A confession is about Leo Tolstoy’s journey into a void of emptiness that he felt during his mid 20s and then after his 50s. His seeking into the idea of why a man lives at all is very interesting with a letter he has at the very end. When a man achieves everything he aspired for, all the big dreams achieved, he gets to ask the question: what to live for now? The philosophical speculation into why we live and what we hold onto to live is revealing. There is a lot to learn from his confession to find meaning in life, to be able to live a life that’s new every day, and put despair at bay.
Direct Notes
In this book, he starts with the idea that people fall off because they live as others in a guided way. They actually don’t care about the principles of faith/belief. In trying to identify his belief, he retells story about a friend’s recount of faltering of their belief.
A certain S, a clever and veracious man, once related to me how he came to cease to believe. Twenty-six years ago, being on a hunting party, before he lay down to rest, according to a habit of his from childhood, he knelt down to pray. His elder brother, who was of the party, lay on some straw and watched him. When S had finished, and was preparing to lie down, his brother said to him, “Ah, you still keep that up?” Nothing more passed between them, but from that day S ceased to pray and to go to church. For thirty years S has not said a prayer, has not taken the communion, has not been in a church, not because he shared the convictions of his brother, or even knew them, not because he had come to any conclusions of his own, but because his brother’s words were like the push of a finger against a wall ready to tumble over with its own weight; they proved to him that what he had taken for belief was an empty form, and that consequently every word he uttered, every sign of the cross he made, every time he bowed his head during his prayers, his act was an unmeaning one. When he once admitted to himself that such acts had no meaning in them, he could not but discontinue them. Thus it has been, and is, I believe, with the large majority of men.
He seeked for what he believed in. He first started with an idea of “possibility of perfection” of which too, he didn’t know what it meant: the actualization of the idea or the results it imparts. That pursuit led him to do exercise, endurance sport, voluntary hardships, etc. to develop physical perfection. At first, he said, he started with idea of moral perfection. Since it was too vague, he found perfection in the eyes of other men as the ideal. In seeking, he starved for more of that social status. He said that during his process of seeking perfection, he found something unexpected. “I found ambition, love of power, love of gain, lechery, pride, anger, vengeance, held in high esteem.” He himself told that he wrote to please in the book. “During that time I began to write, out of vanity, love of gain, and pride.” He confessed that he taught about what he didn’t knew. Anyway, he got large sums of money, women, friends, and fame as a reward for his writings. He had a military career, and from that he found those individuals at the top of literary men, were man who had immoral lives, worthless and insignificant, and morality of whom Tolstoy couldn’t justify. Then came renunciation of his identities that identified him similarly to these men: a thinker, a poet, and a teacher. He started seeing himself going mad, but later conjured that it’s all a madhouse.
When he asks himself the question similar to all tormented men do, “How was I to better my life?”. In response, he found a common answer fed to everyone. Progress. His feelings about the answer were:
I was only repeating the answer of a man carried away in a boat by the waves and the wind, who to the one important question for him, “Where are we to steer?” should answer, saying, “We are being carried somewhere."
This belief for him shattered, when he saw that there can be no justification for war and us killing each other in the name of Progress. He comes to write:
I understood, not with my reason, but with my whole being, that no theory of the wisdom of all established things, nor of progress, could justify such an act and that if all the men in the world from the day of creation, by whatever theory, had found this thing necessary, it was not so; it was a bad thing, and that therefore I must judge of what was right and necessary, not by what men said and did, not by progress, but what I felt to be true in my heart.
Then came other answers that help soothe: You are developing. One day, this will all make sense. Then, he got married. And, put into rest the search for meaning of life too. He recounts:
The effort to effect my own individual perfection, already replaced by the striving after general progress, was again changed into an effort to secure the particular happiness of my family. In this way fifteen years passed.
Then, he came to crisis again, trying to find a reason to live at all.
I had moments of perplexity, of a stoppage, as it were, of life, as if I did not know how I was to live, what I was to do. I began to wander, and was a victim to low spirits.
He tells that he thought the questions: “Why” and “What after” weren’t urgent, that he had all the time in the world to answer these questions. But, they came all crashing down. He had no time to wait for it. He felt the need for answers right then and there. It all became very significant very quickly. Death was on the line.
My life had come to a sudden stop. I was able to breathe, to eat, to drink, and to sleep. I could not, indeed, help doing so; but there was no real life in me.
He gets too deep into it that he at a point didn’t know what he would ask for even if a fairy offered to help. We, as readers, are dubious as to why wouldn’t he seek the answers to the questions he had asked. Then, he gives the perfect answer to our doubts.
I could not even wish to know the truth, because I guessed what the truth was.
At this point, he truly felt like he had nothing to live for. No progress, no answers, no truth, no seeking.
the idea of suicide came as naturally to me as formerly that of bettering my life. it had so much attraction for me that i was compelled to practise a species of self-deception, in order to avoid carrying it out too hastily.
What a situation. Had to practice self-deception to not do a suicide. Really compelling. Then, in that situation, he realized something about his self-deception. He knew that there was something he still hoped from life. But, the cruelty of life still persists in him.
It is possible to live only as long as life intoxicates us; as soon as we are sober again we see that it is all a delusion, and a stupid one! In this, indeed, there is nothing either ludicrous or amusing; it is only cruel and absurd.
He then asks himself on why he clings to life, when he knows that death is already there waiting. Why he had to be the one to see through this absurdity. Now, he cannot decieve himself of the things that seemed happy previously.
Now, he asks himself: “What of art and poetry then?” Then he answers:
I had long persuaded myself that these were things worth working for, notwithstanding the approach of death, the great destroyer, to annihilate my writings, and the memory of them; but now I soon saw that this was only another delusion, I saw clearly that art is only the ornament and charm of life but when I knew that life had no meaning at all, and was only terrible, the play of the light no longer amused me.
He then finds himself running back and forth, all lost in the process. He said seeking became his second nature: not like anyone’s seeking for just curiosity or knowledge.
I sought an explanation of the questions, which tormented me in every branch of human knowledge; I sought that explanation painfully and long, not out of mere curiosity nor apathetically, but obstinately day and night; I sought it as a perishing man seeks safety, and I found nothing
And then he comes to a place where he felt like it was not just him, but nobody really had any answer to the questions he was asking answers to. And the clear question was:
“What result will there be from what I am doing now, and may do tomorrow? What will be the issue of my life?” Otherwise expressed, it may run: “Why should I live? Why should I wish for anything? Why should I do anything?” Again, in other words it is: “Is there any meaning in my life which can overcome the inevitable death awaiting me?”
He goes on to say that multiple domains studied this question, or at least tried answering it. But, the answers only made sense when it was about growth. When he was growing bigger, memory and muscles strong, power of thinking and understanding better, it all made sense. But, as his capacities withered, so did the faith on these knowledge systems.
when my muscles and memory were strengthening, my power of thinking and understanding on the increase – that I, feeling this, very naturally thought that the law of my own growth was the law of the universe and explained the meaning of my own life. But there came another time when I had ceased to grow, and I felt that I was not developing but drying up; my muscles grew weaker, my teeth began to fall out, and I saw that this law of growth not only explained nothing but that such a law did not and could not exist; that I had taken for a general law what only affected myself at a given age
The relation of experimental science to the question of the meaning of life may be put as follows: Question, “Why do I live?” Answer, “Infinitely small particles, in infinite combinations, in endless space and endless time, eternally change their forms, and when you have learned the laws of these changes, you will know why you live. In the days of my mental weakness this reasoning sufficed for me; but as soon as the problem of life really, as it were, arose within me, the whole theory fell to pieces at once.
