobilized in a type of muscle paralysis called atonia

The first period of REM sleep is short—five or ten minutes. One then repeats the entire cycle over and over in approximately ninety-minute cycles. The proportionate length of the REM periods increases throughout the night, with the total time in REM accounting for 25 percent of a night’s sleep

The sleeper usually awakens briefly fifteen times or more during the night, though these awakenings are rarely noticed. They, too, can be used to enhance the practice of lucid dreaming

Furthermore, it has been discovered that the sense of the passage of time within lucid dreams closely approximates the sense of time in the waking state. If it seems you have dreamed for half an hour, that is probably the case

DREAM CONSCIOUSNESS

According to that statement both states of consciousness—perception when dreaming and when awake—are very similar, with overlapping networks of correlated brain mechanisms

For example, the sun may emit photons (which can be registered by scientific instruments), but it is our perceptual and conceptual organs that experience what we call “light.

The sun, in itself, is not “bright.” Nor is it “hot.” It emits photons and thermal radiation that we perceive as bright and hot

certain deep-sea and cave-dwelling species that are blind. It would seem that for them there is no light and no dark. The same goes for humans who are blind from birth

Seen from this perspective, the effect of conditioning on our perceptions creates a dreamlike reality. Humans dream of human realities, but dogs may dream in scents, whales of underwater songs

When we are awake we experience the world according to our conditioning. For example, we gained some of our initial experiences of gravity as toddlers when we learned to walk

We became conditioned to it in specific ways when we learned to move about as children. In dreams, however, it is possible to escape the law of gravity. Physical laws don’t apply in the nonphysical realm of dreams, in which floating in the air and flying through space are not unusual. In lucid dream training, one of the earliest acquired skills is to fly at will. So, as Stephen LaBerge suggests above, dreams are a mode of experience not constrained by physical input from the environment

But since there is no physical sun in our dreams constraining our perception, we may also choose to experience there a sun in the shape of a cube that emits rays of cold, green light.

Lucid dreamers seek to use the malleability of consciousness for a variety of reasons, including spiritual realization. By exploring dream consciousness directly—by running experiments—both traditions have devised theories and practices that each of us can confirm if we invest sufficient time and energy

TRATEGIES FOR LUCIDITY

Dullness and amnesia—which operate hand-in-hand—are the major obstacles to lucidity as we sleep. Dullness puts us in a daze that prevents us from functioning with anything like the sharpness of our daytime mentality. Amnesia keeps us from remembering while dreaming that we are asleep

Many of the practices of lucid dreaming derive their effectiveness from a positive, proactive motivation based on an intense interest and desire to achieve and develop lucid dreaming

encouraged to prep themselves with strong and repeated statements such as, “Tonight I definitely will recognize the dream state!” spoken out loud prior to sleep

Another useful way to prime ourselves for lucid dreaming is to anticipate lucid dreams during our waking hours

We may imagine a recent dream and see ourselves becoming lucid—perhaps triggered by something odd or impossible that occurred in the dream

In lucid dreaming, the technique is considerably refined with the use of dream signs derived from a dream journal. Keeping a journal with detailed descriptions of your dreams serves several purposes

First, in order to have something to write in your journal you must be able to remember your dreams

The field of lucid dreaming has discovered several techniques for improving memories of dreaming

Since we learn in the early stages of lucid dream training that we tend to forget our dreams easily, learning to lie still on waking, and to immediately cast our attention backward to the dream from which we have emerged, will enable us to capture its details

Second, using prospective memory to enable us to remember to lie still, think back, and remember dreams is itself an introduction to a more advanced technique that can be applied both to trigger lucidity and to train within the lucid dream state

Once enough material has been gathered in your dream journal, an analysis is made to discover things that repeat frequently and to categorize these phenomena. You then familiarize yourself with them, making them the target of prospective memory

If one of your dream signs is, say, the repeated appearance of a white rabbit, you train yourself with the reminder, “The next time I see a white rabbit, I will ask myself whether or not I’m dreaming.

number of activities you can perform to check your state, to determine whether you are dreaming or awake. As mentioned previously, one often can float or fly in dreams

also happens that in dreams printed text and digital clock numerals tend to change when you look away then return your gaze

Using the above example, then you would prep yourself by affirming, “The next time I see a white rabbit I will jump up in the air. If I float or descend more slowly than usual, I will know I am dreaming and become lucid

