Author: The School of Life

Our belief in instinct has been no friend of our chances of happiness. We can’t go back to the Marriage of Reason, but we may need to look for a future beyond the Relationship of Instinct.

If we intend to get better at relationships, we must attempt to examine the calls of Romantic love rationally. This isn’t a question of abandoning instinct, but of improving upon it.

This mechanism of attraction in love is similar to the mechanism of attraction we have around styles of architecture and design. When it comes to buildings and interiors, we also operate with an instinct for completion. The places we call ‘beautiful’ (like the people we call ‘attractive’) are often those that have qualities we want but don’t yet have enough of. Consider these two very different buildings (right).

There is a second instinct that drives us in love: the Instinct for Endorsement.

We might then be powerfully attracted to people who seem to understand the lonely aspects of us. We love them for their ability to endorse fragile, isolated, offbeat traits. They ‘get’ us, in contrast to the legions of the insensitive who cannot.

The way we approach love as adults is highly shaped by how we experienced love as children.

The affection of our partners can end up tinged with a feeling of familiarity. In their arms, in an emotional sense, we come home.

And, without anyone giving the matter too much thought, they sweetly call us ‘baby’.

need only study our instinct for food: half of the rich world’s population is obese and addicted to excess fat, sugar and salt. We’re not spontaneous experts in knowing what is good for us.

An instinct is not easy to discount or dislodge, but it is possible to improve upon it and train it towards maturity.

So although we’re attracted to strengths in others, we don’t necessarily accept that we have to correct the weaknesses in ourselves that fired our attractions in the first place.

Furthermore, our partner may not always be the tolerant, wise teacher we might have needed. However patient they might be in other contexts, they will be at risk of getting scared and offended by our flaws.

The Romantic script of love tells us that a true lover will and must understand us without us needing to speak. They will endorse our lonely, confused, hard-to-reach aspects just by intuition.

Sulking is a highly distinctive phenomenon within the psychology of love. Crucially, we don’t sulk with just anyone. We reserve our sulks for people we believe should understand us but happen not to on a given occasion.

The problem with our instinct for familiarity

The Repetition Dynamic We are led by instinct to potential partners who feel familiar. In many ways, adult love is a search for a rediscovery of emotions first known in childhood. In order to prove attractive, the partner we pick must re-evoke many of the feelings we once had around parental figures.

We may reject candidates without particular flaws and not even know why, simply saying that they are ‘too nice’ or ‘a bit boring’.

We want a partner to feel familiar – and this may mean that we are driven to seek out unhappy circumstances, if the affection we knew as children was connected with certain sorts of pain.

Many people who cared for us had problematic aspects that they didn’t choose. If they caused us trouble, it wasn’t because they meant to. Still, we have to deal with the legacy.

The Recoil Dynamic Challenging past experiences can also shape our relationship instincts in a very different way. Instead of being drawn to an adult who reminds us of a parent, our instincts may turn emphatically in the opposite direction.

Maybe a parent was deeply creative, but had an appalling temper: now we can’t stomach anyone creative.

Maybe a parent was good at business, but emotionally cold: now we can’t stomach anyone who succeeds in commerce.

Improving Our Problematic Instincts

By understanding the way they work, we can take steps to attenuate their worst consequences. We can learn to be intelligently suspicious of our first impulses, and submit them to reasoned examination before following their commands.

Having the weakness doesn’t mean we’ll automatically be a willing and fast-learning pupil. We need to become better students of what we want the other to teach us.

Instinct might take us to someone who in principle has the strengths we’re missing, but the relationship becomes an agony when we grow offended by the idea of learning.

If we understand ourselves properly, we will know that there are many sides of us that need improvement. Love aims to be a safe arena in which two people can gently teach and learn how to grow into better versions of themselves

Even the most intelligent, sensitive lover cannot be expected to navigate around us without a lot of patiently articulated verbal indications of our desires and intentions.

The Repetition Dynamic The instinct for Familiarity leads us to two kinds of difficult types: people who have the same bad qualities as parental figures; and people who have none of the bad qualities as parental figures, but none of their good qualities either.

In the Recoil Dynamic, a pattern of behaviour has been experienced as so dangerous that one seeks its opposite as the natural escape

The trouble is that, with time, the recoil qualities tend to annoy us too. At first, it’s a relief to be with someone who doesn’t have the characteristics we’ve grown allergic to. Then we start to criticise our partners for the very qualities our instincts sought them out for.

The solution isn’t to blame the other person for naivety; it is to learn to show others who we truly are, on the basis of loosening our suspicion of ourselves. We need to make the initially implausible leap of faith that we might be acceptable to someone else who knew us more completely; we don’t necessarily have to lie in order to deserve love.

Showing need is a precondition of strength rather than weakness.