To answer this question, he thinks we can approach the question like this instead.
“What is the life of that unknown quantity to us, mankind, of which we are acquainted with but one minute part in one minute period of time?”
And to it’s answer, when he finds none. He describes his search like this:
In my search for a solution of the problem of life I experienced the same feeling as a man who has lost himself in a wood. He comes to an open plain, climbs up a tree, and sees around him a space without end, but nowhere a house – he sees clearly that there can be none; he goes into the thick of the wood, into the darkness, and sees darkness, but again no house.
Then to the more theoretical answering of the question:
The theoretical side of human knowledge, when it keeps firmly to its own principles, through all time has ever answered and still answers one and the same, “The world is something which is eternal and not to be understood. The life of man is an inconceivable part of this inconceivable whole."
Then he comes to a seeming conclusion that all that remains is nothing. We are nothing more than our wishes to know, and we know nothing beyond that. Then he talks of wisdom:
And I gave my heart to know wisdom, and to know madness and folly: I perceived that this also is vexation of spirit. For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow. For there is no remembrance of the wise more than of the fool forever; seeing that which now is in the days to come shall be forgotten. And how dieth the wise man? As the fool.
Now, he goes on looking into philosopher’s seeking for truth. The idea they had about death, and the meaning of life in general.
“The life of the body is evil and a lie, and so the annihilation of that life is a good for which we ought to wish,” says Socrates. Life is what it ought not to be; “an evil, and a passage from it into nothingness is the only good in life,” says Schopenhauer. Everything in the world, folly and wisdom, riches and poverty, rejoicing and grief, all is vanity and worthless. Man dies and nothing is left of him, and this again is vanity, says Solomon. “To live, knowing that sufferings, illness, old age, and death are inevitable, is not possible; we must get rid of life, get rid of the possibility of living,” says the Buddha. And what these powerful minds have said, what millions on millions of men have thought and felt, has been thought and felt by me.
He sees the truth in all these sayings. He senses that they felt the same way he did. Now, he started to find answer in people close to him. He found everyone using a escape route to this terrible state:
- Through ignorance. So, there’s nothing to learn from them.
- Through epicureanism. They just seem to be licking what’s fed by others. Not their own idea.
- Through Strength and energy of character. Only the strong survive. But, what about the wretched?
- Through weakness. Continuing the drag of life, though aware that nothing can come from it.
He when sees all this, knows on one hand that only way to put up an end to misery, is to give away ones’ life, but in another way feels that he might have confused the ideas to come to this conclusion.
Now, he finds his reasoning in conflict. He feels every reason he has speaks of terminating his life, but he still wants to go on. How can this be possible?
My reason tells me that life is contrary to reason. If there is nothing higher than reason (and there is nothing), reason is the Creator of my life; were there no reason, there would be no life for me. How can it be that reason denies life, and is at the same time its creator? Again, from the other side, if there were no life, I should have no reason, consequently reason is born of life, and life is all. Reason is the product of life, and yet it denies life.” I felt that something here was wrong. I said to myself: “Life undoubtedly has no meaning, and is evil, but I have lived and am still alive, and so also have lived and are living the whole human race. How is it, then? Why do all men live, when all men are able to die? Is it that I and Schopenhauer alone are wise enough to have understood the unmeaning emptiness and evil of life
Then, he thought what if there is something more for him to know. Another part of his mind answers that this is how ignorance acts too. Now, humankind has lived without a real meaning for this long because there’s no clear answer he finds anywhere through human history. He asks why humanity then lived for so long. He felt a contradiction. What he learned came from their learning, and the learning that came from it denies the meaning of that learning. How can this be true? He asks. He tries finding the mistake now.
He felt people lived like animals, not men. He felt sorry for millions who failed to conceive the depth of this question. Now, he turned the prospect towards those very men who are living a life as if it had meaning, whom he saw as animals upto this point.
Then, he sees that faith is the reason that he couldn’t reject. There is god, and all sort of fancy ideas which he seems not to understand. Then, he saw a way out. He needs to abandon the guide that brought him upto this terrible answer: reason because he felt a clear contradiction here. In his own words:
I was stopped by a contradiction which could only be explained in two ways: either what I called reasonable was not so reasonable as I thought it, or what I called unreasonable was not so unreasonable as I thought it.
Now, he found the process complete without a flaw. He saw that the question, though it seemed simple, had included the necessity of explaining infinities after infinities, which led to only answer possible: none at all.
Through all my reasoning with myself I constantly compared, and I could not do otherwise, the finite with the finite, and the infinite with the infinite, and the conclusion was consequently inevitable: a force is a force, matter is matter, will is will, infinity is infinity, nothing is nothing – and beyond that there was no result.
He felt that all the feelings he had made the answers from Science and Schopenhauer more visible to him in light of correctness. Then, he found that faith brings in relation of finite to the infinite in the answers they give. Then, he says that there is a knowledge in each of us except reasoning knowledge which he calls faith, and it gives us the possibility of living.
From the beginning of the human race, wherever there is life there is the faith, which makes life possible, and everywhere the leading characteristics of that faith are the same. He does not see and understand the unreality of the finite, he believes in the finite; if he sees that unreality, he must believe in the infinite. Without faith there is no life.
Now, there seemed two options when he overlooked all the past stages of his mental state that he needed to take answer out of.
- Be ignorant of infinity.
- Accept explanation of meaning of life which should equalize the finite and the infinite.
Experimental science told everything outside of himself, nothing of that which he needed. Philosophy told only what he already knew: that it was impossible to know anything. Then, what is he? : A part of the infinite whole.
Now, he asks to himself: Is it just now that this question has emerged? Has none ever asked this question before? All ideas of God exist to give faith, but he wanted to work this out to get a good answer for himself.
Now, he feels that it’s his burden that he’s standing upon a civilization saved by faith when there was no reason to exist at all. All the fanciful ideas of faith: god, unity, moral conception, were built through infinite mental labors of human race.
He felt a lot of contradictions as he dug deeper into the fact. He felt that these answers, despite having no reason, solved the problem of life.
He then studied faith: Buddhists, Mohammedans, Christianity. In those, he didn’t find any hope of finding explanation to meaning of life. “No arguments were able to convince me of the sincerity of the faith of these men.” He felt because of the believers, he couldn’t have faith because noone cared about what the faith said with sincerity. Then, he started looking at poor, simple, ignorant, monks, etc. He saw that people who passed lives in heavy labor, had an easy death: a death without terror or despair, which he found rarely in his own class of people.
He started growing attached to those kind of people. In process, he felt easier to live. He lived for two years, and in that time lost all attraction to lives of rich and learned men. For the first time, he felt he had a meaning, and really felt convinced about it as well.
All our actions, our reasoning, our science and art, all appeared to me in a new light. I understood that it was all child’s play, that it was useless to seek a meaning in it. The life of the working classes, of the whole of mankind, of those that create life, appeared to me in its true significance. I understood that this was life itself, and that the meaning given to this life was a true one, and I accepted it.