One may simply get in the habit of asking oneself, “Am I dreaming or not?” ten or fifteen times per day. Or one could cultivate the habit of asking such a question on specific cues, such as each time one walks through a doorway or when something bizarre or unusual occurs

Each time the question is asked one can do a state check, like jumping into the air to see if one is indeed dreaming. Training consistently in this way will eventually create a habit that will carry over into your dreams

The most common way we become lucid while dreaming is by experiencing something spectacularly strange that startles us into lucidity

LaBerge calls such dreams DILDs—Dream-Initiated Lucid Dreams. One variation on this is to use an alarm clock to awaken yourself periodically during the night

If your alarm awakens you from a dream, and you have trained yourself to remember your dreams upon waking (remaining motionless and reflecting back on the dream contents), you may be able to fall back into the dream consciously and continue the dream lucidly

You can also deliberately awaken yourself toward the end of the sleep cycle and read (particularly something related to lucid dreaming) for half an hour. You then set your resolve to dream lucidly and go back to sleep. Stepehen LaBerge has calculated that this strategy increases your chances of lucid dreaming by 2,000 percent. The approach of surfacing and then reentering sleep is called WILD—Wake-Initiated Lucid Dreams

RAINING IN THE DREAM

Once you are able to maintain a lucid dream for more than a few seconds, you may notice the dream scenario begins to break up. The images lose their sharpness and cohesiveness. There are a number of techniques you can apply via your “dream body” to stimulate your senses and revive the integrity of dream contents

The techniques used for reconstituting dreams are based on the theory that competing sense data from either the waking state or from dreamless sleep are responsible for the deterioration of lucid dreams

Similarly, there are techniques for maintaining lucidity that range from simple reminders (“This is a dream”) to the creation of story lines that will extend both the dream and your lucidity within it. PUTTING DREAMS TO USE

In lucid dreams, those attracted to extreme sports can go far beyond anything possible in ordinary life. One can also train physical skills in lucid dreams. This parallels the kind of mental training athletes employ using visual imagination to rehearse physical movements

Personally, I prefer to view lucid dreaming as a laboratory for exploring the mind. If you take, say, a Western psychological viewpoint, lucid dreaming can allow you to explore your fears, neuroses, psychological obstacles, and so forth. If you are having difficulty interacting with a boss, coworker, or other acquaintance, you can conjure up that person in your dreams and rehearse your interactions

What are the boundaries of the ego we label “I”? What would it be like to go beyond them? This is essentially a spiritual question. In many contemplative religious traditions, going beyond the dualism of “self” and “other” is a major aim

OUTLINE OF LUCID-DREAMING TECHNIQUES: The power of motivation (making positive affirmations like, “Tonight I will definitely recognize that I am dreaming!”) Prospective memory (planning ahead and imagining an outcome, for example, during the day imagine becoming lucid in a dream) Noting dream signs and writing them down in a dream journal Performing state checks (try to fly; look at written material, turn away, and look again) Noticing anomalies (“How odd is that?”) Developing a critical reflective attitude (“Is this possible?”) Following hypnagogic imagery MILD—Mnemonic Induction of Lucid Dreams (performing a state check when you see a dream sign) DILD—Dream-Initiated Lucid Dreams (deliberately waking in the night and returning to an ongoing dream lucidly) WILD—Wake-Initiated Lucid Dreams (waking in the night, reading, then reentering sleep lucidly) Reconstituting fading dreams (spinning your dream body, giving it a rub-down) Maintaining fading lucidity (reminding yourself, “This is a dream,” creating story lines) Using the later hours effectively (the last two hours of sleep are best for lucid dreaming; even better, on weekends you could sleep a couple of extra hours) 3

The Practice of Lucid Dreaming

O SLEEP, NO DREAMS

When you become drowsy, roll over into your normal sleeping position, and allow yourself to drift off to sleep

GETTING STARTED WITH LUCID DREAMING

The first step toward lucid dreaming is to generate interest in your dreams. If you don’t have a natural curiosity about your sleeping and dreaming, think about this: should you live to the age of ninety, about thirty years—an entire third of your life—will pass in your sleep

am going to try to go back frame-by-frame as far as possible, to capture as much of that dream as I can.

