Notes
- None of us live in an objective world, but instead in a subjective world that we ourselves have given meaning to. The world you see is different from the one I see, and it’s impossible to share your world with anyone else.
- If environments condition people, all those who had bad parents must turn the same way.
- “Past doesn’t matter.” according to Alderian Psychology.
- Teleology: Study of purpose of a given phenomenon rather than study of causation (etiology). Your friend had the goal of not going out beforehand, and he’s been manufacturing a state of anxiety and fear as a means to achieve that goal.
- We make out of trauma whatever suits our purposes. Experiences don’t determine but the meaning we give them is self-determining.
- Immediate rewards for people: e.g. He is creating anxiety and fear as his reasons to stay inside. It’s not that the person is happy or satisfied but there’s no doubt that person is acting in alignment to his/her goal.
- People get angry that they could shout.
- People anticipate things that the other person will say, the measures they will take to correct their mistake and humble apology. But, people want to shout and they shout. This is way you show your power over others. You used emotion of anger as tool to make the other person submit to you.
- Mother, principal, call, anger as a choice, anger to overpower child with loud voice thus assert her opinions.
- People have emotions but they have control over it.
- If past would only determine everyone’s future, we would end up with nihilism and pessimism losing any hope.
- People think their disposition or personality cannot be changed. In Adlerian psychology, we describe personality and disposition with the word “lifestyle." Lifestyle is a word that encompasses the worldview of that person and his or her outlook on life.
- Example of How personality can be reformed: Say there’s someone who worries about himself and says, “I am a pessimist.” One could rephrase that to instead say, “I have a pessimistic view of the world.” You could consider that the issue is not personality but rather the view of the world. It seems that the word “personality” is nuanced and suggests being unchangeable. But if we’re talking about a view of the world, well, then, that should be possible to alter.
- You probably think that lifestyle you have is the most practical one and it’s easier to leave things as they are.
- Changing lifestyle needs courage. Anxiety generated by changing vs Disappointment of not changing. Most people go for the latter.
Examples
Novelist
- An aspiring novelist says job keeps him too busy and he can never find time to write novels. He does all this because he wants to leave the possibility: “I can do it if I try.”
Girl and Fear of Blushing
- She fabricated that fear of blushing as an excuse for her own inability to confess her feelings. Or maybe as a kind of insurance for when he rejected her.
- Fear of blushing makes you accept your dissatisfaction with world around you and a life that isn’t going well. If by getting this fear out, you’d probably come back and say “Give me my fear of blushing which can’t be done.”
- When she didn’t need it, she just went away with it. The guy she liked confessed and there was no need of dealing with it anymore.
Notes
- We similarly are afraid of being negated by other people. We are afraid of being refused and sustaining deep mental wounds.
- It’s impossible to not get hurt in relations with other people. “To get rid of one’s problems, all one can do is live in the universe all alone”
- You were so afraid of interpersonal relationships that you came to dislike yourself. You’ve avoided interpersonal relationships by disliking yourself.
- Subjectivity matters: The choice to view height either as advantage or disadvantage is open to you. It can be disadvantageous to some and advantageous to some.
- Pursuit of superiority : People are born helpless. People have universal desire to escape from that helpless state.
- Feeling of inferiority : Everyone is in “condition of wanting to improve”.
- Both feelings are perfectly normal. Both can promote striving and growth if used in the right way.
Complex :
- Abnormal mental state made up of complicated group of emotions and ideas.
- Example: If one has feeling of inferiority about one’s education –> One can
take two steps:
- Try harder than anyone else
- Use feeling of inferiority as kind of excuse. i.e. Complex
- Person not marrying due to parent’s divorce in childhood simply is scared to take even one step forward. You don’t have courage to change your lifestyle.
Superiority Complex :
- One can’t tolerate inferiority complex of thinking. A is the situation, B cannot be done. One can’t accept one’s incapable self.
- E.g. Excessive allegiance to brands of clothing as forms of giving authority, misrepresenting one’s work etc.
- Such people are trying to look bigger on borrowed power.
- The one who boasts does only out of feeling of inferiority.
- Person who boasts their upbringing, misfortunes; if you try to suggest some helping hand and change, they refuse it by saying “You don’t understand how I feel.”
Notes
- People don’t want to change and don’t take suggestions saying that the other person doesn’t know what he/she is going through.
- People use misfortune to control another party with it. By declaring how suffered they are, they are trying to worry people around them and restrict their behavior, speech and control them.
- The strongest person in our culture is baby. It is because noone can control a baby.
- A healthy feeling of inferiority is something that comes from comparison with one’s ideal self.
- A competitor if is a comrade to you, it brings self improvement.
- Competition at the center of interpersonal relationships cannot escape misfortune.
- When one is conscious of competition and victory and defeat, it is inevitable that feelings of inferiority will arise. Superior and inferiority complex are extensions of that.
- There is a difference between personal anger (personal grudge) and indignation with regard to society’s contradictions and injustices (righteous indignation). Personal anger soon cools but righteous indignation lasts for a long time.
Dealing with anger
- Think about that person’s hidden goal.
- Clarify if person is challenging you to a power struggle.
Personal attacks and Power struggle
- Discussion –> Heated argument –> If neither accepts differences of opinion –> Personal attacks.
- Even if you win the debate, competitor rushes on to the next stage.
- When interpersonal relations reach revenge stage, it is almost impossible for either party to find a solution. One must never allow oneself to a power struggle.
- Idea that your are bearing personal attacks is proof that you are in power struggle. Do not seek action with a reaction. That’s the only thing we can do.
- Anger is to convey our thoughts and intentions. Learning this, anger will disappear on it’s own.
- Irascible poeple don’t have short temper. They have no better communication tool than anger.
- In every instance, however right you are, never try to criticize others based on that. People fall into this trap the most.
- The moment one is convinced “One is right”, one has already entered into power struggle.
- If you think you’re right regardless of what other’s opinion might be, close it then and there. Don’t try to make them submit.
- Admitting mistakes means stepping down from power struggle: not defeat. Superiority should not be pursued through competition with others.
Objectives of human behavior and psychology
- For behavior: a. Be self reliant b. Live in harmony with society
- For psychology that supports these behaviors: a. I have the ability. b. The consciousness that people are my comrades.
How to achieve these? ==> Life tasks
- Classification of life tasks:
- Tasks of work
- No choice but to confront when to live as a social being.
- Work cannot be completed all by oneself.
- Interpersonal relationships of work are lowest bar hurdles because of clear objective of getting good results. So, people work together even if they don’t always get along.
- Persons tripped up in this stage are “NEETs”: young person not in education, training or employment / shut-ins (person confined indoors).
- Tasks of friendship
- Tasks of Love
- Relationships in which people restrict each other eventually fall apart.
- One should not have feeling of inferiority or need of boasting when with the person they love.
- Types:
- Love relationships : Connected by a red string
- Relationships with family (particularly parent-child relation): Connected by rigid chains
- You have a small pair of scissors for both. Even if you have to cut it, you have to face it. Worst you can do is to just stand still with situation as it is.
- People first build the goal of disliking the person and then find flaws to satisfy that goal. People find things irritating that they lived with for so long.
- Tasks of work
Life Lies: Coming up with manner of pretexts to avoid life tasks
- It’s the issue of courage not right or wrong between life tasks and life lies.
- Mind and body are separate but when I fly into rage and shout, its “I as a whole” that’s shouting.
- When people separate “I” from the “shouting emotion”, that becomes a life lie.
- An adult, who has chosen unfree way of life, on seeing young person living freely at the moment, as hedonistic. This is life-lie that comes out when he/she cannot accept his/her unfree life. A free adult will cheer for it.
Reward-Punishment education and Separation of Tasks
- People seek recognition due to this behavior.
- Wishing hard to be recognized will lead to a life of following expectations held by other people who want you to be “this kind of person”.
- Don’t behave without regard for others but there is a concept called “separation of tasks”
- When one is confronted with task of studying, we consider it from perspective “Whose task is this?” For a child, it’s child’s task whether he/she studies or plays out. Parents commanding child to study is intruding another person’s task. People need to separate one’s own tasks from other people’s tasks.
- All interpersonal problems arise by intruding other’s tasks or having own tasks intruded on.
- How to know whose task it is? –> Ask “Who ultimately is going to receive result brought by the choice that is made?”
- It’s true that one often hears parents today using the phrase “It’s for your own good.” But they are clearly doing so in order to fulfill their own goals, which could be their appearance in the eyes of society, their need to put on airs, or their desire for control, for example.
- One has to pay attention. Though it seems like this approach is noninterference, it’s not. Noninterference is attitude of not knowing, not even being interested in knowing what child is doing. Instead, it is by knowing that one protects him/her. If problem is studying, one tells child that it’s his/her task and lets him/her know that one is ready to assist him/her when he/she has the urge to study. One must not intrude child’s task.
- Follow: “You can head a horse to drink but you can’t make it drink.”
- Hypothetical Example: Child locks in, what would you do? Ask whose task it is. It’s the child’s task. I would not intervene into it or focus too much of my attention into it. I would send message that I was ready to assist him whenever child is in need. Now, child has to act upon it. So, child will probably come back and ask for assistance, also trying to work some things on his/her own.
- Closer the family, the more consciously should tasks be separated.
- Act of believing is also a task. How a person acts with regard to your expectations and trust is other people’s task. Intervening in other’s tasks and intervening on other’s tasks will lead to life full of hardships.
- Parents not approving your work is their task not yours.
- People’s judgment over a choice is task of other people and you can do nothing about it.
- Saying I have an awful boss, so I can’t work is etiology. From teleological view: I don’t want to work, so I create an awful boss. I can’t acknowledge my incapable self, so I create an awful boss.
- Separation of tasks is not the objective of interpersonal relationships. It’s the gateway.
- Forming good relationships requires a certain degree of distance. When distance is too small and people get stuck together, it’s impossible to even speak to each other.
- No matter what the other person does for you or sort of appeal the person makes, it’s you who decides what you should do. When reward is the base of interpersonal relationship, there’s a feeling “I gave this much, so you should give that much back.”
- It would be easier to intervene on certain tasks such as a child having hard time trying in tying his/her shoes. For busy mom, it’s easier to take task away and tie it herself. Repeated intervention will result in child not learning and wouldn’t confront challenges later in life.
- Separating one’s tasks is not an egocentric thing. Intervening in other people’s tasks is essentially an egocentric way of thinking, however. Parents force their children to study; they meddle in their life and marriage choices. That is nothing other than an egocentric way of thinking.