He then realizes that the society built around epicureanism made him not see true meaning. He compares that to an executioner who kills, sees life as meaningless. Is that all the meaning? It’s a true one, but only for the man who gave it. He compares himself, and all the aristocrats to that. Then he asks what a man should do then. What is his/her purpose?
What, then, should man do? He also must gain his living like the animals, but with this difference, that he will perish if he attempt it alone; he must labor, not for himself, but for all. And when he does so, I am firmly convinced he is happy, and his life is a reasonable one.
He finds answers in all actions saying that we go through what requires of us. In process, it gets more complex and important. In doing that, we go on understanding the establishment as well. The wise men, he affirms, that they seat themselves more to control the handle than to be led, thinking the master is stupid, and we are the only wise ones. He said that when he was fully convinced of the impossibility of proving existence of God as Kant has shown him, which he had completely grasped through reasoning. But, he still seeked meaning, still belabored to find God. But, he felt there was something more than him that’s making him not cease immediately. During that, he speaks:
No sooner was I conscious of a power over me than I felt a possibility of living.
He then started praying to God to help him, to have mercy on him, to teach him. But, more he prayed, he felt like there was noone to listen. Now, there was a possibility of God that deserted him. Now, he had more reason to kill himself. But, now with a feeling that he should never do it. Deepest of contradictions.
For two years, he had been seeking God. One day, he said to himself:
It is well, there is no God, there is none that has a reality apart from my own imaginings, none as real as my own life – there is none such. Nothing, no miracles can prove there is, for miracles only exist in my own unreasonable imagination.
Now, he asks again: Where does the God I seek come from? Then, he answered to himself: “The conception of God is not God. Conception is what goes on within myself; the conception of God is an idea which I am able to rouse in my mind or not as I choose; it is not what I seek, something without which life could not be”. Now, the situation was like this:
I remembered that I had lived only when I believed in a God. As it was before, so it was now; I had only to know God, and I lived; I had only to forget Him, not to believe In Him, and I died
He found himself in a situation where he needed God to live. He found himself back on the same loop of moral virtue, and progress of humanity as a tradition to give meaning to life. He reckoned that he had accepted all this unconsciously previously, but now he knew this was the only way he could not die.
He felt like being on a boat that knows the end, cannot stop, but doesn’t know how farther it needs to go. Also, the currents get more difficult. He use metaphor to recollect all the ideas into one as follows:
The shore is God, the course tradition; the oars are the free will given me to make for the shore to seek union with the Deity. And thus the vital force was renewed in me, and I began again to live.
Now, he was accepting faith without questions, even the things that appeared stranger to him. And, in following that diligently, there wasn’t a slight opposition in him. Now, comes his realization as a whole:
I reasoned thus: Faith springs, like man and his reason, from the mysterious first cause. That cause is God, in who begin the body and the mind of man. As my body proceeded through successive gradations from God to me, so have my reason and my conception of life proceeded from Him, and consequently the steps of this process of development cannot be false. All that men sincerely believe in must be true; it may be differently expressed, but it cannot be a lie, and consequently, if it seem to me a lie, that must be because I do not understand it.
He followed rituals like this for some time, but felt like lying to himself as he went on. Then, came the assistance of Russian theologians. From there, he felt that he could practice the rites of Orthodox church without having a big understanding of them. It comes from this line:
Love can never make any particular form of creed binding on all believers.
He even accepted that he unconsciously concealed all the contradictions and obscurities of common doctrines in order to continue existing. He retells that he couldn’t do an oath for church because he didn’t feel truly honest about it. He listened to peasant pilgrim, more books, but still with more doubts. Not knowing can sometimes be a gift.
How often have I not envied the peasant, unable to read or write, his lack of learning?
Then, with more doctrine people he followed, he found that the very faith that was supposed to be union of love, were destroying it.
Thus I, who had believed faith, was to be found in the union of love, was unwillingly forced to see that the doctrines of faith destroy the very thing which they should produce.
Now, he wanted to unite these beliefs into one cohesive framework because that was the only way to understand it. Then, he felt that they were dealing with matters of earthly affairs. That was the guiding force for them. And in that search, he recounts:
When I looked around me at all that was done in the name of religion, I was horrified, and almost entirely withdrew from the Orthodox Church.
He couldn’t accept what they were doing in the name of faith:
Not to see that murder is an evil, contrary to the very first principles of every faith, was impossible. In the churches, however, men prayed for the success of our arms, and the teachers of religion accepted these murders as acts, which were the consequence of faith.
Now, he says not all in faith is true. But, he cannot say all in faith is false either. Then, the pursuit got to separating out faith that is true from that isn’t. The comes Tolstoy’s final letter in The Confession
Highlights
This falling off, as it seems to me, for the most part goes on as follows: people live as others live, and their lives are guided, not by the principles of the faith which is taught them, but by their very opposite; belief has no influence on life, nor on the relations between men – it is relegated to some other sphere where life is not; if the two ever come into contact at all, belief is only one of the outward phenomena, and not one of the constituent parts of life
certain S, a clever and veracious man, once related to me how he came to cease to believe. Twenty-six years ago, being on a hunting party, before he lay down to rest, according to a habit of his from childhood, he knelt down to pray. His elder brother, who was of the party, lay on some straw and watched him. When S had finished, and was preparing to lie down, his brother said to him, “Ah, you still keep that up?” Nothing more passed between them, but from that day S ceased to pray and to go to church. For thirty years S has not said a prayer, has not taken the communion, has not been in a church, not because he shared the convictions of his brother, or even knew them, not because he had come to any conclusions of his own, but because his brother’s words were like the push of a finger against a wall ready to tumble over with its own weight; they proved to him that what he had taken for belief was an empty form, and that consequently every word he uttered, every sign of the cross he made, every time he bowed his head during his prayers, his act was an unmeaning one
When he once admitted to himself that such acts had no meaning in them, he could not but discontinue them. Thus it has been, and is, I believe, with the large majority of men
Now, when I think over that time, I see clearly that all the faith I had, the only belief which, apart from mere animal instinct, swayed my life, was a belief in a possibility of perfection, though what it was in itself, or what would be its results, I was unable to say
I did my best to develop my physical powers by every exercise calculated to give strength and agility, and by way of accustoming myself to patient endurance I subjected myself to many voluntary hardships and trials of privation. All this I looked upon as necessary to obtain the perfection at which I aimed. At first, of course, moral perfection seemed to me the main end, but I soon found myself contemplating in its stead an ideal of general perfectibility; in other words, I wished to be better, neither in my own eyes nor in those of God, but in the sight of other men. This feeling again soon ended in another, the desire to have more power than others, to secure for myself a greater share of fame, of social distinction, and of wealth
I tried to express the longings of my heart for a truly virtuous life, I was met with contempt and derisive laughter, but directly I gave way to the lowest of my passions, I was praised and encouraged
I found ambition, love of power, love of gain, lechery, pride, anger, vengeance, held in high esteem
During that time I began to write, out of vanity, love of gain, and pride. I followed as a writer the same path, which I had chosen as a man. In order to obtain the fame and the money for which I wrote, I was obliged to hide what was good and bow down before what was evil
Meanwhile, thinker and poet though I was, I wrote and taught I knew not what. For doing this I received large sums of money; I kept a splendid table, had an excellent lodging, associated with loose women, and received my friends handsomely; moreover, I had fame
Again, when I doubted this faith in the influence of literary men, I began to examine more closely into the character and conduct of its chief professors, and I convinced myself that these writers were men who led immoral lives, most of them worthless and insignificant individuals, and far beneath the moral level of those with whom I had associated during my former dissipated and military career; these men, however, had none the less an amount of self-confidence only to be expected in those who are conscious of being saints, or in those for whom holiness is an empty name
I grew disgusted with mankind and with myself, and I understood that this belief, which I had accepted, was a delusion. The strangest tiling in all this was that, though I soon saw the falseness of this belief and renounced it, I did not renounce the position I had gained by it; I still called myself a thinker, a poet, and a teacher
We were all then convinced that it behooved us to speak, to write, and to print as fast as we could, as much as we could, and that on this depended the welfare of the human race
It is now clear to me that between ourselves and the inhabitants of a madhouse there was no difference: at the time I only vaguely suspected this, and, like all madmen, thought all were mad except myself
It may be summed up in the word “progress.” It then appeared to me this word had a real meaning. I did not understand that, tormented like other men by the question, “How was I to better my life?” When I answered that I must live for progress
I was only repeating the answer of a man carried away in a boat by the waves and the wind, who to the one important question for him, “Where are we to steer?” should answer, saying, “We are being carried somewhere Such a beautiful line !!