A dream that seemed riveting only seconds earlier can vanish instantly. However, if we remain still and keep our eyes closed, we are only halfway out of dreamland. The atmosphere of our dream still lingers, and this gives us a chance to recapture at least some of the story. So you must remain immobile from the instant you begin

When trying to remember dreams it is also important to maintain a relaxed mind. If we become tense or overexcited due to high expectations, our thoughts may interfere with the images we seek to recall. If you

Once you are able to get even a single fragment from any dream you’ve had during the night, write it in your dream journal

If something doesn’t come immediately, keep on trying. By doing so, eventually it will work. “Can I remember anything since I fell asleep last night? Any images? Any story? Any emotions? Anything at all?” If you pick up the end of a dream, concentrate on that, thinking, for example, “OK, that was a dream. I was in Los Angeles. How did I get there? By plane? Where was I coming from? I see now, I came from Denver.” Maybe those two frames are all you will get, or maybe you will be able to un-pack the whole dream

A POSITIVE ATTITUDE You may be able

Rather than becoming negative, beating up on yourself (“I’m no good at this!”), tell yourself, “I wasn’t able to do it this time, but in the future it will be possible. I shall accomplish this

THE DREAM JOURNAL

From the beginning of this process, keep a notebook close by your bed and as soon as you have remembered as much dream material as you can for a given night or period of the night, write it down in as much detail as possible. I have seen people who began with zero dream recall remembering four or five dreams per night

By the time you have gotten really good at this, perhaps in a month or two, you can stop writing. You’ll then be able to remember your dreams very easily. The written material you’ve accumulated will be employed in the next step—identifying your dream signs

Finally there are repeated emotions, such as my travel anxiety from long ago. Certain situations may trigger dread or desire or disbelief in a manner that is unusual or different from your normal daytime emotional responses

EVELOPING A CRITICAL REFLECTIVE ATTITUDE

By logging a sufficient number of dreams in your journal and extracting a list of dream signs, you eventually get a useful and quite interesting picture of your dream life

But for most of us it takes a bit more to break through the dullness and amnesia that prevent us from questioning the nature of the reality we’re experiencing. The fact that the natural occurrence of lucid dreams is so infrequent shows that the fog is very thick

Therefore we establish the habit of making state checks during the daytime

DAYTIME STATE CHECKS

To develop prospective memory, make a list of twenty-five to thirty typical activities that you perform on a daily basis. These can include simple actions like walking through a door, turning a door knob, seeing a bird or animal, noticing a car or house of a particular color, hearing music, looking at yourself in the mirror, tying your shoes

Then choose four or five for each day of the week, at random. At the beginning of each day, memorize the handful of activities listed for that day, and the first time you perform that activity, you are to notice it immediately and then perform a state check

As a slight variation, when you catch yourself performing one of your targeted activities, you can first ask yourself, “Am I dreaming or not?” and then jump into the air.

You can also try pulling your nose. In a dream, doing this will often cause your nose to grow, like Pinocchio’s

Research has shown that by reading something once, looking away, and looking back at the same material, the chances are 85 percent that in a dream the words will change

Walking through a doorway may not be an oddity—whether in daytime or dreaming—but it may happen frequently in your dreams. If you were to get into the habit of performing a state check each time you walked through a doorway, even of merely asking yourself, “Am I dreaming or not?” sooner or later you will do the same thing in a dream

After all, from a lucid perspective, if you know that you went to bed recently and suddenly find yourself awake in some unexpected environment, the critical reflective mind will say, “Hey, I just went to bed! I’m not in the Los Angeles airport. This has to be a dream.”

OMPLEMENTARY STRATEGIES FOR LUCID DREAMING

WILD—Wake-Initiated Lucid Dreaming—provides a more direct approach to attaining lucidity, one that doesn’t require all the daytime preparation of the MILD technique. If we surface from dreaming in the middle of the night, there is the possibility of either slipping back into our dream lucidly or of setting a strong intention to notice oddities or dream signs when we go back to sleep soon afterward. Below are three WILD practices

Since the proportion of each cycle that contains dreams increases progressively throughout the night, if you find it easy to fall asleep, occasionally (when you don’t have to go to work the next day) set your alarm so that you will awaken well into the night at a time when you are likely to be dreaming

Let’s assume you are sleeping nine hours in a given night, which is equal to 540 minutes. Divided by ninety minutes per cycle, that comes to six cycles. If you set your alarm for four-and-a-half hours after you go to bed, you will awaken in 270 minutes—at the end of three sleep cycles. By this time your dream period in the latter part of each cycle has lengthened in comparison to earlier cycles. That means that when you awaken there is a good chance that you will be coming out of a dream of some length. Upon awakening set your alarm for ninety minutes later and go back to sleep with a strong resolve to become lucid. You can also try to lucidly reenter the dream you have just left, remembering and visualizing some of its details. If by now you have become skilled at remembering your dreams, this will come easily

your bedtime were 9 P.M., you would set your alarm for 1:30 A.M., then 3:00, then 4:30, then 6:00, then 7:30, and so on.