- Desire for recognition is a natural desire. We humans are capable of resisting default fallback modes. So, don’t let the stone roll naturally downhill.
- Cost of freedom in interpersonal relationships is being disliked by other people.
- One neither prepares to be self-righteous or defiant. One just separates tasks. One moves forward without fearing possibility of being disliked. This is truly freedom in terms of way of living.
- Not wanting to be disliked is my task but whether so-and-so dislikes me is not my task.
- Philosopher, father issues: I didn’t change in order to change my father. That is notion of manipulating other person. You don’t know what will happen to other person as result and that’s not the aspect you take part in.
- In times, people change tandem with your change but it’s not because of your change. That is not the goal. If the other person doesn’t change, it doesn’t matter then.
Goal of interpersonal relationships: Community Feeling
- Seeing other people as our comrades
- Community is not just household, school, workplace, society or even nations and humanity but entire axis of time from past to the future, all plants, animals and even inanimate objects.
- People who are obsessed with a desire for recognition will seem to be looking at other people while they are actually looking only at themselves.
- “I” is the protagonist in one’s life. But “I” doesn’t rule the center of the world. “I” is never more than a member of community and part of a whole.
- People obsessed with themselves, for them others means only those “who will do something” for them.
- In Alderian psychology, sense of belonging is something that can be attained by making active commitment to community of one’s own accord, not by being here.
- Rather than what will the person give me ? What can I give to this person? This is commitment to the community.
- It’s natural that when we search for a sense of belonging, we will be attracted to the smaller community.
- We search for sense of belonging here and there. Rather than not finding your sense of belonging and shrinking to smaller fo of community such as from school to shutting yourself to home, you can find you belong elsewhere if you see whole world is for you to belong.
- When you run into difficulties with interpersonal relations and no longer see a way out, “Listen to the voice of the larger community.”
- Living in fear of one’s relationships falling apart is an unfree way to live, in which one is living for other people.
Horizontal Relationships
- A relation of equals. You don’t seem to be above or below someone else.
- A parent also must not make a child feel that he/she is in a vertical relationship.
- In child rearing, one must not praise. Physical punishment, rebuking is out of the course obviously. By praising “passing of judgment by a person of ability to a person of no ability”, it’s taking place. e.g. Mother says to a child helping her “You are a good helper.” but not to her husband. This is unconsciously creating hierarchical relationships and seeing child as beneath her.
- Whether we praise or rebuke, background goal is manipulation. Reward-punishment education’s intention is to manipulate children.
- All relationships should be horizontal as per Alderian psychology.
- If one can build horizontal relationships “equal but not the same” for all people, there is no room for inferiority complexes to emerge.
- People intervene because of vertical relationships.
- Assistance and intervention are two different things. Assistance presupposes separation of tasks and horizontal relationships.
- If one is not following through one’s own tasks, it’s not because of ability but because of lack of courage to face one’s tasks. So, all we do is give them courage to work on their task.
- The more one is praised by another person, the more one forms the belief that one has no ability.
- The most important thing is to not judge other people. “Judgment” is a word that comes out of vertical relationships. If one is building horizontal relationships, there will be words of more straightforward gratitude and respect and joy.
- The goal is to be able to say “I can make contributions to other people”.
- Context matters the most. If your life were in danger, and you were hanging on by a thread, the people around you would probably feel very gladdened just by the very fact of your existing. They would simply feel thankful that you are safe in the here and now, and would not be wanting you to perform some direct act.
- People have ideal disposition and subtract scores from that ideal to judge a person. Instead of taking points away from ideal image, people could start from zero. Then, the mere existence is grateful.
- If you are building even one vertical relationship with someone, you will be treating all your interpersonal relationships as vertical.
- Even if you are not treating them in a boss-or-subordinate kind of way, it is as if you are saying, “A is above me, and B is below me,” for example, or “I’ll follow A’s advice, but ignore what B says,” or “I don’t mind breaking my promise to C.” This is what happens.
- People have a space to refuse and a space to propose better way of doing things. We feel there is no space for all of it so that we can avoid conflict and responsibility.
- There is no need to go out of one’s way to be positive and affirm oneself. It’s not self-affirmation that we are concerned with, but self-acceptance.
- Switch from attachment to self –> concern for others requires three things:
- Self-acceptance
- Self-affirmation is making suggestions to oneself when something is beyond one’s ability. It can bring superiority complex. Self-acceptance is accepting a person’s incapable self and moving forward to do best that can be done.
- Confidence in others
- Trust vs Confidence: Trust comes with set conditions. We refer to it as credit. Bank borrows you money based on trust that you can pay back this much of money. Confidence is doing without any set conditions whatsoever when believing in others. Even if someone doesn’t have objective grounds for trust, one believes.
- In Alderian psychology, basis of interpersonal relationships is founded not on trust but on confidence.
- In times, people who believe unconditionally gets taken advantage of. The attitude of continuing to believe in someone even in such instances is what we call confidence.
- Believing unconditionally doesn’t have moral significance here. It’s to make interpersonal relationship with the person better and build a horizontal relationship.
- Don’t just focus on the wounds that people give by believing in them. In long run, you will have many deep relationships if you try this.
- Courage to overcome fear of being taken advantage of comes from self-acceptance. If you see as taking advantage is other person’s task, getting to core of confidence in others becomes less difficult.
- Placing confidence in others is connected to seeing other people as comrades.
- Contribution to others
- Contribution to others doesn’t mean self-sacrifice. People who sacrifice too much are conformed to society too much.
- e.g. If you do all the household work in a family, you normally ask yourself these questions: Why don’t they give me a hand? Why do I have to do all the work? I should have at least received a Thank You from them. If I hum like this, I am probably not much fun to be around. If I am enjoying it, someone might come and give a hand.
- You need to be creating an atmosphere in which its easier to offer help.
- Self-acceptance
- These three go in circle. You accept yourself thereby can have confidence in others. You have confidence, you see others as comrades. Now, you can engage in contributing to others. This gives feeling of “I am of use to someone” and it helps accept oneself as one is. And the circle repeats.
- Stammering, feeling of inferiority, become too self conscious as a result, tipping words more and more.
- People are aware of their worth only when they feel “I am of use to someone”. One just needs a subjective sense of it. Happiness is a feeling of contribution.
- Pursuit of easy superiority: Child who engages in problem behavior are trying to attract attention of other people even as they continue to avoid any such healthy effort. “Revenge” and “pursuit of easy superiority” are easily linked. One makes trouble for another person while trying at the same time to be “special.”
- People can’t accept normal self. People want to feel special. The old way doesn’t work and they make huge leap of being especially bad - the opposite.
- Being normal is not being incapable. One doesn’t need to flaunt superiority.
- Life is a series of dots. It’s a series of moments what you felt like a continuous line. A series of moments called ’now’. Our lives only exist in the moments. If life were a line, life planning would be possible. Since it’s a series of dots, it’s impossible to plan next.
- The life that lies ahead of you is a completely blank page, and there are no tracks that have been laid for you to follow. There’s no story there.
- The greatest life lie of all is not to live here and now. Believing that you know how the line goes is the biggest lie.
- So life in general has no meaning whatsoever. But you can assign meaning to that life. And you are the only one who can assign meaning to your life.
- You are lost in your life. Why are you lost? You are lost because you are trying to choose freedom, that is to say, a path on which you are not afraid of being disliked by others and you are not living others’ lives—a path that is yours alone.
- In Alderian psychology, the guiding star to happiness is “Contribution to others”
- One more time, I give you the words of Adler: “Someone has to start. Other people might not be cooperative, but that is not connected to you. My advice is this: You should start. With no regard to whether others are cooperative or not.”
Kindle highlights (2020)
-
loc 143 - That is not because the world is complicated. It’s because you are making the world complicated. YOUTH: I am? PHILOSOPHER: None of us live in an objective world, but instead in a subjective world that we ourselves have given meaning to. The world you see is different from the one I see, and it’s impossible to share your world with anyone else
-
loc 274 - So if the here and now of everyone in the world is due to their past incidents, according to you, wouldn’t things turn out very strangely? Don’t you see? Everyone who has grown up abused by his or her parents would have to suffer the same effects as your friend and become a recluse, or the whole idea just doesn’t hold water.
-
loc 280 - So you’re saying that the past doesn’t matter? PHILOSOPHER: Yes, that is the standpoint of Adlerian psychology.
-
loc 286 - So in Adlerian psychology, we do not think about past “causes” but rather about present “goals
-
loc 290 - Think about it this way. Your friend had the goal of not going out beforehand, and he’s been manufacturing a state of anxiety and fear as a means to achieve that goal. In Adlerian psychology, this is called “teleology.”
-
loc 297 - This is the difference between etiology (the study of causation) and teleology (the study of the purpose of a given phenomenon, rather than its cause). Everything you have been telling me is based in etiology. As long as we stay in etiology, we will not take a single step forward
-
loc 320 - “No experience is in itself a cause of our success or failure. We do not suffer from the shock of our experiences—the so-called trauma—but instead we make out of them whatever suits our purposes. We are not determined by our experiences, but the meaning we give them is self-determining
-
loc 335 - The immediate thing would probably be the goal of “not going out.” He is creating anxiety and fear as his reasons to stay inside.
-
loc 348 - doubt he’s satisfied, and I’m sure he’s not happy either. But there is no doubt that he is also taking action in line with his goal. This is not something that is unique to your friend. Every one of us is living in line with some goal. That is what teleology tells us.
-
loc 375 - That’s easy. You did not fly into a rage and then start shouting. It is solely that you got angry so that you could shout.
-
loc 382 - No. You could have explained matters without raising your voice, and the waiter would most likely have given you a sincere apology, wiped your jacket with a clean cloth, and taken other appropriate measures. He might have even arranged for it to be dry-cleaned. And somewhere in your mind, you were anticipating that he might do these things but, even so, you shouted. The procedure of explaining things in normal words felt like too much trouble, and you tried to get out of that and make this unresisting person submit to you. The tool you used to do this was the emotion of anger.
-
loc 394 - PHILOSOPHER: Don’t you see? In a word, anger is a tool that can be taken out as needed. It can be put away the moment the phone rings, and pulled out again after one hangs up. The mother isn’t yelling in anger she cannot control. She is simply using the anger to overpower her daughter with a loud voice and thereby assert her opinions.
-
loc 410 - PHILOSOPHER: I am not denying that emotion exists. Everyone has emotions. That goes without saying. But if you are going to tell me that people are beings who can’t resist emotion, I’d argue against that.