When I saw the head divided from the body, and heard the sound with which they fell separately into the box, I understood, not with my reason, but with my whole being, that no theory of the wisdom of all established things, nor of progress, could justify such an act and that if all the men in the world from the day of creation, by whatever theory, had found this thing necessary, it was not so; it was a bad thing, and that therefore I must judge of what was right and necessary, not by what men said and did, not by progress, but what I felt to be true in my heart
Everything develops, and I myself develop as well; and why this is so will one day be apparent,” was the formula I was obliged to adopt
Soon after my return I married. The new circumstances of a happy family life by which I was now surrounded completely led my mind away from the search after the meaning of life as a whole
During their continuance the same questions always presented themselves to me: “Why?” and “What after?” At first it seemed to me that these were empty and unmeaning questions, that all they asked about was well known, and that whenever I wished to find answers to them I could do so without much trouble – then I had no time for it
The sufferings increase, and the patient, before he has time to seek a remedy, is confronted with the fact that what he took for a mere indisposition has become more important to him than anything else on earth, that he is face to face with death
The questions seemed so foolish, so simple, so childish; but no sooner had I begun my attempt to decide them than I was convinced that they were neither childish nor silly, but were concerned with the deepest problems of life, and again that I was, think of them as I would, utterly unable to find an answer to them
Had a fairy appeared and offered me all I desired, I should not have known what to say. If I seemed to have, at a given moment of excitement, not a wish, but a mood resulting from the tendencies of former wishes, at a calmer moment I knew that it was a delusion that I really wished for nothing. I could not even wish to know the truth, because I guessed what the truth was
I knew not what I wanted; I was afraid of life; I shrank from it, and yet there was something I hoped for from it.
The traveller sees this, and knows that he must inevitably perish; but, while still hanging, he looks around him, and, finding some drops of honey on the leaves of the wild plant, he stretches out his tongue and licks them
Thus do I cling to the branch of life, knowing that the dragon of death inevitably awaits me, ready to tear me to pieces, and I cannot understand why such tortures have fallen to my lot
The former delusion of happiness in life, which hid from me the horror of the dragon, no longer deceives me. However I may reason with myself that I cannot understand the meaning of life, that I must live without thinking
But what of art and poetry? Under the influence of success and flattered by praise, I had long persuaded myself that these were things worth working for, notwithstanding the approach of death, the great destroyer, to annihilate my writings, and the memory of them; but now I soon saw that this was only another delusion, I saw clearly that art is only the ornament and charm of life
but when I knew that life had no meaning at all, and was only terrible, the play of the light no longer amused me
Had I been like a man in a wood, out of which he knows that there is no issue, I could have lived on; but I was like a man lost in a wood, and who, terrified by the thought, rushes about trying to find a way out, and, though he knows each step can only lead him farther astray, cannot help running backwards and forwards TRUTH
Had I been like a man in a wood, out of which he knows that there is no issue, I could have lived on; but I was like a man lost in a wood, and who, terrified by the thought, rushes about trying to find a way out, and, though he knows each step can only lead him farther astray, cannot help running backwards and forwards
However persuasive the argument might be that all the same something in the heart or elsewhere would burst and all would be over, still I could not patiently await the end. The horror of the darkness was too great to bear, and I longed to free myself from it by a rope or a pistol ball. This was the feeling that, above all, drew me to think of suicide
sought an explanation of the questions, which tormented me in every branch of human knowledge; I sought that explanation painfully and long, not out of mere curiosity nor apathetically, but obstinately day and night; I sought it as a perishing man seeks safety, and I found nothing
My search not only failed, but I convinced myself that all those who had searched like myself had failed also, and come like me to the despairing conviction that the only absolute knowledge man can possess is this – that life is without a meaning
I had the advantage of all that learning could answer to the question,” What is life?
was at last forced to the conclusion that these questions were just and necessary ones underlying all knowledge, and that it was not I that was in fault in putting them, but science in pretending to have an answer to them
The question, which in my fiftieth year had brought me very close to suicide, was the simplest of all questions
That question was as follows: “What result will there be from what I am doing now, and may do tomorrow? What will be the issue of my life?” Otherwise expressed, it may run: “Why should I live? Why should I wish for anything? Why should I do anything?” Again, in other words it is: “Is there any meaning in my life which can overcome the inevitable death awaiting me?”
One system of knowledge seems to deny that there is such a question, but, on the other hand, has a clear and exact answer to all its own independent inquiries: it is the system of experimental science, at the extreme end of which is mathematics. Another system accepts the question, but does not answer it; it is that of theoretic philosophy, and at its extremity is metaphysics. I had been addicted from my youth to theoretical study; later, mathematics and the exact sciences had attracted me; and till I came to put clearly to myself this question as to the meaning of life, until it grew up in me, as it were, of itself, and till I felt that it demanded an immediate answer, I was content with the artificial and conventional answers given by learning
when my muscles and memory were strengthening, my power of thinking and understanding on the increase – that I, feeling this, very naturally thought that the law of my own growth was the law of the universe and explained the meaning of my own life. But there came another time when I had ceased to grow, and I felt that I was not developing but drying up; my muscles grew weaker, my teeth began to fall out, and I saw that this law of growth not only explained nothing but that such a law did not and could not exist; that I had taken for a general law what only affected myself at a given age HOLY SHIT FUCKING INTERESTING
Those who profess them say, “We cannot tell you what you are and why you live; such questions we do not study. But if you wish to know the laws of light, of chemical affinities, of the development of organisms; if you wish to know the laws that govern different bodies, their form, and relations to number and size; if you wish to know the laws of your own mind, we can give you clear, exact, and absolutely certain answers on every point
The relation of experimental science to the question of the meaning of life may be put as follows: Question, “Why do I live?” Answer, “Infinitely small particles, in infinite combinations, in endless space and endless time, eternally change their forms, and when you have learned the laws of these changes, you will know why you live
In the days of my mental weakness this reasoning sufficed for me; but as soon as the problem of life really, as it were, arose within me, the whole theory fell to pieces at once THE SPIRITUAL ANSWERS
In the days of my mental weakness this reasoning sufficed for me; but as soon as the problem of life really, as it were, arose within me, the whole theory fell to pieces at once
it be not the silliness, of this way of thinking is that, in order to answer the question which occurs to every man – “What am I” or “Why do I live?” or “What am I to do?” – we must first answer this other question: “What is the life of that unknown quantity to us, mankind, of which we are acquainted with but one minute part in one minute period of time?”