second practice makes additional use of this fact. When you have time to sleep in, for instance on a weekend or holiday, take advantage of that by sleeping an additional ninety-minute sequence or two

A third practice requires that you awaken well into the night and then remain awake for thirty to forty-five minutes before going back to sleep. Set your alarm to wake you after you have gone through several sleep cycles. Then get up and read something stimulating. The intention is to become very clearheaded. It would be most helpful if you were to read something associated with lucid dreaming so as to prime your interest in becoming lucid.

Another WILD approach is to pay attention to hypnagogic imagery as you fall asleep. This can be done either when you fall asleep at bedtime or upon awakening during the night. If you are able to maintain some clarity—to stretch your attention a little further than normal into the process of falling asleep—you will be able to detect broken images, dreamlets, and a variety of visual patterns that are part of the process of losing consciousness as we fall asleep. These images occur in a space between initial drowsiness

If we are able to maintain lucidity through this transition, we will find ourselves in NREM 2 and conscious of dreamless sleep

Preparing to fall asleep using the shamatha practice at the beginning of this chapter is very helpful in this approach. This type of WILD has much in common with the practices of dream yoga, which we will explore in later chapters

ULTIVATING LUCIDITY DIRECTLY

One of the best ways to lay a firm foundation for attaining proficiency in lucid dreaming is to train in the shamatha technique of settling the mind in its natural state. In this practice one’s attention is placed neither on the tactile sensations of the body nor on the breath but on the phenomena of the mind itself

You recognize these mental events as mental events, not mistaking them for events in the outer, intersubjective world. Normally we are as caught up in and carried away by our mental activities in the daytime as we are in the nocturnal mental activity we call dreaming. Rarely do we step back and simply observe our minds in action, becoming cognizant of the nature of the reality we are experiencing in the present moment

Then count twenty-one breaths, concentrating not on the counting itself but on the sensations correlated with your breathing. This is a preliminary exercise for stabilizing and calming the mind

Now open your eyes and let them remain at least partially open with your gaze resting vacantly in the space in front of you, and direct your attention to the space of the mind and whatever arises within that space. To facilitate this practice, at first you might generate a mental event or object, a thought or image, like that of a piece of fruit or the face of a relative—something familiar. Generate that image, focus single-pointedly upon that image, allow it to fade, then keep your attention right where it was, ready to detect the next image, thought, or mental event of any kind that arises within this space

You are attending both to the stage and to the players on the stage. So when there are no players, attend to the stage

After twenty-four minutes, bring the practice to a close.

OUTLINE OF THE PRACTICE: Posture: your choice (supine, seated cross-legged, seated on a chair) Body: settled in its natural state Breathing: settled in its natural state Attention: on the space of the mind and whatever mental events that arise in that domain of experience2 When distracted: relax, release whatever captivated your attention, then return your awareness to the space of the mind and its contents Length: one ghatika (twenty-four minutes) Intention: to attend to mental phenomena with lucidity as a preparation for lucid dreaming; to develop concentration using mental phenomena as the object of attention

Proficiency in Lucid Dreaming

KEEPING THE DREAM ALIVE

Losing the dream means that either waking sensory input or the extremely low-key (essentially unconscious) input from dreamless sleep for one reason or another becomes dominant

The antidote to this intrusion on your lucid dreams is to refocus your attention on the sensations of the dream. Several methods have proved extremely effective for reconstituting dreams as they begin to destabilize

If, as you dream lucidly, you sense that the visual scenario of the dream is losing its integrity, spin your dream body with your eyes wide open. This brisk, gyrating motion will cause your senses to be flooded by the images and sensations of the dream environment

As such, spinning can also be used as a means to change dreams—to skip from dream to dream

Another time-tested method is to give your dream body a rubdown. In most cases when you dream lucidly, “you” are located in a close replica of your ordinary body. The feel of this dream body is similar to your waking body. Since you have dream hands, simply rub the skin of your dream body vigorously

Following the same logic of boosting the relative volume of dream phenomena, you can also concentrate your focus on some object within the dream

But your dream body and the ground upon which you are standing will tend to be more stable. Focusing so that they become more vivid will anchor you within the dream, causing any competing data from the waking state or dreamless sleep to fade out

EEPING LUCIDITY ALIVE

So maintaining the critical reflective attitude that is the main support for lucidity in dreaming requires a great deal of vigilance, because you are going against one of the strongest habits of human life—snug, comfy “sleepy time.”