-
loc 423 - PHILOSOPHER: Life isn’t just hard. If the past determined everything and couldn’t be changed, we who are living today would no longer be able to take effective steps forward in our lives. What would happen as a result? We would end up with the kind of nihilism and pessimism that loses hope in the world and gives up on life.
-
loc 453 - You should arrive at answers on your own, not rely upon what you get from someone else. Answers from others are nothing more than stopgap measures; they’re of no value.
-
loc 551 - Earlier you said that any person’s disposition or personality cannot be changed. In Adlerian psychology, we describe personality and disposition with the word “lifestyle.”
-
loc 555 - Think of lifestyle as a concept bringing together these ways of finding meaning. In a narrow sense, lifestyle could be defined as someone’s personality; taken more broadly, it is a word that encompasses the worldview of that person and his or her outlook on life.
-
loc 559 - Say there’s someone who worries about himself and says, “I am a pessimist.” One could rephrase that to instead say, “I have a pessimistic view of the world.” You could consider that the issue is not personality but rather the view of the world. It seems that the word “personality” is nuanced and suggests being unchangeable. But if we’re talking about a view of the world, well, then, that should be possible to alter.
-
loc 577 - Adlerian psychology’s view is that it happens around the age of ten.
-
loc 587 - The issue is not the past, but here, in the present. And now you’ve learned about lifestyle. But what you do with it from here on is your responsibility.
-
loc 599 - Although there are some small inconveniences and limitations, you probably think that the lifestyle you have now is the most practical one, and that it’s easier to leave things as they are.
-
loc 604 - Simply put, people have various complaints about things, but it’s easier and more secure to be just the way one is.
-
loc 607 - When we try to change our lifestyles, we put our great courage to the test. There is the anxiety generated by changing, and the disappointment attendant to not changing. I am sure you have selected the latter.
-
loc 634 - I have a young friend who dreams of becoming a novelist, but he never seems to be able to complete his work. According to him, his job keeps him too busy, and he can never find enough time to write novels, and that’s why he can’t complete work and enter it for writing awards. But is that the real reason? No! It’s actually that he wants to leave the possibility of “I can do it if I try”
-
loc 736 - Okay, so she fabricated that fear of blushing as an excuse for her own inability to confess her feelings. Or maybe as a kind of insurance for when he rejected her.
-
loc 741 - Well, this is what I told her: “Fear of blushing is easy to cure.” She asked, “Really?” I went on: “But I will not cure it.” She pressed me “Why?” I explained, “Look, it’s thanks to your fear of blushing that you can accept your dissatisfaction with yourself and the world around you, and with a life that isn’t going well. It’s thanks to your fear of blushing, and it’s caused by it.” She asked, “How could it be . . . ?” I went on: “If I did cure it, and nothing in your situation changed at all, what would you do? You’d probably come here again and say, ‘Give me back my fear of blushing.’ And that would be beyond my abilities.”
-
loc 761 - Apparently, she had the chance to join a group of friends and spend time with the man, and in the end it was he who confessed his desire to be with her. Of course, she never dropped by this study again after that. I don’t know what became of her fear of blushing. But she probably didn’t need it any longer
-
loc 771 - Just like the young woman with the fear of blushing, who was afraid of being rejected by the man, you are afraid of being negated by other people. You’re afraid of being treated disparagingly, being refused, and sustaining deep mental wounds.
-
loc 784 - Admitting is a good attitude. But don’t forget, it’s basically impossible to not get hurt in your relations with other people. When you enter into interpersonal relationships, it is inevitable that to a greater or lesser extent you will get hurt, and you will hurt someone, too. Adler says, “To get rid of one’s problems, all one can do is live in the universe all alone.” But one can’t do such a thing
-
loc 787 - My Note: A beautful line indeed
-
loc 817 - There is no such thing as worry that is completely defined by the individual; so-called internal worry does not exist. Whatever the worry that may arise, the shadows of other people are always present
-
loc 825 - You were so afraid of interpersonal relationships that you came to dislike yourself. You’ve avoided interpersonal relationships by disliking yourself.
-
loc 847 - Minderwertigkeitsgefühl, which means a feeling (Gefühl) of having less (minder) worth (Wert).
-
loc 862 - With a man who’s big and strong, it’s true, it does seem he can end up intimidating people just because of his size
-
loc 873 - Because if there hadn’t been anyone with whom to compare myself, I wouldn’t have had any occasion to think I was short.
-
loc 879 - You could even say it’s an arbitrary assumption. However,
-
loc 879 - However, there is one good thing about subjectivity: It allows you to make your own choice. Precisely because I am leaving it to subjectivity, the choice to view my height as either an advantage or disadvantage is left open to me.
-
loc 891 - In other words, value is something that’s based on a social context. The value given to a one-dollar bill is not an objectively attributed value, though that might be a commonsense approach.
-
loc 910 - It’s probably necessary to understand this in a certain order. First of all, people enter this world as helpless beings. And people have the universal desire to escape from that helpless state. Adler called this the “pursuit of superiority.”
-
loc 917 - The counterpart of this is the feeling of inferiority. Everyone is in this “condition of wanting to improve” that is the pursuit of superiority.
-
loc 923 - Adler is saying that the pursuit of superiority and the feeling of inferiority are not diseases but stimulants to normal, healthy striving and growth. If it is not used in the wrong way, the feeling of inferiority, too, can promote striving and growth
-
loc 926 - That’s right. One tries to get rid of one’s feeling of inferiority and keep moving forward. One’s never satisfied with one’s present situation—even if it’s just a single step, one wants to make progress. One wants to be happier. There is absolutely nothing wrong with the state of this kind of feeling of inferiority.
-
loc 938 - At base, “complex” refers to an abnormal mental state made up of a complicated group of emotions and ideas, and has nothing to do with the feeling of inferiority.
-
loc 946 - For instance, if one had a feeling of inferiority with regard to one’s education, and resolved to oneself, I’m not well educated, so I’ll just have to try harder than anyone else, that would be a desirable direction. The inferiority complex, on the other hand, refers to a condition of having begun to use one’s feeling of inferiority as a kind of excuse
-
loc 957 - That is to say, you convince yourself that there is some serious causal relationship where there is none whatsoever. The other day, someone told me, “The reason I can’t get married easily is that my parents got divorced when I was a child.” From the viewpoint of Freudian etiology (the attributing of causes), the parents’ divorce was a great trauma, which connects in a clear causal relationship with one’s views on marriage. Adler, however, with his stance of teleology (the attributing of purpose), rejects such arguments as “apparent cause and effect.”
-
loc 967 - It’s simply that it’s scary to take even one step forward; also, that you don’t want to make realistic efforts. You don’t want to change so much that you’d be willing to sacrifice the pleasures you enjoy now—for instance, the time you spend playing and engaged in hobbies. In other words, you’re not equipped with the courage to change your lifestyle. It’s easier with things just as they are now, even if you have some complaints or limitations.
-
loc 987 - How do you fill in the part that’s missing, right? PHILOSOPHER: Exactly. How to compensate for the part that is lacking. The healthiest way is to try to compensate through striving and growth. For instance, it could be by applying oneself to one’s studies, engaging in constant training, or being diligent in one’s work. However, people who aren’t equipped with that courage end up stepping into an inferiority complex
-
loc 998 - Superiority complex? PHILOSOPHER: One is suffering from strong feelings of inferiority, and, on top of that, one doesn’t have the courage to compensate through healthy modes of striving and growth. That being said, one can’t tolerate the inferiority complex of thinking, A is the situation, so B cannot be done. One can’t accept “one’s incapable self.” At that point, the person thinks of trying to compensate in some other fashion and looks for an easier way out
-
loc 999 - One is suffering from strong feelings of inferiority, and, on top of that, one doesn’t have the courage to compensate through healthy modes of striving and growth. That being said,
-
loc 1009 - Behaviors like misrepresenting one’s work experience or excessive allegiance to particular brands of clothing are forms of giving authority, and probably also have aspects of the superiority complex
-
loc 1012 - And at the base of that, there is an intense feeling of inferiority?
-
loc 1017 - But those who make themselves look bigger on borrowed power are essentially living according to other people’s value systems—they are living other people’s lives. This is a point that must be emphasized.
-
loc 1024 - Ah, but you are wrong. Those who go so far as to boast about things out loud actually have no confidence in themselves. As Adler clearly indicates, “The one who boasts does so only out of a feeling of inferiority.”
-
loc 1028 - It’s because one’s feeling of inferiority is strong that one boasts. One feels the need to flaunt one’s superiority all the more.
-
loc 1029 - There’s the fear that if one doesn’t do that, not a single person will accept one “the way I am.” This is a full-blown superiority complex.
-
loc 1036 - The person who assumes a boasting manner when talking about his upbringing and the like, the various misfortunes that have rained down upon him. If someone should try to comfort this person, or suggest some change be made, he’ll refuse the helping hand by saying, “You don’t understand how I feel.”
-
loc 1041 - Let’s say that kind-hearted people come up to me and say, “It’s nothing to worry about,” or “Such things have nothing to do with human values.” Now, if I were to reject them and say, “You think you know what short people go through, huh?” no one would say a thing to me anymore
-
loc 1049 - They use their misfortune to their advantage and try to control the other party with it. By declaring how unfortunate they are and how much they have suffered, they are trying to worry the people around them (their family and friends, for example), and to restrict their speech and behavior, and control them.
-
loc 1054 - Adler says, “In fact, if we were to ask ourselves who is the strongest person in our culture, the logical answer would be, the baby. The baby rules and cannot be dominated.” The baby rules over the adults with his weakness. And it is because of this weakness that no one can control him.
-
loc 1080 - The pursuit of superiority is the mind-set of taking a single step forward on one’s own feet, not the mind-set of competition of the sort that necessitates aiming to be greater than other people
-
loc 1086 - A healthy feeling of inferiority is not something that comes from comparing oneself to others; it comes from one’s comparison with one’s ideal self.
-
loc 1108 - Have you become free from all forms of competition? PHILOSOPHER: Of course. I do not think about gaining status or honor, and I live my life as an outsider philosopher without any connection whatsoever to worldly competition.
-
loc 1109 - Of course. I do not think about gaining status or
-
loc 1116 - If that rival was someone you could call a comrade, it’s possible that it would lead to self-improvement. But in many cases, a competitor will not be your comrade.
-
loc 1127 - If there is competition at the core of a person’s interpersonal relationships, he will not be able to escape interpersonal relationship problems or escape misfortune.
-
loc 1136 - When one is conscious of competition and victory and defeat, it is inevitable that feelings of inferiority will arise. Because one is constantly comparing oneself to others and thinking, I beat that person or I lost to that person. The inferiority complex and the superiority complex are extensions of that. Now, what kind of being do you think the other person is to you, at that point?