When I followed what seemed the bright light of learning, I saw that I had only turned aside from the real question
wherever the philosopher does not overlook the great question of all, the answer is always the same, the answer given by Socrates, Schopenhauer, Solomon, and Buddha. “We approach truth only in the proportion as we are farther from life,” said Socrates, when preparing to die
A wise man seeks death all his life, and death has no terrors for him
The only thing that remains to us is nothing. But this passage to annihilation is opposed by our own nature, by our will to live, which causes our own existence and that of the universe. That we so fear annihilation, or, what is the same, that we so wish to live, only shows that we ourselves are nothing but that wish, and know nothing beyond it.
And I gave my heart to know wisdom, and to know madness and folly: I perceived that this also is vexation of spirit. For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow WOW TRUE SHIT
And I gave my heart to know wisdom, and to know madness and folly: I perceived that this also is vexation of spirit. For in much wisdom is much grief: and he that increaseth knowledge increaseth sorrow
And I turned myself to behold wisdom, and madness, and folly And I myself perceive also that one event happeneth to them all. Then said I in my heart, as it happened to the fool, so it happened even to me and why was I then wiser? Then I said in my heart, that this also is vanity. For there is no remembrance of the wise more than of the fool forever; seeing that which now is in the days to come shall be forgotten. And how dieth the wise man? As the fool
I could not be deceived. All was vanity. A misfortune to be born. Death was better than life, and life’s burden had to be got rid of
Having failed to find an explanation in knowledge, I began to seek it in life itself, hoping to find it in the men who surrounded me; and I began to watch men like myself, to observe how they lived, and how they practically treated the question, which had brought me to despair
I found that for those who occupied the same position as myself there were four means of escape from the terrible state in which we all were
The first means of escape is through ignorance
From these I could learn nothing: we cannot not know what we do know
The second means of escape is the Epicurean. It consists in, while we know the hopelessness of life, taking advantage of every good there is in it, in avoiding the sight of the dragon and mice, and in seeking the honey as best we can, especially wherever there is most of it
That some of them call their dullness of thought and imagination by the name of positive philosophy, does not, in my opinion, separate them from those who, in order not to see the real question, search for and lick the honey
The third means of escape is through strength and energy of character. It consists in destroying life when we have perceived that it is an evil and an absurdity. Only men of strong and unswerving character act thus
The fourth means of escape is through weakness. It consists, though the evil and absurdity of life are well known, in continuing to drag on, though aware that nothing can come of it
Thus do those of my own class, in four different ways, save themselves from a terrible contradiction
, like Sakyamuni, could not drive to the pleasure ground, when I knew of the existence of old age, suffering, and death. My imagination was too lively for that. Moreover, my heart was saddened by the passing joys which fell for a few rare instants to my lot. The third way, knows that life is an evil and a foolish thing, to put an end to it; to kill one’s self
now see that I did not kill myself because I had, in a confused sort of way, inkling that my ideas were wrong
To see the inanity of life is a simple matter enough, and it has long been apparent to the simplest among us, but men still live on. Yes, men live on, and never think of calling in question the reasonableness of life
Then I thought to myself: “But what if there be something more for me to know? Surely this is the way in which ignorance acts. Why, it always says exactly what I do now! What men are ignorant of they say is stupid. It really comes to this, that mankind as a whole have always lived, and are living, as if they understood the meaning of life, for not doing so they could not live at all, and yet I say that all this life has no meaning in it, and that I cannot live.
And I, the work of their hands, their foster child, the pupil of their thoughts and sayings, have proved to them they themselves had no meaning! “There must be something here,” said I, “that is wrong. I have made some mistake.” I could not, however, discover where the mistake lay
Whether in the conclusion itself, or in the way of putting the question, I did not know; I only felt that, though my reason was entirely convinced, that was not enough. All my reasoning could not induce me to act in accordance with my convictions, i.e., to kill myself
It seemed to me that the small circle of learned, rich, and idle people, to which I myself belonged, formed the whole of humanity, and that the millions living outside it were animals, not men
Led away by intellectual pride, it seemed to me not to be doubted that I, with Solomon and Schopenhauer, had put the question so exactly and truly that there could be no other form of it; it seemed unquestionable that all these millions of men had failed to conceive the depth of the question, that I had sought the meaning of my life; and it never once occurred to me to think, “But what meaning has been given, what meaning is given now, by the millions of those who have lived and are living on earth
I felt that, if I wished to live and understand the meaning of life, I must seek it not amongst those who have lost their grasp on it, and wish to kill themselves, but among the millions of the living and the dead, who have made our life what it is, and on whom now rests the burden of our life and their own
The knowledge based on reason, the knowledge of the learned and the wise, denies a meaning in life, and the great mass of all the rest of mankind have an unreasoning consciousness of life which gives a meaning to it
This unreasoning knowledge is the faith, which I could not but reject. This is God, one and yet three; this is the creation in six days, the devils and the angels; and all that I cannot, while I keep my senses, understand. My position was a terrible one
The result of the latter was that, in order to understand the meaning of life, I must abandon the guide without which there can be no meaning in anything, my reason itself
was stopped by a contradiction which could only be explained in two ways: either what I called reasonable was not so reasonable as I thought it, or what I called unreasonable was not so unreasonable as I thought it
On doing this I found the process complete without a flaw. The conclusion that life was nothing was inevitable; but I discovered a mistake. The mistake was that I had not confined my thoughts to the question proposed. The question was, why should I live, i.e., what of real and imperishable will come of my shadowy and perishable life – what meaning has my finite existence in the infinite universe? And I had tried to answer this by studying life. It was evident that the decision of any number of questions concerning life could not satisfy me, because my question, however simple it seemed at first, included the necessity of explaining infinity by infinity, and the contrary. I asked myself what meaning my life had apart from time, causation, and space. After long and earnest efforts of thinking, I could only answer – none at all
It seemed to me at first that science did give a positive answer, the answer of Schopenhauer: life has no meaning, it is an evil; but, when I inquired more closely into the matter, I perceived that the answer was not positive, that it was my own feeling alone made me think it so
This philosophical knowledge denies nothing, but answers that the question cannot be decided by it, – that the matter remains indefinite
I also understood that, however unreasonable and monstrous the answers given by faith, they do bring in the relation of the finite to the infinite
this way I was compelled to admit that, besides the reasoning knowledge, which I once thought the only true knowledge, there was in every living man another kind of knowledge, an unreasoning one, but which gives a possibility of living – faith
From the beginning of the human race, wherever there is life there is the faith, which makes life possible, and everywhere the leading characteristics of that faith are the same.