We are appalled by reciprocated love when we operate with a background idea of sentimental love. This states that loving ourselves is what we can do only when we are totally pure, and that loving another is what we can do only when someone is perfect. Yet we are, of course, all deeply flawed.

HOLY SHIT This needs some meditation from my side

The origins of a sentimental interpretation of love usually lie with parents who could not tolerate their children’s shadow sides. Somewhere in the past, a child had to be perfect in order to deserve affection. Tantrums, bad habits and nasty thoughts had to be banished. The child became outwardly ‘good’ and inwardly ashamed and lonely. We need to move towards a more humane and mature model of complex love; a love that tolerates imperfection and ambivalence, that accepts that we can have faults and love ourselves and can see the faults of another person and still love them.

We are familiar enough with the fear of failure, but it appears that success can bring about as many anxieties, which may culminate in a desire to scupper our chances of happy love in a bid to restore our peace of mind.

pay. We may, when we were younger, have been exposed to brutal disappointments at a time when we were too fragile to withstand them. Perhaps we hoped our parents would stay together and they didn’t. Or we hoped our father would eventually come back from another country and he stayed there. Perhaps we dared to love an adult and, after a period of happiness, they swiftly and oddly changed their attitude and let us down. Somewhere in our characters, a deep association has been forged between hope and danger, along with a corresponding preference to live quietly with disappointment, rather than more freely with hope

The solution is to remind ourselves that we can, despite our fears, survive the loss of hope. We are no longer those who suffered the disappointments responsible for our present timidity. The conditions that forged our caution are no longer those of adult reality. The unconscious mind may, as is its wont, be reading the present through the lenses of decades ago, but what we fear will happen has, in truth, already happened; we are projecting into the future a catastrophe that belongs to a past we have not had the chance to fathom or mourn adequately.

We are suffering from a localised immaturity: an archaic part of us remains as it was when we were a child

The intensity of the fear is based on the idea that we can only bring childhood resources to the problem.

But, in fact we’re big now. We have the capacity to cope very well. Should this relationship fail, we’ll be sad for a while but won’t actually be destroyed. We are not in as much danger as the primitive part of the mind thinks – and as we once were. We are no longer the children for whom loss was unbearable.

One of the key things that can go wrong in our search for love is that we get fixated on a particular person who turns out not to be a promising or realistic option. It may be that the person is in another country, with someone else, definitely not interested in us – or even dead.

Fixation

When a new person comes along who might potentially be a good partner for us, we reject them. We feel it would be disloyal to the individual we are fixated upon, even though they may neither know nor care about this.

Fixation disguises itself as a very Romantic attitude. Our love is unrequited, impossible – yet also seems especially intense and pure.

Fixation is really a fear of love.

The fear may be motivated by a dread of possible loss, self-hatred or a fear of self-revelation: a reluctance to let anyone into the secret parts of ourselves.

Fixation is not a manifestation of love; it is a calculated commitment to an obstacle to finding love.

Another move to unfixate ourselves is not to tell ourselves that we don’t like this person or to attempt to forget how much we are attracted to them.

The careful investigation of what we love about one person shows us – paradoxically but liberatingly – that we could also love someone else.

Understanding what we like in a person – what gives us pleasure – is therefore a central anti-fixation move.

When we properly grasp what draws us to one lover, we necessarily identify qualities that are available in other lovers too.

What we really love isn’t this specific creature, but a range of qualities we located in them first, normally because they were the most conspicuous examples of a repository for them.

This is where the problem started, because over-conspicuous people tend to attract too much attention, get over-subscribed and are then in a position to offer only very modest reciprocation.

It is not so much the idea that they won’t be able to cope that holds us back; it’s the feeling that we won’t be able to cope with upsetting them

We are likely to have experienced moments when adults around us seemed unable to take bad news, be it from us or from others in their lives. They slammed doors, screamed, threatened to kill themselves, threw things at us…. There was no room for us to bring our problems to the table. The parents seemed agitated and unhappy enough as it was. ‘Do you want to kill me or something?’ a parent might have shouted, the day we got caught stealing a ball or had a nosebleed over the carpet. We took care never to do that, or anything else like it, again. Perhaps the reality was not as bad as it seemed to a five-year-old child, but that is the point: children are unable to sense the difference between catastrophe and an evening of deep but passing upset in an easily agitated adult. The two merge into one another and create a confusion – which can survive deep into adulthood – between unhappiness and suicidal grief.

However, in the realm of love, politeness about the future ruins lives.

We are inclined to forget, too, that there are many forms of harm. We don’t only harm by being brutal with others; we can as easily – and perhaps more deeply – harm someone by seeming very nice to them, while wasting their years in a union to which we know all along we don’t feel committed

lack of confidence in seduction

There’s a kind of under-confidence that can afflict us in seduction when we grow too keen never to appear ridiculous. It is impossible to seduce someone and not run a serious risk of looking absurd: they may have a partner already; they may think we’re repulsive; they may not show up at the restaurant; they might say ‘Don’t be so silly!’ when we touch their hand.