-
loc 1206 - All right, so let’s talk about “now.” Last time, you said that people fabricate the emotion of anger, right? And that that is the standpoint of teleology. I still cannot accept that statement. For example, how would you explain instances of anger toward society, or anger toward government? Would you say that these, too, are emotions fabricated in order to push one’s opinions?
-
loc 1211 - There is a difference between personal anger (personal grudge) and indignation with regard to society’s contradictions and injustices (righteous indignation).
-
loc 1211 - There is a difference between personal anger (personal grudge) and indignation with regard to society’s contradictions and injustices (righteous indignation). Personal anger soon cools. Righteous indignation, on the other hand, lasts for a long time.
-
loc 1219 - If someone were to abuse me to my face, I would think about the person’s hidden goal. Even if you are not directly abusive, when you feel genuinely angry due to another person’s words or behavior, please consider that the person is challenging you to a power struggle.
-
loc 1228 - Let’s say you and a friend have been discussing the current political situation. Before long, it turns into a heated argument, and neither of you is willing to accept any differences of opinion until finally it reaches the point where he starts engaging in personal attacks—that you’re stupid, and it’s because of people like you that this country doesn’t change, that sort of thing.
-
loc 1238 - Now let’s say you take control of the quarrel. And then the other man, who was seeking to defeat you, withdraws in a sportsmanlike manner. The thing is, the power struggle doesn’t end there. Having lost the dispute, he rushes on to the next stage.
-
loc 1251 - engages in problem behavior in order to upset his parents?
-
loc 1256 - Yes. And once the interpersonal relationship reaches the revenge stage, it is almost impossible for either party to find a solution. To prevent this from happening, when one is challenged to a power struggle, one must never allow oneself to be taken in.
-
loc 1263 - All right, then what should you do when you’re subjected to personal attacks right to your face? Do you just grin and bear it? PHILOSOPHER: No, the idea that you are “bearing it” is proof that you are still stuck in the power struggle.
-
loc 1265 - When you are challenged to a fight, and you sense that it is a power struggle, step down from the conflict as soon as possible. Do not answer his action with a reaction. That is the only thing we can do.
-
loc 1272 - We can convey our thoughts and intentions and be accepted without any need for anger. If you learn to understand this experientially, the anger emotion will stop appearing all on its own
-
loc 1276 - Irascible people do not have short tempers—it is only that they do not know that there are effective communication tools other than anger. That is why people end up saying things like “I just snapped” or, “He flew into a rage.” We end up relying on anger to communicate.
-
loc 1282 - In every instance, no matter how much you might think you are right, try not to criticize the other party on that basis. This is an interpersonal relationship trap that many people fall into.
-
loc 1285 - The moment one is convinced that “I am right” in an interpersonal relationship, one has already stepped into a power struggle.
-
loc 1293 - If you think you are right, regardless of what other people’s opinions might be, the matter should be closed then and there. However, many people will rush into a power struggle and try to make others submit to them. And that is why they think of “admitting a mistake” as “admitting defeat
-
loc 1297 - Admitting mistakes, conveying words of apology, and stepping down from power struggles—none of these things is defeat. The pursuit of superiority is not something that is carried out through competition with other people.
-
loc 1315 - So why do you see other people as enemies, and why can’t you think of them as your comrades? It is because you have lost your courage and you are running away from your “life tasks.”
-
loc 1318 - In Adlerian psychology, clear objectives are laid out for human behavior and psychology. YOUTH: What sort of objectives? PHILOSOPHER: First, there are two objectives for behavior: to be self-reliant and to live in harmony with society. Then, the two objectives for the psychology that supports these behaviors are the consciousness that I have the ability and the consciousness that people are my comrades.
-
loc 1327 - And these objectives can be achieved by facing what Adler calls “life tasks.”
-
loc 1335 - Adler made three categories of the interpersonal relationships that arise out of these processes. He referred to them as “tasks of work,” “tasks of friendship,” and “tasks of love,” and all together as “life tasks.”
-
loc 1341 - The interpersonal relationships that a single individual has no choice but to confront when attempting to live as a social being—these are the life tasks
-
loc 1344 - First, let’s look at the tasks of work. Regardless of the kind of work, there is no work that can be completed all by oneself.
-
loc 1350 - However, considered from the viewpoint of distance and depth, interpersonal relationships of work may be said to have the lowest hurdles. Interpersonal relationships of work have the easy-to-understand common objective of obtaining good results, so people can cooperate even if they don’t always get along, and to some extent they have no choice but to cooperate.
-
loc 1355 - And the ones who get tripped up in the interpersonal relationships at this stage are the people referred to as “NEETs” (a young person not in education, employment, or training) or “shut-ins” (a person confined indoors).
-
loc 1357 - Are you saying that they don’t try to work simply because they want to avoid the interpersonal relationships that are associated with work, not that they don’t want to work or that they’re refusing to do manual labor
-
loc 1390 - Adlerian psychology is a psychology for changing oneself, not a psychology for changing others. Instead of waiting for others to change or waiting for the situation to change, you take the first step forward yourself.
-
loc 1398 - What about the last one, the task of love? PHILOSOPHER: Think of it as divided into two stages: one, what are known as love relationships; and two, relationships with family, in particular parent-child relationships.
-
loc 1400 - When a friend relationship has turned into love, speech and conduct that were permitted between friends may no longer be permitted the moment they become lovers
-
loc 1405 - But Adler does not accept restricting one’s partner. If the person seems to be happy, one can frankly celebrate that condition. That is love. Relationships in which people restrict each other eventually fall apart.
-
loc 1411 - Whenever I am with this person, I can behave very freely, one can really feel love. One can be in a calm and quite natural state, without having feelings of inferiority or being beset with the need to flaunt one’s superiority.
-
loc 1412 - Restriction, on the other hand, is a manifestation of the mind-set of attempting to control one’s partner, and also an idea founded on a sense of distrust. Being in the same space with someone who distrusts you isn’t a natural situation that one can put up with, is it? As Adler says, “If two people want to live together on good terms, they must treat each other as equal personalities.”
-
loc 1418 - If romantic love is a relationship connected by red string, then the relationship between parents and children is bound in rigid chains.
-
loc 1418 - If romantic love is a relationship connected by red string, then the relationship between parents and children is bound in rigid chains. And a pair of small scissors is all you have. This is the difficulty of the parent-child relationship.
-
loc 1421 - What I can say at this stage is: You must not run away. No matter how distressful the relationship, you must not avoid or put off dealing with it. Even if in the end you’re going to cut it with scissors, first you have to face it. The worst thing to do is to just stand still with the situation as it is.
-
loc 1438 - But it isn’t that you dislike Mr. A because you can’t forgive his flaws. You had the goal of taking a dislike to Mr. A beforehand and then started looking for the flaws to satisfy that goal.
-
loc 1446 - For instance, she doesn’t care for the way he eats; his slovenly appearance at home fills her with revulsion, and even his snoring sets her off. Even though until a few months ago, none of it had ever bothered her before.
-
loc 1449 - The person feels this way because at some stage she has resolved to herself, I want to end this relationship, and she has been looking around for the material with which to end it.
-
loc 1454 - So I am making up flaws in other people just so that I can avoid my life tasks, and further more, so I can avoid interpersonal relationships? And I am running away by thinking of other people as my enemies? PHILOSOPHER: That’s right. Adler called the state of coming up with all manner of pretexts in order to avoid the life tasks the “life-lie.”
-
loc 1471 - You must not use the power of anger to look away. This is a very important point. Adler never discusses the life tasks or life-lies in terms of good and evil. It is not morals or good and evil that we should be discussing, but the issue of courage
-
loc 1483 - will add to that by saying that Adlerian psychology is not a “psychology of possession” but a “psychology of use.”
-
loc 1494 - Maybe what you are saying is right. Actually, I’m sure it is, and courage really is what I am lacking. I can accept the life-lie as well. I am scared of interacting with people. I don’t want to get hurt in interpersonal relationships, and I want to put off my life tasks. That’s why I have all these excuses ready. Yes, it’s exactly as you say. But isn’t what you are talking about a kind of spiritualism? All you’re really saying is, “You’ve lost your courage, you’ve got to pluck up your courage.” It’s no different from the silly instructor who thinks he’s giving you advice when he comes up and slaps you on the shoulder and says, “Cheer up.” Even though the reason I’m not doing well is because I can’t just cheer up!
-
loc 1545 - Well, say for the moment that you have obtained financial freedom. And then, though you have gained great wealth, you have not found happiness. At that time, what problems and privations would remain for you?
-
loc 1550 - Having to be attached to a person you don’t even care for, for example, or to always watch out for your awful boss’s mood swings. Imagine, if you could be released from such petty interpersonal relationships, how easy things would be! But no one can really do such a thing.
-
loc 1584 - Adlerian psychology denies the need to seek recognition from others.
-
loc 1594 - Being recognized by others is certainly something to be happy about. But it would be wrong to say that being recognized is absolutely necessary. For what does one seek recognition in the first place? Or, to put it more succinctly, why does one want to be praised by others? YOUTH: It’s simple. It’s through being
-
loc 1594 - Being recognized by others is certainly something to be happy about. But it would be wrong to say that being recognized is absolutely necessary. For what does one seek recognition in the first place? Or, to put it more succinctly, why does one want to be praised by others?
-
loc 1607 - This is the danger of the desire for recognition. Why is it that people seek recognition from others? In many cases, it is due to the influence of reward-and-punishment education.
-
loc 1630 - Wishing so hard to be recognized will lead to a life of following expectations held by other people who want you to be “this kind of person.”
-
loc 1632 - If you are not living to satisfy other people’s expectations, it follows that other people are not living to satisfy your expectations. Someone might not act the way you want him to, but it doesn’t do to get angry. That’s only natural.
-
loc 1635 - But in order to receive recognition from others, first we have to recognize others ourselves. It is because one recognizes other people and other systems of values that one is recognized by others.
-
loc 1643 - Indeed, it is in order to overcome the nihilism of a godless world that it is necessary to deny recognition from other people.
-
loc 1651 - When trying to be recognized by others, almost all people treat satisfying other people’s expectations as the means to that end. And that is in accordance with the stream of thought of reward-and-punishment education that says one will be praised if one takes appropriate action
-
loc 1658 - Do not behave without regard for others. To understand this, it is necessary to understand the idea in Adlerian psychology known as “separation of tasks
-
loc 1678 - When one is confronted with the task of studying, for instance, in Adlerian psychology we consider it from the perspective of “Whose task is this?”