faith is the knowledge of the meaning of man’s life, through which man does not destroy himself, but lives
he does not see and understand the unreality of the finite, he believes in the finite; if he sees that unreality, he must believe in the infinite. Without faith there is no life
I then went back upon all the past stages of my mental state, and was terrified. It was now clear to me that for any one to live it was necessary for him either to be ignorant of infinity or to accept an explanation of the meaning of life which should equalize the finite and the infinite
What did I do when I sought an answer in the study of experimental science? I wanted to know why I lived, and to that end I studied everything outside myself. Clearly in this way I might learn much, but nothing of that which I needed. What did I do when I sought an answer in the study of philosophy? I studied the thoughts of others in the same position as myself, and who had no answer to the question – what is life? Clearly I could in this way learn nothing but what I myself knew, namely, that it was impossible to know anything. What am I? A part of the infinite whole. In those few words lay the whole problem
Could it be that men had only now begun to put this question to themselves? Could it be that no one before myself had asked this simple question that must occur even to the mind of an intelligent child
The conception of an infinite God, of the divinity of the soul, of the way in which the affairs of men are related to God, of the unity and reality of the spirit, man’s conception of moral good and evil, these are conceptions worked out through the infinite mental labors of mankind; conceptions without which there would be no life, without which I should not myself exist, and yet I dare to reject the labors of the whole human race, and to venture on working out the problem again in my own way alone
we understand that life is an evil, and yet we live. This clearly is foolish, because if life is foolish, and I care so much for reason, life should be put an end to, and then there would be no one to deny it
understood that all our arguments turned in a charmed circle, like a cogwheel the teeth of which no longer catch in another. However much and however well we reason, we get no answer to our question, it will always be = 0, and consequently our method is probably wrong. (3) I began to understand that in the answers given, by faith was to be found the deepest source of human wisdom, that I had no reasonable right to reject them, and that they alone solved the problem of life
I was now ready to accept any faith that did not require of me a direct denial of reason, for that would be to act a lie; and I studied the books of the Buddhists and the Mohammedans, and especially also Christianity, both in its writings and in the lives of its professors around me
The more minutely they laid their doctrines before me, the more clearly I perceived their error, the more I lost all hope of finding in their faith an explanation of the meaning of life
No arguments were able to convince me of the sincerity of the faith of these men
Only actions, proving their conception of life to have destroyed that fear of poverty, illness, and death, so strong in myself, could have convinced me, and such actions among them I could not see. Such actions, I saw, indeed, among the open infidels of my own class in life, but never among its so-called believers
I began to draw nearer to the believers among the poor, the simple, and the ignorant, the pilgrims, the monks, the sectaries, and the peasants. The doctrines of these men of the people, like those of the pretended believers of my own class, were Christian
that the superstition of the believers of my own class was not needed by them, and never influenced their lives beyond serving as a kind of Epicurean distraction, while the superstition of the believing laboring class was so interwoven with their lives that it was impossible to conceive them without it – it was a necessary condition of their living at all
I saw among the people whole lives passed in heavy labor. In direct opposition to what I saw in my own circle – men resisting and indignant with the privations and sufferings of their lot – the people unhesitatingly and unresistingly accepting illness and sorrow, in the quiet and firm conviction that all was for the best
contradiction to the theory that the less learned we are the less we understand the meaning of life, and see in our sufferings and death but an evil joke, these men of the people live, suffer, and draw near to death, in quiet confidence and oftenest with joy. In contradiction to the fact that an easy death, without terror or despair, is a rare exception in my own class, a death, which is uneasy, rebellious, and sorrowful, is among the people the rarest exception of all
All these men, infinitely divided by manners, powers of mind, education, and position, all alike in opposition to my ignorance, were well acquainted with the meaning of life and of death, quietly labored, endured privation and suffering, lived and died, and saw in all this, not a vain, but a good thing. I began to grow attached to these men. The more I learned of their lives, the lives of the living and of the dead of whom I read and heard, the more I liked them, and the easier I felt it so to live. I lived in this way during two years, and then there came a change which had long been preparing in me, and the symptoms of which I had always dimly felt: the life of my own circle of rich and learned men, not only became repulsive, but lost all meaning whatever
When I remembered how these very doctrines had repelled me, how senseless they had seemed when professed by men whose lives were spent in opposition to them, and how they had attracted me and seemed thoroughly reasonable when I saw men living in accordance with them, I understood why I had once rejected them and thought them unmeaning, why I now adopted ‘them and thought them most reasonable. I understood that I had erred, and how I had erred. I had erred, not so much through having thought incorrectly, as through having lived ill. I understood that the truth had been hidden from me, not so much because I had erred in my reasoning, as because I had led the exceptional life of an epicure bent on satisfying the lusts of the flesh. I understood that my question as to what my life was, and the answer, an evil, were in accordance with the truth of things. The mistake lay in my having applied an answer, which only concerned myself to life in general
What if the executioner, who passes his life in torturing and cutting off heads, or a confirmed drunkard, asked himself the question, What is life? He could but get the same answer as a madman would give, who had shut himself up for life in a darkened chamber, and who believed that he would perish if he left it; and that answer could but be – Life is a monstrous evil
The answer would be a true one, but only for the man who gave it. Here, then, was I such a madman? Were all of us rich, clever, idle men, mad like this? I understood at last that we were; that I, at any rate, was. Look at the birds; they live but to fly, to pick up their food, to build their nests, and when I see them doing this their gladness rejoices me. The goat, the hare, the wolf live but to feed and multiply, and bring up their young; and when I see them doing this, I am well convinced of their happiness, and that their life is a reasonable one
The life of the world goes on through the will of some one. Some one makes our own life and that of the universe his own inscrutable care. To have a hope of understanding what that will means, we must first carry it out; we must do what is required of us. Unless I do what is required of me, I can never know what that may be, and much less know what is required of us all and of the whole universe
As he passes from less to more important labors, he will understand better and better the arrangements of the whole establishment; and he will take his share in them without once stopping to ask why he is there, nor will he ever think of reproaching the lord of that place.
But we the while, wise men that we are, devour the goods of the master, and do nothing of that which he wills us to do; but instead, seat ourselves in a circle to argue why we should move the handle, for that seems to us stupid. And when we have thought it all out, what is our conclusion? Why, that the master is stupid, or that there is none, while we ourselves are wise, only we feel that we are fit for nothing, and that we must somehow or other get rid of ourselves
During the whole of that year, when I was constantly asking myself whether I should or should not put an end to it all with a cord or a pistol, during the time that my mind was occupied with the thoughts which I have described, my heart was oppressed by a tormenting feeling, which I cannot describe otherwise than as a searching after God
It was a feeling of dread, or orphan hood, of isolation amid things all apart from me, and of hope in help I knew not from whom. Though I was well convinced of the impossibility of proving the existence of God – Kant had shown me, and I had thoroughly grasped his reasoning, that this did not admit of proof – I still sought to find a God, still hoped to do so, and still, from the force of former habits, addressed myself to one in prayer. Him whom I sought, however, I did not find
No sooner was I conscious of a power over me than I felt a possibility of living. Then I asked myself: “What is this cause, this power? How am I to think of it? What is my relation to what I call God?” And only the old familiar answer came into my mind, “He is the Creator, the giver of all.” This answer did not satisfy me, and I felt that the staff of life failed me; I fell into great fear, and began to pray to Him whom I sought, that He would help me. But the more I prayed, the clearer it became that I was not heard, that there was no one to whom to pray. With despair in my heart that there was no God, I cried: “Lord, have mercy on me, and save me O Lord, my God, teach me!” But no one had mercy on me, and I felt that life stood still within me
Again and again, however, the conviction came back to me that I could not have appeared on earth without any motive or meaning, – that I could not be such a fledgling dropped from a nest as I felt myself to be. What if I wail, as the fallen fledgling does on its back in the grass? It is because I know that a mother bore me, cared for me, fed me, and loved me. Where is that mother? If I have been thrown out, then who threw me? I cannot but see that some one who loved me brought me into being. Who is that some one? Again the same answer is, God
I fell once more into despair, and felt that I had nothing to do but to kill myself, while, worst of all, I felt also that I should never do it
I remember one day in the early springtime I was listening to the sounds of a wood, and thinking only of one thing, the same of which I had constantly thought for two years – I was again seeking God.