If you find yourself dreaming lucidly in what you consider horrid circumstances, and you choose not to confront it, the easiest way out of the dream is to close your (dream) eyes. This, incidentally, is a technique for entering lucid dreamless sleep

SYCHOLOGICAL INSIGHTS

You can use anticipation consciously to maintain lucidity. If, for instance, you think, “I bet my best friend Carl is going to walk through the door now,” often that is precisely what will happen

UCID DREAMLESS SLEEP

It is, however, a state we can explore and benefit from, if we take a keen interest in understanding the nature of consciousness and mental states

One exercise you can perform in the state of lucid dreamless sleep is to address your attention to the vacuity (the substrate) and pose questions such as, “What is the nature of this vacuity? What is its size, shape? What are its characteristics?” Having observed the substrate, resting there, answers to these questions can bring you to a bigger one: “What is the nature of being conscious?” In this rarified atmosphere, devoid of distractions, you can examine consciousness in detail and perhaps find important answers to questions that have puzzled philosophers for millennia.

The Practice of Awareness of Awareness (or Shamatha Without a Sign

One way to directly enter lucid dreamless sleep is to close one’s eyes during the activities of normal lucid dreaming. This brings one immediately to the vacuity of the substrate. Another method, found in dream yoga, is to concentrate on a visualized image at the heart chakra

A Session of Awareness of Awareness: Begin as in previous shamatha sessions by settling the body in its natural state. Find a comfortable posture—either sitting or lying in the supine position. Then, after taking three deep, luxuriant breaths, settle your breathing in its natural rhythm

As you practice mindfulness of breathing, let your eyes be at least partially open and rest your gaze in the space before you, paying no attention to objects near or far. Continue breathing comfortably and gently attune yourself to the qualities of relaxation, stillness, and vigilance. Be peripherally aware of any mental phenomena that pass through your mind’s eye.

Once you have attained a state that is relaxed and even, release your attention to all objects—any and all mental and physical appearances—and settle your awareness in the very state of being aware

What’s left over is the sheer event of knowing. From time to time, check to see that you are not straining and that your breathing remains deeply relaxed. Rest in this state of utter simplicity

OUTLINE OF THE PRACTICE: Settle your body in its natural state Settle your breathing in its natural rhythm Rest evenly—relaxed, still, and vigilant Release any thoughts that come to mind Settle awareness on awareness alone Length: one ghatika (or the time it takes to fall asleep lucidly) Intention: to explore the limpid clarity of the substrate consciousness, possibly as a prelude to a breakthrough to pristine awareness; or to enter into lucid dreamless sleep

The attention must be maintained in a very quiet and subtle manner, especially if your intention is to fall asleep lucidly

For this one, if you try too hard this gives rise to agitation and if you don’t try hard enough you fall into dullness

Once you recognize the two extremes, you want to do something in between, which means bouncing off of those extremes more and more lightly

HE DREAM LAB

Once you have developed enough experience, and the frequency, stability, and vividness of your dreams reach a certain thresh-old, you may create dream laboratories in which to carry out activities of interest to you

lucid dreams one can manipulate environments and the objects within them in a very fluid and vivid manner, ideally suited for anything from the design of experiments to the kind of free-form imagining important to cutting-edge science

This same example would apply to engineers and inventors, who could conceivably devise and try out their designs in the three-dimensional “holodeck” of controlled lucid dreaming. We’ll look at some practical implications of lucid dreaming in greater detail in a later chapter.

SPACE FOR MEDITATION

meditation techniques, many of which require a quiet space where one can meditate for relatively long periods of time without distractions

you desired a visual space conducive to your practice, you could provide yourself a room, a cave, a mountain-top with a glorious view—whatever your desires and skill level in lucid dreaming allowed

Vividness—the sharpness of images and their color and clarity—also takes time to develop, unless one is naturally gifted in the way many visual artists are

If you possessed the stability to create a visual image, such as a candle flame, a jewel, or even an image that is sacred to you, you could develop concentration and eventually arrive at samadhi (meditative concentration) by maintaining your attention exclusively on that image for progressively longer periods

Since everything perceived in the dream state—thoughts, emotions, and physical objects—are mental, you simply pay attention to everything that arises without grasping, without being carried away. This will naturally strengthen your stability as a lucid dreamer since, as we saw previously, being lucid to the appearance of all phenomena—day and night—is the fundamental template for lucid dreaming

Kindle highlights (2020)

  • loc 190 - Stability of attention is a crucial step to freedom—the freedom to transcend normal dream consciousness and recognize we are dreaming,

  • loc 198 - The techniques leading to successful dream practice include prospective memory (preparing to remember something in a future dream), retrospective memory (remembering sequences of dream events from the past), remembering cues that alert one to the dream state, and steady, relaxed concentration on visual images.