-
loc 1681 - Whether the child studies or not. Whether he goes out and plays with his friends or not. Essentially this is the child’s task, not the parent’s task.
-
loc 1686 - Studying is the child’s task. A parent’s handling of that by commanding the child to study is, in effect, an act of intruding on another person’s task. One is unlikely to avert a collision in this way. We need to think with the perspective of “Whose task is this?” and continually separate one’s own tasks from other people’s tasks.
-
loc 1691 - In general, all interpersonal relationship troubles are caused by intruding on other people’s tasks, or having one’s own tasks intruded on. Carrying out the separation of tasks is enough to change one’s interpersonal relationships dramatically.
-
loc 1693 - My Note: If this is the case, mybe it will solve most of my problems for now.
-
loc 1696 - There is a simple way to tell whose task it is. Think, Who ultimately is going to receive the result brought about by the choice that is made?
-
loc 1703 - It’s true that one often hears parents today using the phrase “It’s for your own good.” But they are clearly doing so in order to fulfill their own goals, which could be their appearance in the eyes of society, their need to put on airs, or their desire for control, for example.
-
loc 1703 - It’s true that one often hears parents today using the phrase “It’s for your own good.” But they are clearly doing so in order to fulfill their own goals, which could be their appearance in the eyes of society, their need to put on airs, or their desire for control, for example. In other words, it is not “for your own good” but for the parents’. And it is because the child senses this deception that he rebels.
-
loc 1708 - One has to pay attention. Adlerian psychology does not recommend the noninterference approach. Noninterference is the attitude of not knowing, and not even being interested in knowing what the child is doing. Instead, it is by knowing what the child is doing that one protects him. If it’s studying that is the issue, one tells the child that that is his task, and one lets him know that one is ready to assist him whenever he has the urge to study. But one must not intrude on the child’s task. When no requests are being made, it does not do to meddle in things
-
loc 1719 - Naturally, one gives all the assistance one possibly can. But beyond that, one doesn’t intrude. Remember the old saying, “You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him drink.” Please think of counseling and all other assistance provided to other people in Adlerian psychology as having that kind of stance. Forcing change while ignoring the person’s intentions will only lead to an intense reaction.
-
loc 1734 - suppose your own child had shut himself in, what would you do? Please answer this not as a philosopher but as a parent. PHILOSOPHER: First, I myself would think, This is the child’s task. I would try not to intervene in his shut-in situation, and I would refrain from focusing too much attention on it. Then I would send a message to him to the effect that I am ready to assist him whenever he is in need. In that way, the child, having sensed a change in his parent, will have no choice but to make it his own task to think about what he should do. He’ll probably come and ask for assistance, and he’ll probably try to work some things out on his own
-
loc 1750 - Actually, with families there is less distance, so it’s all the more necessary to consciously separate the tasks.
-
loc 1754 - Look, the act of believing is also the separation of tasks. You believe in your partner; that is your task
-
loc 1754 - Look, the act of believing is also the separation of tasks. You believe in your partner; that is your task. But how that person acts with regard to your expectations and trust is other people’s tasks. When you push your wishes without having drawn that line, before you know it you’re engaging in stalker-like intervention. Suppose your partner did not act as you had wished. Would you still be able to believe in that person? Would you still be able to love that person?
-
loc 1759 - think about it this way: Intervening in other people’s tasks and taking on other people’s tasks turns one’s life into something heavy and full of hardship. If you are leading a life of worry and suffering—which stems from interpersonal relationships—learn the boundary of “From here on, that is not my task.” And discard other people’s tasks. That is the first step toward lightening the load and making life simpler. How to Rid Yourself of Interpersonal Relationship Problems YOUTH: I don’t know, it just doesn’t sit right with me.
-
loc 1759 - Intervening in other people’s tasks and taking on other people’s tasks turns one’s life into something heavy and full of hardship. If you are leading a life of worry and suffering—which stems from interpersonal relationships—learn the boundary of “From here on, that is not my task.” And discard other people’s tasks. That is the first step toward lightening the load and making life simpler.
-
loc 1773 - But how to come to terms with the emotion of “not approving” is your parents’ task, not yours. It is not a problem for you to worry about.
-
loc 1779 - On the other hand, what kind of judgment do other people pass on that choice? That is the task of other people, and is not a matter you can do anything about.
-
loc 1784 - Adlerian psychology has an easy answer. You haven’t done the separation of tasks yet. You assume that even things that should be other people’s tasks are your own. Remember the words of the grandmother: “You’re the only one who’s worried how you look.” Her remark drives right to the heart of the separation of tasks. What other people think when they see your face—that is the task of other people and is not something you have any control over.
-
loc 1798 - I can’t do my work because I’ve been shunned by my boss. It’s the boss’s fault that my work isn’t going well. The person who says such things is bringing up the existence of the boss as an excuse for the work that doesn’t go well. Much
-
loc 1802 - This is a discussion that is concerned with the fundamentals of Adlerian psychology. If you are angry, nothing will sink in. You think, I’ve got that boss, so I can’t work. This is complete etiology. But it’s really, I don’t want to work, so I’ll create an awful boss, or I don’t want to acknowledge my incapable self, so I’ll create an awful boss. That would be the teleological way of looking at it.
-
loc 1814 - Now, last time, you were saying that you wanted some specific steps. This is what I propose. First, one should ask, “Whose task is this?” Then do the separation of tasks. Calmly delineate up to what point one’s own tasks go, and from what point they become another person’s tasks. And do not intervene in other people’s tasks, or allow even a single person to intervene in one’s own tasks. This is a specific and revolutionary viewpoint that is unique to Adlerian psychology and contains the potential to utterly change one’s interpersonal relationship problems.
-
loc 1844 - “Destiny is not something brought about by legend, but by clearing away with one’s own sword.” He had no use for the power of legend and would forge his destiny with his sword. As you know, he then proceeded to become the great conqueror of all the territories of what is now the Middle East and western Asia. This is the famous anecdote known as the Gordian knot
-
loc 1854 - One can build them. The separation of tasks is not the objective for interpersonal relationships. Rather, it is the gateway.
-
loc 1857 - In the same way, forming good interpersonal relationships requires a certain degree of distance. When the distance gets too small and people become stuck together, it becomes impossible to even speak to each other. But the distance must not be too great, either.
-
loc 1863 - Earlier you said that the separation of tasks is something that treads on the other person’s goodwill. That is a notion that is tied to reward. It’s the idea that when another person does something for you, you have to do something in return—even if that person does not want anything. Rather than responding to the goodwill, it is just being tied to reward. No matter what sort of appeal the other person might make, you are the only one who decides what you should do.
-
loc 1868 - Yes. When reward is at the base of an interpersonal relationship, there’s a feeling that wells up in one that says, “I gave this much, so you should give me that much back.”
-
loc 1871 - However, there are certainly situations in which it would be easier to intervene in the tasks of another person without doing any separation of tasks—for instance, in a child-raising situation, when a child is having a hard time tying his shoes. For the busy mother, it is certainly faster to tie them than to wait for him to do it himself. But that is an intervention, and it is taking the child’s task away from him. And as a result of repeating that intervention, the child will cease to learn anything, and will lose the courage to face his life tasks. As Adler says, “Children who have not been taught to confront challenges will try to avoid all challenges.”
-
loc 1904 - YOUTH: Sure, maybe I do! It’s like this: It’s not so difficult to judge what others expect of one, or what kind of role is being demanded of one. Living as one likes, on the other hand, is extremely difficult. What does one want? What does one want to become, and what kind of life does one want to lead? One doesn’t always get such a concrete idea of things. It would be a grave mistake to think that everyone has clear-cut dreams and objectives. Don’t you know that?
-
loc 1911 - YOUTH: That is why I am looking for recognition from others. You were talking about God earlier, and if we were still living in an era when God was something people believed in, I suppose that “God is watching” might serve as a criterion for self-discipline. If one were recognized by God, maybe one didn’t need recognition from others. But that era ended a long time ago. And, in that case, one has no choice but to discipline oneself on the basis that other people are watching. To aspire to be recognized by others and live an honest life. Other people’s eyes are my guide.
-
loc 1932 - Separating one’s tasks is not an egocentric thing. Intervening in other people’s tasks is essentially an egocentric way of thinking, however. Parents force their children to study; they meddle in their life and marriage choices. That is nothing other than an egocentric way of thinking.
-
loc 1938 - An adult, who has chosen an unfree way to live, on seeing a young person living freely here and now in this moment, criticizes the youth as being hedonistic. Of course, this is a life-lie that comes out so that the adult can accept his own unfree life. An adult who has chosen real freedom himself will not make such comments and will instead cheer on the will to be free.
-
loc 1962 - To live in such a way is only to be a slave to one’s desires and impulses. Real freedom is an attitude akin to pushing up one’s tumbling self from below.
-
loc 1964 - A stone is powerless. Once it has begun to roll downhill, it will continue to roll until released from the natural laws of gravity and inertia. But we are not stones. We are beings who are capable of resisting inclination. We can stop our tumbling selves and climb uphill. The desire for recognition is probably a natural desire. So are you going to keep rolling downhill in order to receive recognition from others? Are you going to wear yourself down like a rolling stone, until everything is smoothed away? When all that is left is a little round ball, would that be “the real I”? It cannot be.
-
loc 1979 - It is certainly distressful to be disliked. If possible, one would like to live without being disliked by anyone. One wants to satisfy one’s desire for recognition. But conducting oneself in such a way as to not be disliked by anyone is an extremely unfree way of living, and is also impossible. There is a cost incurred when one wants to exercise one’s freedom. And the cost of freedom in interpersonal relationships is that one is disliked by other people
-
loc 1995 - One neither prepares to be self-righteous nor becomes defiant. One just separates tasks. There may be a person who does not think well of you, but that is not your task. And again, thinking things like He should like me or I’ve done all this, so it’s strange that he doesn’t like me, is the reward-oriented way of thinking of having intervened in another person’s tasks. One moves forward without fearing the possibility of being disliked. One does not live as if one were rolling downhill, but instead climbs the slope that lies ahead. That is freedom for a human being. Suppose that I had two choices in front of me—a life in which all people like me, and a life in which there are people who dislike me—and I was told to choose one. I would choose the latter without a second thought. Before being concerned with what others think of me, I want to follow through with my own being. That is to say, I want to live in freedom.
-
loc 2005 - Yes, that’s right. Not wanting to be disliked is probably my task, but whether or not so-and-so dislikes me is the other person’s task. Even if there is a person who doesn’t think well of me, I cannot intervene in that. To borrow from the proverb I mentioned earlier, naturally one would make the effort to lead someone to water, but whether he drinks or not is that person’s task.