I said to myself: “It is well, there is no God, there is none that has a reality apart from my own imaginings, none as real as my own life – there is none such. Nothing, no miracles can prove there is, for miracles only exist in my own unreasonable imagination
And then I asked myself: “But my conception of the God whom I seek, whence comes it?” And again life flashed joyously through my veins. All around me seemed to revive, to have a new meaning. My joy, though, did not last long, for reason continued its work: “The conception of God is not God. Conception is what goes on within myself; the conception of God is an idea which I am able to rouse in my mind or not as I choose; it is not what I seek, something without which life could not be
Then again all seemed to die around and within me, and again I wished to kill myself
I only really live when I feel and seek Him. “What more, then, do I seek?” A voice seemed to cry within me, “This is He, He without whom there is no life. To know God and to live are one. God is life
Live to seek God, and life will not be without Him. And stronger than ever rose up life within and around me, and the light that then shone never left me again.
returned to the belief that the one single aim of life should be to become better; that is, to live in accordance with that Will; I returned to the idea that the expression of that Will was to be found in what, in the dim obscurity of the past, the great human unity had fashioned for its own guidance; in other words, I returned to a belief in God, in. moral perfectibility, and in the tradition which gives a meaning to life. The difference was that formerly I had unconsciously accepted this, whereas now I knew that without it I could not live
The state of mind in which I then was may be likened to the following. It was as if I had suddenly found myself sitting in a boat which had been pushed off from some shore unknown to me, had been shown the direction of the opposite shore, had had oars given me, and had been left alone. I use the oars as best I can, and row on; but the farther I go towards the centre, the stronger becomes the current which carries me out of my course, and the more often I meet other navigators, like myself, carried away by the stream
In the very middle of the stream, beset by the crowd of boats and vessels, and carried like them along, I forget altogether in what direction I started, and abandon my oars. From all sides the joyful and exulting navigators, as they row, or sail down stream, with one voice cry out to me that there can be no other direction
I believe them, and let myself go with them. I am carried far, so far that I hear the roar of the rapids in which I must perish, and I already see boats that have been broken up within them. Then I come to myself. It is long before I clearly comprehend what has happened. I see before me nothing but destruction. I am hurrying towards it; what, then, must I do? On looking back, however, I perceive a countless multitude of boats engaged in a ceaseless struggle against the force of the torrent, and then I remember all about the shore, the oars, and the course, and at once I begin to row hard up the stream and again towards the shore
again to live
This meaning was clear to me, and dear to my heart. This popular faith, however, among the non-sectarian communities in which I moved, was inextricably bound up with something else so incapable of being explained that it repelled me. I mean the sacraments of the Church, the fasts, and the bowing before relics and images
The people were unable to separate these things, and no more could I. Though many things belonging to the faith of the people appeared strange to me, I accepted everything, I attended the church services, prayed, morning and evening, fasted, prepared for the communion; and, while doing all this, for the first time felt that my reason found nothing to object to. What had formerly seemed to me impossible now roused not the slightest opposition in me
Formerly, life itself had seemed to me full of meaning, and faith an arbitrary assertion of certain useless and unreasonable propositions, which had no direct bearing on life
Formerly I looked upon them as a worthless, illegible scrawl; now I did not understand them, but knew that they had a meaning, and resolved to find it out
reasoned thus: Faith springs, like man and his reason, from the mysterious first cause. That cause is God, in who begin the body and the mind of man. As my body proceeded through successive gradations from God to me, so have my reason and my conception of life proceeded from Him, and consequently the steps of this process of development cannot be false. All that men sincerely believe in must be true; it may be differently expressed, but it cannot be a lie, and consequently, if it seem to me a lie, that must be because I do not understand it
Again, I said to myself: The true office of faith is to give a meaning to life which death cannot destroy
Why do I live, and what will come of my life?” – the answer, though one and the same in reality, should be infinitely varied in its form ; that, in exact proportion to its unvarying unity, to its truth, and its depth, it should appear strange, and even monstrous, in the attempts to find due expression which are owing to the bringing up, and the social state of each individual answerer. But this reasoning, which justified the oddities of the ritual side of faith, was insufficient to make me feel that I had a right, in a matter like faith, now become the one business of my life, to take part in acts of which I still am doubtful
I ardently desired to be one with the people, and conform to the rites, which they practised, but I could not do it. I felt that I should lie to myself, and mock what I held most sacred, if I did this thing. At this point our new Russian theologians came to my assistance
that love can never make any particular form of creed binding on all believers. I did not then see error in this reasoning, and, thanks to it, I was able to accept and practise all the rites of the Orthodox Church, but without understanding the greater part of them. I struggled earnestly to set aside all reasoning, all contradictions, and endeavored to explain as reasonably as I could all the doctrines of the Church which presented any difficulty
While thus fulfilling the ordinances of the Church, I submitted my reason to the tradition adopted by the mass of my fellow men. I united myself to my ancestors, to my beloved father, mother, and grandparents. They and all before them, lived, and believed, and brought me into being. I joined the millions of the people whom I loved. Moreover, there was nothing bad in all this, for bad with me meant the indulgence of the lusts of the flesh
It was so necessary for me at that time to believe in order to live, that I unconsciously concealed from myself the contradictions and the obscurities in the commonly received doctrines
in short, two-thirds of the whole service – either remained for me without an explanation at all, or made me feel that the only one I could apply to them was false, while to lie was to break off my connection with God, and lose utterly the possibility of believing
On these holidays, I felt that the greatest importance was given to what I believed to be of the least, and I either held fast to the explanation which quieted me most, or else shut my eyes so as not to see what disquieted me
This feeling came upon me strongest whenever I took part in the most ordinary, and generally considered the most important, sacraments, as christening and the Holy Communion. Here I had to do with nothing difficult, but with what was easy to be understood: such acts appeared to me a delusion, and I was on the horns of a dilemma – to lie, or to reject
The communion I explained to myself as an action done in remembrance of Christ, and as signifying a cleansing from sin and a complete acceptance of Christ’s teaching. If this explanation was an artificial one, I at least did not perceive it
But when I drew near to the altar, and the priest called upon me to repeat that I believed that what I was about to swallow was the real body and blood, I felt a sharp pain at the heart; it was no unconsidered word, it was the hard demand of one who could never have known what faith was
I still continued an exact observance of the rites of the Church, and I still believed that the doctrines I followed were true; and then there happened to me a thing which now is clear enough, but which then appeared to me very strange
I once listened to the discourse of an unlettered peasant pilgrim. He spoke of God, of faith, of life, and of salvation, and knowledge of what faith was seemed open to me.