At the heart of our under-confidence in seduction is a skewed picture of how dignified a normal person can be

The way to greater confidence isn’t to reassure ourselves of our own dignity; it’s to grow at peace with the inevitable nature of our ridiculousness. We are idiots now, we have been idiots in the past, and we will be idiots again in the future – and that is OK. There aren’t any other options available for human beings

Once we learn to see ourselves as already, and by nature, foolish, it doesn’t matter so much if we do one more thing that might look quite stupid.

The person we try to kiss could indeed think us ridiculous. But if they did so, it wouldn’t be news to us; they would only be confirming what we had already gracefully accepted long ago: that we, like them – and every other person on the earth – are a nitwit. The risk of trying and failing would have its sting substantially removed.

We would grow free to give things a go by accepting that failure was the norm. And every so often, amid the endless rebuffs we’d have factored in from the outset, it would work: we’d get a kiss, we’d make a friend, we’d get married… .

The wiser response is to remember that this paragon of apparent beauty and perfection will, with time, prove to be much more complicated than they appear and will at points be heart-wrenchingly disappointing and maddening.

The road to greater confidence in seduction begins with a ritual of telling oneself solemnly every morning, before heading out for the day, that one is a muttonhead, a cretin, a dumbbell and an imbecile, rarely capable of being happy for longer than fifteen minutes. One or two more acts of folly should, thereafter, not matter very much.

Being satisfied with being single is a precondition of satisfactory coupledom. We cannot choose wisely when remaining single feels unbearable.

When sex was only available within marriage, people recognised that this led people to marry for the wrong reasons: to obtain something that was artificially restricted in society as a whole. Sexual liberation was intended to allow people to have a clearer head when choosing who they really wanted to be with.

There are plenty of people out there for us, and we have already encountered a range of candidates it would be entirely plausible for us to be with; it’s just that we are unable to see the opportunities. More particularly, we believe – rather wrongly – that there is no one out there ‘good enough’ for us. We feel we could do better, and yet – tellingly – we never do. To shake us from our proud and unhelpful assumption, there are two moves we can make.

Firstly, we should take an honest look at ourselves and wonder whether we really are such deserving, special beings.

It is in few people’s interests to inform us of quite what tricky types we are. Our parents are too kind, our friends lack an incentive, and our ex-lovers are more likely to have left us with a blithe claim that they needed more ‘space’ or were going to India, rather than explaining how nightmarish we could be.

We can’t tell that we are, in many ways, real trouble to be with.

Excessive self-hatred is a great enemy of relationships, but so too is excessive self-love. Only by realising that we’re not perfect in certain hard-to-see areas can we be liberated to get together with people who are not perfect either; the only kind of people we are ever going to meet.

We need to rediscover the role of the imagination in the genesis of love. When our imaginations are switched off, we judge people on the very obvious things about them. We meet someone who is quite nice, but their nose is big. That’s a no. Or they are an engineer, and engineers are unsophisticated. So that’s a no. Maybe they are rich, and rich people are snobs. A no too.

But what we call imagination means sensitivity to the less obvious things. One scans past the surface and wonders about what else might be going on in a person. They look conventional and a bit formal, but they could turn out to have playful and wild sides too. They look mousey, but maybe they are also very witty around people they know well.

Our ideals crush the available realities. But maybe what we’re encountering isn’t a bad relationship, just a normal one.

In the mid-20th century, the English psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott coined a phrase to help anxious parents doing their best but constantly worried that they were falling short of being perfect parents. The real goal, Winnicott said, wasn’t to be ideal in every way, just to be ‘good enough’. A child doesn’t need a perfect parent. They need an ordinary, somewhat flawed, well-intentioned parent who will makes mistakes, have regrets, worry, get cross, then apologise; someone who will have other demands in their life that will sometimes have to take precedence, but who will still love and be kind and fulfil many of their needs. They will be ‘good enough’.

In Kierkegaard’s eyes, we can get stuck choosing because of one reason: we are so hopeful that we can choose well. We are convinced that there is one potentially very right choice and lots of very bad ones. That is why we are so careful, so choosy and so worried. Actually, Kierkegaard insists, we exaggerate the difference. We don’t face a perilous moment of decision between an excellent path and a dark one, because everything we choose is going to be fairly grim in certain ways, because life is necessarily rather than incidentally awful.

In other words, whatever we choose will be a bit wrong, so we shouldn’t agonise too much about any one choice we make. The real skill is not always to strive to make better choices; it’s to know how to make our peace with our necessarily bad choices

They are inviting us to be more modest in our expectations of relationships, not to make us unhappy, but in order to help us make our peace with the only thing that is actually on offer: a radically imperfect but genuine love for another flawed person and a necessarily troubled but still valuable shared life beside them.