-
loc 2028 - think that until I encountered Adlerian psychology, I understood it in that kind of way. Because my father was a moody, taciturn person. But to think to myself, He hit me that time, and that is why our relationship went bad, is a Freudian etiological way of thinking. The Adlerian teleology position completely reverses the cause-and-effect interpretation. That is to say, I brought out the memory of being hit because I don’t want my relationship with my father to get better.
-
loc 2033 - That’s right. For me, it was more convenient to not repair my relationship with my father. I could use having a father like that as an excuse for why my own life wasn’t going well. That for me was a virtue. And there was also the aspect of taking revenge on a feudal father
-
loc 2041 - It is because he hit me that I have a bad relationship with my father, it would be a matter that was impossible for me to do anything about. But if I can think, I brought out the memory of being hit because I don’t want my relationship with my father to get better, then I will be holding the card to repair relations. Because if I can just change the goal, that fixes everything.
-
loc 2059 - I did not change in order to change my father. That is an erroneous notion of trying to manipulate another person. Even if I change, it is only “I” who changes. I do not know what will happen to the other person as a result, and that is not an aspect I can take part in. This
-
loc 2061 - Of course, there are times when, in tandem with my change—not due to my change—the other person changes too. In many cases, that person will have no choice but to change. But that is not the goal, and it is certainly possible that the other person will not change. In any case, changing one’s own speech and conduct as a way of manipulating other people is clearly a mistaken way of thinking.
-
loc 2065 - When we speak of interpersonal relationships, it always seems to be two-person relationships and one’s relationship to a large group that come to mind, but first it is oneself. When one is tied to the desire for recognition, the interpersonal relationship cards will always stay in the hands of other people.
-
loc 2117 - Yes. In other words, it is the smallest possible unit and therefore cannot be broken down any further. Now, what is it exactly that cannot be divided? Adler was opposed to any kind of dualistic value system that treated the mind as separate from the body—reason as separate from emotion, or the conscious mind as separate from the unconscious mind
-
loc 2123 - Tension in the mind can make one’s arms and legs shake, or cause one’s cheeks to turn red, and fear can make one’s face turn white. And so on
-
loc 2131 - Certainly it is true that the mind and the body are separate things, that reason and emotion are different, and that both the conscious mind and the unconscious mind exist. That said, however, when one flies into a rage and shouts at another person, it is “I as a whole” who is choosing to shout
-
loc 2133 - One would never think of emotions that somehow exist independently—unrelated to one’s intentions, as it were—as having produced that shouting voice. When one separates the “I” from “emotion” and thinks, It was the emotion that made me do it, or The emotion got the best of me, and I couldn’t help it, such thinking quickly becomes a life-lie
-
loc 2147 - This is something I believe I went over last time—that forming good interpersonal relationships requires a certain degree of distance. At the same time, people who get too close end up not even being able to speak to each other, so it is not good to get too far apart, either. Please do not think of the separation of tasks as something that is meant to keep other people away; instead, see it as a way of thinking with which to unravel the threads of the complex entanglement of one’s interpersonal relations.
-
loc 2155 - Last time, I spoke of the separation of tasks as a prescription for resolving interpersonal relationship problems. But interpersonal relationships are not something that end just because one has separated the tasks. The separating of tasks is actually the point of departure for interpersonal relations. Today, let’s take the discussion deeper and address how interpersonal relations as a whole are viewed in Adlerian psychology, and consider the kind of relationships we should form with others
-
loc 2165 - Well, what is the goal of interpersonal relations? PHILOSOPHER: To get straight to the heart of the matter, it is “community feeling.”
-
loc 2170 - It was the time before last, I believe, that I brought up the matter of how one sees others, that is, as enemies or as comrades. Now, take that a step deeper. If other people are our comrades, and we live surrounded by them, we should be able to find in that life our own place of “refuge.” Moreover, in doing so, we should begin to have the desire to share with our comrades, to contribute to the community. This sense of others as comrades, this awareness of “having one’s own refuge,” is called “community feeling.”
-
loc 2179 - When Adler refers to community, he goes beyond the household, school, workplace, and local society, and treats it as all-inclusive, covering not only nations and all of humanity but also the entire axis of time from the past to the future—and he includes plants and animals and even inanimate objects.
-
loc 2186 - The majority of those who hear this have similar doubts. This is not something one can comprehend immediately. Adler himself acknowledged that the community he was espousing was “an unattainable ideal.”
-
loc 2199 - Society’s smallest unit, huh? I’d say the family. PHILOSOPHER: No, it is “you and I.
-
loc 2204 - You make the switch from attachment to self (self-interest) to concern for others (social interest).
-
loc 2218 - He’s someone who can’t operate in a group and prefers to act alone. He never stops to reflect on his actions, even when he’s late for appointments or fails to keep his promises. In a word, he is an egotist.
-
loc 2221 - People who are incapable of carrying out the separation of tasks and who are obsessed with the desire for recognition are also extremely self-centered.
-
loc 2224 - Consider the reality of the desire for recognition. How much do others pay attention to you, and what is their judgment of you? That is to say, how much do they satisfy your desire? People who are obsessed with such a desire for recognition will seem to be looking at other people, while they are actually looking only at themselves. They lack concern for others and are concerned solely with the “I.” Simply put, they are self-centered.
-
loc 2252 - And the protagonist in one’s life is the “I.” There is nothing wrong with the train of thought up to this point. But the “I” does not rule the center of the world. While the “I” is life’s protagonist, it is never more than a member of the community and a part of the whole
-
loc 2255 - People who have concern only for themselves think that they are at the center of the world. To such people, others are merely “people who will do something for me.” They half genuinely believe that everyone else exists to serve them and should give precedence to their feelings.
-
loc 2284 - Now we will go back to where we started. All of us are searching for the sense of belonging, that “it’s okay to be here.” In Adlerian psychology, however, a sense of belonging is something that one can attain only by making an active commitment to the community of one’s own accord, and not simply by being here.
-
loc 2291 - One has to stand on one’s own two feet, and take one’s own steps forward with the tasks of interpersonal relations. One needs to think not, What will this person give me? but rather, What can I give to this person? That is commitment to the community.
-
loc 2313 - Take, for example, a man who, on reaching retirement age and stopping work, quickly loses his vitality and becomes depressed. Abruptly cut off from the company that was his community and bereft of title or profession, he becomes an “ordinary nobody.” As he is unable to accept the fact that he is now “normal,” he becomes old practically overnight.
-
loc 2320 - It’s true, there’s no way one can just imagine the entire universe all of a sudden. Even so, I would like you to gain the awareness that you belong to a separate, larger community that is beyond the one you see in your immediate vicinity—for example, the country or local society in which you live—and that you are contributing in some way within that community.
-
loc 2336 - To borrow your terminology, the distance and depth of the interpersonal relations are completely different. It’s only natural that when we search for a sense of belonging, we will be attracted to the smaller community.
-
loc 2353 - That there is a larger world that extends far beyond the confines of the school. And every one of us is a member of that world. If there is no place of refuge in your school, you should find a different refuge outside the walls of the school. You can change schools, and it’s fine to withdraw from school, too. A community that you can break relations with by simply submitting a withdrawal notice is one that you can have only so much connection to, in any case. Once you know how big the world is, you will see that all the hardship you went through in school was a storm in a teacup. The moment you leave the teacup, that raging storm will be gone, and a gentle breeze will greet you in its place.
-
loc 2358 - My Note: We ssearch for sense of belonging here and there. Rather than not finding your sense of belonging and shrinking to smaller fo of community such as from school to shutting yourself to home, you can find you belong elsewhere if you see whole world is for you to belong.
-
loc 2363 - I am sure you are right—it would not be easy. Therefore, there is a principle of action that I would like you to commit to memory. When we run into difficulties in our interpersonal relations, or when we can no longer see a way out, what we should consider first and foremost is the principle that says, “Listen to the voice of the larger community.”
-
loc 2366 - My Note: Listen !! Listen to the voice of the bigger world.
-
loc 2374 - Not at all. Though this might be termed a “you and I” relationship, if it is one that can break down just because you raise an objection, then it is not the sort of relationship you need to get into in the first place. It is fine to just let go of it. Living in fear of one’s relationships falling apart is an unfree way to live, in which one is living for other people.
-
loc 2385 - So first, I separate the tasks. I think of my tasks as being up to this point, and everything beyond that is other people’s tasks. I don’t intervene in other people’s tasks, and I draw a line so that other people won’t intervene in mine. But how can one build interpersonal relations with this separation of tasks and arrive in the end at the community feeling that “it’s okay to be here”? How does Adlerian psychology advise us to overcome the life tasks of work, friendship, and love? It seems like you’re just trying to confuse me with abstract words, without going into any concrete explanation.
-
loc 2390 - How does carrying out the separating of tasks connect with good relations? That is to say, how does it connect with building the kind of relations in which we cooperate and act in harmony with each other? Which brings us to the concept of “horizontal relationship.”
-
loc 2405 - Animal training is an interesting example. Now let’s look at this from the standpoint of Adlerian psychology. In Adlerian psychology, we take the stance that in child-rearing, and in all other forms of communication with other people, one must not praise.
-
loc 2409 - Physical punishment is out of the question, of course, and rebuking is not accepted, either. One
-
loc 2416 - In the act of praise, there is the aspect of it being “the passing of judgment by a person of ability on a person of no ability.” A mother praises her child who has helped her prepare dinner, saying, “You’re such a good helper!” But when her husband does the same things, you can be sure she won’t be telling him, “You’re such a good helper!”
-
loc 2421 - unconsciously creating a hierarchical relationship and seeing the child as beneath her.
-
loc 2426 - That’s right. Whether we praise or rebuke others, the only difference is one of the carrot or the stick, and the background goal is manipulation. The reason Adlerian psychology is highly critical of reward-and-punishment education is that its intention is to manipulate children.
-
loc 2435 - Adlerian psychology refutes all manner of vertical relationships and proposes that all interpersonal relationships be horizontal relationships.
-
loc 2448 - So it seems. In the first place, the feeling of inferiority is an awareness that arises within vertical relationships. If one can build horizontal relationships that are “equal but not the same” for all people, there will no longer be any room for inferiority complexes to emerge.
-
loc 2461 - So why does a person intervene? Here, too, in the background, vertical relationships are at play. It is precisely because one perceives interpersonal relations as vertical, and sees the other party as beneath one, that one intervenes
-
loc 2469 - Well, it’s one thing if you’re just talking about a child’s studies. But when someone’s suffering right there in front of you, you can’t just leave him or her be, can you? Would you still say that lending a helping hand is intervention, and then do nothing?