But no sooner did I mix with learned believers, or consult their books, than doubts, uneasiness, and the bitterness of dispute came over me, and I felt that the more I studied their discourses the more I wandered from the truth, the nearer I came to the precipice
When I failed to understand anything, I said, “I am wrong, I am wicked.” But the more I became imbued with the spirit of the truths which I studied, the more surely I saw them to be the substratum of life, the greater and more formidable became the obstacles, the more clearly defined the line which I was unable to understand, and of which I could only seek an explanation through lying unto myself
Notwithstanding all my doubts and sufferings, I still remained in the Orthodox Church; but practical questions arose which required immediate decision, and the decisions of the Church, contrary to the elementary principles of the faith by which I lived, compelled me finally to abandon all communion with it
The interest which I took in this great question of faith led me at this time to form acquaintance with the professors of different creeds, Catholics, Protestants, Old Believers, New Dissenters, and others, and among them I found many who sincerely believed and obeyed the highest moral standard. I desired to be a brother to these men, and what came of it? The doctrines which had seemed to promise me the union of all men in faith and love, in the persons of their best representatives, showed themselves but capable of educating men in a lie; resulted but in this, that what gives them strength to live is a temptation of the devil, the belief that they alone possess the possibility of knowing truth
We say to ourselves, “No, it cannot be so simple as that, and yet these men have not seen that when two propositions flatly contradict each other, the truth on which faith should rest is in neither. There must be some cause for this, there must be some explanation
I myself thought there was, and sought for it. I read everything I could get on the subject, and consulted with as many as I could, but the only explanation I obtained was that of the hussar, who accounts his regiment the first in the world, while his friend the lancer says the same of his own. The clergy of all religions, the best among them, all told me of their belief that they alone were right and all others wrong, and that all they could do for those who were in error was to pray for them. I went to the Archimandrites, the Archprelates, the Priors, and the Monks, and asked them, but no one made the slightest attempt to explain this snare to me but one, and his explanation was such that I put no more questions to anyone
Is it not possible, as I have already said, for a higher knowledge to issue from the disappearance of these differences, as they do already disappear for those who sincerely believe? Can we not go farther on our way to meet the Old Believers? They affirm that our way of signing the cross, of singing hallelujah, and of moving round the altar, is not the same as theirs
Then I understood it all. I am in search of faith, the staff and strength of life, while these men seek the best means of fulfilling in the sight of men certain human obligations, and having to deal with earthly affairs they fulfil them as ordinary men ever do. However much they may talk of their pity for the errors of their brethren, of praying for them at the throne of the Most High, for earthly affairs force is needed, and force always has been, is, and will be, applied
The second point, which concerned the relations of the Church to the problems of life, was her connection with war and executions
Not to think of this was impossible. Not to see that murder is an evil, contrary to the very first principles of every faith, was impossible. In the churches, however, men prayed for the success of our arms, and the teachers of religion accepted these murders as acts, which were the consequence of faith
ceased from this time to doubt, and became firmly convinced that all was not truth in the faith which I had joined. Formerly I should have said that all in this faith was false, but now it was impossible to say so.
Although I saw that there was less of what had repelled me as false among the people than among the representatives of the Church, I also saw that in the belief of the people what was false was mingled with what was true
To be understood, it must be cautiously and carefully examined, even though the result might not be the certain knowledge of science, which, aware as I was of the special character of religious inquiry, I did not and could not seek to obtain
I wished to understand so that every unexplained proposition should appear to my reason necessarily unexplainable, and not an obligatory part of belief
I never doubted that the doctrines contained both truth and falsehood, and I was bound to separate the one from the other. I began to do this. What I found of false and of true, and to what results I came, forms the second part of this work, which, if it be thought worthwhile, and if it can be useful to any one, will probably be some day published
I am lying on my back in bed, and I feel neither particularly well nor comfortable, nor the contrary. I begin to think whether it is well for me to lie, and something makes me feel uncomfortable in the legs; if the bed be too short or ill made, I know not, but something is not right. I move my legs about, and at the same time begin to think how and on what I am lying, a thing which previously had never troubled me. I examine the bed, and see that I am lying on a network of cords fastened to the sides of the bedstead. My heels lie on one of these cords, my legs on another, and this is uncomfortable. I am somehow aware that the cords can be moved, and with my legs I push the cord away, and it seems to me that thus it will be easier. But I had pushed the cord too far; I try to catch it with my legs, but this movement causes another cord to slip from under me, and my legs hang down. I move my body to get right again, convinced that it will be easy, but this movement causes other cords to slip and change their places beneath me, and I perceive that my position is altogether worse; my whole body sinks and hangs without my legs touching the ground. I hold myself up only by the upper part of the back, and I feel now not only discomfort, but horror. I now begin to ask myself what I had not thought of before. I ask myself where I am, and on what I am lying. I begin to look round, and first I look below, to the place towards which my body sank, and where I feel it must soon fall. I look below, and I cannot believe my eyes. I am on a height far above that of the highest tower or mountain, a height beyond all my previous powers of conception. I cannot even make out whether I see anything or not below me, in the depths of that bottomless abyss over which I am hanging and into which I feel drawn. My heart ceases to beat, and horror fills my mind. To look down is too terrible. I feel that if I look down I shall slip from the last cord and perish. I stop looking, but not to look is still worse, for then I think of what will at once happen to me when the last cord breaks. I feel that I am losing in my terror the last remnant of my strength, and that my back is gradually sinking lower and lower. Another instant, and I shall fall. Then all at once came into my mind the thought that it could not be true, that it was a dream; I will awake. I strive to wake myself and cannot. “What can I do?” I ask myself, and as I put the question I look above. Above stretches another gulf. I look into this, and try to forget the abyss below, and I do forget. The infinite depth repels and horrifies me; the infinite height attracts and satisfies me. I still hang on the last cords, which have not yet slipped from under me over the precipice; I know that I am hanging thus, but I look only upwards, and my fear leaves me. As happens in dreams, I hear a voice saying, “Look well; it is there!” I pierce farther and farther into the infinity above, and I feel that it calms me. I remember all that has happened – how I moved my legs, how I was left hanging in air, how I was terrified, and how I was saved from my fears by looking above. I ask myself, “And now, am I not hanging still?” and I feel in all my limbs, without looking, the support by which I am held. I perceive that I no longer hang nor fall, but have a fast hold. I question myself how it is that I hold on. I touch myself, I look around, and I see that under the middle of my body there passes a stay, and on looking up I find that I am lying perfectly balanced, and that it was this stay alone that held me up before. As it happens in dreams, the mechanism by which I am supported appears perfectly natural to me, a thing to be easily understood, and not to be doubted, although this mechanism has no apparent sense when I am awake. In my sleep I was even astonished that I had not understood this before. At my bedside stands a pillar, the Solidity of which is beyond doubt, though there is nothing for it to stand upon. From this pillar runs a cord, somehow cunningly and simply fixed, and if I lie across this cord and look upwards, there cannot be even a question of my falling. All this was clear to me, and I was glad and easy in my mind. It seemed as if some one said to me, “See that you remember!” And I awoke. Lyof N. Tolstoy. 1882