Notes
- In order for a canon theme to work, a melody has to function in different parts yet make sense as a whole. It must first be part of a melody, and secondly a harmonization of same melody.
Bach and Braid in music
- Ways music was canonized:
- Copies of theme staggered in time
- Copies of theme staggered in time as well as pitch. e.g. If a voice starts at C, another second overlapping voice can start at G which is 5 notes higher. Third voice then can start after next 5 notes at D.
- Speed of voices can speed up. e.g. Second voice gets twice as fast.
- Speed of voices get slower. e.g. Second voice is twice as slow as first voice.
- Invert and make it jump up and down exactly as the original theme.
- Play the theme backwards in time. Comes from peculiarities of crab canon.
- Based on one theme which gets played in different voices and different keys, and occasionally at different speeds or upside down or backwards.
- Bach wrote a fugue for the king with text note: “As the modulation rises, so may the King’s glory.”
- Music can go infinitely recursively.
Escher and Braid in drawings
- Escher’s drawings to show infinite recursion.
- Escher’s drawings:
- Strange Loops: A picture of picture which contains itself.
- Print Gallery
- Drawing Hands
Godel and Braid in mathematics
- Epimenides Paradox explains how just stating a statement can create violations in logical system. This liar paradox has helped prove the properties of our current mathematical system.
- Godel found out that mathematics was incomplete by proving that some statements in mathematics cannot even be proved.
- “All consistent axiomatic formulations of number theory include undecidable propositions.”
- The grand conclusion of Principia Mathematica started by Bertrand Russell is that the system is incomplete as proven by Godel. Godel’s incompleteness theorem
- Kurt Godel showed that provability is a weaker notion than truth, no matter what axiomatic system is involved.
Highlights
Contracrostipunctus
The problem with the harpsichord was that pieces could only be played at a rather uniform loudness-there was no way to strike one note more loudly than its neighbors. The “soft-loud”, as its name implies, provided a remedy to this problem.
most straightforward of all canons is the round, such as “Three Blind Mice”, “Row, Row, Row Your Boat”, or " Frere Jacques". Here, the theme enters in the first voice and, after a fixed time-delay, a “copy” of it enters, in precisely the same key. After the same fixed time-delay in the second voice, the third voice enters carrying the theme, and so on. Most themes will not harmonize with themselves in this way. In order for a theme to work as a canon theme, each of its notes must be able to serve in a dual (or triple, or quadruple) role: it must firstly be part of a melody, and secondly it must be part of a harmonization of the same melody
Thus, each note in a canon has more than one musical meaning; the listener’s ear and brain automatically figure out the appropriate meaning, by referring to context.
There are more complicated sorts of canons, of course. The first escalation in complexity comes when the “copies” of the theme are staggered not only in time, but also in pitch; thus, the first voice might sing the theme starting on C, and the second voice, overlapping with the first voice, might sing the identical theme starting five notes higher, on G. A third voice, starting on the D yet five notes higher, might overlap with the first two, and so on. The next escalation in complexity comes when the speeds of’ the different voices are not equal; thus, the second voice might sing twice as quickly, or twice as slowly, as the first voice. The former is called diminution, the latter augmentation (since the theme seems to shrink or to expand).
The next stage of complexity in canon construction is to invert the theme, which means to make a melody which jumps down wherever the original theme jumps up, and by exactly the same number of semitones. This is a rather weird melodic transformation, but when one has heard many themes inverted, it begins to seem quite natural.
Finally, the most esoteric of “copies” is the retrograde copy-where the theme is played backwards in time. A canon which uses this trick is affectionately known as a crab canon, because of the peculiarities of crab locomotion.
A fugue is like a canon, in that it is usually based on one theme which gets played in different voices and different keys, and occasionally at different speeds or upside down or backwards.
The telltale sign of a fugue is the way it begins: with a single voice singing its theme. When it is done, then a second voice enters, either five scale-notes up, or four down. Meanwhile the first voice goes on, singing the “countersubject”: a secondary theme, chosen to provide rhythmic, harmonic, and melodic contrasts to the subject. Each of the voices enters in turn, singing the theme, often to the accompaniment of the countersubject in some other voice, with the remaining voices doing whatever fanciful things entered the composer’s mind.
Bach indubitably also relished the implication that this process could go on ad infinitum, which is perhaps why he wrote in the margin “As the modulation rises, so may the King’s Glory.” To emphasize its potentially infinite aspect, I like to call this the “Endlessly Rising Canon”.
And finally, the tightest of all Strange Loops is realized in Print Gallery (Fig. 142): a picture of a picture which contains itself. Or is it a picture of a gallery which contains itself? Or of a town which contains itself? Or a young man who contains himself'?
(Incidentally, the illusion underlying Ascending and Descending and Waterfall was not invented by Escher, but by Roger Penrose, a British mathematician, in 1958. However, the theme of the Strange Loop was already present in Escher’s work in 1948, the year he drew Drawing Hands. Print Gallery dates from 1956.)
Implicit in the concept of Strange Loops is the concept of infinity, since what else is a loop but a way of representing an endless process in a finite way? And infinity plays a large role n many of Escher’s drawings.
The genius of Escher was that he could not only concoct, but actually portray, dozens of half-real, half-mythical worlds, worlds filled with Strange Loops, which he seems to be inviting his viewers to enter.
That paradox is the so-called Epimenides paradox, or liar paradox. Epimenides was a Cretan who made one immortal statement: “All Cretans are liars.” A sharper version of the statement is simply “I am lying”; or, “This statement is false”. It is that last version which I will usually mean when I speak of the Epimenides paradox. It is a statement which rudely violates the usually assumed dichotomy of statements into true and false, because if you tentatively think it is true, then it immediately backfires on you and makes you think it is false. But once you’ve decided it is false, a similar backfiring returns you to the idea that it must be true. Try it!
His idea was to use mathematical reasoning in exploring mathematical reasoning itself. This notion of making mathematics “introspective” proved to be enormously powerful, and perhaps its richest implication was the one Godel found: Godel’s Incompleteness Theorem.
All consistent axiomatic formulations of number theory include undecidable propositions
proofs are demonstrations within fixed systems of propositions.
Whereas the Epimenides statement creates a paradox since it is neither true nor false, the Godel sentence G is unprovable (inside P.M.) but true. The grand conclusion% That the system of Principia Mathematica is “incomplete”-there are true statements of number theory which its methods of proof are too weak to demonstrate.
The phrase “and Related Systems” in the title of Godel’s article is a telling one: for if Godel’s result had merely pointed out a defect in the work of Russell and Whitehead, then others could have been inspired to improve upon P.M. and to outwit Godel’s Theorem. But this was not possible: Godel’s proof pertained to any axiomatic system which purported to achieve the aims which Whitehead and Russell had set for themselves.
Godel showed that provability is a weaker notion than truth, no matter what axiomatic system is involved.
it seems somewhat paradoxical, on first thought, to mechanize that which is most human. Yet even the ancient Greeks knew that reasoning is a patterned process, and is at least partially governed by statable laws. Aristotle codified syllogisms, and Euclid codified geometry; but thereafter, many centuries had to pass before progress in the study of axiomatic reasoning would take place again
Russell’s paradox
Clearly, every set is either run-of-the-mill or self-swallowing, and no set can be both. Now nothing prevents us from inventing R: the set of all run-o,-the-mill sets. At first, R might seem a rather run-of-the-mill invention-but that opinion must be revised when you ask yourself, “Is R itself “a run-of-the-mill set or a self-swallowing set?” You will find that the answer is: “R is neither run-of-the-mill nor self-swallowing, for either choice leads to paradox.” Try