-
loc 2472 - It is necessary to offer assistance that does not turn into intervention.
-
loc 2476 - assistance, on the other hand, presupposes the separation of tasks, and also horizontal relationships. Having understood that studying is the child’s task, one considers what one can do for him. Concretely speaking, instead of commanding from above that the child must study, one acts on him in such a way that he can gain the confidence to take care of his own studies and face his tasks on his own.
-
loc 2487 - When one is not following through with one’s tasks, it is not because one is without ability. Adlerian psychology tells us that the issue here is not one of ability but simply that “one has lost the courage to face one’s tasks.” And if that is the case, the thing to do before anything else is to recover that lost courage.
-
loc 2495 - Being praised is what leads people to form the belief that they have no ability
-
loc 2497 - The more one is praised by another person, the more one forms the belief that one has no ability. Please do your best to remember this.
-
loc 2503 - When receiving praise becomes one’s goal, one is choosing a way of living that is in line with another person’s system of values. Looking at your life until now, aren’t you tired of trying to live up to your parents’ expectations?
-
loc 2520 - The most important thing is to not judge other people. “Judgment” is a word that comes out of vertical relationships. If one is building horizontal relationships, there will be words of more straightforward gratitude and respect and joy.
-
loc 2527 - receiving praise is what one is after, one will have no choice but to adapt to that person’s yardstick and put the brakes on one’s own freedom. “Thank you,” on the other hand, rather than being judgment, is a clear expression of gratitude. When one hears words of gratitude, one knows that one has made a contribution to another person.
-
loc 2541 - It’s quite simple. It is when one is able to feel “I am beneficial to the community” that one can have a true sense of one’s worth. This is the answer that would be offered in Adlerian psychology.
-
loc 2544 - That one can act on the community, that is to say, on other people, and that one can feel “I am of use to someone.” Instead of feeling judged by another person as “good,” being able to feel, by way of one’s own subjective viewpoint, that “I can make contributions to other people.” It is at that point that, at last, we
-
loc 2575 - There are parents who refute my explanation of the concept of encouragement by saying, “Our child does bad things from morning to night, and there is never an occasion to tell him, ‘Thank you,’ or ‘You helped a lot.’ ” The context is probably the same as what you are talking about, isn’t it?
-
loc 2584 - If you consider things at the level of being, we are of use to others and have worth just by being here. This is an indisputable fact
-
loc 2591 - That’s what it means to be grateful on the level of being. Your mother might not be able to do anything in her critical condition that would be considered an act, but just by being alive, she would be supporting the psychological state of you and your family, and would therefore be of use.
-
loc 2593 - If your life were in danger, and you were hanging on by a thread, the people around you would probably feel very gladdened just by the very fact of your existing. They would simply feel thankful that you are safe in the here and now, and would not be wanting you to perform some direct act.
-
loc 2600 - When we look at other people, we are prone to construct our own ideal images of ourselves, which we then detract from and judge. Imagine, for example, a child who never talks back to his parents, excels in both schoolwork and sports, attends a good university, and joins a large company. There are parents who will compare their child to such an image of an ideal child—which is an impossible fiction—and then be filled with complaints and dissatisfaction. They treat the idealized image as one hundred points, and they gradually subtract from that. This is truly a “judgment” way of thinking. Instead, the parents could refrain from comparing their child to anyone else, see him for who he actually is, and be glad and grateful for his being there. Instead of taking away points from some idealized image, they could start from zero. And if they do that, they should be able to call out to his existence itself.
-
loc 2609 - Suppose your shut-in child helped you wash the dishes after a meal. If you were to say then, “Enough of that already—just go to school,” you would be using the words of such parents who detract from an image of an ideal child
-
loc 2616 - “Someone has to start. Other people might not be cooperative, but that is not connected to you. My advice is this: you should start. With no regard to whether others are cooperative or not.”
-
loc 2625 - “People can be of use to someone else simply by being alive, and have a true sense of their worth just by being alive.”
-
loc 2638 - From an Adlerian psychology point of view, the answer is simple. First of all, build a horizontal relationship between yourself and another person. One is enough. Let’s start from there.
-
loc 2649 - If you are building even one vertical relationship with someone, before you even notice what is happening, you will be treating all your interpersonal relations as vertical.
-
loc 2651 - That is correct. Even if you are not treating them in a boss-or-subordinate kind of way, it is as if you are saying, “A is above me, and B is below me,” for example, or “I’ll follow A’s advice, but ignore what B says,” or “I don’t mind breaking my promise to C.”
-
loc 2665 - I am not someone who can mouth off to my seniors, and I would never think of trying. My social common sense would be called into question if I did.
-
loc 2666 - What is “senior”? What is this “mouthing off”? If one is gauging the atmosphere of a situation and being dependent on vertical relationships, one is engaging in irresponsible acts—one is trying to avoid one’s responsibilities.
-
loc 2675 - There is space for you to refuse, and there should also be space to propose a better way of doing things. You are just thinking there is no space to refuse so that you can avoid the conflict of the associated interpersonal relations and avoid responsibility—and you are being dependent on vertical relationships
-
loc 2689 - Age does not matter in love and friendship. It is certainly true that the tasks of friendship require a steady courage. With regard to your relationship with me, it will be fine to reduce the distance little by little. To a degree of distance in which we are not in very close contact but can still reach out and touch each other’s faces with our outstretched arms, so to speak. YOUTH: Please give me some time.
-
loc 2689 - Age does not matter in love and friendship. It is certainly true that the tasks of friendship require a steady courage. With regard to your relationship with me, it will be fine to reduce the distance little by little. To a degree of distance in which we are not in very close contact but can still reach out and touch each other’s faces with our outstretched arms, so to speak.
-
loc 2782 - what should I do then? PHILOSOPHER: It’s about community feeling, after all. Concretely speaking, it’s making the switch from attachment to self (self-interest) to concern for others (social interest) and gaining a sense of community feeling. Three things are needed at this point: “self-acceptance,” “confidence in others,” and “contribution to others.”
-
loc 2785 - My Note: What should I do as i only dance with myself and not infront of anyone else as i find it so that people will judge me ?
-
loc 2793 - There is no need to go out of one’s way to be positive and affirm oneself. It’s not self-affirmation that we are concerned with, but self-acceptance.
-
loc 2794 - Not self-affirmation, but self-acceptance? PHILOSOPHER: That’s right. There is a clear difference. Self-affirmation is making suggestions to oneself, such as “I can do it” or “I am strong,” even when something is simply beyond one’s ability. It is a notion that can bring about a superiority complex, and may even be termed a way of living in which one lies to oneself. With self-acceptance, on the other hand, if one cannot do something, one is simply accepting “one’s incapable self” as is and moving forward so that one can do whatever one can. It is not a way of lying to oneself. To put it more simply, say you’ve got a score of 60 percent, but you tell yourself, I just happened to get unlucky this time around, and the real me is 100 percent. That is self-affirmation. By contrast, if one accepts oneself as one is, as 60 percent, and thinks to oneself, How should I go about getting closer to 100 percent?—that is self-acceptance.
-
loc 2805 - there is no such thing as a 100 percent person. This is something we should actively acknowledge.
-
loc 2808 - Affirmative resignation? PHILOSOPHER: This is also the case with the separation of tasks—one ascertains the things one can change and the things one cannot change. One cannot change what one is born with. But one can, under one’s own power, go about changing what use one makes of that equipment. So in that case, one simply has to focus on what one can change, rather than on what one cannot. This is what I call self-acceptance.
-
loc 2829 - Resignation has the connotation of seeing clearly with fortitude and acceptance. Having a firm grasp on the truth of things—that is resignation. There is nothing pessimistic about
-
loc 2833 - When one is switching from attachment to self to concern for others, the second key concept—confidence in others—becomes absolutely essential.
-
loc 2835 - Here, I will consider the words “believing in others” in the context of distinguishing trust from confidence. First, when we speak of trust, we are referring to something that comes with set conditions. We refer to it as credit. For example, when one wants to borrow money from a bank, one has to have some kind of security. The bank calculates the amount of the loan based on the value of that security, and says, “We will lend you this much.” The attitude of “We will lend it to you on the condition that you will pay it back” or “We will lend you as much as you are able to pay back” is not one of having confidence in someone. It is trust
-
loc 2842 - from the standpoint of Adlerian psychology, the basis of interpersonal relations is founded not on trust but on confidence.
-
loc 2844 - It is doing without any set conditions whatsoever when believing in others. Even if one does not have sufficient objective grounds for trusting someone, one believes. One believes unconditionally without concerning oneself with such things as security. That is confidence. YOUTH: Believing unconditionally?
-
loc 2848 - if one believes in others without setting any conditions whatsoever, there will be times when one gets taken advantage of. Just like the guarantor of a debt, there are times when one may suffer damages. The attitude of continuing to believe in someone even in such instances is what we call confidence
-
loc 2861 - An antonym of confidence? Uh . . . PHILOSOPHER: It is doubt. Suppose you have placed “doubt” at the foundation of your interpersonal relations. That you live your life doubting other people—doubting your friends and even your family and those you love. What sort of relationship could possibly arise from that? The
-
loc 2869 - Right now, you are thinking, If I were to have confidence in someone unconditionally, I would just get taken advantage of. However, you are not the one who decides whether or not to take advantage. That
-
loc 2879 - Unconditional confidence is a means for making your interpersonal relationship with a person better and for building a horizontal relationship. If you do not have the desire to make your relationship with that person better, then go ahead and sever it. Because carrying out the severing is your task. YOUTH: Then what if I’ve placed unconditional confidence in a friend in order to make our relationship better?
-
loc 2879 - Adlerian psychology is not saying “have confidence in others unconditionally” on the basis of a moralistic system of values. Unconditional confidence is a means for making your interpersonal relationship with a person better and for building a horizontal relationship. If you do not have the desire to make your relationship with that person better, then go ahead and sever it. Because carrying out the severing is your task.
-
loc 2896 - Right now, you are only concerned about the times you were taken advantage of, and nothing else. You focus only on the pain from the wounds you sustained on such occasions. But if you are afraid to have confidence in others, in the long run you will not be able to build deep relationships with anyone
-
loc 2904 - The courage to overcome the fear of being taken advantage of—where does it come from? PHILOSOPHER: It comes from self-acceptance. If one can simply accept oneself as one is, and ascertain what one can do and what one cannot, one becomes able to understand that “taking advantage” is the other person’s task, and getting to the core of “confidence in others” becomes less difficult.