  • loc 205 - Research has shown that most of us awaken and then quickly return to sleep a number of times during the night. Few notice this habit. However, these spontaneous awakenings provide one of the most useful opportunities for entering into lucid dreams.

  • loc 210 - Over time, we can compile a list of events that occur regularly in our dreams.

  • loc 210 - Over time, we can compile a list of events that occur regularly in our dreams. We may, for instance, repeatedly find ourselves in a specific location, or encounter a certain situation or the same people or objects. If we have the mental clarity to remember the importance of these signs when they appear in our dreams, that can prompt us to awaken within them.

  • loc 257 - I recommend that mindfulness of breathing be practiced in stages one through four. For the next three stages—five through seven—I recommend settling the mind in the natural state. In this practice, attention to mental phenomena replaces focus on the breath. One observes all appearing mental events—thoughts, mental images, and emotions—neutrally, objectively, without any involvement. These events—which usually draw us in—are allowed to pass before the window of the mind like clouds blown across the sky. From stage eight onward one practices shamatha without a sign, also called awareness of awareness.

  • loc 297 - Keep the length of your practice session to twenty-four minutes (called, in Sanskrit, a ghatika, which was considered the ideal length for beginning meditation training in ancient India).

  • loc 307 - The basic technique of shamatha involves the interaction of two mental faculties: mindfulness and introspection. Mindfulness can be defined as continuous attention to a chosen object, which requires that one remember what the task is and not become distracted by other phenomena. Introspection (as the eighth-century Indian Buddhist adept Shantideva defined it) is “the repeated examination of the state of one’s body and mind.”6 Therefore introspection allows for a kind of quality control, recognizing when one’s attention strays and alerting mindfulness to reassert itself.

  • loc 322 - At bedtime, try this practice in the supine position for a short time—five, ten, twenty minutes, or more if you like—before you go into your normal sleeping position. On the initial exhalations release first all muscular tension in the body, and once you are thoroughly relaxed physically, also release all thoughts that appear—slowly breathing out . . . out . . . out . . .—and then allow the inhalation to flow in of its own accord.

  • loc 337 - A sense of ease and relaxation is indispensable for cultivating attention skills and for dream practice. But by itself it’s not enough. We need to also introduce the element of stability—the voluntary continuity of attention. So let’s step up this practice now by narrowing the focus of attention. Instead of focusing on the whole body or letting the attention rove within the body, now zero in more steadily on the tactile sensations of the rise and fall of the abdomen with each inhalation and exhalation.

  • loc 357 - OUTLINE OF THE PRACTICE: Settle the body in its natural state Breathe in a natural rhythm Phase one: attention on the field of tactile sensations (training relaxation) Phase two: attention on the rise and fall of the abdomen (training stability) Alternate overcoming agitation (on exhalation) and arousing attention (inhalation) Count the breaths Length: one ghatika (twenty-four minutes) Intention: training in stability

  • loc 430 - The technique for increasing vividness is to focus your attention on a subtler object, such as the sensations of the breath in the area of the nostrils. It takes greater attention to follow these sensations than the relatively coarser movement of the abdomen during respiration.

  • loc 432 - The overall strategy, then, is to allow stability to develop from relaxation and vividness to emerge from stability

  • loc 514 - it has been discovered that the sense of the passage of time within lucid dreams closely approximates the sense of time in the waking state. If it seems you have dreamed for half an hour, that is probably the case.

  • loc 517 - In the words of Stephen LaBerge, “dreaming can be viewed as the special case of perception without the constraints of external sensory input. Conversely, perception can be viewed as the special case of dreaming constrained by sensory input.”6 According to that statement both states of consciousness—perception when dreaming and when awake—are very similar, with overlapping networks of correlated brain mechanisms. And both states can potentially be just as clear, just as “awake.”

  • loc 544 - So gravity—whatever that is (there are several scientific hypotheses)—is a physical constraint experienced with waking consciousness. We became conditioned to it in specific ways when we learned to move about as children. In dreams, however, it is possible to escape the law of gravity.