-
loc 2911 - When one is sad, one should be sad to one’s heart’s content. It is precisely when one tries to escape the pain and sadness that one gets stuck and ceases to be able to build deep relationships with anyone. Think about it this way. We can believe. And we can doubt. But we are aspiring to see others as our comrades. To believe or to doubt—the choice should be clear.
-
loc 2923 - In effect, placing confidence in others is connected to seeing others as comrades. It is because they are one’s comrades that one can have confidence in them.
-
loc 2934 - Of course, community feeling is not something that is attainable with just self-acceptance and confidence in others. It is at this point that the third key concept—contribution to others—becomes necessary
-
loc 2939 - Contribution to others does not connote self-sacrifice. Adler goes so far as to warn that those who sacrifice their own lives for others are people who have conformed to society too much.
-
loc 2978 - In such a situation, normally one would think, Why won’t they give me a hand? or Why do I have to do all the work? Even if I do not hear the words “thank you” from my family while I am cleaning up, I want them to think that I am of use to the family.
-
loc 2982 - Just by having that feeling of contribution, the reality right in front of me will take on a completely different hue. In fact, if I am grumbling to myself as I wash the dishes, I am probably not much fun to be around, so everyone just wants to keep their distance. On the other hand, if I’m humming away to myself and washing the dishes in good spirits, the children might come and give me a hand
-
loc 2985 - the very least, I’d be creating an atmosphere in which it is easier for them to offer their help.
-
loc 2989 - Contribution that is carried out while one is seeing other people as enemies may indeed lead to hypocrisy. But if other people are one’s comrades, that should never happen, regardless of the contributions one makes
-
loc 2993 - For the sake of convenience, up to this point I have discussed self-acceptance, confidence in others, and contribution to others, in that order. However, these three are linked as an indispensable whole, in a sort of circular structure. It is because one accepts oneself just as one is—one self-accepts—that one can have “confidence in others” without the fear of being taken advantage of. And it is because one can place unconditional confidence in others, and feel that people are one’s comrades, that one can engage in “contribution to others.” Further, it is because one contributes to others that one can have the deep awareness that “I am of use to someone” and accept oneself just as one is. One can self-accept.
-
loc 2998 - My Note: Indeed an amazing thought.
-
loc 3049 - Why is stammering hard to deal with? The view in Adlerian psychology is that people who suffer from stammering are concerned only about their own way of speaking, and they have feelings of inferiority and see their lives as unbearably hard. And they become too self-conscious as a result and start tripping over their words more and more.
-
loc 3071 - People who suffer from stammering are looking at only a part of things but judging the whole. With workaholics, the focus is solely on one specific aspect of life.
-
loc 3079 - In a sense, that is a way of living of refusing to acknowledge one’s life tasks. “Work” does not mean having a job at a company. Work in the home, child-rearing, contributing to the local society, hobbies, and all manner of other things are work. Companies and such are just one small part of that. A way of living that acknowledges only company work is one that is lacking in harmony of life
-
loc 3102 - You say that all problems are interpersonal relationship problems. And then you turn that around and say that our happiness is to be found in our interpersonal relations, too
-
loc 3137 - All human beings can be happy. But it must be understood that this does not mean all human beings are happy. Whether it is on the level of acts or on the level of being, one needs to feel that one is of use to someone. That is to say, one needs a feeling of contribution.
-
loc 3144 - Earlier, we were talking about desire for recognition. In response to my statement that one must not seek recognition, you said that desire for recognition is a universal desire.
-
loc 3156 - If one’s means for gaining a feeling of contribution turns out to be “being recognized by others,” in the long run, one will have no choice but to walk through life in accordance with other people’s wishes. There is no freedom in a feeling of contribution that is gained through the desire for recognition. We are beings who choose freedom while aspiring to happiness.
-
loc 3169 - The philosopher’s points could be summed up as follows: People can be truly aware of their worth only when they are able to feel “I am of use to someone.” However, it doesn’t matter if the contribution one makes at such a time is without any visible form. It is enough to have the subjective sense of being of use to someone, that is to say, a feeling of contribution. And then the philosopher arrives at the following conclusion: Happiness is the feeling of contribution. There certainly seemed to be aspects of the truth there. But is that really all that happiness is? Not if it’s the happiness I’m searching for
-
loc 3198 - There are many children who, in their early stages, try to be especially good. In particular, they obey their parents, comport themselves in a socially acceptable manner, apply themselves assiduously to their studies and in sports, and excel in extracurricular activities as well. In this way, they try to get their parents to acknowledge them. However, when being especially good does not work out—their studies or sports don’t go well, for example—they do an about-face and try to be especially bad.
-
loc 3207 - the children who try to be especially bad—that is to say, the ones who engage in problem behavior—are endeavoring to attract the attention of other people even as they continue to avoid any such healthy effort
-
loc 3207 - the children who try to be especially bad—that is to say, the ones who engage in problem behavior—are endeavoring to attract the attention of other people even as they continue to avoid any such healthy effort. In Adlerian psychology, this is referred to as the “pursuit of easy superiority.”
-
loc 3223 - Yes. “Revenge” and “pursuit of easy superiority” are easily linked. One makes trouble for another person while trying at the same time to be “special.”
-
loc 3237 - Why is it necessary to be special? Probably because one cannot accept one’s normal self. And it is precisely for this reason that when being especially good becomes a lost cause, one makes the huge leap to being especially bad—the opposite extreme. But is being normal, being ordinary, really such a bad thing? Is it something inferior? Or, in truth, isn’t everybody normal? It is necessary to think this through to its logical conclusion.
-
loc 3240 - My Note: I know bht its hard to grasp
-
loc 3244 - You are probably rejecting normality because you equate being normal with being incapable. Being normal is not being incapable. One does not need to flaunt one’s superiority
-
loc 3269 - But if life were climbing a mountain in order to reach the top, then the greater part of life would end up being “en route.” That is to say, one’s “real life” would begin with one’s trek on the mountainside, and the distance one has traveled up until that point would be a “tentative life” led by a “tentative me.
-
loc 3280 - People who think of life as being like climbing a mountain are treating their own existences as lines. As if there is a line that started the instant one came into this world, and that continues in all manner of curves of varying sizes until it arrives at the summit, and then at long last reaches its terminus, which is death. This conception, which treats life as a kind of story, is an idea that links with Freudian etiology (the attributing of causes), and is a way of thinking that makes the greater part of life into something that is “en route
-
loc 3285 - Do not treat it as a line. Think of life as a series of dots. If you look through a magnifying glass at a solid line drawn with chalk, you will discover that what you thought was a line is actually a series of small dots. Seemingly linear existence is actually a series of dots; in other words, life is a series of moments
-
loc 3289 - a series of moments called “now.” We can live only in the here and now. Our lives exist only in moments. Adults who do not know this attempt to impose “linear” lives onto young people. Their thinking is that staying on the conventional tracks—good university, big company, stable household—is a happy life. But life is not made up of lines or anything like that.
-
loc 3293 - If life were a line, then life planning would be possible. But our lives are only a series of dots. A well-planned life is not something to be treated as necessary or unnecessary, as it is impossible.
-
loc 3311 - Think of it this way: Life is a series of moments, which one lives as if one were dancing, right now, around and around each passing instant. And when one happens to survey one’s surroundings, one realizes, I guess I’ve made it this far. Among those who have danced the dance of the violin, there are people who stay the course and become professional musicians. Among
-
loc 3319 - Since one is dancing, one does not stay in the same place. But there is no destination.
-
loc 3338 - What kind of goal is the act of going on a journey? Suppose you are going on a journey to Egypt. Would you try to arrive at the Great Pyramid of Giza as efficiently and quickly as possible, and then head straight back home by the shortest route? One would not call that a “journey
-
loc 3364 - Imagine that you are standing on a theater stage. If the house lights are on, you’ll probably be able to see all the way to the back of the hall. But if you’re under a bright spotlight, you won’t be able to make out even the front row. That’s exactly how it is with our lives. It’s because we cast a dim light on our entire lives that we are able to see the past and the future. Or at least we imagine we can. But if one is shining a bright spotlight on here and now,
-
loc 3383 - Lifestyle is about here and now, and is something that one can change of one’s own volition. The life of the past that looks like a straight line appears that way to you only as a result of your making ceaseless resolutions to not change. The life that lies ahead of you is a completely blank page, and there are no tracks that have been laid for you to follow. There is no story there.
-
loc 3393 - For example, one wants to get into a university but makes no attempt to study. This an attitude of not living earnestly here and now. Of course, maybe the entrance examination is still far off. Maybe one is not sure what needs to be studied or how thoroughly, and one finds it troublesome. However, it is enough to do it little by little—every day one can work out some mathematical formulas, one can memorize some words. In short, one can dance the dance. By doing so, one is sure
-
loc 3405 - You set objectives for the distant future, and think of now as your preparatory period. You think, I really want to do this, and I’ll do it when the time comes. This is a way of living that postpones life. As long as we postpone life, we can never go anywhere and will pass our days only one after the next in dull monotony, because we think of here and now as just a preparatory period, as a time for patience. But a “here and now” in which one is studying for an entrance examination in the distant future, for example, is the real thing.
-
loc 3424 - The greatest life-lie of all is to not live here and now. It is to look at the past and the future, cast a dim light on one’s entire life, and believe that one has been able to see something. Until now, you have turned away from the here and now and shone a light only on invented pasts and
-
loc 3424 - The greatest life-lie of all is to not live here and now. It is to look at the past and the future, cast a dim light on one’s entire life, and believe that one has been able to see something. Until now, you have turned away from the here and now and shone a light only on invented pasts and futures. You have told a great lie to your life, to these irreplaceable moments
-
loc 3464 - So life in general has no meaning whatsoever. But you can assign meaning to that life. And you are the only one who can assign meaning to your life.
-
loc 3467 - You are lost in your life. Why are you lost? You are lost because you are trying to choose freedom, that is to say, a path on which you are not afraid of being disliked by others and you are not living others’ lives—a path that is yours alone
-
loc 3473 - Just like the traveler who relies on the North Star, in our lives we need a guiding star. That is the Adlerian psychology way of thinking. It is an expansive ideal that says, as long as we do not lose sight of this compass and keep on moving in this direction, there is happiness. YOUTH: Where is that star? PHILOSOPHER: It is contribution to others.
-
loc 3507 - One more time, I give you the words of Adler: “Someone has to start. Other people might not be cooperative, but that is not connected to you. My advice is this: You should start. With no regard to whether others are cooperative or not.”